Cross Currents

A cross cultural blog
JANUARY 11, 2009 6:05AM

A Moral Question

Rate: 1 Flag

The best numbers I can find state that in the current Israeli attack on Gaza, around 850 Palestinians have died and over 3,000 have been wounded (CNN). It’s estimated that 30 to 40% of the dead are women or children. From the rocket attacks that Hamas is still launching into Israel, 3 Israeli citizens have been killed since the conflict started. 

Yep. That’s three. Three Israeli citizens and ten Israeli soldiers. Compare that with four UN aid workers and eight hundred and fifty Palestinians. 

The best estimates I’ve found for Qassam rocket attacks state that in the 7 years before this latest outbreak, 15 Israeli citizens have been killed (Wikipedia). Hamas has launched thousands of rockets, but even the Israeli Defense Force stated that the rockets were “more a psychological than a physical threat.”

The Gaza strip is one of the most densely populated areas on earth. It is not possible to launch a military operation on the scale that Israel has done without “collateral damage” on the scale that can easily be seen on our TV screens every night. That hundreds of Palestinians would die was well known. 

Do the sufferings of Palestinians not matter? The death of 18 Israelis is certainly a tragedy, but does it justify the death of 850 Palestinians? That is the moral question: does the death of 18 innocent Israeli citizens justify a military action that is killing hundreds of innocent Palestinians?


Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Its a tragedy and an absolute disgrace. There is no justification for the slaughter that has taken place over the recent days.

Nobody seems to count the civilian men casualties. Hundreds of brothers, fathers and sons died alongside their women and children.

Dr Mads Gilbert said he had seen ONE Hamas militant among the patients at the hospital he was working in.
I don't think there are statistics for male civilian causalties. I doubt Hamas fighters wear uniforms, so there's probably no visible way to identify who is a soldier and who is a civilian.