mistercomedy

mistercomedy
Location
Minneapolis, Minnesota,
Birthday
March 30
Bio
Michael Dane is America's favorite middle-aged, Jewish, bisexual social satirist. Or, at least one of them. Often referring to himself in the third person, he used to do standup comedy on the road, but now he just writes down funny things. He's putting together a book of food humor called "Does This Taste Funny? A Half-Baked Look at Food and Foodies."

MY RECENT POSTS

MARCH 11, 2009 2:39AM

do i belong here?

Rate: 45 Flag

I realize the title of this piece implies some sort of deep ontological questioning--sorry, it's actually just me being neurotic...See, I joined Open Salon  a couple months ago, and now, suddenly, I'm not sure if I should be here. I feel a bit like I'm back to being the nerd I was in high school (I carried a briefcase AND played clarinet in the marching band--jeez, how did I not get beat up more?), and I decided to show up at a party where all the cool kids were. Although I was welcomed at the door, I spent most of the time standing by the punch bowl.

Understand--it hasn't been you, the OS community. I've gotten some great comments, even made the cover twice. It's me. See, what I write is comedy (at least in theory), and I've started to worry my stuff isn't...I dunno...substantial enough. Significant enough. Soul-baring enough.

For example, I think I'm fairly politically aware, but my 'comedy' take on the issues of the day is usually a kind of superficial gloss. Then I read some devastatingly astute analysis of the Middle East or the economic crisis, and I think "ok...my stuff is just gonna look tawdry now--like the guy who tries to break the tension at a funeral with some inappropriate wisecrack ." 

And then I see all the self-revelation. All the heart-wrenching tales of violence, or addiction, or mental illness...I read these, and as a writer, I just freeze up. I'm trying of late to be a bit more revelatory in my writing, but I am surely not at the place yet where I can take my personal demons and put them in the service of a well-crafted essay. It's almost like I get envious--at the bravery, the openness--hell, I'm just envious that someone could expose themself so...comfortably, and yet still make it compelling to others. 

 I'm also not sure I'm keeping with the spirit of blogging, if there is such a thing  (maybe I'll be visited by The Spirit of Blogging Future)...Although a few of my pieces here have been written 'in the moment,' a lot of them are just wacky comedy pieces, not the 'here's where I'm at right now and here's what I'm feeling' vibe that seems to define blogging. I take an idea (or, since I'm confessing here, sometimes a few ideas I've already written) and try to create a few hundred words that are reasonably funny. Then I click 'publish.' It's not a very spontaneous process for me, and it's definitely not a 'journal,' or 'diary,' which I worry is the whole point of doing the regular posting/blog thing.

So, I guess what I'm getting at is that I'm concerned that I'm not contributing to what this community is really about. Because I truly love this community and what I think it represents. When I started putting some pieces up here, I told everyone I could that OS is this amazingly nurturing fellowship of writers, and I love me some nurture. Don't get me wrong--I have no intention of leaving. I just hope that you all don't feel like "ah, here's another bit of prepared schtick from Jokey McStandup--time to get back to the real stories."

Of  course at this point, I now feel awkward from all this sharing. Now I really feel like I'm back in high school. Maybe I just need someone to ask me to dance.

 

Author tags:

writing, musings

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Now you just stop sillying! Your stuff fits right in here. Face it, any where that lets me do what *I* do, is pretty much accepting of anything!
Well, there's the passingly strange fact that you just wrote a post with no funny in it, wondering if a guy who brings the funny belongs here. I'd say yes, you do - liberals aren't known for their sense of humor (oh, I can hear the huffing and puffing as the blooooow my house down). We could use some lightening up. The funniest things about this site are a guy with a monacle, a Ph.D. troll and a snowman. We need you, man. Bring the funny.
I write dumb haiga!

I only reveal myself through 17 syllables a day and a cell phone pic.

Making people laugh is a mitsvah. (I think)

A gift. A joy. I don't read the miserable self-revelations unless the writing is extremely compelling. You get one paragraph to make me care or I am out. If I laugh, I care. Not the best strategy for exploring serious writing, but it works for me. Humor is a necessary balance to tragedy.

So, if you want to go dark, go dark funny! MASH was an excellent show. And it was bleak. Use your force.
Wanna dance? Lindy, Balboa? (Sorry ... was that your foot?)

We need the funny.
What it is, what it ain't, Will you dance with me?
I guess I'm gonna completely pimp myself, but if you
want silly please check out my recent post:
http://open.salon.com/blog/dakinidancer/2009/03/07/
a_1,000_stars_performance_video_with_pole_sex!
All types are welcome here. The more, and diverse, the merrier!
Mister, I am a loyal reader. I need all the comedy I can get 'cause life is just too serious in my world.
You definitely belong on OS more than I. People here are writers, comedians, artists and on and on. I am a customer service agent with a high school education who just wants to write short pieces that make people feel or think about life or nature. Every time I post I promise myself it will be my last time and then I'm driving to work and another idea comes along and after work I'm back at it again. If nobody reads, then nobody reads, at least I've written my piece but sometimes a couple of dear people come by and comment. It makes my day. Shouldn't, but it still does. I'm working on not caring.
THERE IS NOTHING WRONG WITH YOU! YOU ARE A COMIC GENIUS. GET OVER IT.
Funny is a very important element to OS. Any kind of funny. As long as it doesn't smell funny, you're good. Stay. Dance. Play the clarinet. Write. Read my stuff. Sometimes it's funny too.
I know what you mean. You want someone to come over to your corner of the room, say "Hello", say that he/she ( preferably she) remembers you from the band march, where you played the clarinet exceptionally well and that he/she (again preferably she) would love to hear you play again.

I have that feeling too, I am having one of those feelings right now.

So here we are, the ladies of OS all reassuring you that we love the way you play with words and really want more.

;)
Wow. How did this happen? It's all women over here, asking you not to go. I think you have found the spigot, my man. Well done!

No, seriously. Please stay. Those of us who spill our guts here, well, I can only speak for myself. I'm working on essays and a book that I'm trying to get published, so I put stuff out here as a testing ground. And also, really, I'm a writing whore. You don't have to be a writing whore. You can be a writing ... shit I can't come up with the word I'm looking for, but please keep writing.
ABSOLUTELY!!!

... and you have the Freaky Troll, PhD Seal of Approval
::honk:: ::honk::

:) We LOVE funny ... We NEED funny ... Funny helps us all cope with the other crazy serious stuff here.
Maybe we need an open call that will provoke and inspire levity...all that brushing with death took us to the dark side...as I said in my death post, I have been tested positive for being alive, and while alive I want to LAUGH!
Yeah, I've kind of felt the same way. I typically write humorous little pieces, mostly about the goofiness of poopular music or dumb stuff that's happened to me. (occasionally I will write a serious piece). Most of the time I'm happy after writing a funny little post...until I publish it and see it sharing space with a very serious personal story. then I feel like I just took a big turd all over the place.
Hey man, I don't think I want to dance with ya, but we could always go play D&D and drink my dad's beer!
mister c,
I must strenuously but respectfully disagree with you, sir.
1. Comedy makes me laugh. Laughing does something beneficial physiologically, I read somewhere. Hence, i need to laugh more. Hence, keep writing.
2. Lord Byron tells me, "Let us have wine and women, mirth and laughter/Sermons and soda water the day after." I'm not about to argue with a published writer. And he's got a point: life is comic tragedy, or tragic comedy...plenty of room, and NEED, for both...too much of one is stultifying.
3. God Himself is a comedian. Quite a few good wisecracks in the New Testament. And in His other, Eastern, guises, too. Ever read any Zen? Buncha jokers.
4.Seriously: Comedy undermines...it de-solidifies stuff that's been around too long: attitudes, values, practices...breaks it up, helps to reform it in more agreeable, human ways...

Best, Jim...rated
3.
keep on riffing. os'ers who read you appreciate it
Hell, you bio alone is a gate-key to this place!
Bad writing day for denese.

That should say "your" not "you"
Most of us were the new kids once. Just keep on writing well --especially funny -- and you'll be dancing all night.
Of course you fit in. I agree with Sandra (well, not about the liberal not funny thing but ...) Bring the funny!!
When I close my eyes. This is what I see ...
Freaky Trolls Phd, Everybody. No Boogie.
It's back to the good 'ole high school prom.
A line goes clear out the gymnasium doors.
@ Open Salon we all tap each other's belly.
May I please dance with Freaky Troll PhD?
O, best to slow dance. Stick behind outside.
No gig close. No risk Freaky Troll's bumps.
O, stick a butt outward and no be too close?
After a prom dance, take Freaky Troll PhD?
Freaky Troll PhD dances in a pink tutu? Oy!
One kiss is too much. One bump leads to '2'!
One Freaky Troll PhD is to hold sweet hand!
Pretend this is the daily kindergarden party.
I loved to hug monsters at the masquerades.
We all fit in. We part and parcel human race.
Freaky Troll PhD? May we pokes Ya button?
I mean inter-are? No sin tho. O, belly button!
OS is a great community because of the diversity. I think your comedy is a welcome addition to the brilliant writers already here. I feel overwhelmed sometimes too, because there are so many deep, personal stories here. But variety is truly the spice of life! Where else can you read about politics, religion, music, art, parenting, food, comedy, poetry and everything else all at the same time????? Very thoughtful post. :)
I forgot CAKE!!!! (For Freaky....)
A blog is what you want it to be. You don't have to be spontaneous. Emotion recollected in tranquility. Or something. All the better if that emotion grows out of or into humor. I love to laugh! Who doesn't?
You, Sheldon the Wonderhorse, Con Chapman, and many others (including some cross-genre posters) frequently make me laugh out loud. Honestly, if it were all misery, blood, death, addiction, pain, woe, gloom, despair, and agony around here, I'd have to conclude it'd morphed into a 12-step meeting. And I'd be outta here.

Thanks for pointing out that this isn't a flounce (i.e., you're not leaving), because otherwise I'm afraid I'd have had to offer you a hoop skirt to go with that clarinet.

;-)

(Band geeks were the best kissers.)
oh. my. god...i am quite simply overwhelmed...i posted this very late last night, and figured when i woke up i would answer the couple of comments i had received--now, insteadof answering you individually, let me just thank the whole diverse, rag-tag, motley group of you for your kindness and support....now i suppose i'd better write something funny (just as soon as i finish having this Sally Field moment)...much love to everyone!
Guess, I'm the only one who will speak the truth (as usual). Sorry, dude, you gotta go. The place for you is OSS (Open Silly Salon, which, funny enough, has the exact same cover) . And, uh, don't let us catch you here again! (barring a sex change operation story done while sharing a scrumptious cupcake recipe as you muse on space aliens and their political agendas)
I couldn't even make the cover. I think nobody reads my stuff. I'm NOT even a writer. I do so many misspelling. But I do write because it makes me happy. Don't worry about what the other people think! Keep the good work!
Talent - check.
Intelligence - check.
Loyal readership - check.
Frozen lake performance experience - check.

You seem to meet all the criteria...
Oh man- to quote the wise man, "Dying is easy. Comedy is hard." The one piece I got an EP for was my funny piece and I'm quite proud of it. Being funny is great fun but it's also hard damn work. I get completely jealous of the funny people on OS. I love reading them. Then I hate them for being funnier than me. I don't know what I'm doing here either. Screwing around when I should be working mostly.
Will you dance with me?

Most of my stuff is fluff....not to worry.
More often than not, the comedy is in the responses. I get so caught up in reading the responses that I end up reading half the night away. So, if you add a comedy story (and some are), you'll be doing way better than me. Now, hey, that's an idea!! ROTFLMAO!!
There's certainly plenty of room here for comic pieces!
I think Helen Polychronakos makes he perennial point: "A blog is what you want it to be."

You shouldn't feel the pressure to contribute -- much less in any prescribed way. Write what you want. And don't underestimate Funny -- I think Saturn's point about the importance of entertaining today is pretty applicable.
I'm new here. too but I've been reading a while and "funny" is what I search out! Keep writing. For God's sake, keep making people smile. It's a wonderful gift! Keep giving!
I too am one of the people who make innappropriate comments at funerals. If you look at my postings, there is not one that comments seriously on the world at large and, for the most part, are ridiculously inane. I get what you're saying though - there are some SERIOUS writers here, and I'm just not one of them. I say, stick around. We'll hang out around the keg while all the politicos debate, and we'll have a laugh at their expense.
I have the same thoughts!!! I think what you are experiencing can be found in Julia Cameron's book: "The Artists Way." Boiled down it is this: once you begin putting work out there, you expereince some anxiety that 1. it's not good enough, 2. others will ridicule or condemn or otherwise discourage, 3. a little shame. It is a fact that the act of creating is potentially shame producing as we expose ourselves to "others" who might tell us we're wasting our time.

Now that being said: stay stay stay! Don't make the rest of us be the only ones who are sick of all the bad news!!!!

Rated!
MisterComedy,

If you're standing next to the casket and somebody near you is sobbing and saying " He looks so natural" and you don't say " You should have seen him last week", well, you're just not a funny guy.

I got really scared you were going to wrap this up telling us you just don't feel like cleaning the house while your spouse is out in the world doing stuff. That is way too "in the moment" .
Bring on the funny.
so, let's dance. i have many of the same feelings as you. which is partly why i do not ever post actually writing. :)
Welcome. Look forward to your future entries.
Bob
Serious is overrated and overdone. If OS were all serious, I wouldn't be here. don't worry about what anyone else is doing, just do what makes you happy. Keep at it, you'll find your audience and come into your own.
Write whatever suits your fancy. If you know funny best, then do funny. I don't post political critiques because I'm an ignorant jackass when it comes to politics - ditto on finance.

Comedy is always welcomed - so get back to work now, young man.

Thumbed.
The trick to art is not to over think it. One stroke too many can ruin the painting.

Alternatively: Having a stroke over the joke kills the humor cells in the brain.

Just do it!
hey! you've crossed over into my territory, jokey mcstandup...

standing next to the punchbowl is my thing!..look...i INVENTED hanging out by the punchbowl!!

so...i get first dibs on everyone of those lonely, thirsty ladies..like this one headed over here now...

hey, how ya doin babe?..warm isn't it?..let me get you a drink...
In my not-so-humble opinion, we need more Jokey McStandup around here. Please stay and keep writing. The whole world is not tragedy.
I'm pretty new as well, and now I'm looking forward to reading some of your past comedy posts. If Verbal Remedy says you and Sheldon make her laugh out loud, I'm definitely all over it.

You played clarinet? Were you fairly skilled, or one of the squeakers? Played french horn myself. At least you had a reasonable chance of concealing your band geekiness in your locker. There was NO hiding that french horn on the school bus!

(Of course, I really thought band was awesome, and now that I'm the parent of a choir geek, I think that's pretty awesome, too!)
Wanna dance?

You fit in just fine. I have no idea what I'm doing here half the time, but I keep doing it, mostly daily, just so I can keep writing and people will read what I write. So what if it's not what people want. And sure, I'm more like to get EP if I post a picture with no words, or if I bare my soul, but I can be funny too, I LIKE to be funny, we need more funny. Hang out with us. You won't be sorry.
I have similar doubts and find myself hovering in the doorway lots of days - not sure how to join the serious political discussions, or too slow in my process to answer the open calls. Funny around the punch bowl is a good place to be - looks like I won't be the only one stopping by for a laugh.
if feel no belong, can abduct. take trip to sirius (far from planet Kaw-maddy).

peace (4 now)
I need more funny! Some days this place can be a real downer.