Ray, people will come, Ray. They'll come to Iowa for reasons they can't even fathom. They'll turn up your driveway not knowing for sure why they're doing it. They'll arrive at your door as innocent as children, longing for the past.
…It reminds us of all that once was good and it could be again. Oh, people will come, Ray. People will most definitely come.
-Terence Mann (James Earl Jones), in “Field of Dreams”
Everyone in the media seems puzzled by the “Restoring Honor” rally. “What’s it all about?” they’re asking.
Hundreds of thousands of Americans gathered in Washington. They came because Glenn Beck asked them to, without ever telling them precisely why.
“This really is build it and they will come,” Mr. Beck said in his opening comments, fighting to hold back tears.
And they sure did come, in massive numbers. Ray Kinsella’s Field of Dreams got nothin’ on Glenn Beck’s.
Time Magazine couldn’t figure out why all those people came. There didn’t seem to be any single issue, agenda or outrage that connected all those rally participants. Salon’s Mark Benjamin sounded a bit quizzical as to what united the crowd, with its “strong but vague feelings”.
Even Chris Wallace of Fox News, who scored the only post-rally interview with Mr. Beck, struggled to characterize the rally, and Glenn Beck himself.
“I’m trying to figure you out,” Mr. Wallace said. “In the 40 years that I’ve been in this business, I have to say I’ve never seen anybody quite like you. You’re not a newsman, you’re not a preacher, you’re not a politician… What are you?”
And all this confusion is understandable, because Mr. Beck never made it clear – either in advance, or at the rally itself – what the whole thing was about.
He spoke at length and with passion about God, and the need for Americans to restore the role of God in their lives. He even hinted that something big – something supernatural - was in progress there on the Mall in Washington.
“Something beyond imagination is happening. Something that is beyond Man is happening. America today begins to turn back to God,” he said.
Then Mr. Beck spoke of heroes, and how much we need them.“We have lost too many heroes in this nation. Heroes are just people who stand and do the right thing, usually at their own peril,” he told us.
With this, he segued into an interesting and affecting segment on the military.
“What is it today that America truly believes in? We have very little trust in most of our institutions. But there is one thing that still is 15 points higher – at the top of the list on things America trusts: our military.”
Next, he introduced John T. Carney, Junior, the President of the Special Operations Warrior Foundation (SOWF), which raises money and provides for the families of special forces personnel killed in action. The next speaker was the mother of a lost Air Force special operations officer, who had a very personal, very touching story to tell.
The emotions of the huge crowd were palpable and very real. When Mr. Beck asked people to text a $10 donation to the SOWF, mobile phones appeared in the thousands.
Sarah Palin joined Mr. Beck’s rally and spoke, she said, not as a politician, but as a mother who had “raised a combat vet.”
And the crowd listened respectfully, and they cheered in the right places. And when it was all over, they went home. They went home without a specific task or assignment. None of them, nor any reporters, seemed to be able to say what the rally was all about. But I think it’s very clear.
This certainly was not a Republican rally. Mr. Beck was quite sweeping in dismissing all politics, existing institutions, and both parties.
It wasn’t a Tea Party rally, nor a Sarah Palin rally – though they were both co-opted for a purpose.
It wasn’t a support-the-military rally – though Mr. Beck did want to tie himself to the deep and broad respect and support for the military in this country.
And it wasn’t even a religious rally, steeped though it was in exhortations and incantations.
The rally was about Glenn Beck. Period. The mediator is the message.
Mr. Beck is placing himself, personally, at the center of a vague, inchoate, but potentially powerful movement. A populist identification and alignment. He is gathering people. People who are unsettled, unhappy and worried about much of what they see in America, and in their own lives. People who are well-primed not to look for answers through traditional politics, politicians and political institutions.
Republicans have done some of the work. They have successfully undercut the credibility of the President and his administration. The Tea Party and Sarah Palin have done some of the work. They have decoupled a nascent populist movement from the established political process.
At the “Restoring Honor” rally, Glenn Beck tacitly proclaimed something important. That he is bigger than any of them. It was Glenn Beck who made those hundreds of thousands of Americans gather in Washington, without knowing for sure why they were doing it.
They were doing it for Glenn Beck.
They came because he asked them to. They were beckoned by a man who is certain that today’s America is irredeemably broken. A man who feels so deeply about this certainty – and also his certainty that America can be restored – that he can barely control his emotions. A man with the passion of a messiah.
The rally was about Glenn Beck, his cultural and political influence and power. Where things go now, we don’t know. But this was a big step toward something. To borrow from Buffalo Springfield, there’s something happening here, and what it is ain’t exactly clear.
We don’t know what will happen on Glenn Beck’s Field of Dreams. We don’t know what the agenda is. And we’ll just have to wait to find out, whenever the prophet sees fit to tells us.
Now saying odd things on Twitter: http://twitter.com/ManTalkNow


Salon.com
Comments
Anyone who was truly interested in restoring honor to America would be shot in a heartbeat.
I remember the Viet Nam protest of 1969 at the Reflecting Pool...I was there as a pretty impressionable pre-teenager.
Now THAT rally had a purpose.
Viet Nam War Protest
Also, what Bonnie said.
The references to Mormonism were provided clearly, but unthreateningly. (And the arrival of two Native Americans in traditional garb was timed for this portion of his comments.)
The choice of rally music interested me, too. It was "Hoe-Down", from "Rodeo" by Aaron Copland - a famous cowboy tune, also famous from beef commercials.
It was a meticulously assembled presentation that touched on a number of American things - images, sounds, icons - to which Mr. Beck appears to be consciously tying himself.
And the nature of the rally itself was fascinating: all positive. No anger or outrage, no specific criticisms or call-outs. It was different from Mr. Beck's TV and radio rants. As if he's trying something out.
My overall impression was of someone who has both an immensely strong belief in himself as exceptional and needed, and some kind of plan. And he's working on ways to mobilize people toward that plan through very particular use of certain media, and through subtle manipulation of a range of emotions and identifications.
I'd love to know what the plan is, because there definitely has to be one. You don't invest this level of money and effort just to have an "up with people" pep rally.
As in sports, there are a majority of undecideds who go with the "underdog." Very unpredictable, both in sports and politics.
On Deborah Young's post, I explained my apprehension about Mr. Beck and all he does (and doesn't) stand for. That kind of misguided influence is nothing short of dangerous.
One question that I have and I'm working on a post on this subject, is "What Does Beck Do Now?"
He's assumed the mantle of a leader and he has thousands of followers expecting him to keep up the energy. Beck hasn't come through in the past for other causes that he's touted.
Time will tell.
Words to watch out for, I should think.
Rated.
This is not grass roots, it is the petrochemical elite funding the destruction of any meaningful government. It is fascism aided by a dumbed down populace who given real choices prefer bread and circus.
It is scary.
The thing that I add into my thinking though is what Tim4change mentioned: Glenn Beck isn't smart enough to have pulled this off himself. I have to think that somebody is pulling his strings and is setting him up as a front man.
As a self-idenfied borderline schitzophrenic on medication, Glenn Beck is indeed in a dangerous position. To paraphrase Stephen Colbert, "I've got my Addidas on, and I'm ready to drink the Kool-Aid, Glenn!"
Someday, we'll be teaching this time as a dark dangerous turn in our country's history, like McCarthyism.
You can't predict what a crazy person will do, but you can predict that something indeed is happening here. Be on guard.
That's Frank Rich on it, but his source is the New Yorker article first posted by an Open Saloner:
http://open.salon.com/blog/susanthur/2010/08/25/the_billionaire_brothers_who_are_waging_a_war_against_obama
It might be simple; we could be overthinking this. This may be about Mr. Beck wanting to be something rather than wanting to do something. You know, like he wants to be the messiah when he grows up.
"It's a Wonderful Life" was a movie about a man who selflessly put aside his own ambitions to do the right thing by his family and community and was eventually rewarded through the gratitude of the people he had helped.
"Field of Dreams" was a movie about a self-absorbed man who selfishly put his family at risk to chase a voice in his head and was eventually rewarded through magic. The image that sticks with me is that long line of cars, headed toward the ball field like cows headed home for the afternoon milking.
Your metaphor is apt is so many ways. The whole Glenn Beck/Tea Party phenomenon is definitely the work of magical thinking. His followers are like so many trusting, unthinking cows, heading home to be milked. Or bilked. Or both.
It was about restoring Faith (As in the goodness of God -YHWH, Christ, Allah,etc.-and your fellow man)
and Honor (As in faith in your self ).
I realized something last week while reading and commenting on Koshersalaami’s post on the “Ground Zero Mosque” and noting how outraged everyone was about such an obviously manufactured for effect “News Item” Everyone seems to be so fearfully and rabidly into “Knee-Jerk” “destroy the enemy” mode that they’ve all but forgotten how comforting belonging to a community is.
Towards the end of Koshersalaami’s comments he mentioned that he had an idea about a commercial that he would like to see made.
A camera focuses on a flag, flying over a military cemetery. Taps plays. The camera pans the grave markers showing Crosses, Star of David, … and Crescents indicating respectively, Christians, Jews and Muslims who have given their lives in service to our country. A voice narrates:
"Each Crescent represents a Muslim American soldier who gave his life for his country - Our country. They and their families deserve our undying gratitude. Here's the kind of gratitude they're getting: [cut to a picture within picture, a quick cut of, say, Glen Beck saying something nasty about Islam and Muslims, another few of other political commentators saying the stuff we know they say.] Who made the sacrifices here? Who are the real Americans?"
We all know that American Muslims were killed in the 9/11 attacks. We just need to remind a few people that that's true.”
Koshersalaami
He seemed astounded when I said it sounded like an excellent idea and that I would love to contribute to it if he had any plans to make it.
What it made me realize was that the point I was trying to make is that so long as we let the “News” and the “politicians” make the issues, they will have us beating each other bloody over senseless imponderables, while they steal the country, assured we will never unite in the things we have in common.
We need to stop arguing about who is desecrating whose sacred ground, and remember what makes ground sacred.
Such as instead of fighting about a Mosque, why aren’t we focusing on the common love of country that makes us all, Christians, Jews, Muslims, etc. simply “Americans”
What Beck did was to call for a Family Reunion.
It’s a gathering of the family America.
And If you want to be an American, all you have to do is share the community
Yeah, I hear you, “drink the Tea”
Believe it or not, it’s about communion, not Wine, Kool-aid or Tea
Lot’s of us are tired of being told to hate and being angry all the time.
Beating up on Obama these days is like whipping on the neighborhood smart aleck bully, after he’s already been whipped to sniveling ribbons.
One could surely as easily in 2008 have said of Obama
“I’m trying to figure you out … What are you?- What is this “Hope and Change?”
And all this confusion is understandable, because Mr. Obama never made it clear – either in advance, or up to the election itself – what the whole thing was about.”
I fell for it. I regret my naiveté
Why are you so surprised that your fellow Americans can come together for “Faith and Honor” as readily and as naturally as we came together for “Hope and Change”?
Beck isn’t the Cause.
He’s an effect.
The difference between him and Obama is that Beck knows it.
That’s how he’s becoming a wealthy National Figure.
We may never know for sure if it’s “Why”
But I like having Hope
It's harder all the time, but it takes Faith
"Faith and Honor"
And we need to make Koshersalaami’s commercial
(R)ated for coloring between the lines!
By God, you people sure are confounded. All of these questions on what it is all about. Let’s blame a man and throw accusations through from your ignorant mind. Throw assumptions wildly into the wind and let it be carried to deaf ears that do not want to hear the Truth. You always have to find some evil plot behind everything, which I guess just shows how evil and morally corrupt Progressives really are. A deluded and blind mind cannot understand the way that the Almighty God works. He works through people who are brave and willing enough to stand up for Him against a growing godless society. It is God’s Spirit that will enable your eyes to see and your ears to hear the Truth. Ask Him, you may be knocked down in awe of what God will show you. God transcends politics.
What is it all about? Restoring America back to God!
John 8:32 “Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free."
America isn't broken. It's just turning into something new. But it will break if we don't fix our educational system.
I expect the worst thing about Restoring Honor is its constant reference to God. That horrible word we dare not say would now probably make George Carlin's list, were the other words still on it.
Say what you will about Glenn Beck, and this event, I'm very used to scorn from leftists. It's not easy being right.
I don't write about politics very much. In fact, this may be the first time I've posted something like this here. I'm also not much of a standard carrier for leftist politics. I'm way liberal-libertarian on social issues, but I'm also a dirty capitalist business owner who worries a lot when the state begins to control too much of the economy.
I'm also a churchgoer (albeit an inconsistent one), I believe in God and have great respect for people's faiths.
You don't have to be an activist progressive, liberal, leftist, atheist... or any other particular thing... to be wary of what Mr. Beck appears (to me) to be trying to do.
Huffington Poster Offers $100,000 for Nonexistent Glenn Beck Sex Tape
Beau Friedlander, a Huffington Post contributor and former editor of the failed liberal radio network Air America is offering $100,000 for a nonexistent sex tape featuring Glenn Beck.
His piece predictably went Beck:
Glenn Beck is also a Mormon. It matters. His religion typifies the noble lie that the neocons originally set out to defend against the counterculture--Archie Bunker's America--where a woman's place was in the home and with baby, and an African American's place was in a ghetto. (Mormons revere women much like Hindis do the cow, and they didn't accept African Americans in their ranks at all till 1978--draw whatever inferences you like). [...]
It is time to pop the tea baggers' favorite balloon, and with that in mind I hereby offer to negotiate a $100,000 payday to the person who will come forward with a sex tape or phone records or anything else that succeeds in removing Glenn Beck from the public eye forever. I am not offering the cash myself, but I will broker the deal and/or raise the money for what you bring to the table. (And it better be good.)
If you have the goods, or if you want to contribute to a slush fund to buy more takedowns (probably not tax deductible), please contact me at: glennbecksextape@gmail.com.
Welcome to modern day liberalism: if you can't beat 'em, smear 'em!
rated.
Like Ray in Field of Dreams, everything about Beck is fictional -- but I have another character in mind -- Larry "Lonesome" Rhodes, the facile cum despicable character played by Andy Griffith in A Face in the Crowd.
Keith Olbermann makes regular reference to "Lonesome Rhodes" Beck. Both Beck and Rhodes are jaded, self-serving, self-aggrandizing -- and despite their crude, clownish behavior, both are potentially dangerous. Beck has the potential to be another Huey Long or Joe McCarthy or Jim Jones, and yes, even another Hitler.
Stay tuned -- or preferably not.
~nodding~
Good post by the way, well worth the big EP.
Rated by a lowly Tink.....**Wanders off**
Seems to me that this rally ought to have been held in a beer hall.
I do believe that the ulterior motives are exactly as they were in that other beer hall.
This entire ruse has been choreographed with precisely the same song and dance as that to which Godwin referred however, this comparison is legitimate and diabolically correct.
There is nothing to be afraid of, people. Period.
Wade, Hitchens is a smart man.
Veronica, thank you, but I think I'll return to writing silly junk food for the brain. Politics makes me unhappy and jumpy. Until it becomes history. Then it's interesting.
XJS, I think it's ultimately about power, too. Wish I knew what the intent was.
Belinda, I hope you're right and I'm wrong.
Dear reader I married him, the "child" aspect has occurred to me, too. Watching Mr. Beck, I sometimes think of a teenager flexing newly-grown muscles, saying "Look how much I can lift!" Very pleased with himself, and thinking what he can do with his newfound power.
But in addition, Mr. Beck has access to very great resources. And the nature and tone, the symbols at the heart of the rally, and its meticulously thought-out presentation seem to suggest there's some kind of plan to take Mr. Beck to a different level, with a different intent. It feels like more than just an effort to boost his ratings.
"Standing up to the Likes of Glenn Beck and his Gang of Thugs"
http://open.salon.com/blog/mauibrad/2010/08/30/finally_a_democrat_standing_up_to_glenn_becks_gang_of_thugs
It seems that some seem to think that God has sent Glenn Beck to speak for Him.
I don't think so.
Satan and Glenn have more of a connection.
I hope people see this before it's too late.
Yes, we have a black President.
Don't be afraid.
He is a good man, and he is trying to help us.
The wealthy only care about more money.
They certainly don't care about you.
But those things will come. Never doubt it. Right now he is capitalizing on the unease felt by Americans at the collapsing American Empire. He is building a legion of followers who are awaiting direction.
When his masters let him in on where he is to take his troops, America will have its Crystal Nacht.
^R^++
"They came because he asked them to. They were beckoned by a man who is certain that today’s America is irredeemably broken. A man who feels so deeply about this certainty – and also his certainty that _______ can be restored – that he can barely control his emotions. A man with the passion of a messiah.
"The rally was about _____ ______, his cultural and political influence and power. "
Could have been written in 1938, about a similar figure with similar methods and ambitions.