Between the Synapse

Blogging by Mark Toubin

M Toubin

M Toubin
Location
Houston, Texas, USA
Birthday
December 03
Bio
Mark Toubin practiced civil litigation for eleven years and participated in federal, state and local politics before joining the American Israel Public Affairs Committee ("AIPAC") as its Southwest Regional Director from 1999 to early 2008. Most recently, Mark runs his own consulting practice focusing on public affairs, politics, non-profit and business. The full version of Between the Synapse may be found at www.betweenthesynapse.com

M Toubin's Links

New list
DECEMBER 27, 2008 6:12PM

Understanding Israel's Gaza Action

Rate: 3 Flag

Understanding Israel's Gaza Action

6300 rockets from Gaza on Israel since 2005.

3000 rockets launched in 2008.

4000 fired since Israel’s full withdrawal from Gaza in August of 2005.

3,000 rockets shot 2008.

150 missiles sent to Israel in November 2008 alone, during the so-called calm.

Dozens of rockets fired in the last ten days.

ALL deliberately aimed at Israeli civilians and fired within civilian populations in Gaza; resulting in thirteen innocent people killed in Israel, over 780 wounded, and thousands traumatized.

It’s no wonder Israel finally launched a defensive operation to defend its civilian population in the south from the terror that Hamas has inflicted in spite of Israel’s and other Palestinian’s desire for peace.  Why?  Because Hamas’ objectives are the same as Iran, Hezbollah and Islamic Jihad: the destruction of Israel and installation of Islamic rule throughout the Middle East.  How? Hamas receives significant funding and arms from Iran.  In fact, Hamas smuggles Iranian-made rockets into Gaza through complex underground tunnel systems that eventually terrorize Israeli cities such as Sderot and Ashkelon.

In spite of these rocket attacks, Israel has worked to allow for trucks carrying fuel, food, medicine, and humanitarian equipment to cross into Gaza.  In 2008, more than 12,000 Palestinians entered Israel to receive medical attention.  However, Hamas utilizes strategizes that deprive its own people of necessary services.  For example, Hamas once used a cancer patient returning to Israel for treatment as a suicide bomber causing Israel to be much more rigorous in its border activities. Hamas then blamed Israel for creating a humanitarian crisis.  The current situation is much the same.  Hamas provokes Israel to defend its citizens, and then screams to the international media that Israel is killing innocents.

And yes, in spite of its best efforts, civilians will be hurt and killed in Gaza and the death of Palestinian child is no less of a tragedy than that of the Israeli child.  I must note however, that when Hamas fires its rockets, it intends to kill civilians.  Israel, on the other hand, does its utmost to avoid the same.  (A vast majority the killed today were Hamas terrorists).  And, while international law specifically forbids the use of human shields, Hamas intentional stations its installations within civilian buildings and areas for the purpose of causing civilian causalities.

 

I know that the vast majority of Palestinians and Israeli want to end this conflict; all want a better more peaceful future for their children.  Today’s air strikes do not discount that hope.  But as long as Iranian-backed Hamas continues its terrorist attacks on Israeli civilians, Israel will undertake the same defensive operations as any other any government would do to protect its citizens.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Another rehash of the political fantasies of the Likud. Likudniks keep promoting the propagandist fallacy the all the conflict is caused by Arab aggression.

I pray that Bibi Netanyahu fails in his election campaign.

Are you registered as an agent of a foreign country?
Relatively few deaths compared with the number of innocent Palestinians who have died. And none of this changes the fact that the Palestinians in Gaza have been under siege for years; that it is an impoverished territory largely controlled by Israel - the most powerful nation-state in the region; and that many of the Palestinians in Gaza (or their family-members) were forced to leave their homes decades ago during the ethnic cleansing that led to the creation of the Israeli state. But Israel is the victim in all of this of course.
I don't think she was being entirely honest on the foregiveness front:
"When peace comes we will perhaps in time be able to forgive the Arabs for killing our sons, but it will be harder for us to forgive them for having forced us to kill their sons."
--Golda Meir, at a press conference after the Six Day War
It is easy to feel compassion for those we view as victims, but it takes a broader mind than some of the commentators seem to have to feel grief and understanding for both sides.

After being fired upon by Hamas, Israel has responded with frightening force and too many innocent people are now dead. But Hamas itself is not innocent. They have long sheltered behind innocent citizens, thereby ensuring maximum civilian casualties. This is fact. Those people, Palestinian AND Israeli, are the victims.
'...resulting in thirteen innocent people killed in Israel, over 780 wounded, and thousands traumatized.'

And so Israel responds by killing 1000+ Palestinians (so far), injuring countless more, and traumatising a population of 1.5 million living in stifling conditions, under an Israeli blockade for the better part of two years, and for circumstances infinitely more complex than you've outlined here.

Tell me why reason should give way for madness and I'll begin to understand. Tell me why Israel has broken, and is breaking international law, and maybe I'll understand. Tell me why we should continue to pretend as though the combatants in this conflict (a heavily armed, wealthy and foreign-subsidised state versus a small, crowded, impoverished and imprisoned population) are in a an equal position to respond to each other's tactics...and then perhaps you can acknowledge the crimes recognised by the United Nations, and those perpetrated against it in the last 24 hours; the surreal, angry accusations of the (neutral and legally recognised) International Red Cross; and widespread condemnation worldwide.
If you are biased against Israel, fine --but please check out one or two history books or even articles, and maybe even a law book for all those studying law, before submitting fabrications that insult us all. and while your at it, try understanding some of the facts and not just the propaganda. If there is ever going to be a resolution, the lies have to stop. Israel has a right ot defend herself. Under international law, if enemy combatants use civilian buildings for carrying out warfare, those sites are lawful targets. Hamas intentionally launches and shots from UN and civilian areas. UNWRA is notorious for allowing terroriest to operate in its midst. Proportionality is a complete red herring. Just because Hamas' rockets are less accurate does not mean that Isael is less obligated to defend its people. What kind of logic would that be? Hamas has controlled Gaza for 3 years, has continued to fire rockets the entire time, has continued to bring in more sophisicated weaponry, has evoked orthodox shira law on its people, has snuck into Israel and killed IDF soldiers and still holds one hostage. Because of this, Israel has had to take defensive actions but the fault lies on Hamas. Hamas calls for Israel's destruction, not a negotiated two state solution.

M Toubin's Favorites

  1. facewall Kerry Lauerman
  2. facewall Joan Walsh

view all