• The Finical Filmgoer •

Peering from behind eyelet curtains: the cloistral apartments of M. Chariot
Of late, M. Chariot seems entirely unable to capture the proper modus operandi which confers attention on Open Salon: namely an unhesitating ability to jump to immediate, infuriated conclusions regarding current events — particularly events about which one knows next to nothing. My unfortunate tendency to ruminate on subject matter over a period of time, plus a natural, discreet resistance to the temptation to add to the pandemonia, seem to define my abject failure as a contemporary writer.
And yet, complaining is against my nature: I have larger issues with which to entertain myself. Readers with outdated tendencies to loyalty or affection may have noted my recent intimations of ill health, but you haven't heard the half of it, my dears: this has been a very precipitous year. During times of political and economic upheaval, it should come as no surprise that the aesthete does not fare well; delicacy is not served by cultural temblors. Fainting among the bibelots and hairline cracks in the Limoges tea set foretold greater fissures in the constitution, with which the author now finds himself contending.

Nights racked with feverish imaginings
These days one invariably finds M. Chariot sulking on a meticulously polished, walnut Victorian wheelchair, peering forlornly through eyelet curtains. To think I was once le toast français! Sigh. It seems such a long time ago.

Better days on the Boulevard
And yet one question remains: what to do with oneself during a long convalescence?
Casting about to give life some meaning against this period of personal collapse, I came to notice that my tiny film reviews of the past piqued not a few lively commentaries among those gentlepersons incomprehensibly participating on the forum — which led to the newish submission you are reading now.
I am chagrined to inform you that the following material cannot be described by even the most reticent among us as thrillingly of-the-moment; this post may therefore be subject to even more obscurity than Open Salon generally confers upon her roster of the obscure. Still, one languishes in the hope that considerations of contemporaneity will not inhibit you, lovely reader, from the leisurely perusal.
And if, like mine, your health is a bit iffy at the moment, let's splash the face with a few drops of cool water, put on a pot of our favorite tea, fluff the pillows of our respective daybeds and sit up, shall we? A return to some degree of health or vigor may well be around the corner, and how shall we be able to revel in a bit of self-indulgence then, I ask you? Housebound and invalidated, we may as well enjoy ourselves while we can. So fire up the telly, plug in the following, and let's talk cinema: Cinema for the Indisposed!
.........................................................................................................

Last Year at Marienbad (1961)
One is swept away by the sheer enchantment of this film, which is considered a classic of French Nouveau Roman. Much has been written about it, and afterward I was absorbed for hours not just by fascinating professional reviews, but also by myriad User Reviews on IMDb. Last Year has captured the imagination of countless intelligent moviegoers, whose ruminations on the story, the style and the philosophical underpinnings of memory and narrative provide some fascinating reading.
Last Year at Marienbad is set in an opulent, meticulously maintained hotel, where the sophisticated guests pose in elegant tableau, and wander about slowly, enigmatically. We are treated to long pans of the salons, the windows, the doors, the chandeliers, the carpets and the boiserie. Dream-like and repetitive, the narration and dialogue have a cantatory quality, with subtle changes and shifts in content, focus and detail.
There are three central characters: the Stranger, the Woman, and the woman's Husband. The Stranger is attempting to seduce the Woman, to convince her that they have been meeting yearly, and that they must run off together. The Woman resists, refusing (or mysteriously unable) to recall the Stranger or their affair, while the Husband, unsuspecting at first, imposes increasing menace. 
Delphine Seyrig
The luminous Delphine Seyrig portrays the Woman with soigneé opacity, a suffocating and brittle French elegance, all poses, evening gowns and bewitching romantic anxiety. The Stranger (Giorgio Albertazzi) and the Husband (Sacha Pitoeff), perfectly dressed in tuxedos, present the viewer with emblems of masculine romantic yearning, suspicion and betrayal.
The film is like an eerie bath in the chilly waters of an alienated social milieu, throwing into high relief the frustrating checkmate of passion vs. artifice, desire vs. a thwarting façade of wealth and refinement. It is open to endless interpretation, as revealed by a perusal of its countless commentaries. My own interpretation is that the Woman and the Stranger are ghosts, trapped in endless repetition of their tragic melodrama within the walls of a haunted hotel. Written by Alain Robbe-Grillet and directed by Alain Resnais.
.........................................................................................................

Edge of Darkness (2010)
I resisted seeing Mel Gibson's 2010 "comeback" — Edge of Darkness — for as long as I could, for several reasons.
First, I found the telephone tapes of Mr. Gibson's virulent attacks on his wife to be so utterly repulsive that I wished no longer to support the actor's work.
Secondly, stories which focus on characters who are malevolently injected with or exposed to chemicals/diseases/bacteria/tiny foreign creatures which infiltrate the body and require a "race against the clock" to find a cure/antidote fill me with a deep, existential dread: M. Chariot cannot stomach plots of this kind.
Perhaps it is because I have seen up-close-and-personal the magnitude of suffering endured by friends with serious, real-world ilnesses. Perhaps I find it outrageously exploitive that such suffering should be tapped for edge-of-your-seat entertainment purposes. Or perhaps it is the ongoing horror of my splayed pinkie disorder.
But, like many weak-willed persons hoping to display a bit of integrity in the face of massive juggernauts of greedy commercialism, I was eventually worn down by the unrelenting, seductive presence of that Eye of commerce — namely, the television — which looms, glaring implacably at every feeble human alternative played out on the stage of my cloistral apartments. Books, conversations, cocktails, musical interludes, all eventually peter out, until I finally look into the Eye and the Eye looks back and says, "I will now screen The Edge of Darkness and you will watch it." Exhausted, I obey.
What I can confirm, for those who may have forgotten, is that Mr. Gibson is an actor of no small skill. His forehead now etched with the kind of lines which indicate frequent paroxysms of spleen, he capably carries the film without any other visible signs of strain.
Mr. Gibson portrays a Boston police officer whose activist daughter, on a visit home, is shot to death on his doorstep. His investigation of the murder uncovers a (zzzzzzzzz) vast conspiracy (zzzzzzzzz) — oh, I'm sorry, I seem to have collapsed into contemporary plot narcolepsy for a few moments — a vast conspiracy which involves her having been poisoned with radiation to keep her from revealing the criminal secrets of some malevolent corporation involved in weapons manufacture. Gibson is eventually also poisoned in the same manner, as his flinch-free, rage-fueled investigation threatens to expose corporate machinations.
Along the way, we are introduced to cops, FBI, elected government officials and, of course, corporate operatives exemplifying the most degenerate sensibilities, and we are gratified to see them thrown down staircases, run over in automobiles, waterboarded with radioactive milk and shot point blank in the face. Many of these actions are performed by Mr. Gibson himself, whose personal predilection for murderous, eye-popping, spittle-flecked revenge lends the entire affair a certain panic-stricken believability.
Perhaps vast, malevolent conspiracies are the only thing horrible enough to give personalities like Gibson's an air of legitimacy. By film's end, his unshrinking ferocity has rendered him not only legitimate but saintly, and he strides, arm-in-arm with his tragic daughter, into the heavenly Light.
With Ray Winstone, Danny Huston and Bojana Novakovic, directed by Martin Campbell (Casino Royale, Golden Eye).
.........................................................................................................

Far from the Madding Crowd (1967)
Directed by John Schlesinger from a novel by Thomas Hardy, with Nicholas Roeg as cinematographer. Julie Christie is Bathsheba Everdine, a strong-willed, flirtatious young woman, who inherits a large farm and becomes romantically involved with three very different gentlemen: a shepherd (Alan Bates), a lonely, wealthy farmer (Peter Finch) and a philandering soldier (Terence Stamp). This is one of M. Chariot's favorite films; I would even say it's a masterpiece. I've seen it at different times in my life, and it evokes different issues and perceptions with each viewing.
Deftly capturing the mood and tone of pastoral England prior to the Industrial Revolution, the film represents the best work of each of these great actors. Far has an archetypal quality: the characters embody classical themes of love, ambivalence, constancy, loneliness, control, arrogance, power and obsession. There is a curious pre-feminist subtext which examines the havoc a singular woman can wreak on the kinds of men who cannot fathom her independence.
Not shying away from Hardy's bleak view of existence, we see how romantic obsession can ruin lives, and how the pursuit of true love is not simple, but fraught with obstacles, danger, self-delusion, tragedy and death. Haunting, poignant and unforgettable.
.........................................................................................................

It's Complicated (2009)
Don't get me wrong. I adore Meryl Streep, and I adore Meryl Streep in practically everything. But ugh. I loathed Meryl Streep's characterization in It's Complicated. Why?
I once read in an interview that Mme Streep hates to be photographed. Isn't that odd? The one person you'd think wouldn't mind a damned bit. But she explained that if she is portraying a character, it's no problem; she simply can't stand being photographed as herself.
Is this a kind of clue as to why she is so difficult to watch in this film? She most definitely is not portraying a Holocaust Survivor or a Mother Superior or a South African Scientist or an Urban High-Fashionista. I wonder if the character she was asked to portray in Complicated was a little too close to herself - and she didn't quite know how to manage it?
Additionally, seeing Meryl Streep play the lead in a romantic comedy really does shed a light on the dynamics of the genre. The most intelligent and accomplished actress of our generation is suddenly rendered so giggly, ditzy, loopy and flustery she seemed like a feeble-minded idiot. I found myself wondering if she was simply channeling Diane Keaton (who has made a career of that particular gambit)! My dear Meryl, such monkey business is simply beneath you, and I beg your pardon for thinking so, but there you have it.
The only scene worthy of our esteemed actress is the last, where she and Steve Martin look into each others' eyes and decide, despite an obstacle course of syrupy, clownish nonsense, to make a go of their fledgling relationship. Suddenly the sniggly tittering is evaporated and one can see two intelligent, vulnerable, middle-aged people reaching out to one another. I only wish the film could have started there. Directed by Nancy Meyers, with Alec Baldwin as a hairy sugarplum marzipan teddy bear.
Finical Filmgoer Reviews:
Perfume: The Story of a Murderer (2006)
The Twilight Saga: New Moon (2009)
Antonioni's L'Avventura (1960)
The Golden Bowl (2000)
Last Year at Marienbad (1961)
Far from the Madding Crowd (1967)
Goodbye Again (1961)
Antichrist (2009)
The Big Lebowski (1998)
Smash His Camera (2010)

Salon.com
Comments
Here's to feeling better, M.C.
And re Meryl Streep, she's a wonderful actress but a bit of blank canvas for directors to paint on. I once saw her in an interview and was surprised to find that she had nothing of note to say.
And may I suggest a couple of my favourites: Amelie; M. Hulot's Holiday.
Jim K
I wish you health dear friend...and happiness through the Holidays, and always
i would like to recommend a different type of film, 'leaves of grass' with edward norton in a dual role. it is basically a comedy, but with a lot of darkness. norton does an amazing job with this one. it was written by tim blake nelson (whom i consider a genius); tbn is also in it, along with susan sarandon.
while i find mel gibson's behaviour detestable, i was gobsmacked by 'apocolypto'...the man has talent; too bad he's incredibly nuts and self-destructive. plus, i don't watch movies with dead children in them; just can't. (r)
r
A Mel Gibson movie?!!!
Perhaps a consultation with your physician about adjusting the strength or kind of your medicines would be in order.
(**Mel Gibson.....tsk, tsk**)
^R^ (but NOT for that M.G. ...."?"....)
so sorry to hear your pinky problems persist and do hope you're on the mend, monsieur. you've been terribly missed and not only for your unique ability to unearth words like "contemporaneity."
Mel Gibson, has alas, used up my last atom of good will; And the Vast Shadowy Government Plot will be with us as long as there are movies.
rated!
I often like to watch TV with the sound turned off, I Love Lucy was my favorite show to watch without sound, now I'm just left with youtubes of GW on mute.
Perhaps I'll see if Mel Gibson is amusing on mute, he always looks like an axe murderer. Sorry to chatter, I just like you and wanted to visit. Get well, love to you.
I'm very sorry to hear that your health problems continue. And the description of the current state of the Limoges tea set brought tears to my eyes, as I recall how in better days the Limoges featured prominently in "Bombarded by the Booty," one of your earlier and most-beloved posts. Now it appears that both Monsieur Chariot and the Limoges are frail and housebound, a tragic state of affairs.
I came away from Edge of Darkness with something a little different. As our corporate and governmental masters (increasingly one and the same) continue to lead the country into ruin, I was happy to see both get some payback at the hand of Gibson et al. (E.g., "you can't shoot me; I'm a U.S. senator!" to which the response was "By what standard?" By what standard indeed.)
A couple of other recent cable offerings also "stick it to the man." Entry Level, a movie about a fellow who tries to get an entry-level corporate job after losing his restaurant, rightly skewers the absurd and humiliating job interview process that we must go through. Up In The Air has George Clooney as a hired-gun hatchet man flying around the country firing people so that gutless managers don't have to do it.
I like to think that these movies, revealing the dark side of the corporate world through both tragedy and comedy, might augur the start of a little revolution against the forces that are leading the country to ruin. I can hope anyway.
I can't agree with you on the Gibson matter, unfortunately. Nothing this 'gentleman' can do or say would allow his presence in the parlor at this late date, but one must admire gumption, however pointless.
I am off to pop some corn and relive the glory days with Delphine. Marienbad was so wonderful....
May I suggest that you refrain from filling your gentle mind with actions and sounds made by Mr. Gibson. This cannot possibly be helpful during your convalescence. A Meryl Streep or Julie Christie film fest, where all films in their oeuvre are viewed back to back in chronological order, would be more fitting entertainment for a man of your intellect and fine taste. Do you have a nice pair of slippers, I hope?
After reading your exquisite analyses of these films, a few of which I have seen, it occurred to me that I would enjoy seeing your criticism on film better than the films themselves. I could not agree more about Streep, "It's Complicated, and romantic comedy in general. It seems like all we get are neon characters from space with things exploding every 5 minutes, or romantic comedies. Quel dommage.
For your convalescence, I prescribe prisms on a line of string. It worked wonders for Agnes Moorehead! The very best to you, dear Msr.
It has been years since I saw "Last Year at Marienbad." You have inspired me to take another look. As for the Mel Gibson film, I will simply take your word for it.
The primary reason for my comment, however, is that I am utterly nonplussed with "Far from the Madding Crowd." I am a Thomas Hardy fan, one of a hardy few. (Heh.) However, I do not believe that I have ever seen this film version of the novel. I certainly think that I would have remembered such a thing. Mysterious. In any event I shall remedy that situation by viewing it. High praise from you indeed, man of impeccable taste that you are.
So sorry you are not well, but you will get lots of healing love and I believe you will feel better. As for my thoughts of you: In Israel, where I am currently, I watch "In Treatment" and though the stories are close to the USA version, Assi Dayan is nothing like Gabriel Byne, each great in very different ways. Sending love and healing. By the by, what color candle seems best? I am drawn to green but would like your "take'. Love you MC, Wendy
Merci also for mentioning Last Year at Marienbad, which captures the sense that our daily reality and inexplicable dreams are tangled in ways we can't unravel.
Your watching The Madding Crowd, which brings together Julie Christie, Terrence Stamp, and Peter Finch, was risky because their electricity could cause one not in optimal health to swoon. Thank heaven you were equal to the challenge.
As for Mel Gibson, I can only wonder if Monsieur watched him on one of those "nights of feverish imaginings," and that your altered state colored your impeccable taste.
I hesitate to comment on Meryl Streep, as I would be devastated if Monsieur, during this period of personal collapse and sulking, were to judge my indifference to her as unsuitable for the virtual friend of a gentleman of refined sensibilities. And I have only slim hope of helping my cause by adding that she did a fine job in "The Devil Wears Prada." But there it is. You deserve no less than candor.
Along with affectionate admiration, I send fevered good wishes for your health and happiness.
I loved "It's Complicated" tho, for the comic timing (mainly the character of Harley played by the talented young John Krasinski) and the kitchen porn - yes, this and other films like it (try Nancy's other film, "Something's Gotta Give") are called kitchen porn, aimed at women my age who would love such a sunny white kitchen and all that entails....
Hope you feel better soon, man. When I want to chill out and just laugh, my man Will Smith always provides in the MIB series. (quel diverse, you say? Yes, my tastes *are* quite eclectic, as are yours!) Rated.
As for me, laughter being medicinal, I've found it's often quite uplifting to rent "The Incredible Shrinking Man" or "Mars Need Women", mute the sound and make up my own script. That also works for many of the new films as well.
And then, there's always "All About Eve." Knowing every word of dialog never diminishes my enjoyment.
Cheers,
MOC
Que te mejores pronto, Monsieur Chariot!
A fine kettle of film! I do tend to agree your assessments on the quality of the movies, however my personal interest centers more on the quality of the actresses. The exquisite Delphine Seyrig, smoldering under her feathers brings me back to my youth when I traveled in France and fell in love with a dark haired french woman at a dance in Chamonix. Julie Christie, the passionate love interest of Rod Steiger showed me that a woman could have as high a libido as a man. And Meryl Streep looks sexier as the years roll by, although she has never looked comfortable, as you so skillfully observe, as a sex object. As for Mel Gibson...I pass.
this piece was excellent. I love your victorian pic of "feverish imaginings." Looks just like something some victorian would put in a book about their hallucinations!
Reminded me of those funny fairie photos that fooled Sir Arthur Conan Doyle back in the day!
http://www.lhup.edu/~dsimanek/doyle.htm
Even the layout of the entry (OS readers take note) is so smashing. It simply looks well organized and sharp. You linked up to past posts like a mad mother effer. But more than hyperlink, you enticed me to WANT to read those other pieces.
As for your film reviews, they are professional AND a fun read.
I shall add Maddening to my Netflix queue. As well as you. Can I add YOU to my Netflix queue?
And get better. I'm concerned.
If I may be so bold as to suggest several other titles which may help to alleviate such a foul condition as you refer to:
Godard's 'Breathless.' So full of energy and danger. Jean Seberg is priceless.
Luhrmann's 'Moulin Rouge.' Also packed with energy and the added thrill of star crossed true love. Nicole Kidman: The 'Sparkling Diamond.'
John Huston's 'Maltese Falcon.' Bogey, Astor and Lorre. That oughta do it.
Dennis Hopper's 'Easy Rider.' Hopper's first directed feature, slices through America while running down the road. Plus introduces Jack Nicholson. Freedom.
Feel better.