Arran's Alley

Watch what they do, not what they say.

Mick Arran

Mick Arran
Location
Savannah, Georgia, USA
Bio
I've done everything from recycling to teaching in a pre-school. Most recently I was for 10 years an acting and theater teacher as well as a pallet builder. I read a lot and I'm an old man who remembers the distant past with somewhat more clarity than this morning's breakfast. I've been blogging for a decade and I don't do "light". If you're looking for recipes, self-promoting displays of items made for sale, titillating stories about how I was a pimp for an afternoon, or the beauties of toasters, you've come to the wrong place. Check the Front Page.

MY RECENT POSTS

DECEMBER 3, 2009 1:27PM

Some Questions About Our Newly Ungovernable Democracy

Rate: 5 Flag

Has it occurred to the Democrat majority – or to anyone else, for that matter – that it is impossible to govern a democracy when 2/3 of us have to agree on virtually every policy? 

Just think about this for a minute, in the light of that question:

In its first vote on health care overhaul, the Senate Thursday narrowly approved an amendment to safeguard coverage of mammograms and preventive screening tests for women under a revamped system.The 61-39 vote on an amendment by Sen. Barbara Mikulski, D-Md., and Sen. Olympia Snowe, R-Maine, would allow the Health and Human Services secretary to require insurers to cover preventive health screenings free of charge.

Under special provisions agreed to prior to the tally, 60 votes were needed to pass the amendment. The margin underscored the fragility of the coalition Democrats are counting on to move forward on President Barack Obama’s signature issue.

Fragility?

Question #1:

Why do we need 60 votes – a filibuster-proof majority – in order to approve something as non-controversial and obviously necessary as mammograms and cancer screening tests?

Question #2:

Why did something as obvious, necessary, and minor barely squeak through this cloth-headed Congress?

Question #3:

How “fragile” is the Democrat “coalition” (between Democrats and Blue Dogs, presumably) when it takes that much effort to pass an amendment this bland?

Question #4:

How “fragile” is our democracy when it takes that much effort to pass an amendment this bland?

Just curious.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
(stentorian voice:) We are entering THE LAST DAYS!
I suspect the problem is that too many politicians are beholden to interests other than their constituents'.

They're trying to make the companies who are lobbying them and supporting their campaigns happy. They're trying to posture for the segment of their districts that voted for them to prove they're different from their opposition. They're trying to cater to other politicians, whose votes they'll need for their own proposals later on.

In other words, they're playing politics instead of being representatives.
It's a good question! I am not sure the answer is 100% the lobbyists. Part of it could be the nature of the modern campaign - take a stand now at your peril later, b/c who knows what Rush and Glen and yes, Keith and Rachel could make of something you did 10 years ago for what were the best of reasons in your view at that time...
if you insist on describing the usa as a 'democracy', the world will always be a confusing place.

switzerland is a democracy. there are no others. america is an oligarchy, one dominated by money, so you could call it a plutocracy. it is also a moribund empire, in which the various bureaucracies, notably department of defense and the cia, have taken control away from politicians.

you are right about the 'last days,' though it will be many years of fading power and collapsing economy. let's hope the collapsing economy saves the planet, for the american government is incapable of planned greenhouse reduction.
It's the money, Lebowski. Cash donations beats voting every time.