All Things Inconsiderate

Mark & Otis

Mark & Otis
Location
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Title
His name is Otis
Company
A Boston Terrier
Bio
I'm a human, he's a Boston Terrier. We have a tempestuous love/hate relationship. We spend a great deal of time together on the couch. I watch TV and blog, he mostly sleeps. Yet I'M the one society labels as "lazy". Such bullshit.

MY RECENT POSTS

Mark & Otis's Links

Salon.com
JULY 24, 2009 3:25PM

Dear America: You're Embarrassing Yourself

Rate: 24 Flag

Hi America. This is my first Open Salon post and I thought I’d start off with bang. And as a preface let me say that there’s nothing I dislike more than Canada’s obsession with the difference between our two countries (it’s a one way obsession – like Otis’ love for the neighborhood tabby).

Having said that, let me be frank with you: you’re embarrassing yourself over health care reform.

A few years ago Canada’s persistent navel gazing produced a mini-series on public television that was an American Idol-like contest to proclaim “The Greatest Canadian”. Advocates each week pitched to the public various reasons why so and so deserved the title. You know who won? A prairie Baptist minister and social democratic politician from the 1950’s whose major claim to fame was the formation of the socialized (gasp!) Canadian health care system.

With this in mind, needless to say we as a nation feel pretty strongly about public health care. It’s one of those things we hold up with pride to differentiate ourselves from our neighbours to the south. Which is why, in the last few weeks, the outcry from the Right over Obama’s proposed reforms to your health care system has left us a little confused. And honestly it’s not just us. The British, who have a similar system (with slight differences) to ours, appear to be equally dumbfounded.

I get that you may not want reform (especially if you make more than $250K a year) or just don’t want the Obama version of reform. This may because you genuinely believe it’s not in your interest (which is a weak reason) or because you just really hate Obama (which is a pathology you should probably get checked out).

OR you may just be ill informed. There are lots of places you can go to get simplified facts about the proposal. Many of them are bi-partisan and impartial and I assure you, Fox News is not one of them.

But if you would like me to clear the air about the dreaded “socialized medicine” that British or Canadian systems would bring you, I can tell you a few things for certain. First, there is no bureaucrat standing between you and your doctor. I have had everything from a CAT scan to a colonoscopy (I’ll post that video soon). I’ve had sports injuries and head injuries (a mild concussion). I’ve seen specialists galore, been diagnosed with a common auto-immune disease (celiac disease) and have even started getting annual physicals. There is no man or woman in a suit deciding whether any of these tests or procedures are necessary. That’s what the doctors are for and they’ll all tell you that they don’t check in with a bureaucrat either. You can thank the Hippocratic Oath for that.

Secondly, please stop pimping this one Canadian woman who went to the Mayo Clinic for treatment instead of her local Hospital. She’s become a bit of a public oddity in this country as one of the few Canadians who would suggest that taking out a mortgage to finance her Mayo trip was a better decision than what may have happened had she listened to her Canadian doctors.

And finally: shit happens. I assure this happens as often in an expensive American hospital as a public Canadian one. This system is far from perfect but when your system sucks so bad why are you so intent on using, as a boogey man, one that works so well?

The reality is it’s more tedious and expensive to get a check-up for Otis. Just one more reason he’s a pain in my ass.

Author tags:

canada, health care, news, politics

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Thanks for putting this so bluntly and helpfully for our American cousins.

Since the Republicans have started banging on Canada lately, I expect to see many such explanatory articles from Canadians on Open Salon. Manchu Wok has a good one, too.
Thanks for the post. I just wish we could run it 7/24 on all the major news channels.
You are SO right about that one woman who did the double-mortgage shuffle down to the Mayo. Somewhere between her PR machine and Michael Moore's "Sicko" there's the real story of the Canadian health system: we get sick and go to the clinic. We don't have to sell everything we own or undertake vicious financial risks.

The system is NOT perfect, and most Cdns would admit it, but it certainly seems to be a far better model to base your changes on than a target of vitriol.

But do NOT get me started on Vet costs. Keep Otis out of the hockey bag or risk mortgaging and Mayo-visiting with him.
I want to hear from Otis next!
PS please send this to Reddit, etc. I would but I am not 21st century yet....
The left has just banned...see Franken Rule....which prohibits the use of the term "Gov. Controlled Health Care". If you are in Congress and want to mail out letters to your constituents you will have to pay for the mailing yourself if you use this term...Now that's freedom, liberal style... Welcome to Obamaland
i do wish canadians would stop instructing yanks on how to run a health care system, or any other.

listen up, canucks: america is screwed up not because they are ignorant, not because they are in the grip of plutocrats and megalomaniacs, although this is true. they are screwed up because they would rather live in a third world society than admit they were suckered by the plutocrats and megalomaniacs. it's pride, folks!

so don't laugh at them, it just makes the situation worse. praise them instead, something like: "i bet living without insurance in a society where admission to med school depends on a high score in the money-lust category is immensely stimulating. i really admire this kind of independent spirit."

then they will trust you a little, and you can mention that cheap prescription drugs are really inferior, and they shouldn't come across the border to buy them. they are after all, subsidized by canadian tax-payers and americans hate socialism.
PS when my divorce is final, my meds will be 145 smackaroos/mo. For epilepsy. The cheapo kind, not the glamorous kind. Of course, I'm talking about being without insurance. So, maybe I awttta just head North. I already live where it's cold, In Wiscawwwwsinnnn. I bless every place that knows how to care for their people. We all need decent health care.
God...I wish that this sort of reasonable explanation of how one lives with public healthcare could be prevalent in our media "down here"...unfortunately...seems the fear and idiocy tend to prevail...I hope it doesn't last too long. Cheers!
I so appreciated your humor and informed perspective.
I'm sure about our health care system being more than adequate. Not so sure about the headline. It's not America that's embarrassing itself, it's their right wing networks, and Blue Dog democrats. They're getting closer than they've ever been, so I want to at least congratulate thinking Americans for that.

Also, I feel I embarrassed them enough last week with that lame Paso Doble on So You Think You Can Dance. I think they need a little recovery time.
Great post! Love your perspective on the issue and I totally agree. America is supposed to be the greatest country on earth but yet most of the families can't even afford to live here. We need a health care reform system of some kind. Yes all systems are not perfect and they all have their down falls.
Thanks for this. Something down here has got to give.
Excellent! Educating! Keep 'em coming! The more the naysayers know, the better.
Thank you!
i have a 2 litre pepsi, a bucket of cheddar-flavoured popcorn and a giant kit-kat bar at the ready. When can I expect to see that colonoscopy video put up?

And i know there probably won't be any car chases in it but hey, maybe something explodes. Wait, no, don't ruin it for me!

If this turns out to be another chick flick, I'm going to be really pissed off. If Sandra Bullock appears I'm turning it off immediately and NEVER reading your blog again .

(Seriously though, great post - but in my case, you're preaching to the choir)

rated
Thanks for this post. I am so frustrated with the demonizing of the Obama plan, led by politicians and media who seem to be in the pocket of the insurance industry. What other motive would they have to spread their ridiculous stories?
Bumping this back into the feed!

Altho one doesn't have to be as blunt as al loomis, I think he has a point....My fella Americans are embarrassingly ignorant - of policy, of other countries, of preventive health care, of Canada, fergodssake.

You are so right about comparisons - we don't have to mimic anyone else's plan - just make a stab at something intelligent - then work on it!