I'm not an expert on trans-racial/trans-cultural adoptions. But I have been married "interracially" for over thirty three years. I don't like that term but that is how we are categorized on the US Census. Biologically speaking there is only one race. I've believed that since I can remember. I hope the white people who want to adopt children from Haiti believe that. And understand what they will face raising a child of color, especially dark color, in America. I'm worried for them, and frankly a little scared for the children.
Before my husband and I were married, we were asked to attend a conference about "bi-racial" (black/white) adoptions. Ninety-five percent of the potential parents registered were white. The conference organizers were college professors who knew us. They thought potential parents would enjoy meeting a couple who might be similar to the biological parents of the children they hoped to adopt.
My fiancé and I were assigned different discussion groups. In my group the leader arranged us in a circle. We began by telling why we were here. It was a friendly group. Lots of smiles and head nodding as people shared their stories. I heard a few things that should have warned me but I chose to ignore them. When my turn came I explained why I was asked to attend. My story was received with silence. The only smiling face was the leader's. Some shifted in their seats. Others looked down or away. A woman directly across from me began shaking her head and blurted out "You plan to marry one? We are here to adopt the "mistakes". And you are here planning to marry one?" The man sitting next to me said, "You seem like a nice girl. Why would you do this?"
It wasn't the first time I experienced this reaction. I just didn't expect it here. I didn't have my guard up, so this hurt, but I could get over it. After this I would never see these people. But I feared for the children they planned to adopt.
Many of these people had their own kids but wanted to help a needy child. Some had already adopted but wanted more. White children were harder to get. You had to wait longer and the rules were more rigid. A woman said she couldn't get a white baby since she already had one, so this would be better than nothing.
I told them I was marrying this man because I loved him. The reason I could love a man of another color was because my parents chose to raise me in an integrated neighborhood and school so I knew from life experience we are all human. Now they regretted that decision. My father said if he knew this would happen, "it would have been "nigger" from day one".
I told the group if they had white children they need to be prepared one day their son or daughter may chose to marry someone who wasn't white. Having a black brother or sister, their white child may come to the same conclusion I did. It makes no sense to limit options when you discover everyone is human.
I could tell this was the first time they considered this possibility. I probably should have left at that point and let them talk more freely. But I was young and thought I needed to make my point clear. I also liked making them squirm. I said the only way they could try to prevent this was to teach their children whites were superior. They would have to treat their black child as an inferior and not provide the same advantages. I hoped the nods were for understanding this was ridiculous and not for giving them a strategy.
At the end of the conference, one of the black social workers attending gave the final address. She listened in on the group discussions. She was outraged. Whites in the audience looked ashamed, sad, frightened, or mad. I remember her ending words... "I'd rather see these babies be put through a meat grinder than adopted by the white people here today." Soon after the Illinois Social Worker Association imposed high restrictions on inter-racial adoptions.
Ten years later I was out with my children and a woman approached me. She admired my beautiful children. I returned the compliment. Peeking out behind her was a lovely "bi-racial" little girl. The woman belonged to an inter-racial adoption group that met monthly. She invited me to an upcoming picnic. I explained my children weren't adopted, my husband was black, but we would love to come. It would be great for our kids to get together with other inter-racial children and we would enjoy meeting the parents. Her smile faded. "I'm sorry. This is only for adopted bi-racial children." She turned away and then looked back. "Maybe you should start your own group."
When our children were little I asked my husband for advice on raising them. He worked long hours. The kids were mostly with me. I was afraid I might not be giving them what they needed to survive. He told me to ask his mother.
I didn't want to admit to her I was afraid. I was still trying to prove that her son was not an idiot for marrying me. So I asked her to tell me the family stories. My mother-in-law is one of the smartest and most intutitive people I have ever met. She knew exactly why I was asking. From then on, every visit, she shared stories. She still does.
They lived in Chicago but had migrated from the South. It was the custom to send children down South to stay with relatives for the summer. It kept the family bonds strong. But this was in the late 50's. Before civil rights. Not long after Emmett Till, a black boy from Chicago, was lynched for speaking to a white woman. He was showing off to his southern cousins. My mother-in-law refused to send her sons south and withstood all manner of critcism and accusations she was protecting them too much. Thought she was "too good" for the rest of the family. If they went she would have to teach them to get off the sidewalk for a white person. Never look or speak directly to them. Obey the "for colored only" signs. She knew if she taught them that, it would damage their spirits. She had seen it happen to her father and uncles and the boys she grew up with. It happened to her mother and sisters. It happened to her. It wouldn't make any difference how much she told her sons they were just as good as whites, that action would tell them something else.
She also didn't speak badly about white people. She didn't want to make them fear or hate or expect discrimination. They would feel defeated and never try. She knew there were good white people. Her sons would need to be able to discern the difference. I always wondered if she regretted teaching him that, the same as my father had.
Taking a cue from my mother-in-law, I would not let our children be around people, even relatives, who were racists. I bartered to send them to a private arts school because I had been in too many teachers' lounges throughout the city and heard the way the teachers talked about the black students. I was a guest artist doing mime shows. They had no clue I was married to a black man so they spoke freely. I could not trust my children's spirits to people who did not believe they were capable of learning as much as whites. That is a direct quote. These teacher's believed they were being asked to do the impossible. I work with the public schools now. The disparity between white and black student test scores hasn't improved. The drop out rate for African American students is 50%. There are veiled explanations that amount to the same thinking as I heard twenty-five years ago.
If I had not been able to barter tuition at the private school, I would have homeschooled. There wouldn't have been any other choice I could have lived with. The school wasn't perfect, but since I worked there, I could watch out for them.
When my son was a teenager, I was walking a distance behind him and one of his black friends in a store. They were laughing and talking, oblivious to the women clutching their purses and the detective following them. I remembered how white women used to stop me to admire my adorable, cute son with those full kissable cheeks. Now he was a man and they feared him. I knew this was coming because I had people in my life that shared similar experiences. I believed them and didn't dismiss it as being overly sensitive. Even so, I had to fight back tears.
When my husband taught our son to drive he also had to teach him what to do when the police stopped him so he wouldn't get killed. My son protested. Said he would tell the cop off if he was unfairly stopped. It was one of the few times I saw my husband get angry. He had to get through to him the danger of driving black in America. It wasn't a joke. And it wasn't something I would have known to teach him.
Our children are grown and married. They have children. There are all shades in our family. We belong to a religious community that embraces all and means it. We have friends from varied cultures. Yet, even with this richness, this love and acceptance of all people, my seven year old grandson scans every new situation for people as dark as he and is not happy unless he finds one. Last week he asked why most of the black people in movies are bad.
I want to believe that every white person who adopts a child from Haiti knows the inherent goodness of this child, and has genuine respect for the culture. I want to believe they will love this child so much they will dedicate their lives to learning about the rich history and culture of Haiti and will understand that while they are providing an easier material life for this child here, there are family members in Haiti that love this child too. This child must be told about their love and sacrifice.
I want to believe they are willing to examine their inner thoughts and motivations and conscientiously eradicate prejudicial thoughts replacing them with new insights and knowldege. I want them to study the history of race in America and the impact of slavery on everyone and be willing to see it. No excuses, no denials. Just see and try to understand what has happened and continues to happen in this country.
Most of all, I want to believe they will cultivate friendships with people from Hati and African Americans who will drop in for coffee, sit around the dinner table and come to family gatherings. Friends who will grow to trust and honestly share their own stories of struggle and triumph. Friends who will laugh with them and sometimes cry.
They will need these friends to talk to when their little girl says she wants to be "white" like her mommy. Or their son, before watching a movie with black actors, says "Please tell me they aren't going to be bad this time."
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NOTE: My parents eventually gave their blessings to our marriage and became wonderful supporters of us and loving grandparents and great-grandparents. (Didn't want to leave the impression my parents never accepted our marriage.) The story about that is here on my blog: "Our Love Story in Black and White"
http://open.salon.com/blog/mimetalker/2009/11/22/open_call_our_love_story


Salon.com
Comments
Myriad-I let myself despair too sometimes for a minute, but I can't afford to let it go longer than that...too much work to do.
As luck would have it, I discovered the answer about twelve years ago. My niece's daughter married a black man and they had two children. Then, my brother's daughter had a child with a black man. Before I knew it I had three bi-racial children in my family.
All my self-doubts ended as soon as I first saw each child. Now, I am happy to say, I am their favorite Uncle and even though the oldest is almost a teenager, they all still run to claim my lap when I visit their homes. They are my family and I love them. I have no idea what else to add to this discussion besides my own experiences.
Racial bigotry exists on both sides and always will. It is up to each of us in our own small, quite way to fight against it. On both sides.
I have grown tired of the ignorance that surrounds race, especially in America. I have little hope that those anonymous racists who feign love for their fellow human will step out of their stultifying suits of ignorance and embrace decency in a genuine way. I am hesitant to discuss it because the purveyors of such supremacy fantasy are never uniformly among any one group, and some of those for whom it does not apply resent it, and call opposition to racism a racist act, or that absurd notion of "reverse racism." I'm bitter. I am a committed non gun owner, and as a result of the public's behavior toward this president, I have considered buying a couple for my home. That is how bitter I am. So there's your warning.
First, your story is very touching. I know the concern of the child in the movies. I remember the moment when I turned away from mass culture pop hit movies. I remember watching how the single or few blacks in a movie presented to a general audience would get killed early. I ignored or joked, or laughed at jokes about that for years. I still would. Then I remember seeing the movie "Terminator". The scientist responsible for "finding" and not developing the computer chip which eventually led to the artificially intelligent computers which threatened the entire world was a black scientist. It was all this guy's fault. He eventually died a death in the movie as his strength failed. He died due to weakness. I was done. Your husband is right to caution your Son about "driving while black". It is real. I am a former cop, and I use all deliberate caution when dealing with cops in uniform. One good practice is to announce or request every single movement and et the officer's agreement. I do this very thing myself when in a tactical situation. I hope your Son listens to your husband. I also know your Son's type of naivete on this issue. It was mine at one time.
And to you, your story is a side that I dont get to see directly very often. I am of at least two things that has shielded me most of the days of my life. As a child I grew up in a rather progressive suburb, with rather progressive attitudes and practices. I just did not see it (racism) much. Then by the time I was an adult, I was a large, rather fit, articulate, clean cut individual. Even if I did have attributes to inspire the thought, I was not the opportunity that most would take to express them. I am not the type to bully in person, in other words. As a result I always have the "you're kidding me" response when told of some of the profoundly assertively rude things that others have endured. Now, after I was a cop, I was more aware of the subtle things that people do in fear for defensive reasons. I was a more detailed observer of people. I saw profound differences in behavior around me whether I was jogging in shorts and a t-shirt, or wearing a suit. I dont hold those behaviors against those who do them out of fear, but I am aware that it causes some of them to do more problematic things at other times....also do to that fear. So that white supremacy fantasy/separation/dysfunction persists. Incidentally a white family member taught me to refer to racism as "white supremacy fantasy". I thought it was extreme at first, but later realized it is accurate. It is a social paradigm which seeks to tear down all that conflicts with it. It is Napoleon using a cannon to blow the nose off of the Sphinx, or whatever. History is full of this. That is what it is.
Now as for white people adopting black children, and especially Haitian children, I am fully for it. I refuse to use expressions like 150% percent because in this context they are absurd, but if I could be more than completely in favor of something, I would be here. Life stacks a series of unknowns one upon the next. And when it comes to people, we stack imperfect characteristics one upon the next. A child from Haiti may come to a fully nurturing home, and have the most perfect, loving adoption ever. Or she may have adopted parents who are imperfect in any number of ways, not just the white supremacist fantasy. No matter the case, the child would likely be better off here than in what they face there currently. In the best of circumstances here in the U.S., we have a society that maintains no small measure of shit. It is in need of improving. That young girl or boy may help here, may help Haiti, or may help his adoptive parents who suffer from the white supremacist fantasy. No matter what happens, they are almost certainly better off here now, than there. They can adjust. If I were to advise these children, I would tell them to learn to understand how Americans operate. Some ideas are cloudy and obscure. Learn the beliefs that undergird the expressions, but do not qualify yourself. Americans will dance around you as they try to find ways to place you taxonomically. Let them dance. Do not qualify yourself. If they need an expression to make a distinction to themselves, if it is truly needed, let them qualify themselves. As long as you are here, you are not "other", no matter how many apparent "others" there are. As a free American, you simply are. Most americans do not understand that. And they certainly wont understand it about you, but dont let that influence you. Let them qualify themselves until they learn to stop qualifying.
By making more people aware of the racisim that still pervades our culture, you're creating another ripple.
My husband and I have discussed adopting children from Haiti and are cautiously going forward with exploring the idea. There are a couple of things that I have Insisted upon though. First I have insisted that if we do this then we are NOT splitting siblings up... I absolutely LOATHE the idea of taking children away from their familial support and *siblings* are familial support. Second I have insisted that the child/ren NOT be denied either their culture or their history... and if that means that we take them to Haiti frequently so that they can connect with the history and the culture then that's what we do.
We have a positive "rainbow" of friends, family and friends who are as close as family so I hadn't given thought to whether or not any children that we adopted from Haiti would find acceptance amongst friends and family. Finding acceptance amongst the rest of society though I had and have worried about.
If we go through with adopting a child/children from Haiti I will do what is both necessary and in *their* best interests.
I am lucky. I am part of an interracial family in a diverse city and school system. Racism exists of course in our neck of the woods, but I consider my daughter extremely fortunate to have grown up around people of every color. That is her *normal.* I am wary of the people you describe taking these Haitian children. Racism is quiet and insidious, not always overtly ugly. This was a fascinating post. thank you._r
Mrs. Raptor-your family sounds fun... and you have obvious understanding of what this commitment would be. I love your "rules". I look forward to hearing what you decide
Dwindl-thank you so much for your comment.
Joan-It is amazing...most of the time I choose not to think about it, but every now and it gushes out. I'm glad your daughter has had such a rich experience. My children both feel most comfortable in a multi-hued environment too. My grandson is proving to be the most sensitive of any member of the family. We'll work through this with him, but it breaks my heart sometimes.
There are deep wounds to be healed. We all need each other to do that and just like any disease, it will become worse if not treated.
Thank you for your thoughtful comments, Torman.
Rated
Between my two straight brothers, I have had four white sisters-in-law, all of whom I'm sure have had experiences similar to yours.
Btw, for the first time since I've been on OS I agree TOTALLY with Bill !
Rainee-My hopes exactly
Moviegeek-I don't talk much about these things...minor stuff in comparison to what other's have dealt with
My daughter has married a man from another nation, who is another color, who was raised in a different culture. I am blessed to have such a son-in-law. He is generous and kind to my daughter and to me and to my family.
Because I am a fat jolly white woman, I get away with a lot. People are automatically nice to me. If I will be so lucky to have grandchildren, they will be "bi-racial" and - because of that, because we live in a mostly racist country - they may not be treated as I have been. I want to be the best grandmother I can be, so I appreciate your telling of the way you protected your own children from racism and the way you continue to struggle to balance that protection with freedom from worry. Thanks.
Rated (*****)
Wrightsight-thank you. Your comments, as always are very thoughtful.
Julie-Thank you-yes, I was so dissapointed when I heard the comments. People trust teachers to educate their children. I feel conflicted about integrated schools now. I have black friends who attended segregated schools in the South and said though they didn't have as good of buildings and materials, they at least had teachers who believed they could learn. Everyone who graduated could read, write, recite poetry, do math, speak French, and read the classics.
R