Look, I was trying – really trying – to keep my mouth shut. But the assault on manhood continues unabated. It goes on and on, like the girl who won’t stop talking frantically about her cat, or her Pilates. To the point at which you make the remarkable decision that it’s actually not worth trying to bed her. Just not worth the price of submission.
The worst kind of attack on masculinity, of course comes from within. That fifth column that insists on chipping away at the things that make men… men. Like the fact that we don’t wear makeup. Men do not wear makeup. That’s for ladies. It’s supposed to be a self-evident fact.
I was at a normal business-social cocktail function, in a normal city. A man in his early 30s, with whom I’d been in a normal meeting hours earlier, greeted me heartily, lager in hand. He had questions about the proposed deal and the companies involved, but I couldn’t stop staring at his eyes. They were outlined in black. He was wearing eyeliner.
What’s wrong with your eyes? Have you been injured? “It’s guyliner, mate. Makes me look fresh after a long day.” I was appalled. Does your wife know you do this? “Yah, she wasn’t too chuffed I was using hers, so I got my own.”
It turns out that major cosmetics manufacturers are enthusiastically enabling this nefarious new front in the battle to emasculate us, and to undermine another bastion of maleness. They sell not just eyeliner, but blush, concealer and foundation. For men. MAC seems to be a leading offender. Jean Paul Gaultier has an entire line of testicle-shrinking products it calls Monsieur, as it slowly transforms us into madame.
Men don’t have many natural rights left, granted to us by God or Nature or both, and that’s fine. Too many of the old natural rights just turned us into walking hindquarters anyway. But one privilege that had survived the ages was the right to look like Hell, and still be seen as tremendous, titanic and worthy of deference. We could let our hair go gray, or fall away. Our skin could become pasty and dry. These were badges of courage, battle scars, announcing our stamina and prowess in work, our command of resources and our power in the realm.
Gentlemen, I am extending a hand to you. Join me not simply in resisting, but also in condemning “man-makeup”. This is a bad thing for men. It needs to be crushed. And we’re good at crushing things, such as beer cans and other people’s dreams.
For the record, there are some personal grooming steps in which it is acceptable to indulge. You may use conditioner on your hair. A masculine cologne is not only attractive to (the right kind of) women, but also proclaims a traveling space around you as your personal territory, thereby increasing your power. If you absolutely must, you may use some kind of moisturizing goop on your face at night, but only if you never tell anyone.
But if and when you encounter an erstwhile member of the Man Club sporting makeup worthy of a representative of the gender with which we spend so much time trying to celebrate la difference, it is imperative that you follow this process:
1. Express shock and concern.
2. Inquire about the individual’s gender identity. (If that’s at issue, abandon discussion. There may be legitimate things at work here, and we’re defending masculinity, not promoting homophobia or trans-whatever-it’s-called.)
3. Apply derision, thickly.
If we fight this abhorrence now, with force, there is hope that it will die away in time, like those ill-fated “man-skirts” from the 1980s, and talking after sex.


Salon.com
Comments
In fact...almost all men.
Almost.
(Sorry...I will love Adam Ant till the day I die, fey or no.)
Missed you.
On the eyeliner thing, I will admit I don't want to share my make-up table with any man...
But having spent enough time around musicians of all stripe, I will forgive the occasional on-stage (as in, you're at work and it's the tools of the trade) smudges of eyeliner...
Anyhoo, I gotta go with icemilkcoffee on this one, lol
Pawed!
But what about football players with smudges of greasepaint under their eyes? And commandos in camouflage make-up? And Indians in wild west re-enactments? And mimes? ...Okay, I'll give you mimes.
I mean women go without it, men with it. It's fast and loose out there.
"Fast and loose"? That describes the date you enjoyed at the time, but who left you itching and requiring medical attention. It does not describe the carved-in-stone rules of manhood.
Grrrr! Theeere's the growl.
And Lord I've missed you. You're my methadone.
Howdy, Mrs. Michaels. Delighted to see you. Methadone, is it? Couldn't I be a substance with rather a more sense-expanding effect? And a more benign connotation?!
Incandescent, I don't disagree with you about the attractiveness of restraint in makeup use among the distaff set. Still, artfully applied, don't you think it can accentuate and enhance the difference?
Mumbletypeg... I'm with you now. A vampire. But they're supposed to be all gothic and creepy, aren't they?
I can, however, think of a couple of places, and a couple of scenarios, and a couple of ensembles that would rejoice in the art. In fact, I'm thinking of some now. And grinning.
Luluandphoebe... you do have my sympathies. Have you considered moving?
Just so you know, you'll have to pry the John Varvatos Pore Refining Mattifier (TM) out of my cold, dead hands.
However: Some manly men look amazingly manly in eye liner. I'm an old-school goth (in my heart, at least), and eye liner and black lipstick just go with the territory. One of the sexiest photos of my husband EVER is with a shaved head, eyeliner, and a leather jacket, all ready to go clubbing. Yum.... :D
Persephone, that boy could rock him some makeup, couldn't he?
I'm a tolerant man, and I want full credit for tolerating the utter wrongness of your comment - and for smiling at you as I fight my rising gorge.
Now, shoo, before I eat you. With this recession, it's a canine-eat-canine world, you know?
Then there's earrings. The old man always said "I better not catch you wearing an earring unless you're a pirate." Back in the good old days when men were still men, the only latter-day pirates wearing an earring were butt pirates.
I'm also not a fan of all the other piercing. When I see a young lady with a tongue-post, my immediate thought is that she thinks it pays to advertise. Maybe it does, but not in my neighborhood.
Then there's cosmetic surgery which is waaaay up for men. And let us not forget Rogaine and hair plugs, etc, etc, etc. At least guys can lie about these things and maybe get away with it, but makeup?!! Nope. Not. Never.
What's this world coming to, Tom said, brushing his shoulder length locks.
I was forced to wear makeup in the Army. We called it "face paint." Is this acceptable? Does the fact that we were crawling around in the woods with guns looking to shoot people negate our unfortunate face makeup?
Tom, I share your appreciation of women stepping fresh from the shower. In fact, I believe that was the occasion and location of my most recent arrest, at a spa in Arizona.
(1) "like the girl who won’t stop talking frantically about her cat, or her Pilates." I resemble that remark.
(2) You got it mostly right in the title---real men don't wear makeup, unless they are on a movie or television set and are being paid handsomely to do so.
http://gizmodo.com/5092694/man-bra-keeps-your-moobs-in-check
Gah! Rated for crushing beer cans and other people's dreams.
JustJuli, we men are happy to be of service, whenever you need something crushed. A threatening scorpion, for example. Or a stable banking system. Just dial 6-2-6 (M-A-N) on any phone. We'll be there, with boots on.
(It's also a complete and total pain in the ass to learn to apply, melts into your eyes and burns, clogs up your tear ducts and causes stys, and, IMHO, not worth the effort except for Halloween and Mardi Gras.)
Anddddd this posting made front page. So sad! I'll be damn!!! Simply NOT rated!!!
All the same, I can hardly imagine having to fight any guy I'd want to call mine for access to the bathroom mirror each morning.
That's how you know he can't be trusted. Word.
Two words, MTN. Johnny Depp. I rest my case.
Welcome back, MTN, I missed you!
I agree wholeheartedly about the man make-up. I dislike most of the slide into metrosexuality. It needs to end. Can a man be a gentleman without being a primper? Surely.
Now, to the issue - while I am unlikely to fall for a guy who's more made up than me, I do go for guys with long hair in a big way. THAT used to be the dividing line between men and sissies. It seems to me you are just redefining that line in the sand that keeps getting washed away by the tide of fashion. Men are men, no matter what they draw on their face. It's the equipment that counts. And how they use it.
And also, it might be a good thing that men feel like they have to work at looking good, since that "fresh out of the shower" look is rarely achieved with just a shower. (Hours at the gym, skin toner, hair treatments, etc, etc. ) Girls, am I right here?
Cuticle cream can go either way.
In the meantime....
Rrrrrrrrated!!!!
Just so you know, you'll have to pry the Maybeline Eyelectric Color Collection (TM) out of my cold, dead hands.
"Your sister's titties."
Seriously, let's read some Raymond Chandler and put this nonsense behind us.
Nowadays, the operative word is low-maintenance. Whose got time to stand in front of a mirror? I yam what I yam.
skeptic... nail polish! Don't make me write another rant!
peppermint, mock the defence of masculinity, will you? Please address your mind, madam, to the fact that this is a multi-front conflict, and men are being pecked to death by ducks (or other, equally silly title of a PJ O'Rourke book).
Hi, Voicegal. Johnny Depp? Depp as a validation of man-makeup? I think not. You just want to jump Depp. The eyeliner just happens to be there. (grin)
BTW - I have worn makeup on stage and I'm pretty good at applying it, so I guess I've crossed that line. Come to think of it, I've also worn it while heavily armed and practicing calling in air strikes.
MTN -good to see you back.
I like your new avatar, by the way. Very "spring-y" and cheerful. Suits you.
Ardee, nothing wrong with longer hair, as long as a fella doesn't look like a girl. My own mane is a bit long and shaggy, and I make no apologies, even in the boardroom.
(Adam ant was hot, and I suspect Prince wears it too, also hawt!)
I found a present for you mantalk.
You might like it.
As a man who used to wear eyeliner regularly and was constantly asked "you ain't queer are you boy? I don't like queers!" (being in my home state of Alabama, this happened a lot. It was usually followed by a threat of violence implicit or explicit, depending) I'm hoping this topic is pure satire along with comments about "butt pirates."
See my response to this question back in the day was "Do you want your friends to know a man w/ makeup on beat the shit out of you? Coz if you do, we can discuss what you think about me being queer or not outside."
Seeing as my big, strong self was obviously big and strong the conversation usually ended there. When it didn't some men (oddly enough with long flowing girly locks of hair most of the time) wound up w/ a limp. I'm just saying, if you're going to confront people about their personal style habits while ridiculing them and questioning sexuality, hope they aren't naturally violent and/or sensitive.
I feel you, dude, but what you said? Only in some parts of the world, and even in many of those it was recently different. If you were an upper class male in medieval/renaissance western Europe, you wore makeup and stockings, at least in some settings. In the orient men wore eyeliner and shadow and other stuff if they were higher class. In the ancient east ditto.
But yeah, unless you're a crossdresser/tv/ts (which is fine) eyeliner on men is... viscerally disconcerting? :)
Still, folks be doing they thang till they get a different thang they wanna do. Whatchu gonna do about it, 'cept pick your company?
I wouldn't be worried. Can't see too many het (or man-seeking bi) women giving any kind of edge to the eyelined male over the natural man. Some, no doubt, but not many overall. The barbarians are not quite at the gate just yet. :-)
Take a hike, breeders.
Either way, I think the definition of masculinity is going to have to start involving an element of weakness if it is so easily undermined by a kohl pencil.
Also, I have a thing against guys with chick hair. Simple long hair is fine on some guys. But layered and highlighted hair like Keith Urban or Zac Efron is just too much. I don’t want a man who spends more time on his hair than me.
Oh, and Rob’s mime comment was hilarious!
First and foremost, REAL MEN, of which there are very, very, very few, wear, do, say, and think whatever the hell they want to, nor do they feel it necessary to explain their behavior, tastes, values, etc. to anyone.
But let me define "real man". A real man is a gentleman as in the classical definition of a gentleman. And such a man is a nearly extinct creature. Too many men these days, worldwide, are simply crude barbarians.
Remember, too, as men are further "emasculated": men control the governments, the militaries, weaponry, the banks, the money, the land, the courts, the professions, most of the world's business, Wall Street, Congress, most governorships, on and on and on....
Men have absolute control over just about everything, and women are whores and blame targets. But remember guys, this is the world YOU created!!!! Women as whores and blame targets are YOUR creations!!!!! (And too many women, to my constant disappointment, accept these male definitions of women!)
But, poor emasculated men!!! Boo-hoo-hoo-hoo for men assaulted by a world THEY control!! And by the way, based entirely, solely, and only on genital organs, and according to the leading expert on male sexuality in this nation, Dr. Sherman Silber, men should wear skirts (those Scots, my ancestors, got it right: "Our balls are swinging free!") and women should wear pants...again, based solely on maintaining the health and function of genital organs. So, there. And isn't this simple logic?
The Egyptian pyramid crews went on strike once because they ran out of Kohl eyeliner. Turns out that it helped to cut the glare. Now maybe a big, hunky Egyptian pyramid construction worker could pull such a stunt.
But anorexic, pasty boys...nahhhh.
I’m just saying, once you get started using "product", no matter how you get hooked, a dangerous slope you are on!
Now I go leave blog thing to special folk who understand hard stuff.
Man thank you and go put band-aid on sore knuckles. Must stop dragging.
I remain, to this day, a sucker for a man in makeup.
Eddie Izzard can throw me down onto the pillows anyday.
:-P
Verbal... Verbal, when you put it that way, I think the only sane male response is: Please pass the CoverGirl.
That crap ain't never going on my face. The only way I will accept any makeup is if I'm going to be filmed. And then, I accept it as part of the job. Other than that? Forget it.
I was feeling all bad after Christian yelled at me, called me names and tried, incorrectly, to correct my grammar. (Those smart people should be careful to consult... what do you call that book that tells you what words mean? right, a dictionary... before they attempt to beat people with a vocabulary stick.)
But now I feel terrific! Thank you.
A man has to know where to draw the line.
As long as it isn't around his eyes. :-D
Welcome back. I didn't miss you. Nah. That'd be namby-pamby.
*Thumps MTN on the shoulder*
There ya go.
You said: "...as recently as 1783 "abhorrence" was used as a noun." The problem, you see, is that "abhorrence" is just that - a noun. A noun with two meanings. Either a feeling of extreme repugnance, or the object of that feeling.
How would you prefer to use "abhorrence", other than as a noun? Do tell.
Now, on to another matter. Was your comment about my gender identity cues forming in the 1700s a crack about my age? I hope not. Not only am I young man in the very prime of my vigor, but I am also strongly opposed to predjudice based on age.
Age-ism, of course, is a very bad thing. An abomination. An execration. Dare I say, an abhorrence, even.
Christian, forgive my high spirits, but there are few things more satisfying than to witness the utter self-demolition of a mean-spirited snob.
Let me say, though, I hate being dragged in by those felines. They think they're better than canines, because they poop in a box, and have English degrees...
I'd really like to know.
Welcome back!
Yes, I am fickle, but I don't wear eyeliner either. And I'm going to step into the shower now...
Also, many of my male students wear makeup, it is much more mainstream today. I mean, look at Adam Lambert. Is he straight? Gay? Do I care? No. What he is is hot.
That large piece of lumber on your shoulder must be so heavy a burden to carry that it makes you incapable of recognizing satire - often self-mocking - from someone who prefers a good chuckle over a painfully earnest screed.
Gun club conservative? (grin) I'm a pro- gun control, pro-choice, pro- gay marriage, extremly socially-liberal, fiscally-conservative, Obama-supporting business owner.
I also don't try to start vocabulary duels when I'm obviously unarmed, as some do. I don't construct bizzare, extreme mischaracterizations of people, as some do. And I very much enjoy a good laugh, as some, unfortunately, do not.
Oh, and I think makeup on men looks really, really, really silly.
As I said... try to stay in the shallow end until you can shed your water wings. (chuckle)
I think I like eyeliner on a man, as long as it's not screaming "I'm wearing eyeliner". Course, it's the same for women.
Although...he's kinda mental these days.
How the hell did I overlook you, MTN, in all these long months on OS?
I'm glad that's been remedied!
Do you ever laugh? Do you ever laugh at yourself? I do, and it's a Hell of a lot of fun.
You're throwing your labels at a hetero guy who thinks love is more important than just about anything, and therefore supports gay marriage, with gusto. No homophobia here, my friend.
So keep your pamphleteering to yourself.
But... men look deeply silly when they wear makeup. (wink) You have no idea how delighted I'd be if you continued to be pissed off and sent me another nasty barrage.