The Rich Man and Lazarus: Approaching the Coming Holidays
One of the things that I miss the most being retired is researching, writing and giving sermons. Several members of the OS family have asked why I mostly write about politics and not about the vocation that is my passion. I suppose it is because many of the OS family do not share my faith, or have no faith at all. So, as one who has never forced my religious views on anyone, I have hesitated to write about religion. But now I am going to share with you a sermon that I wrote that seems, at least to me, to address a moral/ethical issue that is just as applicable to a secular humanist as it is to a religious person. We’ll see how it is received.
The little story Jesus relates about the Rich Man and Lazarus is told by St. Luke at Chapter 16 of his Gospel, verses 19-31. This is a good time of year to consider the meaning of that story. You do not have to be a Christian to understand the universality of the moral of this story.
Why this time of year? Because we are about to unleash ourselves upon the annual rituals of gluttony and greed and self gratification that begins at Thanksgiving and runs through New Year’s Day.
We will lavish on ourselves huge dinners, and attend many parties, most of which will have tables laden with food. We will go to holiday movies, and maybe take trips to the city to see the lights, or a play, or other entertainment. We will watch football games with friends and spare no calories in the process. Booze will flow and a good time will be had by all. Well, maybe not all. Maybe not the Lazuruses of the world.
And most of us have already started buying the massive piles of Christmas and Chanukah presents which we will give to each other, and our children, and our grandchildren. We will spend and spend some more, convincing ourselves that we can delay worrying about the economic impact on our selves until no earlier than January 2nd. And, mostly, we’ll keep all this within our own families and our closest friends.
Oh, I know that we will make some efforts to share some of this with others. We may ring the bell for the Salvation Army, or, if we are church goers we give our December benevolence to the a specified charity, and our Christmas Eve donations will go to another. Some churches and synagogues will finance and distribute food baskets to some needy families.
And all of this is well and good. No, I will go farther. This is not only well and good: it is our moral obligation to do these things. The question isn’t whether or not these are good and necessary things. They are. The question is whether or not they are all we can do; and, for the faithful, whether or not God will find them generous.
So, let’s honestly ask ourselves: as a percentage of our total self indulgences on food and presents and decorations and parties, and all the rest that goes into the Holiday Season, what percentage of our spending do we think we will actually give to the poor; to those outside of our family and friends; to those whom Jesus calls, “the least of these, my children?”
And, while we ponder that question – which, incidentally, I am not going to answer for you – it is something each must answer for him or her self – let’s spend some time looking at the story of Lazarus.
There was a rich man, dressed in purple and fine linen, who feasted every day. At his gate lay the poorest of the poor, Lazarus by name, covered with sores, who longed to satisfy his hunger even from the crumbs which would drop from the rich man’s table.
Notice the contrast. Jesus sets the entire story as a story of stark contrasts. Black or white; no shades of gray. No subtleties, no way to justify or explain or alibi oneself out of this situation. The Rich man is very rich. The poor man is not only dirt poor, but sick, covered with sores. And then there is the gate. The gate accentuates the contrast. The gate is the great dividing line between them. The boundary between the two men is set in solid wood, not to be breached.
The story is about boundaries: great gaps between us and our neighbors, between people who have it: money, power, prestige, education: who have the power to move in and out of the gates that society erects, and those who have nothing; and certainly have no power to move anywhere at all, who lie helpless, just beyond the gate, dying.
The contrasts are stark, and Jesus piles them on. The rich man feasts “every day,” and not just feasts, but feasts “sumptuously.” Lazarus doesn’t eat. The rich man is covered in fine linens, purple – the most expensive cloth. Lazarus is covered too: with sores! Lazarus would settle for the garbage that the rich man threw out. Nothing in the story suggests he gets even that.
The stark contract is accentuated by that infernal gate. Inside the gate, protected by the wall surrounding the house, secure, well-housed, well-fed, well-clothed, sits the rich man. Outside the gate lies Lazarus, wild dogs licking his sores.
Lazarus is refuse. What to do? At this point in the story a “good Christian” would hope that the next words would be that the rich man saw the plight of Lazarus and took him in, called a doctor to heal his sores, gave him some decent clothes, and fed him until he was on his feet. Maybe then find him some work so he could have a little dignity, a little sense of self-worth. After all, that’s what the Bible says he should do. What does Micah say? “What does the Lord require of you? To do justice, to show kindness, and to walk humbly with God.” What would justice and kindness and humility require in this case? What would God require?
Well, however you see the answer to that question, what God requires never happens. What happens is what you would expect: Lazarus dies. And, although sometimes we don’t expect it to happen to us when it does, the rich man also dies. Dead. Both are now stone dead.
And dead is dead. Right? No. Wrong. Not in this story. Lazarus is carried away by angels and placed in the seat of honor, in the bosom of Father Abraham. The rich man is simply buried. Which is bad enough. But it gets worse. The rich man goes to hell, where he is tormented day and night. The rich man sees Father Abraham and calls out to him to send Lazarus to wet his tongue with some cool water because, as he says, “I am in agony in these flames.”
Now, I don’t know about you, but this image of Hades that Jesus paints is pretty upsetting. I am pretty used to the hyperbole “fire and torment”; I guess because I have heard about it since I was a child. But, have you stopped to think how much worse it would be if you could actually see and talk to those who were on the other side? Now, folks, THAT is hell!
Father Abraham replies to him, and note how sorrowful the reply. The rich man is called “my child.” Abraham says, “My child, remember that during your lifetime you received your good things, and Lazarus in like manner evil things; but now he is comforted here, and you are in agony. Besides all this, between you and us a great chasm has been fixed, so that those who might want to pass from here to you cannot do so, and no one can cross from there to us.”
Contrast again. Stark, harsh contrast. There is no gate separating them now. Instead, the gate has been replaced by something even more fearful: a deep chasm; a chasm so deep and so wide that it is literally impossible to bridge: and it is forever!
As in life, the two, Lazarus and the rich man, are divided. First by a gate; now by a chasm. But. Surprise! Their situations are reversed. Lazarus, who had nothing in life, now, in heaven, has everything. And, here we learn the significance of the name of Lazarus. Oh, that’s right! I forgot to mention what his name means in Hebrew, didn’t I? It means, “The one whom God helps.” No one helped Lazarus during his lifetime. Lazarus was so low, so socially repugnant, that no one helped him; certainly not the rich man. Now, however, he is lifted up. God helps!
From his place in eternal torment, and for the first time in the story, the rich man tries to bridge the gap, to eliminate the boundary between him and Lazarus. But, it is too late. The gate is forever closed; the chasm forever in place. Even Father Abraham himself cannot bridge the gap. There is nothing to be done.
There was a gap between rich in poor in life; now, in the after life, there is still a gap. The only difference is that the tables are turned. The gate which the rich man closed of his own free will in life has become the chasm between him and God in death.
The rich man, who undoubtedly had a big name in life: everybody knew who HE was; doesn’t even have a name in Jesus’ story. Lazarus, whom nobody knew in life, and whose name would not be caught on the lips of the socially acceptable if it were known, is the only person in any of Jesus’ parables who is identified by name. A name signifies many things; but most of all it signifies individual value: value in the eyes of God. Lazarus is “somebody.” Why? Because Lazarus is “one whom God helps.” It’s that simple.
All of which is to say that, the way the Bible tells us to value things and people who are other than us or our own is a far cry from the way our culture tells us to value them. Those whom we honor as insiders often end up as outsiders in God’s economy; and those we treat as outsiders, beneath us and barely worthy of our consideration, often end up as insiders in God’s eyes.
Jesus said it a hundred times, but still we don’t get it: The last will be first and the first will be last. The least will inherit the Kingdom of God. The humble will know God. Those who feed the hungry, give water to the thirsty, welcome the stranger, clothe the naked, heal the sick, help the poor, will inherit the Kingdom. The others? Don’t ask! Read Matthew 25 if you don’t believe me.
There is great injustice in the world now. It is all around us. We have become good at being jaded, at going through our gates into our protected homes without so much as an embarrassing glance at the Lazaruses of this world. This story from the lips of Jesus tells us that the justice of God will not be mocked forever. There will come a time of judgment, if not in this life then in the next. That is good news for the Lazaruses of this world. But whether or not it is good news for those who are clothed in purple, who have more than a small portion of the bounty of God’s blessing, depends not on whether or not they have been abundantly blessed. It depends on what they do with the riches God has given them. And, incidentally, if you wonder who is them; well, them is us.
697 page views as of 2009 11 09

Salon.com
Comments
I think the coming worsening of the global economic scene is going to have a telling effect on people's ability to survive - those who have already figured out survival - those who have learned to live on very little - will be the ones who will make it through.
Those who have come to depend on their luxuries as though they were extensions of themselves, will have a very hard time indeed, and may not be able to survive spiritually or emotionally. I know people who would rather lay down in the street and die than do without their twice-daily coffee treat and their SUV and their designer clothes. What on earth will they do if they income is decreased or cut off?
If Donald Trump's daughter says in an interview that the wealthy people she knows have begun to keep track of their day-to-day expenditures because they're starting to feel the beginnings of deprivation, then what can be next for the suburban soccer mom who has her nails done every other week at a cost of $50, at the same time the homeless are digging out of dumpsters behind the grocery store next door?
Nearly every religion and belief system through0ut history has recognized that our lives are enriched on many levels when we remember to spend time in service to others. Whether this is done by giving money or by volunteering, it has the same effect - it makes us feel that we're all in this together.
Religion fro me is a puzzle. With the upcoming feast we can Thankgiving, I always put out at least one extra chair and invite a homeless person to the table. Works great!
My family doesn't do big gifts. We usually do necessities as personal gifts from one of us to the other. Any other goes to charity. I do very litttle decorating. I do a Christmas with a small 'c'. I have never known what to make of the orgy of spending that accompanies this season just never got it.
I enjoyed reading this immensely. I don't know that the majority of OS reader and writers have no faith. I would hope they hav e a lot of faith, if not in God, in something outside our own knowledge. God, Allah, Buddha, or some over-seeing deity. And, if not, then I hope they have faith in mankind and themselves.
I don't know if you're familiar with the music of Sting, but I thought the lyrics to this song appropriate for you to read. I love this song musically and lyrically.
"The Lazarus Heart"
by Gordon Sumner/Sting
He looked beneath his shirt today
There was a wound in his flesh so deep and wide
From the wound a lovely flower grew
From somewhere deep inside
He turned around to face his mother
To show her the wound in his breast that burned like a brand
But the sword that cut him open
Was the sword in his mothers hand
Every day another miracle
Only death will tear us apart
To sacrifice a life for yours
Id be the blood of the lazarus heart
The blood of the lazarus heart
Though the sword was his protection
The wound itself would give him power
The power to remake himself at the time of his darkest hour
She said the wound would give him courage and pain
The kind of pain that you cant hide
From the wound a lovely flower grew
From somewhere deep inside
Every day another miracle
Only death will keep us apart
To sacrifice a life for yours
Id be the blood of the lazarus heart
The blood of the lazarus heart
Birds on the roof of my mothers house
Ive no stones that chase them away
Birds on the roof of my mothers house
Will sit on my roof some day
They fly at the window, they fly at the door
Where does she get the strength to fight them anymore
She counts all her children as a shield against the pain
Lifts her eyes to the sky like a flower in the rain
Every day another miracle
Only death will keep us apart
To sacrifice a life for yours
Id be the blood of the lazarus heart
The blood of the lazarus heart
Video of the song performed Live. Branford Marsalis is a Bad Ass saxophonist and one of my favorites.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f24Y66ZBOwE
On another list someone posted a diatribe about Christians. They had lumped in all those of faith with the Right Wing Evangelical Christians. Many of those Evangelicals could learn a thing or two by reading and taking in this lesson of Lazarus as well as many more of the Bibles parables.
My response was to remind the writer that the Evangelical Christians are not representative of the entire Christian faith in the US. Unfortunately they have had an outsized impact on our political system and have brought a backlash that has been directed at others of Faith.
I also reminded the writer that although I no longer call myself a Christian my moral compass is that of the Christian teachings. I was raised in the Church and left it as I could no longer find agreement with that which I was reading in the Bible and that which was preached within the church. At that time an opposition to the Civil Rights movement was the finial break and sent me on a soul searching quest that lasted for many years.
Yes this was a church who taught the “literal” translation of the Bible as the undeniable truth of God. That the Bible is full of metaphors is lost on those who try to interpret as the will of God. I now look at it as a partial lesson in the history of the Jews for the Old Testimony and lesions on morality in the New Testament with the parables Jesus spoke of.
Monte brings up something good here that is missed on those who take the Bible as the literal translation of God. God allows you free will. Ultimately you are responsible for how you conduct your life. In this life he has no interest in interceding. If you are a believer you are responsible for your actions and you just rewards will not be here on Earth.
As one who is not sure if there is a heaven or hell and after life, I believe as well that you are for the most part rewarded here on Earth by your deeds. Not in monetary ways but that of the spirit. I and many others I have known have felt rewarded numerous times in our lives for what we have given. If indeed there is an afterlife I hope that what I have done in this life on Earth will have an additional reward to what I have done in this life.
If God is the Ocean of Love, then within each of us is the soul which is nothing less than an inlet in that sea. The body is the gate which seals us off from that Ocean. If we only look at the earthen banks, we do not recognize the Ocean within our selves.
The rich man's flaw lay in his dogged identification with his body, and he kept his gate strong and high believing it would protect him from the inevitable. He refused to see the Other as himself.
Lazarus had nothing to protect. He was a supplicant. Surrender was his path. When his time came, he surrendered his gate gladly, small and broken as it was, rent with holes that let the familiar Ocean pour in.
As both bodies fell away, Lazarus, joined the Ocean of Love happily. But what of the rich man? As his gate crumbled he cast his eye on the earthen banks, the remnants of his life, which, sadly, he could connect with no longer. And what was the chasm which surrounded him, newly bereft of his gate? It was nothing but the lingering sense of separate self. To his eyes the Ocean was fierce and mighty and unknown, as he had not, during his brief span of life, taken time to taste the Ocean within himself. So he clings to the fading images of his life on earth, and the need to protect, extend and maintain his own separate existence.
Lazarus could not give him a drop of water, for to do that the rich man would have to face and welcome the Ocean, by releasing the memory of that by which he defines himself.
And the moral?
When we practice giving from the heart, we disentangle from those patterns which dictate that we are not one with the Other. With each gift of love we are less distanced from the whole. Selfless service allows us to recognize that Ocean within ourselves, so that when the gate falls away, as it will for each of us, we gladly expand outwards, without fear, as we dissolve, once again, into the loving sea from which we come.
Monte
Without diminishing the parable itself, my late mother and I agreed that heaven would not be heaven if those who have passed could look back on us humans in our weakness, pain, stupidity, and ignorance.
How could heaven be heaven if we were to experience the pain of our loved ones? As my mother approached death at a severely premature age, the most profound moment we shared was when we agreed that when she reached heaven, she would be released from sharing OUR pain.
I'll concede that, theoretically, there is a transcendant understanding that would allow the departed to "understand" why we suffer on this earth. I can, barely, imagine a heaven where our ancestors chuckle at our ignorance, where they know that what we experience as pain, trauma, and uncertainty is perfectly normal for mortals and that all will come clear in the afterlife.
Still, I believe that your sermon is based on a parable designed to illustrate, not to educate.
No matter. My mom is either a) oblivious to the mistakes I make and thus insulated from the consequences and empathic pain, or b) so overwhelmed with more transcendent matters that what we experience here on Earth is merely trivial existence, or c) chuckling at our weak understanding of God and his will and our destinies.
Do not hesitate to express yourself, sir.
Mystery is not something that we "modern" humans handle very well. Our job, as we see it, is to demystify mystery. With faith, that won't work. Faith is the belief in things unseen, as the apostle tells us. One of the great mysteries of faith is, of course, the afterlife and what it will be like. Since that is not fleshed out well in the Bible, and when it is described it is in parable, vision, and metaphor. Therefore, we are free to imagine for ourselves how it will be. C.S. Lewis was a modern and popular Christian apologist who celebrated religious mystery as a positive thing. I share his view.
Sue is in Venice and has access to a rental computer at the hotel she is now at. I won't know what the computer situation is in Florence and Rome. If not she will call me on her cell. She says that it has been rainy but has not deterred their sight seeing. Today is an "off day" for the tour so several of them are going to sign on to a charter boat to visit several of the outlying areas around the main island.
Take care.
Monte