Man Talk Now's Blog

Testosterone Ain't Hormone Pollution
MAY 25, 2011 2:23PM

Women Want Sex with Unhappy Men: Study

Rate: 20 Flag

Unhappy is sexy 

Photo from University of British Columbia, via CBC News

 

Everyone who knows me is well aware that I keep a close eye on the latest in research about men and women.

 

What you may not know is that I also adapt my approaches to women, according to what the latest research tells me. I’m very scientific about seduction.

 

This week’s research guidance comes from a study by investigators at the University of British Columbia, Canada. In a scholarly article published online in the American Psychological Association journal Emotion, the Canadian researchers discovered that women are not attracted to smiling men.

 

A number of women reviewed different photos of men. The female study participants were shown photos of men wearing different facial expressions:

 
  • Happy (smiling).
  • Proud (with arms raised overhead).
  • Ashamed (with eyes downcast).
  • Neutral (staring straight ahead, expressionless).

The women were then asked to rate the photos for sexual attractiveness. The study results found that ladies liked the proud and ashamed men most. They liked the happy and neutral men least.

 

Lead researcher Jessica Tracy told Reuters: "Men who smile were considered fairly unattractive by women. So to the extent that men think that smiling is a good thing to do if they want to be found sexually attractive, our findings suggest that's not the case."

 

Now, I don’t argue with science. Especially psychological science, no matter how often it contradicts itself. I just do what science tells me.

 

So I’m working on a new script to use with the ladies, in order to keep my mattress bouncing.

Me:

Hello, my name is Man. I am tortured and brooding, and suffer from feelings of shame.

 

Woman:

 

Oooh, tell me more about yourself.

Me:

I am unhappy, but also triumphant, bold and proud.

 

Woman:

 

I can hardly stand it! I find you very sexually attractive.

 

Me:

(smiling) Hey, that’s great! Maybe you and I could…

Woman:

 

Oh, wait. No, you just lost me there. I don’t think you’re my type after all.

 

Me:

 

It figures. Life is all about pain and disappointment. I’m going back to my dark apartment, drink a bottle of something, and think unpleasant thoughts about people who are lesser than I.

 

Woman:

 

Take me with you! I must have you now!

 

 [Later, at my place] 

Woman:

I really enjoyed having sex with you, Man.

 

Me:

 

Of course you did. I am simply titanic in every way. But my conquest of you does not please me. I remain unhappy. Leave me now. I must brood.

 

Woman:

 

I’ll be back tomorrow, you irresistible hunk of manhood.

 

Me:

 

I’ll look forward to it! Uh, I mean… I will anticipate your return with a sense of foreboding. At the appointed time, I will perform my duty in elevating you to ecstasy. But I won’t enjoy it.

 

Woman:

 

That’s it, I’m moving in!

  

Now saying odd things on Twitter: http://twitter.com/#!/ManTalkNow

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Can't talk now. I have to go glower seductively at some women.
It's okay to smile if you don't show your teeth. Is that you in the photos?
No, Sarah, that's not me. I wear fitted T-shirts.

Can't show my teeth? That's not fair. I have such nice teeth.
Sounds like a good plan. You know we all need a project, and depressed men are like a house that always needs renovating.... Depressed men NEED sex more, to feel good about themselves. Happy men already figured out that beer and football was all they have to have, right? :) Please keep me updated with your field research. Are Mimes considered unhappy men? they certainly never say anything that could turn a woman off.....
can I get that in writing? I'm so damned brooding and depressed that I actually block out the sun, I never smile and still I can't get sex.
I love tortured and brooding mal-adjusted men..that is why I used to only date Quant Jocks...I was the key to unlock their secret inner selves...bout time someone figured this out.
(sigh) You people aren't right in the head. I'm convinced of it.

Oryoki: Beer and football are excellent things, but they can't compare to intimacy with a woman. The proper sequence is:

1. Play football with woman.
2. Drink beer with woman.
3. Sin with woman.

And smile throughout each activity.

bobbot: Maybe you need to move to British Columbia? ;)

Snarky: Stop dating brooding men! They suck the life out of you. I don't know... maybe that's why so many women seem to get hot over vampires?
Remember, these were Canadian women.
What that really says is that women want to feel useful. More sex= less wars. For most women, marriage is a wasted life.
Will: I know! It hurts my head to think about it.

And what about this? When women are attracted to me and have sex with me, it makes me very, very happy. And ebullient! Is that going to drive them away?
u got a pair kid. the book that will give u more info than u need is "Brain Sex," (don't ask any more) Freud said it with "anatomy is destiny," but that's only the beginning. i don't think u get who i am yet.
I like smiling faces - other women here too like smiling faces - infact we have a term for it "hanshi-khushi" for a man is an attractive term/ So it must be cultural after all those Canadians are still ruled by the Queen and we heard the Brits believe in not wearing their hearts on their sleeve pr at least tht kind of thing is considered to be a virtue in your part of the world :)
A brooding man in India - that looks proud and absorbed or depressed would attarct the "boudis" - the married women that are looking for easy prey - married but dont get enough sex types , you know? Your posts alwasy make me laugh. R~
Another survey about women; are these fat women, or women that wear horrible perfume as per the last women you wrote about.. these are just strange women who like unhappy men? Do the surveys you read ever say anything good about women? Just askin'.. Try to keep that mattress bouncin' I just read a survey that says women love men who are scientific about that.
Harry's Ghost: Why is marriage a wasted life for most women? Detail required!

Ben Sen: "Brain Sex" got it. I'll look for it on Amazon. Sounds interesting.

Then you said: " i don't think u get who i am yet." Well... that's probably true. Will it blow my mind when I find out? In a good way or a bad way?

Rolling: Thanks for the kind words - and even more for the good advice about Indian women! Next time I'm in Bangalore, I'll be ready to brood and pout them right into my arms. ;)
I yearn to ask in person rita sibr if she knows a better hillbilly pickup line?
I love picking up farmer and taking then with a six pack and fat abs for a joyride.
It's joy. Go for a night cruise in a bumpy Open PU. What fun to ride over groundhog holes.
Maybe She hop in truck?
Rita: If you keep making comments like this, I'm going to start getting the impression you don't like my blog. That would make me sad. Which would be bad overall, but would have the virtue of attracting Canadian women.

I like your hat, by the way. I wish more women would wear hats. I think they look nice.
I seem to recall that, when I was a college boy, right after marathon sex I would walk down the street with a big ol grin and girls would be attracted to me more than at any other time.
(sigh)
loFl! This could explain some of my past success Man.
Only pride works in the barnyard. I've tested both approaches, and have the scars to prove it. Ever see a rooster try to smile? Ain't pretty, I've been told.
Hi there

you like me

i like you

if we are going to do this

let us both together

put up a large sum

(a tontine)
noah tawls: Without getting too specific, I've noticed that phenomenon myself on occasion. ;)

tr ig: Naw, your success is due to your being a wild man who women feel is dangerous... but not to them. I'd call that a sweet spot.

Chicken Man: Are roosters' smiles as rare as hens' teeth?
Because women usually marry for the security or other ill-advised reasons, taking themselves out of play. Then they're trapped, not feeling they're doing anyone any real good (since they did not marry for love) with no way out. As time passes the harder it is to get out and stand on your own again.

I knew this guy who went to Cocoa beach and scored like crazy with married babes because they were all dying inside. But most married women are not willing to risk that sort of honest statement on their lives.
@Harry's Ghost: Love when you're in your twenties is very different from love when you've been married 20+ years. I think most women marry for love - the kind of wild, romantic passion that typifies the early part of a relationship. That kind of love disappears very quickly once the bills come piling in, not to mention the babies. So yeah...a lot of women who've been married for a while are unhappy and unfulfilled.

As for smiling or not smiling...depends on the guy, the situation...and the country, apparently.
The one thing that no man (or woman either) can state with any certainty at all, is, "Women like a man who........"

I know of no way to be more wrong, more of the time, than to make such a generalization about the (sometimes) fair sex. To make it within the actual hearing of a woman is even more ill advised. And can be painful......

;-)
.
This is news. They used to say that women go for the happy guy because he looks like he's getting some. Great dialog. R
I followed Kerry the editor to see what former poster/commenter `
`
Thoth wrote.
He seek forgiveness?
Thoth ask who?
Ophra Winfrey?
Thoth write too?
Oy Memoir Oops?
Troth?
Ya a Manhattanite?
This is news? This research merely confirms what poster peddlers have known for a long, long time -- moody sells. Just look at the brooding faces on posters of Brando or James Dean or early Johnny Depp.
My rule of thumb, if a guy isn't smiling during sexyz, then he isn't enjoying it, so I go do something else. If he complains, then I know he definitely doesn't like it, and I stop offering altogether. It's very simple.
Bangalore is a hep place - what I said applies to little towns :)

B'lore is diff.
You say you keep track of everything to do with the latest research in affairs of the Man and Woman, well, what I wrote about is not about latest research par se, but it could lead to some modern research easily - when you have time, try and give my post on India and Sex a read. It might amuse you. I don't think there is any precedent in the epics of any other culture regarding such matters - is there?
pppffffttt!
there is nothing sexier than a man who doesnt take himself too seriously. if i wanted broody angsty types i would sleep with poets... which i dont do.... errr anymore.
Proud and pouty? Ugh.
Further proof that I am an anomaly. Give me the mischievous eye-twinkle and the lopsided grin. Mr. Rochester and other melancholy midnite moor wanderers always made me want to shake them and say BUCK UP, dude!
greenheron, we're on the same page, you and I. "Mischievous" is one of my middle names. I have a few. One of them is "Lester", I think. I don't use that one.

Mary, quite so. "Proud and pouty"... well, it's certainly not my own style. I tend more toward the "pompous and playful". Or "irritating and irrepressible". Or maybe "affable a-hole." And, certainly, "seductively stupid".
My take is that the arrogant but tortured male persona is a classic brittle personality construction, representing intense vulnerability: he needs someone who will both bolster his ego and resolve his misery. Mr Neutral/Happy doesn't look needy enough. When insecure, immature women are seeking a love connection among strangers, being needed,— even if its due to maladjustment — is a big draw.

The equation also works in reverse: the childlike, virginal young woman needs a big strong man to take care of her: hence the intense appeal to certain types of (generally, immature) men.
I tend to be attracted to happy men but they are occasionally broody or moody. A truly unhappy man wouldn't light any of my fires.
Kathy, I think that's eminently sensible. I imagine I'd say the same about women.

M. Chariot, that's an astute and concise summation. With respect to the "childlike, virginal" woman and the "big, strong man"... that kind of pairing is fairly common in certain business circles, with both first and second wives.

From a male perspective, I find that pretty much incomprehensible. I like a girl who knows some things I don't. And if she's also got a bit of a "history"? Well, I won't chide her for being like me. My hypocrisy only extends so far.
I would propose that any woman with a "history" like yours be shot on sight.
Ha! Touché, M. Chariot.
As a reasonably cheerful sort, I can't express how much these findings depress me. They imply, hey, wait a minute...
I'm attracted to women who are atrracted to me. That makes me smile. Am I in trouble here? R
Oh be still my heart. I think I shall swoon! hee hee
amusing study but it glosses over various/numerous issues. one, maybe a big smile is a turnoff but a small one is. also, smiles do not reveal how happy someone is. so the issue of whether women are attracted to happy men is not really studied by this experiment. but its a worthwhile question. you have to be very careful about the distinctions in scientific studies, huh. the average public is not very astute on the subtleties.