I have a temper.
This isn't obvious when people first meet me. On the east coast where I now live, acquaintances sometimes mistake my California speaking style for mellowness. I've heard "you seem so laid back" so often that I have to suppress howls of laughter. If my husband is in the vicinity, he usually snorts.
It's tempting to say my temper has been genetically determined. My mother's long-time excuse for her rages? "I'm sorry! I'm Sicilian!"
But just as I've never let her off the hook for screaming meanness, I don't believe my Italian ancestry explains my moods.
"The Angry Monk," a piece reprinted in the September/October 2010 issue of the Utne Reader, got me thinking about anger. And it's helped me to understand why my anger, an old, old friend, no longer seems so useful.
The article by Shozan Jack Haubner originally ran as "When the Tornado Touches Down" in Buddhadharma: The Practitioner's Quarterly. "A lot of pissed-off people wind up at our monastery," Haubner starts off. He's very funny. He lays out his own struggles with anger as a Buddhist monk, and it's soon clear why he's writing under a pseudonym.
I'm sure anyone with even a brushing acquaintance with Buddhism or meditation knows that sitting in silence can be far from emotional peace. Regardless of how quiet one's body is, the mind can be a wreckless thing.
But I like Haubner's witty article for personal reasons, too. It came into my hands at precisely the moment I needed it: on a recent Jetblue flight to California, my eight-year-old son at my side, me facing a very difficult visit with my ailing elderly parents.
I'd been dreading this trip, because various sad details needed to be worked out about my mother's living arrangements; her bipolar mental state was hard to predict. Yet what I'd been dreading most was my own anger unleashed: my frustration with her inability to make choices, my rage at nobody listening to me for years—rage, rage, rage, all of which I'd expressed to some family member or other, at some point, and which had gone nowhere.
I'm not a Buddhist or a Christian; my spiritual leanings are more amorphous, and like so many of my boomer/slacker generation, I look to psychotherapy as an explanatory savior for what's wrong with me. Yet Haubner notes that spiritual work, unlike the therapeutic agenda, isn't necessarily "instructive":
"It's not supposed to boss you around with behavioral or self-help dictates, or to shoehorn you into the slipper of well-adjusted citizenhood.... [I]t's transformative, and this kind of transformation can get messy. The Sanskrit term for this is clusterfuck."
Yes! Clusterfuck. The old angry me thinks that's a swell motto.
But I realized on the plane how worried I was about getting angry in front of my son. I wanted to shield him from the kind of terrifying rages I'd witnessed as a child. I didn't think I could control a cascading series of events—and, oh, how a lack of control used to make me shake my fists at the gods.
Now, back home on the "unrelaxed" east coast, I know these worries didn't come to pass. I felt plenty of frustration on this trip; I had moments of intense irritation with my son and others. Yet my old familiar anger—the often embarassing but tough buddy who had bulled me through so many hard times—did not materialize in quite the same way. As Haubner writes,
"Some people...seem to be born angry. Not me. I was born a coward. So when the energy gets moving through Zen practice and I suddenly become angry rather than a quivering eunuch, this can feel like an improvement.... A sharp word suddenly tastes good in my mouth. Anger takes on the illusion of upward spiritual mobility in comparison with my habitual cravenness."
Me, I was born talking. My didactic impulse has channeled all sorts of feelings in the past, including anger and guilt. But more than anything, it's been about my need to control what cannot be controlled: a mentally-ill parent.
My talkiness surfaced on this trip, when I was telling my mother to stop focusing on every worry. I delivered a string of advice in a flat, loud voice, because she's deaf and on principle resists anyone telling her what to do.
But my son, who was justifiably worried about his grandmother, finally whispered in my ear, "I don't think the chat is helping." He was right.
Once I might have said I was born pissed-off, given the many angry letters I've sent to corporations about a variety of customer-service infractions—software that doesn't work, canceled airline flights, the usual rostrum of complaints. I remember so well that particular monkey on my back, my dudgeon rising, the need to do something, anything, to shake it off.
Yet this kind of high dudgeon at faceless corporate or political stand-ins doesn't work for me now. Here's where I believe a spiritual analysis like Haubner's offers forgiveness of everybody's weaknesses, including my own.
He calls anger a lateral move. It packs a punch, so to speak, and it often demands immediate action. The energy of anger can feel like something has been released inside, and maybe it has. For women especially, access to one's anger—and to expressing that anger—can certainly be cathartic. (Think of the response to Alanis Morissette's big hit "You Oughta Know.")
There are many reasons in this world to stand up for yourself, to demand change, to not just smile nicely when others are far from nice. But often anger is a cover for thornier feelings—fear, sadness, grief, soul weariness—all the decidedly unsparky emotions I'm grappling with now.
So am I still scuttling sideways, Shozan Jack? Have I moved forward at all?
I'm not sure. Well, yes, I am. Anger, my old friend, has come back in a new guise. These past weeks, I've been struck by a feeling that used to seem so transgressive: Why can't I be the screw-up, the one who isn't in charge? Why do I have to be so good?
That's not how I operate as a responsible adult, of course. But the disorganized spin of this last year, with all its joyrides and sorrows and trails of logistical detritus, is starting to seem like my spiritual work, the thing that can both drag me down and open me to new ways of being.
My soul is messier than it's ever been. I've outgrown "the slipper of well-adjusted citizenhood." That's my particular clusterfuck these days, my Zen practice—but what the hell. It's a good thing.
Just in case you need a little karaoke for the mess someone made when they went away...


Salon.com
Comments
"There are many reasons in this world to stand up for yourself, to demand change, to not just smile nicely when others are far from nice. But often anger is a cover for thornier feelings—fear, sadness, grief, soul weariness" ~r
Thanks, all, for letting the clusterfuck live. Regarding "east coast": for kids in the '70s in the Bay Area, I think it had a bunch of overlapping meanings--it was partly about social and economic class, about race, and, even occasionally, about a longing for a different coast/town than the one we lived in.
If anger is natural, our expressions of anger are not. On the contrary, they are learned behaviors that we acquire from our parents and siblings and other influencers with whom we come into contact.
The Buddhist monk who makes excuses for himself is also telling us that he's so out of touch with his emotions that it requires an extreme reaction to notice when he's upset by somethings. That's really out of touch.
Anger is a teacher, but the lesson is that anger is normally fleeting and when it hangs around, it's because you are talking to yourself about it. This is the root problem with zen practice. The objective of mindlessness is not achieved by dialoguing with yourself.
In my own case, it's not about snuffing out my anger. I will forever live with my temper. The difference for me is that I've made some small steps towards being angry about the right things, for a change, and at the right people. That is when anger truly feels cathartic and can be very cleansing in a relationship.
I also like Haubner's emphasis on the difference between a traditional psychotherapeutic approach--the idea that one can resolve everything in the equivalent of a toilet flush--or, hey, just take a pill to "manage" your anger--versus the messiness of spiritual practice.
I recently began going to Al-Anon and it -- more than years of therapy -- melted away much of the rage, knowing it was empathized with, understood and others had survived similar.
Caitlin: Oh, I do know. Maybe we're living inside each other's heads, having such similar experiences. Al-Anon makes sense. For me, writing about it is another means of sharing (and healing) with others.
I am a talker too. I have slowed my life down, a lot and write more now than talk. I rarely have an anger melt down. I noticed that as I aged it took more out of me than it was worth. I guess that could be by I am the one frustrated by my siblings. Anyway, someone on OS the other day was writing something very interesting and said that you have to look at things you can't change, stop bringing them forward to work on them, and move on. Wise words. Very wise words. R
My take is that it's usually fear - and a pretty universal fear(s). Fear of abandonment, rejection, not measuring up, not being good enough, not being validated, accepted. In fact these fears are so common and basic as to be overlooked as too easy to serve as the basis for anger. We do tend to complicate things.
Anger in itself is not the issue . I mean things happen that piss me off momentarily . I'm talking about anger as a typical interactional/response style to the world. I too had a very angry and bitter to the core mother who really only seemed to connect when her anger was spilling out. Of course it made me hypervigilant to my environment. And it was my role model for how to not handle anger - so I just developed strategies to avoid angry people and I find myself less angry in a chronic sense. Getting late and starting to ramble so stopping. Enjoyed your post.
I completely understand the East Coast/West Coast thing, having had fantasies of moving to New York my entire adolescence.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fWkKIBpQG9g
"He calls anger a lateral move. It packs a punch, so to speak, and it often demands immediate action. The energy of anger can feel like something has been released inside, and maybe it has. For women especially, access to one's anger—and to expressing that anger—can certainly be cathartic. (Think of the response to Alanis Morissette's big hit "You Oughta Know.")
That graf perfectly describes the seductive power of expressing anger for me. It feels so good, so righteous to drop the act and just let go. To vent, as the saying goes. And while it lasts, it's about as good as it gets.
But it doesn't last. It's a hurricane, leaving nothing but destruction in its wake.
I've made a study of anger over the years and have slowly realized that every rationale I've ever held for its expression is bogus. It's brought nothing but unhappiness in every instance. Like you, I thought it was my friend, that I could use it to some good. But time & again it betrayed me.
That's why I was so excited to read your conclusion:
"But the disorganized spin of this last year, with all its joyrides and sorrows and trails of logistical detritus, is starting to seem like my spiritual work, the thing that can both drag me down and open me to new ways of being."
Yes! It took me a long time to grow up and realize the messiness of my life was something I could use to help me see the way out of that messiness. My practice ever since has been to at least recognize how easily I fall for the angry way and then to not express it. That's quite a trick if you make your living as a newspaperman, but there it is.
Your report from the frontlines of your life and the struggle you so gracefully describe was a thrill to read, in much the same way as you may have felt in reading Haubner's account. It made me fell part of the cluster.
As for anger, I'm sorry I think anger, not the throwing-a-chair-through-a-window vintage, can accomplish some things. People, I have learned, generally will push you until you push back. Many times anger has helped me define who a real friend is. But I'll also confess that my mellowing in my old age often reveals that the thing I think I'm angry about really isn't that big a deal. Amazing what 30 minutes of delayed reaction can do for you.
As for anger having legitimate uses, I certainly agree. The issue for me has to do with my anger hitting the right targets rather than just leaking out all over everybody else. I'm more in touch with my grief these days, which means sometimes I actually know what I'm feeling. I don't lash out as a cover for something else--well, sometimes I still do, but I don't feel like I wander in the desert of internal rage in the same way I used to.
That's what I was doing all those years BEFORE I began the practice, to no avail. That is self-absorption. The effort of zen, for me, is to get beyond the small and greedy (and often aggrieved) self.
I do agree with him that it's important what you do with your anger, that consideration and courtesy and empathy matter a great deal. Not what some people think of as self-control, in which they barely manage to suppress lethal rage; that's dangerous, the person only waiting for a "sufficient" cause to blow up--the anger is then like a contained explosive needing only a lit fuse--but a respect for others, an realization that you never, never have the full story.
Which doesn't mean you should stand idly by while a child is beaten, which doesn't mean you tolerate cruelty. In fact anger, since it is always personal, masks true injustice, causes us to confuse our own sense of injury with things that are just plain wrong. Makes it HARDER to do the right thing.
You're a good writer, Martha, but you need to work on proofreading.
It's also true that I'm very happy to have copy editors and proofreaders at Talking Writing...!
Great read.
Athena put these words on another's mortal lips to share with the twenty-first century bloggers @ Open Salon and to BC humanity:
`
"Your anger will become sweeter than honeycomb." I read that after doing Postal Union USPS service clerk advocacy. The Postal Creepy Management fabricated a blatant Lie. Management (drunks and womanizers) alleged that I assaulted a nasty Postal Supervisor - It wasn't true.
Creeps are bad jokes.
I was being scoled in close breath range.
The 401 2b - had atrocious nasty breath.
I gently took my palm of my hand to chin.
I said "out of my face" & "your breath stinks!"
`
I was asked a few hours later to demonstrate.
Management (behind closed doors) was cruel/
I smiled. I pretended to "choke a adams apple\
I never imagined that Postal Manager trumped!
A team of baby-acting bullies false charge-crime!
The USPS tried to fire me. Charge? Assault Charge!
I eventually 'won' and received all back pay back.
I remained home with my three young children.
I personally traveled to DC under Ron Reagan.
The nominated director of the Merit System: Ay!
The Federal government has a Protection Board.
The conservative, and bald headed, ant the former:
Interior Department Chief - Mr. Watts intervened.
He and I didn't agree about forestry. Heads rolled.
Heads didn't "roll on the floor" as in `literally tho.
That's one reason I believe in taking some actions.
Web Bloggers can't just spew our di`satiss`fat`ion.
(that's a made up word) People get pissed off bad.
I went to work at the Veteran Outreach Center.
Nature didn't give human boxing glove/bombs.
Teasers?
We are not to use guns, lawyer's frivolous shoes,
fancy suits, spit, sucker punches, and we smile.
When we are angry (who's not" numb people)?
We let the Anger transform. That's discipline.
`
Ann N. Thanks.
I am not Christian/Buddha Muslim et., Glean.
If I had a business\Better than farming? Bum.
I'd hand out Bum/Cards. Beg for beer Change.
I'd be petitioning the highest levels of B. Obama.
I'd be angry with any prison job like Barack's got.
He is behind bars every day and faxed bah crap.
Thanks again. The past struggles make us who?
Hopefully we don't cower in a chicken cluck ball.
It be sad ruin and a crying shame to be chickens.
Hamartia - means to be a coward who self-ruins.
I use a few word to try to govern my inner being.
We people have a inner constitution. I love you.
All comments from others are valued. No delete.
I reread your comment from otter later. Maybe?
I am late again to help y son sell heirloom fruits.
Tomatoes are good for a males prostrate glands