mamoore

mamoore
Location
Michigan,
Birthday
December 13
Bio
At my best, I try to be a voice for children. At my very best, I help them find their own voice. ************************************ We don't accomplish anything in this world alone...and whatever happens is the result of the whole tapestry of one's life and all the weavings of individual threads from one to another that creates something. - Sandra Day O'Connor * ************************************

MY RECENT POSTS

Mamoore's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
MARCH 27, 2009 9:07AM

Raise Your Hand If...

Rate: 60 Flag

 clara's hand

 

I’m washing the dishes after dinner.  My middle daughter, a 3rd grader, sits across from me recounting her day.  She’s the one that seeks me out when the others are busy, knowing she will finally get my full attention.

 

This time, she doesn’t lead in with a warm up story about a joke she learned on the school bus or which friend she really, really wants to have sleep over this weekend.  She just goes straight for the heart.

 

“Today in class…” she pauses to make sure I am really paying attention.

 

“Yes, I’m listening.”

 

“Well, today in class, Mrs. Beda asked us to raise our hand if one of our parents had lost their job.”

 

“Really?”  I’m surprised her teacher would bring up such a potentially sensitive subject as a group discussion topic. “So, what happened?”

 

“Well, actually, first she told us her husband lost his job last week.” 

 

My mind starts calculating how much teachers make these days and I wonder if that will be enough for her family of four.  I love this woman and am worried for her, but still question her choice to talk about such a life-altering topic in class. I have stopped washing dishes now and am focusing my attention entirely on my daughter.

 

“So, did kids raise their hands?”

 

“Yeah, seven not including the teacher.”

 

“Seven?  And how many kids in your class?”

 

“22.”

 

Math was never one of my best subjects but it doesn’t take me long to figure it out.  Seven out of twenty-two, that’s close to a third of the kids in her class.  That doesn’t even include the teachers’ husband.

 

My daughter is waiting for me to say something but no words of wisdom are coming.  I keep asking questions.  Which kids?  Did they seem scared?  What did your teacher say after that?

 

“I was the only one who knew about Sarah’s dad.  She didn’t want to tell anyone else.  But she raised her hand after the other kids did.”  

 

And then I got it.  I understood why the teacher had asked them to raise their hands. 

 

In homes around the country, spanning all income levels, parents are having conversations.  The news is on during dinner. The radio plays on the drive to school.  And kids are listening.  Teachers know this, just like they knew it before. 

 

The Twin Towers fell and Mrs. Hollinger had them all sit in a circle and hold hands.

 

The Tsunami hit Indonesia and Mrs. Ogmundson showed them on a map how very far away it was and helped them raise money to send to the school children there.

 

The War began and Mr. Crothers told stories about when he was in the army and had them make cards for the soldiers.

 

The Gunman inexplicably kills his peers and Mrs. Semans teaches them what to do in a lock down situation and then let’s them ask “Why?’.

 

A local family’s house burns down and they collect clothes and toys in the classrooms.  A parent dies in a car accident and the teacher is the one to break the news to the class and then attends the funeral.

 

Everyday our children go to school carrying with them bits and pieces of information.  Things they overhear, things they see, things their parents scream and cry about.  They comprehend what they hear at levels as diverse as their learning abilities.  But they know when something is in the air.  And our teachers know when the time has come.  When they can not move forward with the daily lesson plan until they have somehow addressed another one of those issues that we would all rather not have to discuss with an 8 year-old.

 

Sometimes, when something really bad happens, I struggle with how to approach the subject with my kids. I don’t want to make them afraid of the world.  I will admit there have even been times I might have chosen not to tell them. Almost without fail, those are the times the teachers have stepped up to the plate.  It is so much easier to talk to my kids about violent school shootings when they have already spent time processing it with their peers, under the guidance of a teacher who gets where they are at.  It is empowering when they are given a task like raising money or collecting clothes. They are doing something, and that helps them to move forward.  It has been an invaluable gift to me as a parent.

 

So, there was Mrs. Beda.  Asking them to raise their hands.  Telling the kids about her husband.  Letting them know they are not alone.  Giving them a forum to share their own stories. Allowing them to ask the questions that maybe they were too afraid to ask at home.  She is teaching them life skills that are going to be especially valuable in the months ahead.  She is wrapping her arms around them. She gave them a writing assignment that day, “Write about a time when you felt afraid.”  Maybe this will be their pathway to discussion with their parents.

 

It’s an old story.  The role teachers play in our lives is under-valued.  Today, I want to recognize the teachers who are there for our kids when life feels uncertain.  The ones who don’t back away from the tough subjects but make them accessible to an 8 year-old.  The ones who show up even when their own lives are overwhelming. The ones who look into their student’s eyes and know it’s time to put the math lesson aside.

 

website statistics

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Yeh Mrs. Beda for her compassion! I hope everyone who is unemployed/under employed finds a way to make it.
Thank you for this story, children are so often forgotten.
I love her too, she is an amazing gift in my daughter's life!
Here's to our teachers!

I love this post. It made me very teary for many, many reasons.
Thank you so much.
:) Ann
Thanks Mom! When I try to think of end of the year presents for my kids' teachers I can never pick one that really expresses the deep level of gratitude I feel.
There are so many wonderful teachers and your post gives tribute to them with a story that reminds us of the influence teachers can have in our lives. Thanks!
The Irritated Mom pointed me over here. That was really good. I am going to forward the link to our superintendent of schools....
This was so beautiful and is much appreciated. Teachers often fail to achieve the appreciation they deserve, especially in these extraordinary times. Thanks for such lovely writing, too.

By the way, I have a third grader as well. When you were describing your daughter's "Today in class..." I could hear my son's voice in my head. A recap of "today in class" is a daily event in our house, too.
Good teachers are the one's that leave an indelible imprint on our lives. They are many. A wonderful, wonderful post. Thanks
Rated
Amen, and very well said. I don't think we have a problem with teachers so much as we have with a problem with parents.
This is my understanding of what teachers are. I never did understand the backlash against teachers. It certainly has not helped anything. When my Mom started teaching in the 1950's, she was revered. When she was near retirement in the 1980's, in her 50's, she was threatened with violence from parents. America had changed, and not for the better.
Exquisite. Thank you.
There should be more like her. Many more.

Discussing topics with kids that frighten adults is tough. But it needs doing, because the kids do know when something's up.

Thumbed. Excellent writing.
I am so glad that this has touched people. No teacher is perfect, and some of those I mentioned above had moments that I questioned, but they have all made my children better humans and made me a better parent.
A MUST read. Kerry, Joan??? Hello???????
Yhea ... Tooch ~ This is an EP / Cover ... let's move it people!
Thanks for the support! Maybe if I gave it a racier name????
Wonderful! You are lucky your child has this teacher. My partner's son was in high school when 9/11 happened and the school did nothing, nothing to help the kids through it. He's a therapist and offered to come in and spend time with the kids or whatever they needed and they said no, they wouldn't be doing that. sheesh. It's like back in the dark ages when people didn't talk about the dead and thought talking about "bad things" was wrong.
Melissa: this made my eyes water. Very well-written. It should make EP and be featured on the cover!

I briefly saw a headline on the Holland paper kiosk that Michigan has lost 264,000 jobs--but I don't know the time frame. Sadly, we're losing population, too. I believe the rate is much higher. It never takes into consideration those who stopped looking and those who lost part-time jobs.

Rated. I posted this on DIGG
Oh gosh, you got me all teary-eyed. Mrs. Beda sounds wonderful.

We had a parent-teacher conference this week. After the teacher talked to us about my daughter, my husband was wise enough to say, “Our daughter says she loves her teacher. She says you are very fair.” Her smile was huge! If you could let Mrs. Beda know how you appreciate her, I’m sure it would mean a lot.

Thumbed.
I love it when this happens! Congratulations on the EP and cover. Now, go and answer those interview questions I sent you, would you? ;)
YAY! I loved this post. Smart, full of heart and well said.
It's interesting to view these times from a child's perspective. 7 out of 22 kids experiencing a parent loosing a job is heart wrenching. --rated--
Thank you for sharing this story. It brings back bittersweet memories of me having to use the globe to show how far away we were from the Tsunami, too.

We lost a very very good volunteer at our parochial school and I did not find out about it until five minutes before class. The lady and her husband had died in a car crash. She was to help us with the liturgy for Mass that week. We went back to the classroom after prayer circle stunned. One kid said: Boy that was fast. It can happen so fast.

I said: "Guys I think I need a hug. " The girls came and we had a group hug.. the boys were not sure how to react but they were clearly thinking inside their own heads. These were fifth graders. It was a long, long day. We all loved her so, and we all were numb the rest of the week, as this happened on a Monday.
I think some parents thought it was inappropriate that I cried in front of the students. It may have been but I was just being myself. I think they learned something from it and I valued how they felt.

This was a wonderful post and from teachers: Thank you. You get it how we constantly have issues to react to and comment on, or choose not to comment on... it is never easy to decide how to react or not react. Sept. 11th I was teaching third grade, so I was limited to telling them: something has happened to our country and the principal has asked me to let your parents explain it to you. I was off the hook but I felt uncomfortable having them wonder all day what it was about.

Thanks again.
Thank you for sharing this. My children are all adults now, happily settled with husbands and careers. This brought back memories of the many wonderful teachers that influenced them 20 years ago.

Rated.
My mom was teaching 5th graders when the first plane hit on 9/11. She turned on the t.v. and let them watch. She knew history was being made. When people started jumping, she turned it off. She knew some things they might never forget should not be seen.

For those interested in sharing what 9/11 was really like, there is a remarkable documentary shot during that day by two brother filmmakers who were shooting a movie about a rookie firefighter in New York. They caught the first plane, the second plane, were on sight with the first responding firefighters, and there when the buildings fell. It shows it like it was, in all its surreality. It is called 9/11. I would not recommend it for anyone under 11.
Great story! I spoke to my kids about this very difficult topic and to my surprise, it had been raised as a topic in their classrooms several weeks ago. They had started a food drive to donate to the local foodbank. My daughters gave me a list of the kids they new whose parents lost their jobs and eventually their homes. It was very sad. I'm glad to hear these types of "real life" subjects are being discussed in the classroom.
I remember several times when some tragedy struck very close to home and as a pastor and counselor I would be called to the schools to help the guidance counselors and teachers as the kids processed the loss of a classmate in an auto accident or when someone's parent was killed in a factory accident. I always left those grueling days thinking that I do this once in a blue moon for these kids, but the teachers do it daily, year in year out. The events dealt with may not be as dramatic, but they can be just as frightening or important to a child.

I had the same issues come up in my own congregations, but there the support system is built in and continually functioning, so while the pastor leads in the support he has automatically a large portion of the congregation as fellow ministers. The teacher often has no support system, including the too often tuned out parents at home. There care and savvy are indespensible. Often we treat then instead as woodwork.

Monte
Great job, Mrs. Beda.

I taught preschool in Appalachia for a year, the year AFTER 9-11. On the first anniversary, I remember the surreal nature of picking up/dropping off kids on the school bus and almost all of them had seen some sort of memorial service on the TV. Most of them, being only 3-5 years old, had only the vaguest memories, if any at all, of the previous year's events and didn't understand that it wasn't actually happening now, or happening again, that it was just a memorial.

Another teacher at the school had an Army Ranger brother. When we went to war against Iraq, the kids all wanted to know why she was so upset all day.

It's a hard job, trying to figure out just how and how much to explain.
Brava, Mrs. Beda! Those kids are lucky, and this is one of the (perhaps few) ways in which this generation is luckier than mine was. Back then, so much was shameful and hidden.
Unfortunately among the parents who are unemployed are an increasing number of teachers as property tax revenue drops, and districts make painful cuts in staff. A harsh reality.
Excellent topic, excellent writing, excellent points made. I don't have kids so I don't think of these things often. I'm glad to be reminded what an important role our good teachers play in children's lives.
I applaud this teacher.
Rated!
I was expecting sap - I was pleasantly surprised. I'm forwarding this to the teachers I know. (and a few miserable cretins who still don't believe things are all that bad)

for what it's worth, I was in my 8th grade English teacher's class when they announced he had been killed that morning in an accident. I remember being not terribly fond of the man. I remember crying quite a bit.

I drove past a billboard earlier this week - it was touting that the area was "still 93% employed!" as if it were an accomplishment. My math puts that at 7% unemployed, and last time I checked, that was pretty high.
Lovely article. I've had some wonderful teachers in my life and this brought back fond memories. I'm old enough that I was in 3rd grade during the Iran hostage crisis, and I remember our teacher teaching us what it was all about.
Well! That's just about the best thing I've heard all day. Thank you.
This is just warming my heart (which is a little comatose right now after sitting through 3 1/2 hours of South Pacific at the high school). Our parent/teacher conferences are next week and I can't wait to tell Mrs. Beda how many fans she has! Thanks to everyone who passed this on to the teachers in their life, that means a lot to me.
i got halfway through your wonderful story then scrolled back quickly to the top to see if it had gotten an EP..and it did, thank god

so that saves me having to rant at the editors

yours is a voice that is completely missing from the media...the real truth about how terrific our teachers often are..and how we depend on them for so much more than reading and 'riting and 'rithmatic

i wish that every parent could read this..it's positively inspring
Beautiful teacher story.
Loved it!
"And our teachers know when the time has come. When they can not move forward with the daily lesson plan until they have somehow addressed another one of those issues that we would all rather not have to discuss with an 8 year-old."

Sadly, a lot of households suffer from the 'White elephant in the living room" syndrome and matters affecting all are never discussed.

As much as I want to shelter my daughter from the ills of the world, I want her to realize what's going on and how it relates to us. I also want her to know that it is okay to come to mom and dad with any question(s).

Rated.
Wow, great story, beautifully told! What a perfect thing for Mrs. Beda to have done. Kids live with a lot of fear, as you say, from things half heard or understood. To have such a great bunch of teachers for your kids says a lot about teachers in general.
Thanks for this warm and lovely post.
Could you come and sit in on all my parent/teacher conferences from now on? Maybe bring this post?

After Columbine, I was teaching in Rapid City. As it happened in many other places across the country, we had a kid think it would be funny to call in with a threat to the students. We went into lock down and were told that no one could leave the school, since the threat also said some of the cars had been rigged. So, they herded us into the gym. Some of the kids began to speculate that this is exactly what the killers would want...all of us in one place. Then, I noticed her...a freshman girl sitting in the bleachers trying really hard not to let anyone notice her shaking and sobbing. I sat by her and tried my best to comfort her and answer questions...and of course not act somewhat nervous myself. You're right, we see things parents never do and don't have the option of avoiding them. That girl deserved more than that.

Thanks so much for recognizing that in your daughter's teacher and all teachers. We could do the same for all jobs (except of course AIG CEOs haha).