mamoore

mamoore
Location
Michigan,
Birthday
December 13
Bio
At my best, I try to be a voice for children. At my very best, I help them find their own voice. ************************************ We don't accomplish anything in this world alone...and whatever happens is the result of the whole tapestry of one's life and all the weavings of individual threads from one to another that creates something. - Sandra Day O'Connor * ************************************

MY RECENT POSTS

Mamoore's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
JULY 1, 2009 11:01AM

Unparenting: A Six Day Lesson

Rate: 30 Flag

 

                                        

                 sunset

                                     

I’ve had the event penciled into my mental calendar since the day of her birth:

 “Teen years: Need for independence will bring about painful yet joyous steps away from parents, often involving a lot of tears.  Be prepared.” 

Over the years, I’ve done a lot of reading and observation, getting myself ready.  I knew there would come a day when I would have to start taking small steps backwards while my daughter attempted to leap forward. The thing is, I thought I had more time.  My daughter is only eight.  I was far from prepared for the week we just experienced together. Or was that apart?

For those of you who don’t know, we spend our summers living at a camp.  A camp where kids come to stay for one to six weeks beginning the summer they are entering fourth grade. It seems like forever that my daughter has waited for this summer to come – the year she would officially transition from a staff kid to a real camper.  The summer she would not have to sit at a table in the dining hall with her parents. The summer she would be able to choose her activities and not have to spend endless hours playing house with the littler girls. The summer she would watch the sunset on the beach while softly singing songs and then walk arm-in-arm with her new friends back to their cabin for the night. 

We were all prepared. We thought it would be easy, not much different than the camp life she had always known. She would see us everywhere.  She knows the staff like she knows family. She knows her way around, knows the schedule, knows how to set the tables, knows the words to the songs, knows many of the older campers. 

 

Oh, how wrong we were.

 

 Day 1: Check-in

We packed her bags, her initials carefully printed in the outfits she had agonized over.  I tried to give her one last thorough scrubbing but our well pump somehow broke down at this exact moment and I was forced to dump bowls of cold water over her soapy head – oh well, camp is not about shiny hair and nails.  As her dad and I took her proudly to the check-in desk and joked with our fellow staff members about being “concerned parents”, my daughter beamed.  She was thrilled to find out her cabin leader was one of the spunky girls from the UK that everyone adores.  Most parents drop and run – sometimes with a few tears, but almost always looking forward to what they will accomplish in the weeks ahead. My husband and I didn’t go anywhere, except a brief pit stop on the boy’s side of camp to drop off our son.  By the time I returned to Girls Camp, she had passed her swim test and was happily playing 4-square with her cabin mates.  I watched her at dinner and noticed she sneaked small glimpses at us but seemed to be smiling.  I watched her at the opening night show, playing with her flashlight and singing along to the songs she knows so well.  All seemed right with the world - though I did feel a twinge of sadness as we headed back to our cabin without her. 

Day 2: Something’s not quite right

Morning comes and we head back to Girls Camp for breakfast.  I look for my daughter through the trees during flag raising, trying to catch just a glimpse of her.  I don’t see her at first but then I find her.  Let’s just say it was not the picture of the proud beaming camper I had left the night before.  It was not even just the look of a tired camper who isn’t used to sleeping in her cabin.  Something’s not quite right, but I can’t do anything.  I can’t go to her. It’s not my job, that’s what the camp staff is there for. “Pretend you’re not her mom, pretend you don’t notice, don’t look at her, don’t catch her eye, keep walking.”  I get to the breakfast table and purposely sit with my back to my daughter.  It’s all I can do to keep my head from constantly rotating to check her out.  After breakfast, I sit outside chatting with friends and suddenly there she is, steps quickening as she gets nearer to me, until suddenly she flings herself into my lap and starts to cry.  What do I do?  No other camper gets their mom’s lap when something isn’t going as planned.  Do I push her away?  Force her to seek out her leader or one of the other staff members?  Maybe an older camper?  I can’t do it.  I let her sit and cry, though she never tells me why. What’s happening?  The staff is trying to keep me uninformed, trying to treat my daughter like any other camper. Bless them. I try to find new places to hang out where she won’t see me but I find that I want to see her.  I am peeking around bushes, sitting just over the other side of the sand dune, watching her perform a skit from a perch up above the council circle.  I walk back home that night with an ache in my stomach.  I don’t sleep well. 

Day 3: This is not what we had planned

At breakfast, she has scabs under her eyes from rubbing away so many tears. When I see her, there is barely a trace of the energetic young girl I know.  I can tell something is still being sorted out but something has changed. She isn’t coming to find me, she’s trying to fix whatever it is on her own.  I feel like I am dying a slow death from afar, wanting to curl her up and take her home and tell her we can try again next year.  I know that is the worst thing I can do but it is going against every mothering instinct I have to sit and watch her suffer without helping.  I put my trust in the staff we love so much and I walk away. The day is sunny and warm, a day that would brighten anyone’s spirits, and when I see her walking up to me before lunch she’s smiling.  She sits beside me and tells me about her morning activities and I notice she seems happier.  I am trying to keep some emotional distance but finally I reach over and say “Can I just give you a hug?” as I am already wrapping my arms around her. Her tears let loose and I am really working hard to hold mine back.  What a stupid move on my part.  I ask her if she is doing better and she says “I was until you did that.” 

Day 4: We take the day off

We get 24 hours off per week, sacred time to escape camp and return to our other home 20 miles away.  I agonize over whether to remind my daughter that she won’t see us around – I don’t want her to think we didn’t care enough to say goodbye but I don’t want to make her cry again. In the end, I sneak it in during a quick exchange. “Is there anything I can pick up for you to share with your cabin mates while we are on our day off?”  As we jump in the car I am again close to tears. Will she survive without me there?  Maybe it will be better for her, but maybe not.  We spend our day off doing errands and playing at the beach with our youngest child, the only one not old enough to be a real camper yet.  The vision of those teary eyes haunts me all day, follows me around like a lost puppy whining at my feet.  I do have moments of relaxation and joy, guilty relief that what ever is happening with my daughter is not my problem and is happening out of my sight.

 

 Day5: Something has changed

I return to breakfast at the dining hall and it’s immediately apparent that something has changed.  She’s smiling, she’s doing cheers with her tribe, she’s letting people hug her, she’s raising her hand to participate.  Her leader catches my eye and winks, gives me a secret smile.  I notice I have mixed emotions.  Such pride that she has worked her way through whatever it was.  Such sadness that she has taken a step away from me.  Such guilt that this all would have been easier for her if I had just disappeared and stayed out of her way.  I realize there is a sense of mourning for the little girl that is growing up.  But that’s about me, and this experience is supposed to be about her.  That night, I sit with the rest of camp at the council circle, directly across from my daughter who gives me a small wave and a big smile.  She has volunteered to be in all three of the skits that her tribe performs, a big deal because she is not a “look at me” kind of kid.  We end the night singing “Stars in the Sky” and I watch her sway back and forth with her arms around her cabin mates.  She stands and walks away. 

 Day 6: It works

It is time to pick up our daughter at the closing council ceremony for the one-week campers.  She is full of energy, once again just beaming, holding hands with her new friends.  She is a non-stop narrative of everything she has done in the past six days. Nothing but fun. We watch a slide show full of pictures of happy, smiling campers and I almost start to wonder if everything I thought I saw those first few days was real. The only sign - the telltale scabs under her eyes that are still slightly visible. I approach my daughter’s leader and give her a hug, thank her for her patience and her caring.  We look at each other trying to hold back our tears.  She tells me how proud she is of my daughter, how much she has seen her grow.  I won’t find out the details of just what they were dealing with until later that afternoon. For now, all I know is that my 8 year-old daughter has made one huge step towards independence.  I have taken one small step back to let her move forward.

 

click tracking

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
You have so much self-control!
I know how hard this is - BigGirlChild just turned 12. How much, how soon, how far, what to say, what to back away from... it's so hard to know. Your kind heart and thoughtfulness will guide you.

I'm glad she's okay.

Now, can I come live with you at camp?
I was only there for a half hour and I miss it!

(thumbified for letting go)
Mamoore, I think it's the hardest part of parenting, the letting go part. A post I could resonate with. Thank you!
Letting go enough to watch a child's self-discovery is a challenge, but worth it. Enjoy the developing memories. Thanks for sharing.
The trauma of growing up. Who is scarred more, parents or kids?
My boy, who is closing in on eleven, is going to camp for an entire week starting Sunday night. I'm looking forward to a restful week but not the separation which is always painful. Like you, I know that it's time to start scaling back the parenting operation so he can begin to go his own way. But it's not easy, is it.

Great work, Ma.
mamoore - this is truly the universal story - "I feel like I am dying a slow death from afar, wanting to curl her up and take her home and tell her we can try again next year."

You did so very well, and how lucky you both are. Had you not been there, perhaps it would have been easier . . . but watching the whole thing . . . damn. And yet - how cool. Thanks so much for sharing it. As always, your writing is compelling and smart and heartfelt. Wow.
*speechless*

I cannot believe what I've just read.

Poor wee soul.
Jodi - Self-control was not what I felt when I was going through this but I guess, in many ways, I showed a fair amount of restraint and trust. I felt glad I had some hands to hold while I watched from a distance. Spare bunks are always available (and we need to start work on that writer''s workshop)!

MTK- I am not sure how ready I am for this part of parenting but I guess we have no choice. Do we?

MM - It's a funny mixture of pride, fear, and sadness but I know it is a universal part of growing up.

Athomepilgrim - Exactly.

JK- Let me know what your mom says. I do think it was harder for my duaghter to have me there, I know it was harder for me. Now go celebrate Canada Day!

Michael - I hope you both enjoy your week!

Owl - It was a mixed blessing being able to watch the process. She still hasn't said a negative word about her week. She goes back for another 3 weeks in mid-July and she can't wait. We both know it will be a whole different experience...I hope.

Webbigail - That's how I felt too, until I saw her on that closing day. It was a different kind of birth process.
I am glad that things came out fine in the end. She will always be your baby, in a way.
That had to be tough in such close proximity.
You did a great job, Mom. I am really impressed, with you and your daughter as well. What a great kid she seems to be.
A universal story--and so well told!
It's hard, these little kids growing up so fast. I looked at my son the other day and didn't recognize him. I thought someone took my little boy and left a big kid in his place.

You both did great. And it's what camp is all about, isn't it? Growing, stretching, experiencing. You're a good mom! But, gosh, it must have been hard to be so close and yet so far away.
Delia - I was glad for the ahppy ending too!

Gwool - I am basically a sap so tears are always a toughy for me.

Ash - Thanks. I think she's a great kid too.

Hells Bells - Thank you, too.

Maria - I know what you mean. There are moments where I glance at my kids and they seem like they have grown while I was looking away.
OK, sorry, I don't get it. I had to go back and re-read because I missed her age the first time. I was thinking she must be like, 14. No, she's 8. EIGHT. I am now very confused by this post and all the acclaim it's getting. It strikes me as incredibly sad, that's all. At that age, you're not talking about an adolescent, you're talking about a child who still needs mom. "Pre-teen" is a marketing term, not a real psychological developmental stage distinct from "child." Small steps toward independence are good, absolutely, but making a show out of ignoring a child that age in distress just strikes me as cruel. It would have felt that way to me as an 8 year old, also, even if I did try to compensate and put on a brave face so as to not be called "uncool."

I don't understand the American obsession with "independence." Practically the day a kid is born here everyone's dinging the mom to "cut the apron strings" and leave him or her to "make their own mistakes." What could possibly be so horrible about giving a distraught EIGHT YEAR OLD affection and comforting? We're not talking about barging into a 30 year old's marital problems or driving back to retrieve a 19 year old because of one bad night in the dorm.
My nine-year old daughter attends school where I teach Kindergarten. I can completely identify with those moments of wanting to help when you can see she's in trouble, but knowing she needs to learn to trust herself and other adults. And, of course, so do we. :)
lilyrahel - As much as this may surprise you, I do understand how you feel. I do want to say, she was in no way ignored, ever.

sweetfeet - Thanks for your wise words - I love Kindergarten teachers!
I so appreciated this heartfelt post, even as I recognize that I would probably have handled your situation differently. I think all parents find themselves landing somewhere on that continuum of running interference for their children's problems, and both ends have merit. I sat through several weeks of preschool (to give you an example) for my youngest son, knowing that most mothers would have listened to the teachers who insisted that parents of the crying kids should just leave. It didn't feel right to me, and I have no regrets about taking in some extra ABCs. I knew enough not to hover and sat back inconspicuously, letting my son come to me if he wanted to. He never did but was happy knowing I was there. Having two older children who were not built that way gave me the confidence to understand that I knew my kids best, that this one needed something different. (I'm also privy to the inside world of teachers, and they often demonstrate a different face to parents than they do to the children alone). Anyway, all this is to say that there are certainly some benefits to allowing kids to figure out their fears on their own, and it's an amazingly dicey decision to make. And there are so many of these decisions that happen every single day, even when kids are old enough to move out. I'll never forget when my mom mentioned that she secretly called my youngest brother, at the time around 40, to come and help my oldest brother, 50, move into her basement for a short stay. She had asked the oldest if he needed help, he said no, she called the youngest anyway but on the sly. It all made me realize that this worry about the emotional stability of our children never seems to go away. sigh.
A post I wrote last fall, Invisible Girl, describes this same quandary about a much older girl. It's heartbreaking and true. I've always wished more people would read it and comment because the friend (the girl's mother) is still dealing with the situation and just doesn't know what to do. I would love your input, mamoore. You seem both wise and sensitive to the complexities of this sort of thing.
Mamoore, you showed some excellent restraint and good decisions here. I sometimes look at old pics of my kids when they were little and wonder where all the years went.
I bet the daughter you describe here will turn out very independent.
Subtle and beautifully presented.
Lainey - A big part of me felt the need to rescue her, but a bigger part knew that it wasn't the right thing to do. There were lots of things that factored into that decision- it was our daughter's choice to become a camper this summer, she never once asked to come home even when she ran to me in tears, many of the staff members that were with her throughout the week are as close to her as any family member, I believe in what we do at our camp and the environment in which we nuture young people. I wasn't sure that homesickness was what was going on (it wasn't, it was social), that coming home would solve the problem, or that I could even help solve it. I caught her when she needed me and let her go when she was ready. I wasn't perfect. And you're right, I will probably worry about the emotional well being of my kids as long as I am around.

SaoKay- I remember your 8 yr old daughter's beautiful Easter eggs. I keep thinking that if you guys had seen me wandering aimlessly around camp trying not to run into my daughter you might not be calling it self-restraint! But thanks, I guess I did my best.

Lainey - I don't know how wise I am on this issue but I am interested in reading your post - I'll do it tonight.

Mission -Thanks for your kind words. Now, get some sleep you have to get up early for that new job!

Steve - Thanks, I'm always happy when you visit.
You're a better mom than I am. I can't imagine seeing my child hurting yet having enough restraint to not involve myself. It was the right thing to do, albeit painful, and your daughter is now a bit more resilient than she was before she attended camp.

Thanks for this great piece (and for linking to my summer camp piece!)
Exactly my point, mamoore--you know your children better than anyone else and you knew what was right for her. I'm so glad things turned out so well!
Melissa: We’re so happy you got an EP for this, mamoore. It’s an exquisite piece. Thoughtful, moving, inspiring. You’re the perfect model of a Nurturant Parent.

Michael: This picture’s perfect, too. It’s like the child standing out there alone in the sea, which is the world. You wanna protect them, but you don’t want to coddle them. You want them to be independent, but there’s this inner need to protect them, so it’s a conflict, always.

Melissa: I realize this reminds me of Newton’s latest post. See, listen: he describes “the inner strength to navigate the painful circumstances required for growth to greater and greater levels of response-ability.”

Michael: Hahaha. That’s exactly right.

Melissa: And then he talks about the metaphor “of the butterfly who was innocently helped to escape from its cocoon by a concerned bystander. In wanting to aid it in its struggle, he helped open the cocoon, but unintentionally releasing a butterfly that would never ever fly. Unknowingly denying it the time required for its wings to develop the necessary strength that it one day be capable of defying the forces drawing it to the ground. Instead, leaving a helpless creature that will whither away and die, without ever having had a chance to be what its magnificent life potential had promised it could be.”

See, mamoore, you had the courage to let your daughter develop her wings. Bravo for being such a wonderful parent, and for sharing this significant step with us in such a tender, eloquent story.
Lisa - Based on your posts, I am sure you are one amazing mom.

Lainey - Hi again. I hope other people find the post you mentioned above and can offer some support. I wish I knew the right answer.

M&M - I love that butterfly story, thanks for reminding me of it. I saw Newton's post and had forgotten to go back and read it but now it is on my list. My daughter does seem to have sprouted some min-wings since her return. She is testing them out but still lands safely in my lap when she needs to.
So well done, Melissa. I was a camp counselor of 8-year olds, and they were absolutely the best. Sweet, yet conversational and fun. Congrats on letting go.
Oh Mama ... I just want to throw my arms around you! You did it. It hurts soooo much, I know. You are some kind of wonderful woman and mother, I hope you know that. I love your stories about interactions with your children ... your spirit just shines through and the writing just goes straight into my heart. xoxo
Ah, the joys of parenting and letting go. Very touching. MB wrote a camp post too the other day about her 13 year old going off to camp for month: http://open.salon.com/blog/m_b that was poignant. Maybe the Eds will do a feature on camp posts one day this month. I enjoy keeping up with you.
Oh my goodness... this is a part of the American culture which is so different from our culture... the summer camp institution does not exist in my country. I guess it´s because we are very "latin" and would die in masses if we sent our children to camps over the summer, being away from then. The whole thing is a strange notion for us Argentinians; just to imagine that I would leave my children, even in the most wonderful environment during the weekdays, it gives me the creeps! However, it´s fascinating how we all grow up healthy and strong all the same, living over here ore over there, either staying in a summer camp or spending the daytime in a "colonia de vacaciones" (9 to 17 hs every day, very optional by the way) here in Buenos Aires. Our children mainly get together with other children at someone´s house, always with parents around, always close. We parents would definitely die in masses otherwise...
Kisses, and congrats for being so brave!
Marcela
Lea- Thanks. When I used to be a camp counselor I had the 8 yr olds, too - I love them.

1IM - Big hugs all around for the aches and pains and joys of parenting. You already have teenagers so I am sure you are much more familiar with this whole rollercoaster ride than I am!

Grif - Thanks. I missed MB's post, I'll have to read it when I get back from lunch.

Marcela- You made me laugh at the thought of a mass of mothers collapsing as they watched their children leave for camp. I understand that camp is a very cultural thing. My husband is Australian and they don't have summer camp there either - summer vacation is over their Chirstmas/New Year holidays so most wouldn't think of sending their kids away. It's funny that he ended up running a camp. Your summer traditions sound lovely!
Hi Melissa, well done to you for your courage. I think that type of parenting is very missing today as we sadly are raising increasingly narcissistic entitled sedentary cybernetic children. We have to teach them to struggle as we have, and even at times to let them suffer their own fights in order for them to grow to thriving vital adults.

I know, my daughter is turning twenty two this year, and her strength and courage absolutely amazes me. When she was young, coming to us about trouble with her teaches or classmates at school, no matter how fair or unfair or real the situation may have been, we gave her all the love and support, but always told her "you've got to fight you own battles", and she did. Though it's the hardest most courageous thing you can ever do, it's the best thing for them and their growing spirits--though your must also be vigilant because some situations can indelibly scar a child as well, a truly touch call.

Thought I'd leave you with this verse by Kahlil Gibran:

Your children are not your children.

They are the sons and daughters of Life’s longing for itself.

They come through you but not from you,

And though they are with you yet they belong not to you.

You may give them your love but not your thoughts,

For they have their own thoughts.

You may house their bodies but not their souls,

For their souls dwell in the house of tomorrow, which you cannot visit,

Not even in your dreams.

You may strive to be like them, but seek not to make them like you.

For life goes not backward nor tarries with yesterday.

You are the bows from which your children as living arrows are sent forth.

The archer sees the mark upon the path of the infinite,

And He bends you with His might that His arrows may go swift and far.

Let your bending in the archer’s hand be for gladness;

For even as He loves the arrow that flies, so He loves also the bow that is stable.


And MM, thanks so much for referring to my work.
I completely enjoyed reading this post. It also made me think a little more than I wanted to about my son having those feelings at his camp. I cannot imagine having to watch his homesickness in real time:-( He was 8 the first time he did a week long overnight camp and he loves going back each summer. How wonderful that she made it through and came out the other side.
Do you do camp for adults that never got to go as a child? I would sign up for that. Great story.
Newton - I love that Kahlil Gibran passage, I haven't read it in years. Thank you for reminding me of it and for your kind words of encouragement.

MB - I am sure your son is having a great time. I can't wait to read about his adventures. Besdies having fun and making great friends, camp is about risking, growing, and finding out how much you can accomplish, sometimes that is best done out of view of the parents (so I am finding out!).

O'Really - We do have times when grown-ups come and play. Bunks are available when you are.
What a touching story MaMoore! And what a big little girl you have, indeed! Cutting the chords is truly a process. I see you are adjusting with all your might... mighty hard for moms. LOL
JS & Mama- I can still tear up just thinking about it! She returns to a cabin this Sunday, I am hoping the experience of her first week will carry her -and me -through.
How did I miss this one?!!! What a brilliant post. We must be kindred spirits because I was suffering along with you - especially when you described the scabs under her eyes! And then her comment, "I was until you did that." Truly, how do we survive this stuff?!!

Hugely rated and admired for your strength in stepping back. I am very curious how this turned out - PM me if you update!