What I Learn From Marty

Marty'sHusband

Marty'sHusband
Location
Waco, Texas,
Birthday
March 30
Bio
I am the chief caregiver for Marty, my wife of 30+ years. In our previous lives Marty was an Educational Psychologist, I was a call center manager. Marty has had two strokes since 2005 which have caused critical physical and cognitive deficits. We are both in our mid-50's and have two adult children. I would never confuse myself with a professional writer, I do this to document our journey and as an act of self discovery. This is what I have learned over the last years, this is our life.

MY RECENT POSTS

JUNE 4, 2012 6:12PM

An Immoral Dilemma

Rate: 27 Flag

It crosses my mind.  Occasionally I think about it, maybe too much, maybe too often.  Then I feel guilty.

It hasn’t happened, in the years since the strokes, it hasn’t even been close, it’s just there, too much, too often.

It’s not like I am a paragon of virtue, it’s not like I have had to turn people away, there haven’t been any real opportunities, it just hasn’t happened, but the guilt for just thinking about it, for rationalizing it, is omni-present.

 I recognize there are people in the world who don’t need to closely connect with others, they don’t need an intimate relationship, they don’t need to be touched, they don’t need to be held, kissed, or caressed.  I’m not one of those people. 

The longer this care giving gig goes, the more I come face to face with who I am and what I need and want.  I need all of those things, I need intimacy, I need affection, I need to be held tight, it’s more than just want, it’s more than just desire, I think I need those things in my life.

There are a lot of people in the world who are either in the same life circumstance as Marty and me or have been there and moved on with life.  Our circumstance is unusual because of our relatively young age but we are not wholly unique and I am not the first to struggle with the concept of living a promise when so life’s circumstances have so radically changed.

There are many, like me, who have had a forced and premature celibacy.  There are many like me who forgo and miss the physical and emotional intimacy that is a part of a healthy relationship between two loving and caring people.  It’s not news that some of those same people try and find ways to meet those needs through someone other than their life’s partner.  It’s also not news that those affairs are fraught with guilt.

The plain truth is the tug of touching, holding, being held, is inevitable and for some of us, primal and part of what makes us a whole being.  To find ways to get physical and emotional needs met while keeping faith with the person you promised to love and honor in sickness and in health till death do you part when they can’t meet those needs is a long impossible struggle.

The needs, the desires don’t die with the onset of catastrophic illness.  They get set aside, they become a low priority for a while, but they still exist, they still pull you, they still start deep in the pit of your stomach pulling and aching to be released.  The feeling, the desire to touch and be touched never dies, it’s like being really thirsty and the only thing around you is the salty ocean, forbidden, untouchable, dangerous to drink, and, like time spent afloat on an empty ocean, the longer you are there, the more isolated, the more thirsty you become.

Just to be clear, this not just about sex.  This is about intimate two way conversations, this is about a touch, a breath, a smell, a sight; this is about the kind of intimacy human beings were created to crave, this is about tactile and emotional touchstones that make us very human and make us want to be with another being.

I can rationalize the idea of finding someone to fill the gap, to meet the need, in fact, I have.  In my mind, in the dark parts of my mind, I have rationalized developing a relationship with someone else, having an affair.  Why not?  I have a wife whom I love and cherish but through no fault of her own or mine simply can’t love and cherish me in a demonstrable way, and that will never, ever get better.  I’m a good, loyal man, how far does the good and loyal have to go?   

I know Marty loves me, I know she appreciates beyond measure what I do for her, what I have sacrificed for her.  I know I am forever and always in love with her, we both know and understand there are things in this life she can never do again, ways she can’t care for me.  Is there a moral high ground here?

It’s a problem, a problem for a lot of spousal caregivers who come to the realization that significant and meaningful parts of what once was can never be again with their spouse.  It’s a problem because the need to be emotionally and physically loved doesn’t go away, the needs continue, they exist in a very real way, in a way the broken spouse can’t meet, in a way that directly contradicts the vows of marriage. 

The vow I took, the promise to love and honor, in sickness and in health till death do us part stays with you.  Sometimes the dreams, the fantasies a real human being constructs don’t include the vows, they hide from the promises I made 35 years ago.  The vows don’t take into account living with illness, caring for the chronically ill, forgoing an important part of life that you are not ready to forgo, that no one should be required to forget.

There are no good answers.  The real answer is for no one to get so sick and still live.  How’s that for the hard and ugly truth?  I neither like nor accept that truth, it’s not what I want now, it’s not what I want for tomorrow.  I don’t want the illness, I mourn for Marty and I grieve every day for my own loss, but I cherish her presence even in the face of the loss of parts of my, our life. 

I don’t know what to do except keep doing what we do, keep living day to day and accept what comes tomorrow as part of the process.  I don’t know……

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I'll say it. You're a great guy. My guess is that Marty agrees.
I don't know how you do it, really.
My goodness, it must be so easy to slide out from your duties, and yet you're there for her.
Amazing. I'm truly wowed.
R
My father went through what you are going through with my mother. however she ended up dying at 34 so he was still able to re-marry.

Every male in my sanction has gone through the same thing with their partners . I know Marty loves you but she knows what is going on and how you feel. She must have the same guilts only she cannot tell you or prefers not to in her own way.

It's a sacrifice of love for the both of you and I admire you greatly.I am the last one standing and this is my biggest fear. I want no one to have to go through what my family and you and Marty go through.

My prayers to you.
HUGGGGGGGGGG
Wow. heavy-duty post. I would not even think to give you any advice on this. But I would say that its a perfectly understandable conversation you have here with yourself, and I certainly commend you for the courage and strength & love you have.
I appreciate the honesty in this post. Your love for your wife is obvious in all your writings. I just have to believe that someone like you, with your true and honest heart, will be ok; that it will work out in a way you will feel is good and right.
r./
You are such a great husband to Marty, and you are doing all you can for her. Of course your needs won't vanish. I don't know what the answer is, either. What an incredibly honest post. Take care of yourself too.
Powerful and well stated. A difficult topic to address, but something many caregivers of spouses/life partners face. A big thank you for writing with such candor in all your posts.
I don't know Marty but if my husband was in the same situation, I would want him to find that loving connection if I was unable to meet his needs that way. Is that wrong?
I get a lotta crap for advocating for AshleyMadison.com ... yeah, on the surface, it's about affairs and sex ... but in reality, once you find a "friend", they fulfill many other things a person needs as well

Perhaps you should lay-out your situation/story on a site such as that ... my guess is that you'll get an inbox full of people to whom you can try and develop a relationship with while keeping your marriage intact.

Best of luck.
Yes, all of it is need, we're wired like that and it seems the more loyal a person is the more they need those intimate things that are more than just sex or idle chit chat. Or maybe it's the other way around and the more we need them the more loyal we are. I don't know, just a lifetime of observation. I wish you peace, love and fullness.
Wow. You are so honest here, and vulnerable. Many relationships change because of health issues. But as you mention, you are still relatively young. I wish you what is best and right for you.
I've wondered about that about you. I concur with what everyone else said, even unto Joisey.

Blessings...
I knew a man 10 years ago in much the same situation as you.
I wrote of her in a piece about Betsy. She was unable to talk,..unable to do more than nod her head and grunt, but had amazing abilities to communicate anyway.

Her husband Ralph spent years and years being the absolutely loyal and caring husband. He was simply the best, just as you are.

We had this chat, he and I. He felt a kind of guilt for simply thinking these thoughts that I thought he was going to lose it.

No matter what I said, no matter what we concluded in discussion, he could not drop the guilt associated with the thoughts even being in his head.

Based on Ralph, I will say this...and I hope it helps some.

We as humans can not always control our thoughts. We ALL think things from time to time that would cause us to blush were the thoughts ever found out.
But we have the ability to act on our thoughts, or not to act.

Perhaps it is not the stray thoughts that should garner guilt after all?


Beyond that, I also fear to speak. How does ANYONE recommend or not recommend something like that intimacy for another?

Peace to you my friend.
My husband took care of me for four years while I was sick and in bed. First I had a Gall Bladder taken out. Then I had a huge back injury. But the Gall Bladder was misdiagnosed for almost two years so I went to college and came home throwing up and then to bed. I was useless. I was no help at all. My husband really did have to care for me, the house, the two children and my son is autistic. He never cheated. I was so lonely in bed by myself though. I was lonelier than I had ever been in my life. I was an emotional wreck because I was on pain killers for a long time. Finally, I am done with the pain killers. It was really hard to get off of them but I am so much better now. I guess what I am saying is I had a small dose of what you are going through.

In the end, you have to make the decision. But I would maybe think about talking to your wife about it if you decide to do it. There are most likely other options for her care and I would have wanted to know and been able to make hard decisions for myself if I had to. Good Luck with your future. I honestly will pray for you two.
L, I have no words that will bring great comfort of course. But, like everyone here, I understand completely the thoughts you have; the needs you have. The need for and the ability to give love on many levels is all part of being human.

You have my deepest respect and admiration, L.

God bless.
This may be poor solace, but, having lived this for five years, I know the toll it takes. What helped me most was that early on I vowed that I would do everything I could to make her feel that she was every bit a woman. As things got worse, it became a challenge to find new and creative ways to accomplish this, right up to the day she died, when I simply was able to scratch her scalp, which she loved. Being a caregiver is unique to every individual; for me it taught a richer, deeper more real and, dare I say earthy, definition of love that help me now confront a future that holds the possibility of sharing what only two people can share.

In the poem I posted today I tried to share some of this, and I thank you for your comment.
My heart goes out to you and to Marty. Second Life seems to have some way of helping people in this respect. Not for everyone but kind of a second life if you will.... There is a fellow at my Memory Center who knew of a man who had a wife with Alzheimers and so he got another lady and then she got Alzheimers. Love and committment. So it goes. A fine fine balance. Thank you so much for writing about these deep things.
I have been in the place where each day is struggled through until the next one arrives. Day by Day, sometimes Hour by Hour, sleeping in hospital chairs, holding hands with someone who you don't know if they even know you are there. I am so sorry you are frustrated and questioning what you have always believed. Use the stillness to go inside and write pieces like this that everyone who has been in your shoes can relate.
rated with love
it is not what you do but the heart you put into what you do. come from a place of love for all (include yourself) and you will find a way forward.
Except for the circumstances depriving you of the intimacy you long for, I could easily have written this post. For years I have longed for intimacy in all forms. I've learned to live without the exact form I desire, but have found intimacy in other ways with the friends in my life. I've simply concentrate on what I DO have, appreciating it completely. I also keep very busy doing stuff that I want to do and that adds to my happiness and fulfillment. I've also allowed fantasy in my mind which also helps.....
Thoughts.. not meant as condoning or condemning.

Here in our very own halls at OS we've had a tale of a working out of just such a situation in an unconventional (and generally socially unacceptable) manner.. but it worked for them.

And this is why I remain mostly quiet when I read/hear anything about John Edwards.. we none of us actually know of the discussions he and his wife might have had, or not had but should have.. Then of course famously (or infamously depending on PoV) we've had Jimmy Carter and his lusting thoughts for which he felt badly morally..

Personally I tend to think that's why we have an imagination. Thought most certainly is not deed - and what these kinds of thoughts are is a pressure valve through which we can release the stress of untenable life circumstances.

If I were to suggest anything it would be this - define - for yourself - what your own sense of morality is, as opposed to what society demands of all of us ; they are very often different things and in the end you have to live with yourself, not some ephemeral sense of the constructed entity 'society'. This is you and Marty, Husband, and only you know the acceptable answer/s to your dilemma.

One last thing. You've been given some interesting alternatives (Second Life, Ashley Madison) but there is another. You're a writer.. that you wonder these things is evidence that you have imagination. Put the two together, write your way to a solution (make use of that pressure valve ;). Just for yourself, make a fictional world. Or.. for yourself and Marty.. a fictional world in which catastrophic illness didn't intervene.. what you think life might have been together in that way (only you can know if reading such a tale *to* Marty might help both of you and provide another sort of closeness..).

Rated for your questions don't make you bad, they make you human.
nothing immoral about it at all. I hope you choose to care for yourself, which may include needed to let go of Marty. Martyrdom only leads to resentment and is not healthy or beneficial for either of you.
I think your solution, whatever it may be, will come as a result of asking yourself these questions. Just honestly putting them out there, to the universe, may set in motion something you could never imagine. I'd never presume to know what kind of a path you're on but I completely understand how you feel and what you long for and it's normal and healthy to feel that way. It has nothing to do with "a moral high ground" - you had something good with Marty and you miss it. And it's scary and sad to think you may never have it again.
I have nothing original to add that won't come out wrong or trite or wildly inappropriate, so I'll just second what H-Julie says and wish you much courage.

R
I am hoping you live a full life now, knowing what you know about how Marty's life was snatched away, knowing we have to savor what we have in each moment.
There is no black or white. If it were my husband I would grant him that, from what I know of Marty, she would want your happiness.
Peace and love to you MH from across the miles.
I guess a lesson for those of us who AREN'T in this situation is to discuss with our significant others BEFORE it happens. Put it all out there and talk about our wishes and fears and wants. My husband and I have -- we've talked about this as we put together living wills, etc.
For you, Husband, I wish you peace in your journey and decision. Take care of yourself, whatever that may be. So you can take care of Marty.