Editor’s Pick
SEPTEMBER 22, 2009 1:35AM

The challenge of making straight men interesting

Rate: 5 Flag

When I was asked to write a book of sex stories in which the narrators were all straight men, I faced a challenge: What was interesting about straight men?

For years I'd written erotica in which the whole point was to blur the boundaries of traditional sexual identities, to take people who thought they were all one way and show how they could, given the right situation, go the other way and enjoy it. I showed straight men blowing other men, gay men getting off on women watching them masturbate, and tops opening up to being topped by somebody else for the first time. In other words, people losing their inhibitions and having new fun -- the basic currency of erotica.

But what could I do with a group of straight men sitting around talking with each other about sex? (Every time I write that sentence, I start out by saying "talking about sex with each other," then have to reorder the clauses.) Men who really are straight, who won't get all hot and bothered by the storytelling and get it on with each other. Getting it on with each other was not what the book was supposed to be about. It was supposed to be about these men getting it on with hot women.

I also faced the challenge of developing several straight male characters who could be distinct from one another for the length of a novel. Shit, I don't even know that many straight people, outside my job. Most of my friends are gay; I'm bi. I dealt with this challenge by going to one of the original source tales showing a bunch of straight men sitting around with each other. No, not the Gospels. Not the Knights of the Round Table. The Seven Dwarves.

seven_dwarves_2

The Seven Dwarves (I'll let you name them for yourself, ready? go!) provide the key to the book's characters. Happy is Hap, the main character. Dopey is Denny, a drug addict. Sneezy is Seth, who has allergies and works in biotech. Get it?

Once that was taken care of, I still had to make it hot at book length without, again, having the Seven Dwarves get it on with each other. Of course I could have done that, but that wasn't what my publisher asked for. I found myself dredging up details of practically every opposite-sex relationship I'd had over the years, and made up several I didn't have. I reused a story I told in nonfiction form in Best Sex Writing 2006. I turned people I knew, and some I'd barely run into -- such as the annoying salesman type who sat next to me at a sushi bar in Las Vegas in 2004 -- into characters. And I did it all in six months.

So to return to the original question: What was interesting about straight men? The way they shove themselves cheerfully into situations without much thought. The way they think everything revolves around them. The fact they'll do anything to get laid.

This turned into my book How They Scored. I'll write more about the book soon, by way of shameless self promotion™.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
If I wasn't at work, I'd click the links... because I am fascinated. I'll click tonight at home. Promise.
Women have been asking this same question for years...
Sounds good...I'm fascinated by erotica. I think straight men are interesting because, deep down, so many are not like the media-promoted stereotype. Not all straight men will do anything for sex.

But, like you, I'd rather write stories where all the walls are torn down. Where people act out in ways that aren't stereotypical.

When I move back to the Bay Area, we should definitely meet up and talk about writing. I might not get there for another year or two. But I will get back to my home. ;)
Sure thing, Gwendolyn, I love talking about writing.
Very interesting. I am looking forward to more of your shameless self promotion. ;)
Well, as shameless self promotion, you failed. You confessed that you can't find anything interesting about your subject matter. Why do you think we will either?

I could be convinced easily that straight men talking about sex would be interesting -- as long as the women were real people and not just bodies.
No way to figure it out. I'm with a straight guy now who, on the other hand, has all the amazingly attractive qualities of a not-so-straight guy. He likes to talk about feelings. He wears makeup. And he's an amazing dancer. I could go on forever. Every day, I'm thinking... seriously? Does this exist? Where's the trick? I don't think there is one though. I think he's just an Elf. That would explain it. :)
We straight men are in fact very boring. We don't have any dramatic "coming out" stories. We don't have any interesting "identity" -- we're like vanilla ice cream without the vanilla. We weren't born into the wrong bodies, and we have no stories of having various body parts removed or attached. We're so boring that we don't even march down the street in our underwear in Straight Pride parades. Unlike women, we don't have any particular ideology that we're supposed to buy into or argue about.

We sometimes function temporarily as husbands and fathers, until our spouses become too bored with us, at which point we are no longer necessary. Beyond our role as sperm-producers we are of little use. Why anyone would want to read about us is beyond me.
Hmmmm, I've thought about this a little more.

Straight men can be very interesting, in terms of sexuality, when they show their vulnerability, because it takes confidence to be vulnerable. When they show emotion, deep emotion, and not just love, when they express themselves sexually. When they open themselves up to sexual expression that is beyond what is typically expected of them. When they understand that their spot on the continuum of sexuality is actually not fixed in place.

That's what I've been thinking.
Good point, Wakingupslowly.

Congrats on the book writing!