Cross Currents

A cross cultural blog
Editor’s Pick
JULY 22, 2010 4:21AM

The Elephant in the Room

Rate: 24 Flag

Throughout my childhood, I viewed my family as average: four kids, stay-at-home Mom, ranch house in the suburbs, public schools.  The drama of my youth was equally banal: broken arm, awkward teen years, best friend moved away. Utterly typical, except for the elephant in the room. I was so used to living with it that I didn’t see it. 

 

My older brother has autism. Not Asperger’s, not mild autism, but the head-banging, knuckle-biting sort. He cracked the plasterboard wall of his room with his head. He’d whack it so hard I was convinced that the front of the forehead has no feeling. I’d touch mine sometimes, but I could feel my fingers. Maybe the senses there are only superficial? I did a few test bangs, which barely hurt (and barely hit) but I never had enough conviction to slam my head full force against the wall and test my theory.  Besides, what if I didn’t hit the sweet spot?  

 

I need to say that my brother’s eruptions of frustration never hurt anyone. On the rare occasions when my sister or I provoked him beyond endurance, he’d pound the wall, holding me (or her) with the other hand so I could feel his anger in every wham, wham, wham against the wall next to my head. Most of the time, we avoided getting cornered, so we scampered off while he lashed out his frustration on the wall.  We had spats over the usual stuff, who empties the dishwasher or gets the bathroom next. No kid is going to let their brother get away with always having his way because of a label that no one understood. 

 

My parents were not members of the PTA nor girl or boy scout troop leaders. They didn’t organize camp-outs or hiking trips. They belonged to organizations like the MARC -- the Massachusetts Association for Retarded Children (now called The Arc) and organizations devoted to understanding autism. They campaigned for the passage of Chapter 766, the groundbreaking Massachusetts law that required public schools to provide education for the developmentally disabled --- and allowed my brother to leave his private boarding school and live at home.  That was merely the first of many local, state and federal laws to help the mentally ill they fought for.  

 

Despite the passage of many laws, my brother has always required an active advocate. The maze of regulations for disability benefits, housing, jobs are complex. Keeping my brother from dropping through the cracks takes endless vigilance. 

 

Along with political action and personal advocacy, they’ve worked with my brother. My father’s tireless devotion and behavior modification have made the explosions and head-banging a dim memory. I think it’s been nearly thirty years since my brother banged a wall or his head. He’s grown much more tolerant of the accidents of chance that can lead to disruptions to his schedule. Until this latest recession, he’s been pretty much continuously employed since aging out of education.

 

If I were writing this in my twenties, I’d have written about how normal my life was. After all, elephants don’t hang in suburban living rooms. 

 

If I was writing in my thirties, this might be an essay about the profound impact of living with a tragedy*. After my brother came home, my parents had much less time for the rest of us. My sister recalls when my younger brother got in some trouble at school.  It kept escalating with messages from the school. It didn’t register with my parents until they got called into the principal’s office --- serious stuff in those days.  They paid attention long enough to figure out my younger brother was not going to jail and not going to be expelled. After that, it dropped off their radar screen. They had real problems to worry about. 

 

Our feelings weren’t on the list. My sister and I had each other, but my younger brother was left to founder on his own. At the same time, we were expected to excel. We were the normal ones, nothing was stopping us. Or encouraging us. We underachieved regularly. My younger brother had a particularly hard time; he was expected to make up for my older brother and for the achievements that might have been my father’s if his job and not my older brother had been his priority. Anything less than outstanding was a disappointment. 

 

But, I’ve lived a little longer. Aspects of my character may have been forged  from minor emotional neglect. Or from living in a family with stressed parents. Some people might even call it a dysfunctional family. Yet, I’ve never doubted my parents’ love. At a fundamental level, I knew that if my needs were as great as my brother’s, they’d fight for me as fiercely as they fought, and are still fighting, for him.  That is what makes a family strong and healthy.

 

 * Not only is my brother a tragedy for my parents, but my brother is an unhappy man. He lives in a world that he doesn’t understand and which constantly frustrates him. So much of what brings other people happiness is out of reach for him.  

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Great, amazing post and I am so glad to see you. I can't say anything except that your writing is so clear and that your talent shines in this very emotional essay. Thank you for sharing it.
You have a very generous view of the needs of your brother and your parents response. In the end, most do the best we can. Thank you for your perspective.
Aim: Thanks for the kind words

Harriet: It took me so long to get there.
Wonderfully penned. Thank you for writing this. So many of us have elephants.
My mother's elder brother is mentally challenged after an attack of brain polio when he was still a toddler.

My mother came along after he was diagnosed and four years later my grandmother died in an accident at work.

My mother often speaks of feeling neglected, less loved than my uncle as a child and a teenager.

Maybe that is why your post resonated so much. Rated.
having a special needs child of any age is a full-time job, and sadly, the other kids are often scooted to the proverbial back burner....you have great understanding of its impact your family, and better still, you seem to be a really good person. thanks for letting me peek behind your windows.
How well you write this; your pain comes across so clearly, and yet even the sadness is tempered by an overriding voice of reasonableness; you seem to see it for what it is. Survival. Thank you for giving us this glimpse.
Another excellent slice of real family life that makes up more and not less of what life in homes across America is really like and not how its portrayed on TV. Your brother is lucky to have such wonderful advocates for parents. You have written this with wisdom and grace.
You have written this with so much candor, but also love and compassion. Thanks for sharing this.
This is warm and real, honest without being sentimental. You've got such a clear-eyed view on your situation. Thanks for this.
This is unflinchingly and clearly written. My oldest has mild Asperger's, and suffered through a terrible episode during puberty where he became convinced if he fell asleep, he would be killed. I know how awful those few months were for our family and for my other two children. I fought bitterly with a psychiatrist we waited weeks to see who decided after talking to my son for all of ten minutes that he needed to be on anti-psychotic drugs (with possible lifelong side effects). As a result I became quite outspoken about the poor mental health services in our area. Your parents have my great respect and admiration--and so do you. One of the best things about living with someone who's "different" is the empathy you gain for other families. Thanks for this post. It means a lot.
You write so well -- very heavy burden to have in one's family, where a part of the family doesn't understand the world and is frustrated over and over, with no end in sight.
Thank you for letting us have some insight to a tough issue all around, and for sharing your family with us...
Thanks Kathy, it's funny how we all take our elephants for granted.

Moana: I don't know how well I'd have turned out if there was only one parent to care for my brother, earn a living, and raise the rest of us. That's a hard row to hoe.

Bethy: there's a hole different quality to problems with someone who is mentally ill. If one of us did something stupid or inappropriate, people would understand that kids are kids. If my older brother did, he might be committed as uncontrollable, yet he understood so little. He saw checks as free money. Why shouldn't he have some? So he took my checkbook to the bank, wrote a check (not well, he didn't understand 'payable to' and he signed it with his name, not mine) and tried to get some money. Had the bank not known him or me (I worked at a different branch) that might have counted as attempted forgery.

Sophie: Ultimately, I think my parents made the right decision. Yes, it would have been nice if they'd had more time for me, but they were told when my brother was diagnosed to stick him in an institution and write him off. I'd be horrified if such a sacrifice had been made for me.

Cartouche, Linda and Dear Reader, Just Thinking, thanks for the kind words.

Fetlock: yes, I think I became much more tolerant. I remember first hearing of homosexuality in my teens, it was discussed as a hush-hush perversion. Yet when a friend in college decided he was gay, I had no problems with it. This is what you are, who am I to say what you should be?
You're not alone. Thanks for sharing this personal tidbit with us. It helps knowing there are so many who listen with their hearts.
My son has PDD-NOS. Which is really autism in so many words. He has two sisters and (I think) we lead a fairly normal life. But the continuous care for autistic children is sometimes very trying for all the family.

Thank you for sharing this.
Thank you, Malusinka, for this enlightening and unsentimental portrait of your brother and your growing-up years. I think it explains you in some ways, if that makes any sense.
OK, I had to come back immediately and make sure you know I like you and that "explains you" comment means that I think you are intelligent and direct and absolutely without self-pity. Your comments on OS are among the most reliable around, imo, in terms of trustworthiness. I always know you're telling the truth as you know it, you're amazingly incisive, and I usually agree with you.
My older brother has autism. Not Asperger’s, not mild autism, but louis vuitton bag the head-banging, knuckle-biting sort. He cracked the plasterboard wall of his room with his head. He’d whack it so hard I was schmuck convinced that the front of the forehead has no feeling. I’d touch mine sometimes, but I could feel my fingers. Maybe the senses there are only superficial? I did a few test bangs, which barely hurt (and barely hit) but I never h thomas sabo
Thank you so much for the beautifully written article. I have tears in my eyes as I write this. My oldest child, a boy, has very severe mental illness. While his diagnosis is different from autism, his behavior can often be the same (prone to sudden outbursts of rage, etc). I work tirelessly on his behalf: doctors, therapy, medication, IEPs, school districts, special child care, etc. And I do this as a single, working parent. I often worry that my daughter is getting lost in the fray and I'm scared that I am not able to give her all of what she needs. It's so hard to know how all of this impacts her. I can't tell you how much it means to me that someone in her place is able to reflect on the experience in a positive way. Thank you thank you thank you
I have a sister in her 40's with a disorder that often seems to have autistic-like components. She lives in a great group home. It took a long time to find such a good one but it is a blessing to her and those of us in the family who care for her.
Thank you for sharing this, with such clarity of vision and complete lack of sentimentality.
malusinka, I'm sorry I'm slow sometimes to come to really important posts, but this is well written. It reminds me of a good friend of mine who is a teacher right now, whose parents also had a child with special needs. He, too, felt emotionally neglected. His parents were college professors.

I can imagine that it would be hard for parents to weigh things out between the children, when one requires so much more attention. But this is an important subject that I've rarely (except with my other friend) heard discussed.

thanks for this essay.
Belinda: Ah, but sometimes it's so hard to get beyond the small hurts to the real picture.

Vanessa: diagnosis for autism is variable and has changed over time. Some people label my brother as having PDD-NOS, not autism. I think there are a lot more supports for families with special needs children now. When my brother was diagnosed, the options were keep him at home with no education or therapy or send to an institution.

Lainey: Wow, I'm flattered, that's quite a compliment!

Bessy: no, I didn't read it. Sometimes I avoid the depressing.

Julien: I think the trick is to communicate with your daughter, make sure she understands why you're pre-occupied or stressed.

Nerd: My parents started the search for a home for my brother over 5 years ago. A lawsuit and an appeal, later and I think he's on a long waiting list.

Brianna: Straight As, that's fantastic.

Ladyslipper: Thanks for stopping by.

Mark: Thanks for the kind words.

Dolores: I don't think parents weigh things. A crisis hits and they get absorbed. We had a flood over the Christmas holidays and came back to a house with no ceiling on the second floor and 3 inches of water on the ground floor. The stress of trying to salvage and dry stuff and get the house repaired just made it hard to have much attention and sympathy for my kids. I made up for it by explaining and, of course, it was pretty obvious that there was a crisis. Luckily, the side of the house where their bedrooms were was not affected.
After reading your comments on my recent story, I was curious to read what your experience was like growing up with an autistic brother. Many of your memories remind me of my own childhood growing up with Bobby. We, too, experienced the head banging with him, although his preference was to bang his head with his fists. The pre-puberty and teen years were the worst for his aggression.

Was your family subjected to any of the "refrigerator mother" and "poor parenting" theories of autism? These were rampant when Bobby was growing up (1960s and 70s) and caused tremendous stress in our family.

Thanks for posting this and for your honest writing on a difficult topic.