Maria Stuart

Maria Stuart
Location
Howell, Michigan, USA
Birthday
February 17
Company
mariastuart on Twitter
Bio
Maria Stuart is a journalist without a print job who lives with her husband and son in southeast Michigan. She is currently working on Livingstontalk.com, a hyper-local information and conversation site.

Maria Stuart's Links

Salon.com
NOVEMBER 5, 2009 9:59AM

Winning versus happiness: Are we confused?

Rate: 8 Flag

In life, there are always winners and losers. I don’t know why that is, only that it is. For someone to win the lottery, a lot of someone elses — always including me, it seems — have to lose. For sharks to stay alive, they’ve got to eat smaller fish or swimmers off the coast of Florida. It’s the yin and yang of life, the scales of justice balancing.

So many of us, though, confuse winning with happiness. Sometimes, those lottery winners end up broke and miserable, while the lottery losers like me muddle through life much higher on the happiness scale.

Maybe it’s expectations too great that beat us down. Maybe, just maybe, we’ve not learned the difference between winning and happiness.

Given that, does it seem that instead of spending so much time and energy on learning to win, that we instead learn how to be happy? We seem so preoccupied with producing winners in life. And the thinking goes that the key to being a winner is a high level of self-esteem.

But prison inmates tend to have pretty high levels of self-esteem, according to a study from several years ago, which got a lot of attention. The study contradicted the popular theory that criminals commit crimes because they have a low sense of self-worth.

This study found that prisoners actually have extremely high levels of self-esteem, which makes sense. Why on earth would someone commit a crime if they thought they were going to get caught? Criminals commit crimes because they think they will get away with them. Criminals always think they’re smarter than everyone else.

Think about it. Why would anyone decide that the best place to live is a big cage in which anyone walking by can see them sitting on the toilet? That lifestyle has no appeal for this writer, and the thought of it has occasionally been the one thing that’s kept her on the straight and narrow.

Another study found that bullies have heightened senses of self esteem, that they bully not because they loathe themselves, but because they think themselves superior and loathe others.

So, prison inmates and bullies tend to have high levels of self-esteem. Why then, do we want our kids to participate in activities meant to raise their levels of self esteem? Are we just asking for trouble?

We’ve never pushed our kid to participate in anything. Will’s tried lots of activities in his 10 years of life while sticking with one: piano, which makes his mother happy. He’s also tried soccer, tennis, swimming and magic, and while he’s not the most athletic kid, he possesses a wonderful attitude, one which I am quite sure isn't inherited from me: The kid has fun, no matter what he does.

baseballboyWill recently finished up a short season of fall baseball — or “baseball light,” as I call it — in which no scores are kept and no trophies are given. This shortened season is for kids who regularly play ball and want the extra practice, or kids like Will, who’ve never played organized ball and who’d like a taste of it before committing time and energy to a regular season.

In this shortened season, the pressure to win is supposedly off kids. As well as not keeping score, there are fewer innings played, and a rule that magically ends an inning if the entire batting order makes it to the plate. Each kid gets to play every position. There are plenty of great assistant coaches/dads who spur the kids on with “great job,” “good eye,” and “super effort.”

It’s a great experience, truly, but I think we kid ourselves. Despite the work and rules to mask who wins and loses, the adults know full well which team ends up on top. And the kids know it most of all.

“We won,” my kid said as he got into the car after a game. “The score was 24 to 7.”

“I thought you didn’t keep score,” I said.

Will shrugged.

“I scored twice,” he said. “Did you see me score?”

“Of course I saw you score,” I said.

My kid was ecstatic. Never mind that he got on base twice because the pitcher hit him with the ball, or that he walked his other times at bat. And his teammates scored not because they’re great runners, but because their coaches have them steal bases when the other team drops the ball, which is a lot.

But I say nothing about any of this. I’m just glad my kid got some exercise.

“Are you proud of me, mom,” Will asked as we wait at the traffic light.

“Of course,” I told him. “And I’m especially proud that you actually swung at the ball this game.”

Will smiles.

“It was so much fun,” he said. “I can’t wait for the next game.”

We drove the rest of the way home in silence, each thinking that we were winners. Happy, for sure, but winners nonetheless.

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
The best youth baseball season our older son had was when he played on a team coached by a great guy. He had all the kids enjoying themselves and having fun and pulling for each other. All he parents came to every game.

The next year, we asked to get that coach again. Couldn't: too many requests had already come in for him. (surprise) My son got on another team, the one that won the championship. He was miserable that year, and never played ball again until high school.

You are so right.
I've coached youth baseball and I loved teaching baseball. The competitive egos of many other coaches — parents, was sad to experience. I witnessed many kids walk away from sports because of this. ~R~
It's those big-headed coaches who create the inflated self-esteem in the kids who are talented (and who are susceptible). Sounds like Will has a pretty good Jiminy Cricket on his side -- keeping him from thinking he's better than.

Good post.
My little guy also played fall baseball, and the entire season was an object lesson in happiness v. winning. (They keep score in his league) For the most part, I think the coaches did a good job of encouraging the boys to have fun, but at times I felt like teaching got lost in the pressure to win. My son, who is extremely sensitive to criticism (wonder where he got that from) got so uptight at the plate that he stopped swinging the bat. He drew a few walks, but he also struck out quite a few times as well. Last week, he took a called third strike and walked back to the dugout all dejected. The coaches nearly had to beg him to take his position in the outfield (he regards playing the outfield as a punishment akin to solitary confinement). When his turn to bat approached again, I decided to do something a bit out of the ordinary, something many parents might consider foolish and rash. I walked up to him, put my arm around his shoulders, smiled and said: "If you walk, you're grounded for the weekend." He looked at me like I had lost my mind. "What?" he screamed. "I don't care if you strike out," I said. "But you WILL swing the bat." So he walked up the plate, swung and missed on the first pitch and then belted a rope up the middle. I nearly jumped over the fence with joy. "Yes," I barked and pumped my fist into the air. Of course the second baseman just had to be playing out of position and of course he made a magnificent catch and my son was out. But when my son came into the dugout, he was smiling. I slapped him on the helmet and told him "that was beautiful. I told you that you could hit." Oh, I forgot to tell you. I did sweeten the deal by offering to take him to the Waffle House for an All-Star breakfast (which he adores) if he got a base hit. "Does this mean we're going to Waffle House?" Technically, no. But since it should have been a hit, I would take him anyway. Later, as we rode home he said this to me (keep in mind that he's eleven). "You know what, daddy," he says. "I had an epiphany tonight." Epiphany! Where did that word come from. "I figured out if you don't swing the bat, you can't hit the ball." Now that may sound silly, but there was an awful lot of existential wisdom in that. I was so proud of him, and so delighted that my desperate ploy had seemed to work.
AHP, Chuck -- Coaches (and parents) do make the difference, and how sad that kids quit playing because of the pressure. They should be playing for fun!

skeletnwmn -- Love the Jiminy Cricket!

Mr. Stone -- We need to get our kids together some day. Will loves Waffle House, too. We always stop when we're heading south. Hmmm. Maybe there's a Waffle House meetup in the future! Hope all is well with the freelance stuff.
@ T Michael: Great story! Great job, Dad! Great epiphany, kid!
I played competitive sports until early adulthood and I was extremely competitive. I was successful but lacked self-esteem. I had some success at singing, but lacked the confidence to pursue it. BUT - I was also a goody-two-shoes. Would I have been a better athlete or vocalist if I'd committed some crimes? Eek, hard to say. What if I only wanted to be remotely successful...run a few stop signs, steal some lipstick? Darn. I'll never know. But I'll hazard a guess that you and I are better moms because of our clean record.
:-) Very cute story about your son.
Outside Myself -- Maybe if you had run some stop signs wearing stolen lipstick. Ha!
That would be excellent. There's a state law in Georgia that requires a Waffle House near every interstate exit ramp. At least it seems that way.
I'd-a looked good for my mug shot!
Sounds too cool, Maria. Rminds me when my daughter played sports. It was fun jsut watching them play and the idea was to teach them sportsmanship, not winning.
Well, I think we associate winning with happiness because winning usually comes with an incentive. For males this is women and respect from their male peers. These are two incredibly important things in a young man's life. Hell, most male pursuits are predicated on acquiring these two things!

The question is why do we regale winners with these gifts? What is wrong with the loser? For the winner to exist someone has to lose. Why don't we revere the sacrificial loser as well?

There is an inherent absurdity present in athletic competition. Two teams gunning for the same thing and both teams understand and readily except the fact that only one can achieve this goal--one team has to lose for the other to win. If winning is better than losing then why can't both teams win? This is obvious of course, winning is relative to losing.

Let's not forget about war which usually goes down like this: the men of Country A call into question the manhood of Country B (lack of respect from peers, most times it starts with comparing the sizes of their nuclear penises) and Country B goes to war with Country A and what is the usual justification for the fight? Typically it's to protect the women and the children they look after.

Here's an interesting tidbit--most of our heroes are sacrificial characters (Jesus, Moses, comic book superheroes, etc.)--do we consider them losers?