Biting the Hand that Feeds You: More Republican Hypocrisy
“And having looked to Government for bread, on the very first scarcity they will turn and bite the hand that fed them.”
Edmund Burke, Thoughts and Details on Scarcity
You might think that Orange County’s Republican elected officials would be caught between a rock and hard place in the current economic crisis.
With the local economy in shambles, home values crashing, foreclosures on the rise, unemployment skyrocketing and good jobs scarcer than Republican fans of Arnold Schwarzenegger, you might think that the staunch and total opposition of Orange County Republicans to President Obama’s stimulus efforts would be, at the least, a political embarrassment.
But then you would underestimate the shameless hypocrisy of Orange County’s Republican establishment.
In her most recent online newsletter, Republican Orange County Supervisor Pat Bates (District 5) makes the following incredible claim:
“Orange County Projects Receive Stimulus Funds
A number of significant environmental enhancement and flood management projects in Orange County will receive vital support from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, better known as the Federal stimulus program.
The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers has announced more than $50 million will be spent in Orange County on projects selected based on their anticipated economic and environmental return. The projects selected for funding include:
- $26,550,000 to complete channel improvements on the lower Santa Ana River within Orange County
- $1,000,000 for mitigation related to the Seven Oaks Dam, which provides flood protection to Orange, San Bernardino and Riverside Counties
- $17,363,000 to complete plans and specifications and award a construction contract for the environmental restoration of Upper Newport Bay
- $5,265,000 for needed maintenance for the Santa Ana River, Carbon Canyon Dam, Prado Dam and Fullerton Dam
- $500,000 for a Dana Point Harbor breakwater study to identify and recommend any repairs to the breakwater/jetties and improve water quality.
The approval of funding for these projects is great news for Orange County. Orange County residents will directly benefit from these improvements and the Federal support is greatly appreciated. Our success is the result of great teamwork involving our County staff, our representatives in Washington and many city and community leaders.”
In informing her constituents of this “great news,” Bates does not mention the fact that all of “our [Republican] representatives in Washington” voted against Obama’s economic stimulus legislation, including these very projects.
Nor does she mention the fact that all of Orange County’s Republican “city and community leaders” have been vocally attacking the stimulus package as an evil socialist plot to destroy capitalism.
And Bates does not mention the fact that every penny of the more than $50 million that she is so grateful that Orange County will receive from the stimulus package will come from -- dare we say it – taxes.
What Bates should have said is the “great teamwork involving our Republican County staff, our Republican representatives in Washington and many Republican city and community leaders failed to prevent President Obama and the Democrats from passing the federal stimulus package – and thank God for that.”
Of course, Bates won't say it.
But the voters in Orange County should.
TIP:
Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
John Jacob Di Gasbarro
So Polite
Tim4change
Rolling
Dorian de Wind
Lairderg
Salon.com
Comments
Note the hypocrisy on the Democratic side too, to be fair:
They will not mention in the stimulus package that federal liabilities have exploded, which will mean higher taxes and or inflation in a maximum of 18 months. There are hypocrites everywhere in politics, who make claims that are logically inconsistent, because politics, per Schumpeter, calls on the sub-rational.
I asked her why on earth she would do that when eventually, there will be another hurricane, complete with power outages. "Oh, FEMA paid for that." So, I guess if there is another hurricane, she'll get FEMA to pay for another one while bitching about her taxes. Meanwhile, I know a divorced mother of two who had a foot of water in her apartment and didn't get a dime.
As a Libertarian, I do everything I can to minimize my tax bills, and always vote against new taxes. That being said, since I am forced to pay into the system, I do everything I can to receive the maximum amount of benefits from that system. I don't think this is hypocritical. I think they're just claiming back what was rightfully theirs to begin with. If they can't put the money back into their own bank account, where they'd like it to be, at least they can get it back into their own community.
So voting against bailout funds, then doing everything you can to get the bailout funds to your constituents isn't hypocritical or stupid. It's just common sense.
Cutting taxes is great, but the tax cuts that have been engineered by the state's Republicans have benefited only the wealthiest Californians -- and caused middle class taxes to dramatically increase. Prop 13 cut hundreds of billions of dollars from the property taxes that used to be paid by giant corporations and large landowners. As a result, we have seen our income taxes, sales taxes and vehicle taxes rise. We have also seen state mandated fees -- really taxes by another name -- rise for everything from community college to the toll roads. If you're not a billionaire, then YOUR TAXES HAVE BEEN INCREASED as a result of these so-called "tax cuts."
Which is why I'm a Libertarian, and not a republican.