During the past few weeks or so, I've noticed that on some mornings, I've been waking in a state of depression, which is a bit alarming as I know all too well just how devastating a full-blown clinical depression can be.
Obviously, I'm struggling deeply with the wear of chronic physical pain, and my brain chemistry is starting to give way, just like it did five years ago when an infection, which I thought had been cured two years earlier after 18 months of agony, took up residency in my jaw and face again (and has been there ever since).
As any hope for a cure seemed so hopeless back then, I slowly began to sink into a hole so black, so absolute, that all roads seemed to point to just one solution if I was ever going to get out of pain, and that solution was suicide. This led to a stint in the local hospital's psych ward, and then a few weeks later, admission to a psychiatric hospital.
With all of the physical complications I've endured as a result of this blood disorder, frequently spending weeks in the hospital at a time, I can say with absolute certainty that nothing--nothing--is as painful as a major clinical depression. And nothing, it seems, is as misunderstood by so many, particularly when it's accompanied by suicidal ideation.
For most people, suicide is unthinkable, so when a loved one takes his or her own life, we can get lost in a state of confusion and anger. I recall reading a book by a psychiatrist a few years ago who'd lost both of his sons in a 13-month period--one was a six-year-old who'd died of cancer and the other was a teenage boy who'd killed himself.
What was shocking, aside from the obvious tragedy of losing two children in such a short amount of time, was that the doctor talked little about his teenager, saying only that suicide was the ultimate "selfish" act, and he chose instead to write about his six-year-old, as the younger boy's ordeal was most likely easier to understand. The boy was, in a sense, an innocent victim of his disease, unlike his "selfish" brother who took his own life.
I remember feeling such shock that this esteemed psychiatrist, of all people, didn't understand the fatal power of depression.
A few years ago, I was hired as a freelance medical editor for a few months, and I was lucky enough to edit tons of the latest materials about depression and suicide. Perhaps what's most misunderstood about clinical depression is that it's not just a state of malaise or of feeling blue; it's a medical disease that if left untreated will only worsen throughout one's lifetime.
In the same way that Type II diabetics cannot absorb their own insulin, when clinical depression occurs, receptors in the brain close, and a person can no longer absorb their own serotonin.
Why this shutdown happens is still a mystery. Take, for example, a set of twins, both raised by the same parents in the same circumstances. In response to a tragedy, one twin will go through a normal grief period while the other will go into a major depression, and no one knows why. All that's known is that a person simply cannot function without serotonin, and the act of suicide is simply a way to get out of excruciating psychic pain.
In my own case, before I got depressed, I was going through one of the happiest periods of my life. For years I'd worked to get myself to a place where I'd perfectly balanced my work life (freelance writing and editing) and my creative life (songwriting and painting), and felt more inspired and joyous than I had in years.
This is what made the sudden return of chronic pain so devastating, and what ultimately made my receptors close to the very chemical so necessary to live.
It's hard to describe suicidal depression, but essentially, it's a loss of control over our own emotional state. Ordinarily, when one is down or feeling blue, there are things that can lift the spirit, like inspirational readings, listening to music, and talking with others. But when one is clinically depressed, absolutely nothing works to lift the darkness, and slowly the will to live can begin to erode.
In the same way one in chronic pain can lose hope that anything will ever change, the depressed patient also loses hope for a cure, and a battle surfaces between our primal will to survive and an aching desire to no longer feel this hell on earth.
In that sense, the act of suicide is the fatal outcome of a deadly disease, not a moral choice by the patient. Far from being selfish or cowardly, when a depressed patient reaches the decision to end his or her own life, nothing is more harrowing or frightening, because there's the realization that pain has overrode the fundamental desire to live. It's hard to imagine that anything in life could be that painful, but unfortunately, these states exist, and the last thing we should do is judge someone in this unthinkable quandary.
In my own case, I knew that I'd reached the limits of my endurance five years ago when I awoke one morning and felt no love whatsoever for anyone in my life anymore (even my mom), as every emotion had become eclipsed by pain. I was shocked at this revelation, because I knew the things that had been keeping me alive--namely the desire to not hurt anyone in my family--were no longer operating. I intuitively knew that I had about 24 hours left to live, and so I called a suicide hotline, which in turn called an ambulance for me, even though my local hospital is just two blocks away.
That's how bad I was; I couldn't even walk this short distance, as every ounce of energy was going into just staying alive and not swallowing the bottle of pills that offered permanent relief.
In time (four agonizing weeks or so), the antidepressants began to work, but not everyone is so lucky, particularly those who've struggled with depression repeatedly in their lives. Studies have shown that clinical depression actually damages the brain, and if left untreated, the illness only gets worse throughout one's lifetime. As the years roll by, the depressions become more frequent, more severe, and require less stimulus to set them off. That's why intervention with medication as soon as possible is so paramount to healing.
Studies have also shown that antidepressants can actually have a curative effect, meaning that if the first depression is treated with medication and therapy, the likelihood of it happening again decreases sharply.
Of course, there are those patients who use a suicide attempt as a cry for help, or as a means to get attention, and some of them do end up dying. But for the patient who is suffering from severe and extended clinical depression, suicide is nothing more than a way out of a type of pain that can never really be put into words.
I've heard it said that suicide is "a permanent solution to a temporary problem," but this isn't quite accurate, at least in terms of a major clinical depression. For some, the problem is debilitating and lifelong, and for these patients, suicide is the means to finally rest, even at the cost of life itself.
***************************
Obviously, I'm struggling deeply with the wear of chronic physical pain, and my brain chemistry is starting to give way, just like it did five years ago when an infection, which I thought had been cured two years earlier after 18 months of agony, took up residency in my jaw and face again (and has been there ever since).
As any hope for a cure seemed so hopeless back then, I slowly began to sink into a hole so black, so absolute, that all roads seemed to point to just one solution if I was ever going to get out of pain, and that solution was suicide. This led to a stint in the local hospital's psych ward, and then a few weeks later, admission to a psychiatric hospital.
With all of the physical complications I've endured as a result of this blood disorder, frequently spending weeks in the hospital at a time, I can say with absolute certainty that nothing--nothing--is as painful as a major clinical depression. And nothing, it seems, is as misunderstood by so many, particularly when it's accompanied by suicidal ideation.
For most people, suicide is unthinkable, so when a loved one takes his or her own life, we can get lost in a state of confusion and anger. I recall reading a book by a psychiatrist a few years ago who'd lost both of his sons in a 13-month period--one was a six-year-old who'd died of cancer and the other was a teenage boy who'd killed himself.
What was shocking, aside from the obvious tragedy of losing two children in such a short amount of time, was that the doctor talked little about his teenager, saying only that suicide was the ultimate "selfish" act, and he chose instead to write about his six-year-old, as the younger boy's ordeal was most likely easier to understand. The boy was, in a sense, an innocent victim of his disease, unlike his "selfish" brother who took his own life.
I remember feeling such shock that this esteemed psychiatrist, of all people, didn't understand the fatal power of depression.
A few years ago, I was hired as a freelance medical editor for a few months, and I was lucky enough to edit tons of the latest materials about depression and suicide. Perhaps what's most misunderstood about clinical depression is that it's not just a state of malaise or of feeling blue; it's a medical disease that if left untreated will only worsen throughout one's lifetime.
In the same way that Type II diabetics cannot absorb their own insulin, when clinical depression occurs, receptors in the brain close, and a person can no longer absorb their own serotonin.
Why this shutdown happens is still a mystery. Take, for example, a set of twins, both raised by the same parents in the same circumstances. In response to a tragedy, one twin will go through a normal grief period while the other will go into a major depression, and no one knows why. All that's known is that a person simply cannot function without serotonin, and the act of suicide is simply a way to get out of excruciating psychic pain.
In my own case, before I got depressed, I was going through one of the happiest periods of my life. For years I'd worked to get myself to a place where I'd perfectly balanced my work life (freelance writing and editing) and my creative life (songwriting and painting), and felt more inspired and joyous than I had in years.
This is what made the sudden return of chronic pain so devastating, and what ultimately made my receptors close to the very chemical so necessary to live.
It's hard to describe suicidal depression, but essentially, it's a loss of control over our own emotional state. Ordinarily, when one is down or feeling blue, there are things that can lift the spirit, like inspirational readings, listening to music, and talking with others. But when one is clinically depressed, absolutely nothing works to lift the darkness, and slowly the will to live can begin to erode.
In the same way one in chronic pain can lose hope that anything will ever change, the depressed patient also loses hope for a cure, and a battle surfaces between our primal will to survive and an aching desire to no longer feel this hell on earth.
In that sense, the act of suicide is the fatal outcome of a deadly disease, not a moral choice by the patient. Far from being selfish or cowardly, when a depressed patient reaches the decision to end his or her own life, nothing is more harrowing or frightening, because there's the realization that pain has overrode the fundamental desire to live. It's hard to imagine that anything in life could be that painful, but unfortunately, these states exist, and the last thing we should do is judge someone in this unthinkable quandary.
In my own case, I knew that I'd reached the limits of my endurance five years ago when I awoke one morning and felt no love whatsoever for anyone in my life anymore (even my mom), as every emotion had become eclipsed by pain. I was shocked at this revelation, because I knew the things that had been keeping me alive--namely the desire to not hurt anyone in my family--were no longer operating. I intuitively knew that I had about 24 hours left to live, and so I called a suicide hotline, which in turn called an ambulance for me, even though my local hospital is just two blocks away.
That's how bad I was; I couldn't even walk this short distance, as every ounce of energy was going into just staying alive and not swallowing the bottle of pills that offered permanent relief.
In time (four agonizing weeks or so), the antidepressants began to work, but not everyone is so lucky, particularly those who've struggled with depression repeatedly in their lives. Studies have shown that clinical depression actually damages the brain, and if left untreated, the illness only gets worse throughout one's lifetime. As the years roll by, the depressions become more frequent, more severe, and require less stimulus to set them off. That's why intervention with medication as soon as possible is so paramount to healing.
Studies have also shown that antidepressants can actually have a curative effect, meaning that if the first depression is treated with medication and therapy, the likelihood of it happening again decreases sharply.
Of course, there are those patients who use a suicide attempt as a cry for help, or as a means to get attention, and some of them do end up dying. But for the patient who is suffering from severe and extended clinical depression, suicide is nothing more than a way out of a type of pain that can never really be put into words.
I've heard it said that suicide is "a permanent solution to a temporary problem," but this isn't quite accurate, at least in terms of a major clinical depression. For some, the problem is debilitating and lifelong, and for these patients, suicide is the means to finally rest, even at the cost of life itself.
***************************


Salon.com
Comments
If I had to pick out one sentence that successfully summed up this post for me, this was it.
I'm one of those people that just didn't get it before. I'm not sure I get it now, but I know I'm closer thanks to your information. For those of us who don't suffer from (or have exposure to someone close to us suffering from) clinical depression, I think we can't wrap our heads around it. It's like getting a cramp to us, something you can "work out" and feel better.
So, many many thanks for this very personal peek into what constitutes depression. You've opened some eyes here, and hopefully someone who is suffering in ignorance will see themselves here and try to get some help.
Thumbed. Marvelous post, Mary Ann. Deserves and EP.
Everyone but the nurses and doctors can be thoughtless, cruel, and unsupportive, especially when they see relationships as a means to their personal ends. They tend to resent chronic illness because we can no longer play to their agendas.
I consider suicide not to be an act of selfishness, but a desperate act of trying to get relief . I consider those who call it such to be the truly selfish ones who think only of themselves, their self serving and twisted definitions of another persons suffering, and their own loss.
Thanks for a comprehensive and educational discussion of depression as another difficult component of chronic illness. Rated, of course.
And Zuma, yes--family members of the depressed patient are indeed feeling their own loss, and instead of blaming the disease, they blame the sufferer.
Between the time of my psych ward stay and hospital stay, I spent some time at my parents' house, and my father was almost stereotypical in his response to the disease. He came up to me one night and said, "Why can't you just snap out of this? You're bringing everyone else down."
Even in this desperate state, I was able to get angry with him for his lack of compassion and cruel comments, and I high-tailed it out of there. The very last thing I needed was criticism for something I had no control over whatsoever. Perhaps it was no accident that within a week or so, I ended up in a full-on psychiatric hospital, which is where I finally got the help I needed.
Yes, yes, yes. When depression is overcome, nothing is so beautiful as the majesty and power of the simple things--in my case, mainly my little nieces.
I myself felt like ending my life many years ago, but I needed to go on because I had a small child and couldn´t stand the notion of leaving him alone in this world... I was lucky and asked for help, but not many receive the help they need, and I think that there is a moment when a person privately feels that they have had enough with life, they just can´t go on.
Life can be so painful sometimes and for such long periods... what a topic really.
Rated, and take care of yourself, ok?
A big hug to you.
because there's the realization that pain has overrode the fundamental desire to live.
Jumped out at me. My Father killed himself when I was 9. I am older now than he was when he died. It will be 30 years ago this Novemeber. I have been going thur a very difficult period in my life lately and been struggling with these thought myself.
I do relate to what you write.
Rated for exploring the subject matter so honestly and openly.
If there is any positive thing to be said about recurring major depression, it's that it recurs - meaning we survived, recovered, lived some more, maybe even experienced moments of joy that we are grateful not to have missed.
The despair can seem permanent, an impenetrable substance that has us trapped like insects in amber. But so it seemed the first time, and here we are. Living proof.
I'm lifting a glass or offering a hug or in some way wishing for you the relief you seek - not succor, Relief! - and, thus, the joy that you know is there, but have missed.
Great article, thanks for sharing.
Of course, rated.
Indie Girl--I'm so sorry that your father took his own life, and that you now struggle with depression yourself. It really gives credence to the inherited gene theory. Please stay strong.
Boeg--Like you, once I can get to the heart of the depression--once the truth is brought out into the light of day--a healing can definitely happen. But there are the unlucky few out there who, no matter what they do, never ever get relief. In a sense, depression at that point is terminal.
Annette--thank you for the sweet hugs, and Redstocking--while I'm happy to hear your depression is under control, keep in mind that in any depressed patient, a suicidal turn can happen quickly, almost without warning. So please stay in close touch with your psychiatrist!
Leonde--The teenage son actually died first, I think. Good question.
To Hello She lied--You're right...I think the average time for an untreated depression is about nine months. My case was a bit different because the intensity and untreatableness of my chronic pain made me feel doubly hopeless. The stimulus for the depression was chronic, so therefore it couldn't lift on its own. All of it was just a mess.
I particularly loved your comment here: "I'm sure I won't be the only one who reads this and reaches a hand down into the darkness to touch yours." Just beautiful. Thank you.
And Blusurly, Connie and Tinker--Thank you for such kind words and touching support.
To see if the first drug will work, one has to wait a full month for potency, and as we both know, that is an AGONIZING wait. I'm lucky in that the standard meds work for me; if I ever had to wait two months or more for relief, I would have been a danger to myself for sure. It's just so hard to hang onto hope during that waiting period.
That's why I got addicted to pain pills, frankly. I didn't take them for the physical pain as much as my fractured emotional state. The narcotic meds saved my life, to be honest. While I've had to deal with addiction issues since then, in no way do I regret popping them when my bottom dropped out.
Great writing, as always, Scanner.
Well done.
Mary you write with fluid, cogent and clear-headed urgency. You personal Voice is accessible but not "on display", so there is a spring water aspect to your writing. Well done. Reading you is a pleasure.
A personal essay that is organized like a useful article is hard to pull off. You do not indulge yourself where most would, methinks.
We are all certainly able to, even entitled to. Just a fact. I share things with you: terrible persistent pain, and I know The Abyss, too, intimately and recently and insistently.
Pain Wins, sometimes.
The only way for some of us to make the best sense of, the love connection to, this dreadful mortal life, is to not flinch at what we Could Do, Might Do. Because only then does choose life, choose life, choose life entwine our bloody lattice, illuminate our deepest darks; only then does it finally Signify.
The great gift of non-belief, to me, is in this respect: This is my one, and only life, from the Big Bang to the heat death of the universe's last and meanest quark in a hundred trillion trillion years, this is my Only One Life, so I Choose Life Choose Life Choose Life.
Fuck Pain.
I have to stress again, though, that the depressed patient is suffering from a biological, medical illness, and when they kill themselves, they are quite simply out of their minds (literally) with pain and at the end of their endurance, which culminates in the act of suicide.
To say you have a "problem" with suicide is like saying you have a problem with someone dying of a heart attack, as if the person had a choice in the matter.
Here's hoping you never have to face a major depression, as I fear you'd be very hard on yourself, which would only make matters worse
I'm a little stumped on how to reply as your paragraphs read like poetry! Beautiful.
I'm sorry that you know depression and persistent pain, too (do you mean physical pain?). Either way, it's a bitch indeed.
And as for this being our one and only life, I have to say that I'm not too sure about that. Perhaps one day soon I'll do a post about a nutty experience I had a couple of years ago that seemed to prove that I have indeed lived before. It was just too weird!!!
That said, I'm not taking any chances. :) I intend to live my life to the very best of my ability, just in case.
In thinking about it, I do recall a thought I had when I was suicidal: I said--if reincarnation is true, if we're really here over and over to learn the lessons we need to learn, if I kill myself now, that means for sure that I'd have to come back.
While I do love life, I think once around is plenty, thank you. So I'm gonna learn those lessons NOW. :)
You might be amused by this too. Full title should be: "oops. I died."
http://open.salon.com/blog/greg_correll/2009/03/09/oops
About serotonin--A neuroscientist professor in college told our class that when people are low (if memory serves) they will sometimes get a craving for pasta and that it can boost serotonin.
I have not had your struggles nearly, but I have struggled. I have tried to write about it, but can't. I really appreciate this and your ability to call for help when you needed it. You are a strong woman.
stay well
Percipi--What you write about here is the "choice" factor. Indeed, the rational person can find it incomprehensible to commit suicide. But when serotonin and dopamine aren't functioning in the brain, the psychic pain is indescribable, and believe me, it's bad enough to consider death as the means of relief.
Also, I so much appreciate your willingness to understand and to feel compassion for the depressed patient.
Kathy--Thank you for such a kind response.
Greg--I will definitely check out those links.
And Coogan, I'm really thrown by your harsh words, particularly since I'm writing to promote understanding and compassion for the suicidally depressed patient, not debate the topic of suicide. You actually sound offended, so I apologize if I inadvertently hit a nerve. I'm wondering if you've had more experience with someone taking their own lives than what you're letting on. If so, it must be devastating to feel so abandoned in such a way. I can't even imagine.
My dad was a shrink and was one of the early proponents of specialized hospitalization for the elderly with depression. Of the people who are afflicted with this disease, they are often the last to be treated, as many physicians simply believe their "sadness" is caused by the loss of friends, chronic illness and loneliness, all of which can exacerbate depression for sure, but are not the "cause" of depression (the illness).
It is true that all those things (chronic illness, etc) can "activate" (for lack of a better word) the disease of depression (as you well know), if one has the chemical predisposition, but in and of themselves they do not "cause" depression. (Brain injury can also "activate" depression).
People should think of all the people in the world who have what others might consider "good" lives, yet commit suicide (Marilyn Monroe comes to mind), and others who have lived through dire circumstances without it (Nelson Mandela, imprisoned for 27 years).
In my family, through my mother's line, we are much predisposed to it, and are very vigilant about its symptoms.
All that said, I am pulling for you, and hope you are staying on top of this. Good luck and love!
I think coogenbluff is making the point that it is impossible to permanently end pain. The pain that prompted the decsion to commit suicide continues on in some form with loved ones who are left behind. I'm not sure that reality should or could make a difference to the person in the depths of clinical depression. But it is probably still true that some version of the victim's pain lives on in survivors.
Coogan and Dave--In no way do I negate the suffering of those left behind as a result of suicide. Yes, the pain does live on in the survivors, and since depression has a hereditary component, a suicide could actually activate (as dickens says) depression in the surviving family. My mom's mother committed suicide (a mixture of alcohol and pills that was most likely NOT an accident), and my mom has had to deal with that, so I'm not at all insensitive to it.
And Dave, thanks for you other wonderful comments. I'm glad I helped you understand just how devastating clinical depression can be. It's like no other pain on earth. You know when you're in it that nothing else even comes close to this horrifying darkness.
When she would say these things, I would have a hard time arguing with her because she was in so much physical pain.
If she had asked me to help her commit suicide, I don't know what I would have done. Maybe I would have said yes.
http://open.salon.com/blog/john_guzlowski/2009/04/03/follow_up_on_sylvia_plaths_sons_suicide
It's a great piece about the aftermath of a suicide--the permanant scars it leaves on a family. Heartbreaking stuff. Thanks, John, for turning me onto it.
Thank you for sharing this. I read it and then reread certain parts.
That feeling of not being able to walk - that hits the nail on the head, when depression is at its worst. You can actually be physically incapacitated. That's a scary feeling. I remember a moment being stuck in my hallway, having no clue where to turn, what to do next. It was an awful moment.
I have difficulty finding the words to say how much your post means to me. I've had depression since my early teens and there have been many many times I wanted to die, simply because the pain of living became unbearable.
I was once told by a family member that I simply needed to make the choice to be happy. The implication clearly being that I chose to be unhappy. I stopped trying to explain to my family after that. That comment crushed me.
Posts such as yours do much to educate those who have not experienced depression, especially long-term severe depression.
Thank you
I wrote a poem recently titled: I Think It's Called Ideations. I felt very apprehensive to post it, but readers were very kind.
This must be talked about... we must talk. Thank you again.
And Waking, I'll go to your blog now to find that poem.
I agree that depression needs to be understood as a MEDICAL DISEASE. Even when I present people with the science, they still refuse to acknowledge it.
There's also such a gross misunderstanding of what antidpressants to. Many think it's "cheating" one's way to happiness, when all it's doing is opening our receptors to the chemical our own brain is already making. Too often, antidepressants get lumped in with addictive pills, and that just drives me nuts.
Anti-depressants offered some relief over the years. I have done a lot of work to improve my diet and fitness, and I also had a medical procedure (endometrial ablation) that seems to have helped. I no longer take any medication although if I thought I needed it again I wouldn't hesitate. I do think that being on meds helped me navigate these waters, and I am certain that they saved me from taking my thoughts and semi-formed plans any further.
There are doctors out there who specialize in natural hormone replacement (or supplementation) as opposed to synthetic hormones.
Based upon what you're saying, I'd suggest to *really* stay on top of this as you approach your pre-menopause years, as it seems that your hormones and depression are closely linked.
And Lainey--yes, depression is TERRIFYING. It's truly a living nightmare when you're in the midst of it.
I don't know the details of your depression, but please don't let the fear of its return ruin your life. Some depressions are so awful that people do experience a type of PTSD once it lifts, and that is a big problem in and of itself. PLEASE get therapy, not only for the fear, but for the reasons the depression erupted in the first place.
Remember, too, that so much can be done for depression these days. It's the rare patient who doesn't respond to medication. Also, be sure to get the right diagnosis so that your treatment is tailored properly. If you have other issues--OCD, anxiety, fluctuating moods--these need to be treated as well.
If anyone needs to email me privately, please feel free to reach out.