The Crux of the Biscuit

MJwycha

MJwycha
Location
Pennsylvania,
Birthday
August 05
Bio
Crux of the Biscuit emerged fully formed on Jan 5 2009. The Crux primarily discusses music, makes fun of music, and celebrates music. The Crux also reserves the right to discuss movies, books, and other aspects of pop culture. And if you don't know what the crux of the biscuit is please, for the sake of humanity, educate yourself. Or look for the answer on my banner.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
JANUARY 27, 2010 10:44PM

The Dylan Files #1: Link in the Chain

Rate: 24 Flag

Link in the Chain (roots and beginnings) 

American folk music.

Blind Lemon Jefferson, Doc Boggs, Buell Kazee, Mississippi John Hurt, Clarence Ashley, Cannon’s Jug Stompers, the Carter Family—these artists, among many others, didn’t invent folk music, but they are responsible for popularizing folk music during the 20s and 30s—for first recording and setting the table for the turn American popular music would take in the 50s and 60s.

                          

Bob Dylan is a vital link in this chain. His music both transcends and is a part of this great musical tradition that stretches back into the mists of American mythology. As we begin our series on the music of Bob Dylan, it is fitting to consider this aspect of Dylan’s musical development.  

Folk songs of the twenties and thirties reveal a rich tapestry of influences—European and African motifs, rhythms, and melodies had blended into a strange and wonderful amalgam that was distinctly American. It is inclusive and participatory. It is simple but also deep and muddy.

                       
                                                           Cannon's Jug Stompers

 The sanctified rhythm, howling blues, whining mountain ballads.

                                  
                                                       Robert Johnson

 The hobo on the rails, the preacher testifying, Robert Johnson at the crossroads. 

                                           
                                                         Dock Boggs
 
It is the flowering of several generations worth of musical amalgamation. This is not only fun and exciting music, but also culturally important music that provides insight into who we were and still are as a people. 

                         
                                                       The Carter Family

The reemergence of traditional folk music during the 1950s makes sense in retrospect. The 50s, having given rise to the modern, disposable consumer culture as well as threat of nuclear annihilation, was ripe for a turn back toward authenticity and mystery. For young people coming of age in the late 50s, folk music must have seemed like a window onto a seemingly more authentic and romantic era.

                                    
                                                     Blind Willie McTell

Robert Zimmerman, who had come down out of the iron ranges of northern Minnesota to college in the late 50s, was one of these young people. He had of course been indoctrinated in the currency of rock n roll and country & western as a high school kid—Little Richard, Gene Vincent, Hank Williams. But it would be the folk world where he would find a doorway to an original and potent artistic expression. Already artists like Joan Baez and the Kingston Trio had found commercial success—and earlier links in the chain like Pete Seeger served as mentors and links to the seemingly ancient folk world.

                                  
                                                 Blind Lemon Jefferson

It was performers like Woody Guthrie, Sonny Terry , Pete Seeger, and Odetta who provide the link between the artists of the 20s and counterculture of the 50s and 60s. Though both Woody and Seeger (and countless other folk artists) had been blacklisted at the start of the Cold War, they were able to get folk music heard in schoolrooms across America. Songs like This Land is Your Land and Michael Row the Boat Ashore have been sung by American school children since the 40s.  By the late fifties a generation was coming of age having been weaned on folk music.

One of the biggest influences on not only Dylan’s metamorphosis but of the entire folk music revival was Harry Smith’s vital and historic Anthology of American Folk Music.

                             

Released on Folkways Records in 1953, the Anthology of American Folk Music featured 84 songs recorded in the late 20s and early 30s . Murder ballads, country blues, work songs, social music, and traditional mountain music, Smith’s collection had one foot in a verdant and mythical America and one foot in the screaming, mechanical modern era. It steps out of the poetic past shrouded in exciting danger and ancient mystery.

                                     
                                                  Mississippi John Hurt

(The Cohen Brothers “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” is brilliant in artistically highlighting the early folk recording era of music and American culture—the movie, borrowing elements from Homeric and Biblical traditions, is a kind of impressionistic view on American mythology moving headlong into the brave new world of the 20th century.)

                               
                                                     Charlie Patton

The Anthology of American Folk Music is an honest-to-God treasure. It was folk and jazz music, after all, where desegregation first took place. It is absolutely essential for understanding the course American popular music took during the 20th century. Both folk and jazz gave us a history and an attitude. It was ours.

                                     
                                                        Buell Kazee

It certainly was influential to young Robert Zimmerman as he immersed himself in the idioms and traditions of folk, blues, and country. Ultimately the transformation of Robert Zimmerman to Bob Dylan was one of Love and Theft—like any great artist he borrowed and incorporated themes and phrases from those who came before. In particular, Dylan focused on the rambling and shambling Woody Guthrie while crafting his persona.  Guthrie was, of course, the folk-singing truth teller during the Great Depression.

Dylan spent countless hours studying the vocal mannerisms of not just Guthrie, but also performers like Willie McTell, Hank Williams, Noah Lewis, and Huddie Ledbetter .

                         
                                                      Woody Guthrie

As Dylan made his escape from the frozen northland to New York, armed with the seemingly secret and powerful knowledge of folk music, he too must have felt like Guthrie once had:  Bound for Glory.

                                        
 
It’s not surprising then that one of the first things Dylan did when he went east in January of 1961 was to introduce himself to Woody Guthrie.  Walked right into the hospital and sang for him. One of the first original songs Bob Dylan wrote was the touching and indebted “Song to Woody,” which manages to pay homage to all those who came before. Link in the chain.  

                         john_cohen_dylan

 

 

Clarance Ashley talks about recording in the 1920s, performs "The Coo Coo Bird" 

 
 
 
 
                       Cannon's Jug Stompers "Big Railroad Blues"
 
 
 
 
                               Furry Lewis: "Kassie Jones Blues" 
 
 
 
                        The Carter Family: "This World's On Fire"
                                                (Sound familiar?)
 
 
 
                            Woody Guthrie "This Land is Your Land"
(Yup, that's the Carter Family tune used for Guthrie's This Land is Your Land.  Blues and folk musicians borrowed ideas, licks and tunes from each other all the time. Remember that the next time someone stupidly says that rock music"ripped off" the blues and folk, or the next time someone complains that hip-hop or sampling isn't music--it's part of the tradition man!)
 
 
 
Bob Dylan pays tribute to Guthrie and his roots: "Song to Woody" (1961)
 
 
 Check it out!
 
 
Next Dylan Files Post: February 19(ish)! Dig it!
 
 
 
 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
from one dylan-head to another--great work! one of the most powerful early performances by bob in my mind has no music whatsoever, just a tapestry of words--"last thoughts on woody guthrie"--beautiful, surrealistic, impressionistic, heartfelt...
Yay, this one will take a long pondering over ... then comments.

I've been revisiting highway sixty-one revisited so this came just in time.
MJ,
It’s hard ot put into words how much I love reading your stuff. I learn something every time and the passion with which you treat your subjects keeps me totally engaged.

This was an outstanding post.

Passion is the one thing that so many music historians and reviewers lack. I never get the feeling, reading you, that you have dialed it in. You heart is fully present in your pieces and this one was pure joy to read.

Descriptions like, “Guthrie was a folk-singing truth teller” are succinct while conveying an entire life story. That kind of insight comes from loving a subject and ruminating on it long enough to let others gain from the passion.

I was thinking about Nashville Skyline while reading this. I don’t know why, because it’s pretty unrelated. But Dylan’s musical journey is filled with so many attempts to immerse his talent in genres that critics may not have understood at the time but defined him as a unique artist for the ages.

Rated and very much appreciated.
I'm up and dancing. I loved this review!
Wonderful review. Thanx much for digging up these treasures. This is a keeper for the archives. (r)
Re: “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” the movie borrowing elements from Homeric and Biblical traditions is a kind of impressionistic view on American mythology moving headlong into the brave new world of the 20th century
I just love this paragraph. i love the whole thing MJ. Awaiting the next insallment. thanks for this.
Great intro to what I'm certain will be a great project. Another reason that folk became popular in the 50s is that it was the only music that spoke with honesty about larger issues in the world around.
Love it. There's a great compilation out there called Songs the Dylan Loved that probably tracks pretty well with the Folkways Anthology. Highly recommended.

Thanks for including Furry, too. When I was in high school a few of the seniors would go buy a half pint of Jim Beam and swing by Furry's place to pick him up and bring him back to school, where he'd play 15 or 20 minutes worth of stuff on the deck off the cafeteria during lunch. Not too many of the white boys at my prep school appreciated ol' Furry but sometimes he was just awesome.
Niiiiice! I think this is your most impressive music-nerd post yet - and some others have been extremely good before. Mad props.
Sweet!

Thanks so much for this piece, MJ. I feel like I just took a history class, teacher that you are.
mistercomedy--"last thoughts", yes, that's a heck of a poem--I'll have something about that for the next post. Thanks for stopping by bro!

Scarlett--hope you enjoy!

Dennis--you always leave the nicest comments man. The various styles Dylan explored is what will make this an interesting journey (I hope). I think Dylan was ahead of the musical curve for many years. At some point he journeyed out of time--into the realm of legend and myth. And he's still with us.

Scupper, ClarkK, and Trilogy--thanks, and enjoy the music!

abrawang--you're right about folk speaking to larger issues--strange (or maybe not so much) that these old folk songs spoke a larger truth for folks than more contemporary music.

Risa--thanks for stopping by

Lonnie--Dude, you met Furry Lewis? You might as well have told me you met Paul Bunyon or that you hung out with the fellas on Steinbeck's Cannary Row. That is amazing! I'd like to hear more about that.

Ricky--thanks for the kind words.

Token Tarheel--Lomax was actually mentioned in a draft, but I have to be careful not to write a novel here. 85% of what I want to say has to be cut or glossed over. Brevity is difficult sometimes; this series will have to be somewhat general--though I'm sure you guys in the comments will fill in the blanks.

Waking--do I really come off as teacherly? I guess I do sometimes, especially when I'm discussing something I know something about. Don't worry though, homework is optional!
mjwycha daunting task good beginning i bow to you
Thanks for collecting all the video. I'll have to watch later (when I'm not at work).
The attitudes about sharing and borrowing bring to mind the wonderful film about young Dylan by Martin Scorcese, "No Direction Home." In it, Dylan cops to ripping off a guy's record collection, no doubt containing the work of many of the artists listed in this wonderful post. I don't recall the quote exactly, but he justified the theft because he needed those records, and felt he just had to have 'em. We can see why.
Devil worshipper! Soul catcher! This boogie-woogie music will go nowhere I say. We must return to the days of musical Greatness, when the lash and the rod set the rhythm. HurumphHurumph
I know very little about Bob Dylan. I did read that his song "Mississippi" used a line from a prisoner at Parchman, then later I read that it is a common refrain at Parchman meant to explain why a prisoner is there: "I stayed in MS a day too long."
You did well to link all these threads together.
From Robert Johnson, to Blind Lemon Jefferson to the Carter Family in among all the others - leading to Bob. Thank you for providing so many links in the chain.

And the timing is perfect.
jimmymac--Yeah, Dylan was quite a scrounger in his early days. Dave Van Ronk referred to him as a schnorer--a Yiddish term for an expert moocher. It was universally overlooked because everyone who met him knew he was special.

Harold--you're probably right. Flash in the pan musical fad. And of course it's also the way to ruin.

Losingmyreligion--I didn't know that about the phrase "stayed in MS a day too long," but it doesn't surprise me--the album is called Love and Theft. It's littered with borrowed blues and folk phrases.
I loved this journey. I'm looking forward to the next installment. Thanks!
David--I know.
I'm doing a whole series on Bob Dylan. http://open.salon.com/blog/mjwycha/2010/01/18/the_dylan_files
Rated for anything "Bob."

Good work!
Marvelous bit of musical genealogy. Looking forward to the next one.
Great writing, great selection. The song The Cuckoo shares melody with a Leadbelly song called Stewball. It's one of his ripped-from-the-headlines songs about a race horse in California. You have a good grasp of the history and tell it well, please keep it up.
A friend of mine has access to years of unreleased recordings, and one day he made a 7-CD collection of Hank Williams outtakes, alternate takes and miscellaneous unreleased stuff. Dylan had asked for it through a mutual friend. He made a duplicate set for me. Some of it's a little hard to listen to, but I feel like I understand Dylan better for it.
awesome. As a long time fan of folk music the first thing I thought of when I read the first sentence was Guthrie and the next thing was the Smithsonian recordings.
Truly inspired. Looking forward to more...
Now this is the way to use the internet.... gather all the gems off of YouTube, etc and bring them together for a great essay on folk music and Dylan
glad to have found this - thank-you

Thanks JK Brady for sending me here...
Just fascinating. Some of this I knew, most I have now learned. Am still replaying and listening with such pleasure. I am so looking forward to the next installment.

I think you might enjoy my Dylan story. Less about his music than a personal experience with Dylan, unguarded.

Bob Dylan, From Bedroom To Beach
MJ - great work as always. I'm one of those people who gave up on Dylan after Blonde on Blonde. Not to say he didn't do some fine work after that, it just didn't appeal to me. On the other hand, I've converted all of my early Dylan LP's over to CD and listen to them all regularly. I'll see you down on Highway 61
CB
Theft with deep love, that's our Bob...
Glad this is going around again. It should keep going around, forever. rated
Images fashion strives to provide a balance of timely, credible business news and key fashion trends. fashion apparel news