MARY T. KELLY

I've Got Issues...

marytkelly

marytkelly
Location
Boulder, Colorado,
Birthday
October 22
Bio
Family, marital, and individual psychotherapist. Mother to four who no longer need my services but still enjoy my love as I do theirs. This is a good thing. I specialize in stepfamily dynamics and difficult transitions. I try to write from the heart with a sense of vulnerability, humor and a frank look at myself. Art shown: "Four Pots" by Lindsey Leavell

MY RECENT POSTS

DECEMBER 14, 2010 10:19AM

Would You Cut Your Right Arm Off?

Rate: 37 Flag
right arm
 
I’m a sucker for survival stories.  They fascinate me.  I marvel at the way people who find themselves in extreme situations, who are ordinary people suddenly literally fighting for their lives, display remarkable previously untapped resources and strengths for coping with their situations.

This past weekend I watched a documentary where survivors of the plane that landed in the Hudson River were interviewed.  They were people, seemingly just like me, who described their harrowing experience on that plane, an experience that didn’t end until they were safely on land.  They spoke calmly and precisely and I wondered how they could.

My husband is a man who was quite fortunate to grow up with the mountains of Vail as his backyard.  He has described himself as a teenager, back in the days where he would run home from school on a Friday afternoon, grab some basic supplies and head out into the back country, strap skis on his back and trudge up the nearest mountain to sleep on ledges steep and stare at stars that kept him company those long solo nights before he hit the virgin snow at the crack of dawn with his skis pointed down, down, down and there was no one but him and the mountain and speed.  How did he manage this?

Once, he took three men on a ski hut trip and got caught midway through in a blizzard so seismic it shut down the ski mountain of Telluride.  I’ve made him tell me that story a dozen times.  I love to hear about his resilience, his strength, his perseverance and how well he took care of the other men who were less experienced than he when they found themselves unable to make it to the next hut.  He built a fire and snow caves before he discovered he was left with a solidly frozen block of a sleeping bag for an interminably long night.  How did he do that?

I’ve wondered when I hear these stories how I would fare in any of those situations.  Would I be the one hysterical passenger trying to jump over people to escape the nearest airplane exit?  Would I, had I been on my husband’s expedition, gotten so tired, cold and worn out I would have simply sat on the ground and refused to budge?

This past weekend, my husband and I went to see “127 Hours”, the story of Aron Ralston, the Colorado climber who went solo hiking in the Canyonlands of Utah only to find himself in the most unthinkable of circumstances, taking a fall down a crevice and bringing a large boulder with him.  His boulder and right arm seemed fated to meet, and at the end of the fall, he slowly realized his arm was wedged into seeming permanence against the canyon wall with the boulder stubbornly protecting it.

My heart was racing when I watched this scene.  My stomach sank as I watched the character of Aron Ralston (played by James Franco) react as he realized his impossible and dire predicament.  It didn’t matter that I knew what was inevitably coming or that in present day, Ralston is alive and well.  I was terrified.

 “Do not lose it, Aron.  Do not lose it!” he told himself over and over again.  The next five days he spent with himself and that boulder transformed into a journey of the past, the present and the future.  Self-examination of the life he had so far lived became foremost present in his mind.

He realized his selfish ways, his taking for granted those he loved, his arrogance at not leaving a note to say where he had gone, and in the middle of that forlorn ancient place where his only company was a black raven who made a routine of flying over him each morning, he realized his inevitable death and sent messages of love to his parents and friends via modern technology in the form of a video camera.

As I watched the movie, I tried to imagine my own reaction.  My heart would race as I tried to anticipate what it would be like to be so stuck and powerless, and all I could imagine was pure terror and darkness. 

The movie takes a sudden turn when Ralston realizes if he breaks his bones, he could possibly amputate his arm.  This is when I closed my eyes.  Mercifully, the scene was brief and the joy Ralston experiences when he was finally free from the rock made me want to jump up in my theater seat and shout for joy!

I will still never understand how he didn’t faint, didn’t collapse after five days of virtually no food or water, and walked eight miles post his savage amputation until he ran into some hikers who had been alerted to look for a missing hiker.

As happy as I was for the outcome for Ralston, I felt somewhat dejected.  Actually, I was disappointed in myself because I felt I never could do what he had done.  And not because I would lack the physical ability to do so (although that is of course very questionable), but rather that I lacked the mental strength it would take to survive such an ordeal.

I read a poll recently where people were asked if they were in Ralston’s situation, would they have done the same thing?  44% of them said, “Yes”.  Wow.  That’s a lot of confidence those 44% have.  I’m not sure I could be so bold as to say that, despite wanting to believe it could be true of me. 

I got home from the movie and I couldn’t get it out of my mind.  I spent the next day pouring over the book Ralston had written about his ordeal and as many interviews of him I could get my hands on.  Repeatedly he would insist that he was an ordinary man and that anyone would be just as capable as he was of making the same decisions in that narrow stone grave.

It made my day more precious thinking of life and death and death and back to life again.  I thought about the things I keep such a death grip on, the things that keep me stuck, the things that serve me no purpose, time wasters, shallow pettiness and Bermuda triangle ruminations that zap me of energy and strength.

Ironically, the holidays have their own savage hold on us.  My office has been filled of late with those stuck between a rock and a hard place with the ridiculous expectations of shopping and presents they can’t afford to give to people who don’t need them anyway.

Inspired by Ralston’s story, I wrote my four children yesterday.  I told them my Christmas wish.  Spend the day with me.  Go for a long hike in the beautiful Colorado woods near our home, share a meal and stories of times gone by, soak each other up, enjoy the present moment, all that we enjoy now for none of us knows what lies ahead.

Now that is something I’d give my right arm for but I didn’t have to.  They all responded with enthusiastic YES’s and one, “Yeah, F…k presents!”

Gawd I love those kids, my husband, my life and… my right arm.

Feliz Navidad.

 

 

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
What a thoughtful post, meandering from a movie to Christmas with nary a bump. I don't know if any of us could do what this young man did, but I suspect given the options he had there would be more self-preservationists than we think. Merry Christmas Mary!
Great story and movie review, Mare. I now do not have to see the movie! It's nice to take stock of all the blessings we have around us, family being the greatest gift in life. Love to you, Nick and the kids this Christmas and always.
how you got there, writing-wise, is as Sheila says right above me, a great read, but the bottom line is seeing through the fogged-up glasses to what is important in life. and what that is *is* life, the people we love, the ones we live with, who make us happy and fulfilled and whose lives we are important to. i'm thanking you for giving me these thoughts first thing today because i *really* needed them. merry christmas, mary.
Considering the fact that I have a problem watching even mild violence on screen I have stayed away from this movie. But I know that I need to see it.

Great comparison with our own, by comparison, trivial struggles.
This is a beautiful reflection on what's important. Thanks, Mary.
Cathy: You're always first...or close to it in my heart.

Buffy: Well, as one who has not only survived, but thrived when given adversity, I believe you! Merry Christmas to you.

JC: Always good to take stock...always.

femme forte: Just read your story about the coyote. What a wide awake person you are and you are so right...focus on those we love over and over again. Merry Christmas. Thank you for reading and such a great comment.

Roger: I don't like watching violence of any kind, but honestly, it was only about 3 minutes and I kept my eyes closed (this is an option!). It was well worth this fantastic and life affirming movie. I can just get so annoyed with my tendency to smallness. Seeing this helped knock some sense into me :)

Lainey: Thank you! Happy holidays to you and yours.
I have discovered doctors can replace just about any body part and at times improve upon the original. So if the arm had to go then the arm would go. What sounds interesting about the movie is the enforced self-reflection.
" . . . the things that keep me stuck, the things that serve me no purpose, time wasters, shallow pettiness and Bermuda triangle ruminations that zap me of energy and strength." Oh, do I got me some of those!

Rated; and can't wait to see the movie now.
Mary, I just loved how you segued into your patients being between "a rock and a hard place" about things so unimportant in life. You share a great lesson here. Thank you & Happy Holidays.
Always a wonder we have about what we would do in situations. I recall from being at Virginia Tech in the midst of the shooting that I wanted to go outside to try to help, when the admissions office had us locked inside. Not sure if that desire was there because I knew it was not feasible as they would not allow it, and what I would have done had I been outside and capable of doing so.

Cutting my arm off? Yeah, I am not sure what I would do there. I doubt those who suggest they know in a heart beat about such stuff. Heck, it even took this guy some time.

Likewise, there are interesting stats around the OR assisted suicide law. Of those who receive the meds, only 10% or so (recalling from memory) actually go through with the euthanasia. I remember thinking it would be about 50-50, but it was way, way less than that.

The guy obviously had courage, or perhaps it is that desperate desire to live as evidenced by those Oregon stats? Chicken/egg to be sure and hard to say with any certainty how one would act.
Loved this. Happy holidays MTK
Oh how I love your writing, Mary, and I marvel at your ability to speak with such simply clarity about these complicated thoughts that take serious mental penetration to analyze. Who knows what any one of us would do until faced with that choice? I've seen supposedly brave men crumble in the face of much lesser challenges and, conversely, seen ordinary and even somewhat timid people rise to a status quite remarkable by any standards. I suppose that is why we have to cultivate a solid relationship of integrity with our heart and our soul because they tend to have the final word when the going gets tough. Wonderful post! Simply wonderful:) Happy Holidays with those beautiful kids and hubby!
What a wise and happy tale. Love to hear about your relationships and how you come to changes and conclusions. Someday we will meet, I hope. Have a wonderful holiday.
Fabulous post, as always........and you surely raised your kids right!

And as for the question of what would WE do in such a spot? I think that we all have the same, powerful, mad desire to survive.....and that if we are threatened with death, we would all step up and surprise ourselves. Fortunately, most of us will never have to find out.

Feliz Navidad!
Great post! And I guess I'm old enough (or realistic enough) to recognize that I'd like to think I'd cut my right arm off . . . but really . . . I'd probably have died out there.
A friend of mine who survived a horrible accident once said you never know what you're going to do in any given situation until you're in that situation. So true; and so are your observations about when and where we might choose to lose an arm, or lose our heads, or give up, or stay in the game. R
Great post with thought provoking questions. I suppose many people cut off (or out) pieces of their hearts in the way they treat and handle people and don't think twice about it, because they are so much more worried what they will "look" like if they had to cut off a limb for their own survival. I'm glad you and your kids will be enjoying the gift of each other over the holidays. Thanks for a great post!
I had a hard time with the TRAILER to the movie!
Great post. Lots to think about.
:) you are such a good Mom
(and I couldn't do it either- I just cannot imagine being able to stay conscious long enough, or not bleed out. I have no idea how he survived.)
I don't think that brave 44% were completely honest..but I digress. Good for you for making such a thoughtful and loving Christmas wish.
R
You write: "I was disappointed in myself because I felt I never could do what he had done."

I don't know if you are correct about that. In extreme circumstances, I think most people will garner the strength to do what they must to survive.

I also like what you suggested to your kids, and I especially like their response!
Have you ever seen the film Stranded? It's a retrospective look back at the survivors of the Andes plane crash and it is WONDERFUL. Pretty sure you can find it on Netflix or even public television. It left me with a feeling that reminds me of what you express here so well. The resilience and fortitude of the human spirit can shock you, in ways both good and bad. Both films are about the good, and the power of such a life threatening experience to effect long lasting changes right down to the inner psyche of a person, that's truly transformative.
Mary T, I don't think I could do it.. and I can't even watch the movie about it. One thing I do wonder about is what is driving these people who are so pressured? The prevalent culture? media? their families? Since I don't feel it (gratefully so) I wonder why and why not. Well posited post.
Wow, Mary. That was one of your best! I think that 44% is a bit high in my estimation. I would guess one out of a hundred might be closer to reality. I don't have a survey, but I've seen a few things and figure most people either panic or freeze up. Neither is good. The ones that survive are the ones that keep their heads, gather in the situation and take positive action. Many of the ones that you'd think would be the hero are the ones who crack. Often it's the quiet one you'd never expect that will surprise you.

'Nough of that, I loved the direction change and the conclusion of this. Peace, Love and Happy Christmas!
I look forward to seeing this movie over the holidays. Based on the trailer alone, Franco deserves an Oscar. But to answer your titular question, I highly doubt I could break my own bones, let alone cut off my own arm.

I don't have any tales of derring-do to measure up to your husband. The worst that ever happened to me were a couple of day hikes that went too long and I had to sleep outside sans sleeping bag and mat. It was merely uncomfortable and not death-defying.
Are you REALLY going to eff the presents? Mary, this is another great piece and so very very well written. Love the seismic blizzard! Among other things. I have a feeling I'm not one of those 44%ers. What would I have done? Try to bash my head against the boulder hard enough to not have to die slowly. Want to hear Nick's hut story when you two come to ski! xoxoxo
Dorinda: "Enforced self-reflection"...yes, that's right. He probably would not have been able to learn what he needed to learn without this extreme circumstance. And for that, he readily admits. It seems inevitable that all of us have opportunities for "enforced self-reflection" but it continues to be optional. I think you know of which I speak. Thank you.

montanarose: I'm glad you picked up on this one paragraph. This is something I must remind myself daily, if not at times, minute to minute. Now go see the movie!

trilogy: Thank you. I was hoping it wouldn't seem too much of a stretch. And to be honest, the name of Aron Ralston's book is, "Between A Rock and A Hard Place". Thank you for reading.

Gwool: I love how you admit that you weren't sure if the desire was there because you knew it wasn't feasible. If you were to ask me the question if I could cut my arm off, I would say I dont think I could. For him, the real dilemma was figuring out how to break his bones first. He was an engineer. There were physics he understood that I would have been completely clueless about. And the bigger question for me: How the heck did he not faint; how did he then walk another 8 miles? An astonishing story from a man who insists he is nothing but ordinary.

OE: Thanks OE! Happy holidays to you and your well loved wife.

Susan: Thank you...a big compliment coming from one as talented as you (you do know how much I love both your writing and your art). You're right...heroism can come in the most unexpected of forms. I love this, We have to cultivate a solid relationship of integrity with our heart and soul". This is a daily practice, but if practiced, will benefit us in many many ways. Thank you!

Lea: Someday we will meet. Period. I refuse to have hope. Only the way to figure out time and place. I'm thinking maybe NYC?

neilpaul: Well, you would have had plenty of time to waste, so you might have been able to do both. And I did have to laugh at your comment. Sometimes we have to pick our poison on what we choose to ruminate about! Thank you.

Ginny Rose: I often think my children turned out quite well despite me, but lets hope that is only false humility. I think you are right about the very strong will to survive and that we would indeed surprise ourselves. And like you, I'm hoping I never find out. Have a wonderful holiday.

Owl: I'm with you. I think I would be a mere memory if that had been me :)

Nikki: You speak from experience and I believe you. You also remind me how much choice we truly do have, even in the worst of circumstances. Thank you.

cartouche: Yes, great point. We do mindlessly cut out our own hearts and those we even love deeply, but would recoil and rebel at the thought of losing a limb. Now, you really have me thinking, as usual. Thank you.

Chicago: So did I! Swore I would never see the movie but then felt compelled to do so. Too much was made of the small 3 minute amputation scene. Really.

Major Mojo: Thank you so much for reading.

Julie: Thank you Julie, for the Mom comment. And I agree with you. How did he not bleed out, stay conscious, walk out, etc.? Incredible story.

Steve: I think the 44% were just a bit full of themselves. Thank you so much for reading.

Procopius: I would love to think I could do something like that. I so admire his ability to focus on a solution for himself rather than the fear. That takes incredible strength but it's the only hope. I like my kids responses, all of them too :)

Ablonde: Is "Stranded" the documentary where the survivors are interviewed so many years later? If so, yes, I saw it and yes, it was WONDERFUL. Inspiring. I've also seen the movie version, "Alive" at least a dozen times. Another fantastic survival story. Thanks for reminding me of the Andes story. It still gives me chills.

rita: Like you, I don't think I could do it either and I surprised myself by going to watch the movie. I leaned over to my husband in the beginning of the movie and said, "I don't think I can do this", but hey I did! Thats gotta be worth something. What drives people? Perfection, ego, fear, pressure to name a few. You are well blessed to not feel these things. They are a complete and total waste of time. Thank you.

Michael: Good to see you! How's school? How are you??? I am so happy you enjoyed this post so much and I agree that the 44% is a bit way too high. And life and people often surprise us, both positively and negatively. And yes, 'nough of that. Peace, Love and Happy Christmas to you too! Thank you so much for reading.

Travis: I'm glad you have plans to see the movie. Please let me know what you think. I think Franco deserves a nomination for sure. He was absolutely incredible. Aron Ralston felt he represented him quite well. As for your not so comfortable night out without a sleeping bag, that sounds death defying to me!

Joan: I'm hoping that my kids eff any kind of present to me or Nick. It would be ridiculous. However, between you and me, I am their Mother and I will be giving them presents. Period. Your solution to this dilemma if you were caught between a rock and a hard place (the title of Ralston's book) had me laughing. Thank you so much sis.
Now THIS is a different Christmas story -- on the other hand, it isn't, since Christmas celebrates the birth of someone we are told made the supreme sacrifice, not for himself, but for others.
Hi Mary!

I liked this a lot. I also believe that when it comes to life over death, many of us would have come to the same conclusion and outcome instinctively. I view it no differently that the wolf that chews its leg off to get out of a trap. But I have no desire to watch it, thanks for telling us THAT scene is breif.

I love Franco's acting ability. And I am happy that you seem happy :-)
You are always a voice of reason Mary and when I find your words I take them to heart. Thank you for making me think about this dire situation. I would like to think I would survive but then again I have to wonder about the depth of my true ability.
Sending you and your family blessings for a Merry Christmas and a happy, healthy New Year.
Tom, well maybe you can grant me that it may be a story that puts a different slant to the commercialism of Christmas. As to the original story, that's true. Happy Holidays to you my good OS friend.

Kellylark: HI! Good to see you again!!! And yes, I am happy, thank you for that. The situation Ralston found himself in was quite rare, but I think you have a point. The desire to survive is quite strong for most of us. I think Franco is a fantastic actor and was happy to see him nominated for a Golden Globe aware. I'm also hoping for an Oscar nomination.

ladyfarmerjed: Hi! Thank you so much for reading. And Im also wishing you and yours a wonderful stress-free Christmas and awesome New Year. It's good to be alive!
Like you, I'm fascinated by survival stories...including because I wonder what I would do in similar situations. (And like you, I doubt my courage to do what would be needed in many, many circumstances.) And finally, also like you, I think that 44% are fooling themselves. I think the way we act in extreme circumstances may be better or may be worse than what we imagine what we would do, but that it's almost always different.