:

  

Monte Canfield

Monte Canfield
Location
Newcomerstown, Ohio, USA
Birthday
December 28
Title
Rev. Dr. Monte Canfield
Bio
Retired Protestant Pastor and Theologian, jointly credentialed in the United Church of Christ and the Moravian Church. Education: BA, MA, M.Div, Thd. Public Service: NY State Office of Executive Development; Federal Exec. Branch: Executive Office of the President, BOB; Interior, BLM; Non Profit: Ford Foundation, Energy Policy Project; Congressional: General Accounting Office; Private industry: Grow Group, Inc.; US Paint; Owner, the Energy Center, St. Louis. Christian service: Pastor, First Congregational UCC, Ottawa, Illinois; Pastor, St. Paul's UCC, Port Washington, Ohio; Pastor, Moravian Church, Gnadenhutten, Ohio.

DECEMBER 22, 2008 9:30PM

My Christmas Gift to My OS Friends- -Blessings & Peace

Rate: 20 Flag
 
birth-of-the-king
 


This is a love story within a love story, and a humble gift to ALL of my new and wonderful friends here on Open Salon.  It is, as you would expect, a Christian story written by a retired Christian pastor. Please understand that. I am who I am and my faith is what it is.

But I mean no disrespect to any who believe differently, or who do not believe at all.  I have no interest in or intent to proselytize my faith. Had I any this would not be the place to do it. Christians may see this story as their story, others, of course, may not.

But I do pray that the many friends I have made here who are not Christians, who might have at one time been Christian but no longer are, who may be of another faith altogether, who have belief systems that does not involve organized religion, or who have no belief system at all, will find some words of love and hope in this message that are universally applicable expressions of the best of what the human condition can be.

Those who hold themselves to be superior to others and who hold their religion high over the heads of others, who look down on those who do not share their faith, have much to account for. Those of you who know me know that I am not that kind of man.

And so, my friends, this is my Christmas gift, humbly offered, to each of you.

Since Advent started and the preparation for Christmas began in earnest I have been thinking of the most important day on the Christian calendar. And, at the same time, I am sometimes painfully aware that you cannot turn on the television without seeing another repackaged “Holiday Special.” And every TV ad beckons us to buy, buy, buy, recession or not. We are told that this will not be a true Christmas without this new car, or perfume, or that toy, or these trinkets.

As my thoughts have drifted back to that most holy day on the church calendar they have turned to another Advent and Christmas season much like this one that occurred 16 years ago.

Sue and I were driving from St. Louis to Sedan, Kansas in the far southeast corner of that State. We left the interstate at Joplin, drove through Joplin on US 66 and then caught US 166 which crossed into Kansas and worked its way west to Sedan, about 90 miles.

This part of the trip was on two lane highway that took us through many small towns as dusk was falling. And each small town was decorated with lights.  Lights and evergreen garland intertwined were wrapped around street lamps, and strung neatly on wires high across main street. Giant candy canes, Santas and candles topped each street lamp.  It was all very pretty.

But amidst the glitter and the anticipation of both the Christ Child and Santa and his reindeer, there was a sadness deep in my soul that bore down on me. My “step” grandfather, Sam Shade, a man who did not know the meaning of the word “step,” the man who claimed both my father and me as his own, who loaned me money several times when I had no other way to continue college, was dead.

In some ways that seemed totally impossible for a man who was a legend in Kansas journalism, who owned, published and edited small Kansas county seat weekly newspapers for over 60 years. A man I loved with all my heart and knew that the feeling was mutual. Where was I to turn to even begin to deal with this loss?  I, a pastor, knew what to say and do to help dozens of others go through the same grief process.  But I was hopelessly out of my element when it came to consoling myself.

But in spite of the stark contrast of the happiness I could see out of my window as I drove through the decorated villages and the pain of losing Sam, something kept drawing me back to that holiest day of the Christian calendar. My thoughts kept turning back to the memory of another death, to another time and place, and to the great gift of hope that followed that death, because, for once, death did not win. My thoughts turned not to Christmas but to Easter, the greatest of holy days for those of my faith.

In the midst of all of my personal grief and pain and at a time when the world called me to be joy filled, my faith reminded me that we Christians are not so much a Christmas people; but rather we are an Easter people living in the shadow of the Cross, for each of us must on day go through the “valley of the shadow of death.”

That could be a somber thought if we do not remember that those words of the Psalmist are intended to be precisely correct: we go “through” the valley of the shadow of death, and death cannot contain us.  We are promised by the One who did it that there will be resurrection and renewed life on the other side of that dark vale.  And it is there, only there, in that saving promise, where our hope lies.

One can fairly ask what any of this has to do with Christmas.  And my answer is everything.  Christmas cannot, even when carefully understood in the clearest statements of orthodox theology, stand on its own. And yet most Christians focus mainly on the birth of the Messiah, in both its aspects of faith and of secular commercialism. And we often so confuse and conflate the two that Christ himself could not unravel the tangled mess that Christmas has become.

Most good Christians believe that spending an hour or two in church on Christmas Eve celebrating the birth of the Messiah in word and song and prayer pretty much does it; gets us through our Christmas obligations, and lets us get back to what is really important like food, fads and football.

We do this shamelessly.  The church has been saying for two thousand years that Easter is the great feast day of the Christian year. But it has far less appeal to us than the promise of Christmas, with its confused conflation of religious and secular idols, its blending of Christian truth and pagan myth, secular fairy tales and commercial magic.

We are drawn like moths to the bright allure of the Christmas message of peace and good will, of close-knit, idyllic families gathered together, and of a mystical, magical baby lying in a manger.  These are the things that tug at our heartstrings, even as the hucksters of consumptions tug at our pocketbooks.

The current Christmas message in many, many churches in American today, especially in the prosperity preaching mega churches, is “Salvation by Good Will.” This message says that a magic, mystical baby will cure our ills, ease our pain, pull our families together, restore our self esteem, overcome our loneliness, and relieve our bitterness, our resentments and our anger.

This message says that just to wait for, to hear a song about, to hope for, the coming of this miracle child will restore our faith in ourselves and in humankind, and, somehow, make us whole. And, depressingly often, we believe it.

I am not a scrooge.  I do not intend to become the OS Grinch that stole Christmas.  We need the  hope and joy and the heartwarming truth of the real Christmas message. We rightfully hunger for stories that talk about peace and goodwill, about the innocence of a baby in a manger.  We need our spirits lifted in a world sadly lacking in words of kindness, compassion and care.  And, yes, we desperately need the Christian Christmas message to help offset the materialism that our consumption crazed society is determined to make the core message of this holy season.

But even as important as the Christian Christmas message is, it should never be confused with the entire Gospel of Jesus Christ.  In fact, it is not even the second most important message of the Christian faith.  If one were to take the time to read the Advent scriptures in the Christian liturgical calendar you would quickly see that none of Advent is focused on building up to the coming of a magical baby in a manger.

Rather, the Advent message that precedes Christmas is an instruction for believers to be alert, stay awake, watch for, and prepare for the coming of the fully prepared Lord of All.  The message is that the Master is coming and we know not when. The focus of all of the Advent passages, every year, is on preparation for the One who comes to save the world, not by his birth, but through his actions, his witness, his death, his resurrection and his enthronement as Lord of Lord and King of Kings.

Christians should not await the coming of the Christ child in the wide-eyed innocence of those who know nothing of what will happen to that child. No. We await the coming of a child with whom we are totally familiar, a child we already know.  There have been over 2000 years since the coming of that child; 2000 years to learn and study who he was, how he lived, what he would become, and how he would die.

That is the true Christmas story.  Christians should own this story, make it a part of us.  Own the story of the baby Jesus in the manger, yes; but also own the story of a Messiah, a suffering servant foretold by the prophet Isaiah.  It  is the story of  One who overcomes a stumbling, bleeding walk up a narrow path to the top of a dirty, wind blown hill outside of  Jerusalem, struggling under the burden of a Cross on which he will die. And it is this same man, Emmanuel, God with us, who three days later will be raised by God the Father to live in glory; the same man who has offered to us a share in his everlasting salvation, in glory for all eternity.

And so, as we approach Christmas Eve and Day we are watching not only for the coming of a baby in a manger but for the coming of our Resurrected Lord and Savior.  And “watching” in the Biblical context does not mean sitting around doing nothing else.  The scripture is clear that watching includes preparation and working to be ready for his coming.

If we set our eyes too low we will never be able to truly watch for the coming of Christ.  We must lift our eyes upward from the manger to the Cross, and then even above that, to the resurrected Christ and to his enthronement as Christ the King.  Because it is there, and only there, where true Christian hope lies.

And when our eyes are properly focused on Jesus and his teachings we will know how to prepare for his coming, for he has already told us that we are to feed the hungry, give drink to the thirsty, welcome the stranger, clothe the naked, care for the sick, and visit the imprisoned. When we do that we are saying with Christ’s mother, Mary, ‘Here I am, the servant of the Lord, let it be with me according to your word.”

This salvation that Christ offers in not only for ourselves, not even primarily for ourselves, but rather it is so that we can be a blessing to others, to those who have little or nothing of this life’s blessings.  Can we hear that message through the din of our holiday buying and feeding frenzy?  That is the true question of Christmas.

Can we look down on the small babe in the manger and see who he will become, what he will have to do and how he will suffer?  Can we look into his eyes and see the hope he has for us, the strength he offers us, while we go about the hard task of preparing for his return?

I think we can. I think we can because all of us, Christian or not, believer or not, are not innocents.  We are a people who share a common human story.  I figured that out 16 years ago.

As Sue and I stood that December on a bitterly cold, windy and snow blown day, gathered with a handful of others under a flapping canopy tent, I felt loss and pain and fear.  But then an old Baptist preacher reminded us of the old, old story and of the promise it held for each of us. It was a story of promise for each who chooses to believe, a story of hope and of love beyond comprehension.

And as Sue and I drove back toward Joplin to the interstate on those two lane roads through the Chautauqua  Hills that Sam so loved, we drove through the same small towns we had come through the day before.  It was getting along toward dusk.  The Christmas lights were coming on; reindeer were prancing in front yards, and, with the help of one faithful reindeer who struggled under his weight, Santa was trying desperately to climb back onto a rooftop that he had fallen off.

And in the lea of the wind, protected by some shaggy old cedar trees in the front of an old Methodist church, the lights came on as we approached, and we slowed to look at a well worn and slightly bedraggled manger scene.  

And, finally the tears came, followed by a small sense of release in my heart. For at last I knew what it all meant to me, not what it should mean to others, but what it meant to my life, to my loss, to my fears.

I finally knew that all my preparation, all my helping of others, all the calls at 4 a.m. to come to someone’s side, all the things I had been studying and preaching all those years applied to me as well. I knew finally that it wasn’t selfish to want and need God to come to me as well as to those I prayed he would come to. 

I finally figured out that he did all this for everybody, and that everybody included me.  That same promise is offered today to all and will be offered until the last days.

At that time I could not have put it into words, which seemed pitifully small to contain such a cosmic reality. But I now knew the meaning of the real Christmas message, and the hope it contained. I knew that Christmas was nailed to a Cross, lay in a tomb and rose in glory that we might be found innocent in the eyes of God, though we yet be sinners.

And I knew that the loss and the pain that I felt on that windy Kansas hilltop could never take that knowledge away from me. I knew that in the hands of God Sam would be OK, that I would be OK, no matter what I had to face in the future.

I remembered through my tears what that babe in the manger was really all about. I remembered that his story was my story, the story of Christians everywhere. And I knew like nothing I had ever known before that there was hope and eternal life available for only the asking because of the coming of that child. I knew that if God could capture my heart and hold it gently in his hand that he could and would do the same for any who but asked.

And so my Christmas gift to all here in the family that is OS is that faith, hope and love can conquer any mountain we must ever climb, can bridge the widest valley between us and our fellow men and women, and that we can come to know and love one another without consideration of any boundary that any human may erect, because the God of the universe has made those boundaries irrelevant.  We only have to ignore them.

May blessings and peace be with each of you and with your families from this day forward and for evermore.

Monte


 772 page views as of 11 09 2009

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Thank you Monte for your beautiful and loving gift. You write so beautifully and most of all from your heart, from your convictions, from your vulnerabilities. This is indeed appealing. While I am no longer a practicing Christian, when I was, I always felt that Easter was the most important and sacred day to celebrate so I resonated with many of your words. Now that my "faith" isn't quite so clearly defined, I still grab hold of the words "faith, hope and love". I love the concept of rebirth, new beginnings, redemption and slates wiped clean. For me, on this cold gray day, Christmas is a reminder to me of that new life, that is available to all of us on a daily basis, no matter the specific beliefs. Thank you Monte and Merry Merry Christmas to you.
Merry Christmas to you and Sue.

Your words of faith are so powerful. Your reminder that Easter is the fulfillment of the promise made by Christmas is so important. The most meaningful line in your sermon above was this:

"I finally figured out that he did all this for everybody, and that everybody included me."

I wish you a safe and happy trip.
Thanks you Mary and COS: This post was a bit long and I wasn't sure how many people would be patient enough to read it.

The recognition of the importance of including people of all faiths or of no faith at all was important to me to add at the beginning and reinforce at the end. That added a lot of words, but it is so important to me to do nothing to fracture further one of the touchy divisions that crop up here in OS more often than I would like. I see no reasons why some of these super sensitive issues have to divide us if we make the effort to me empathetic with one and others beliefs, be they religious, political or social. I think that if people as diverse in faith as UK and I can get along and care for and support each other then others can surely do that too.

Have a wonderful Christmas/Holiday season.

Monte
Merry Christmas, Monte.
Thanks, Jim, and the same to you and yours.


Monte
Merry Christmas, Monte, thanks for ministering to all of us!
Thank you, Joan. I hope you can get off the merry-go-round long enough to take a deep breath, spend some relaxing time with family and friends, and not have to go on MSNBC for a whole day or two! (although the publicity for Salon is wonderful!! ;-)

Have a very Merry, Joan.

Peace,

Monte
Thanks, Monte. I probably won't make it to Christmas Eve services this year -- my husband's family will be with us, and they're dedicated non-churchgoers -- so this is the next best thing. (Actually, your preaching is better than what we get locally, but I'll miss the music and the candles.)

Almost 15 years ago, at the ripe old age of 40, I decided to take up a career in nursing. Fortunately, I got out before I killed anybody (catheters were my waterloo, but I'm a klutz with any sort of equipment). Anyway, the one thing I really loved about hospital work was the chance to visit with patients. Hospitals are a great leveler. Inside those walls, it doesn't matter what your occupation is, what your house looks like, what sort of clothes you normally wear, where you went to school; in a hospital bed, removed from the trappings of regular life, people are reduced to the essence of who they are, without all the extraneous trimmings. I was continually amazed by depth of the conversations I'd get into with patients and the intimacies they would reveal to me, a stranger. I was also struck by how ubiquitous humor is in the hospital, under the most undignified of circumstances, and how it made the indignities more bearable and, in a strange way, kind of fun.

This place where we've all pitched our blogs strikes me as similar in certain ways to that hospital experience of mine. (Some might even argue that a lot of us are pretty sick!) And just as a chaplain is necessary to a hospital, so you, dear new friend, are a vital member of our little virtual community here. So -- ta-da! -- I hereby christen you the unofficial chaplain of Open Salon!

Merry Christmas and safe travels --
Merry Christmas Monte, thank you for sharing your faith, thank you for your kindness and protection, be happy and safe,

Nada
Monte,
Thank you for your Christmas Gift! Although not what one might call a practicing Christian, I'm still a believer and allow the teaching and philosophy of the Bible to help guide my life. (Having trouble typing with my morning cat continually jumping in my lap and helping with keyboard duties.)
You speak of a personal revelation of realizing your place in the broader scheme of things. I've had similar revelations twice in my life and truly consider them a great gift. A moment in time when everything becomes quite clear. It is what gets me though thick and thin without becoming too cynical.
I love your writing style and can see me sitting in a pew listening to you on a Sunday morning. (A rare prospect for me these days) Your perspective on all things is soothing to me. You write it and I'll read it. That is my promise to you. I also share your views that Easter is the prominent Chritian Holiday to remember.

The Best of all things to You and Sue on this Holiday Season,
Your Friend, Mike
I love that you openly share your faith. I know the Lord is pleased! My prayers, too, are that we all come to see that we CAN conquer hate, prejudice, greed and injustice through the love and salvation of Christ. Merry Christmas Monte. :)
In this season of long, dark nights, when the birth of Jesus seems to bring the light back again, thank you. I am alienated from family and from church both because of patriarchal attitudes that limit God to male genitalia and male genitalia to god. This Christmas I am on my way to more and more simplicity in living and find it very liberating. Holding giveaways like many Native Americans, all the THINGS
(Hit the wrong key there...) that I have been taught to long for and cherish, mean nothing when they sit unused gathering dust and moth holes and perhaps thieves (The things of this world, Monte, to quote.) And requiring that they they be insured!?! For money!?! In lightening my material load, I find freedom to sit and meditate upon the true meaning of Jesus, the Sermon on the Mount.... and also "Feed my people!" I'm trying to, Jesus. I'm trying to.

Blessings to you, Monte, and all ministers like you who teach love and not hate. May your tribe increase.
You and Sue have a safe trip and a wonderful Christmas celebration, Monte. One of the thoughts I go back to at various times is the admonition to "Love one another." It's simple and to the point, and it says it all. All the best to you and yours!
I thank you too for your message of hope and tolerance and love of humanity for what we hold in common...our flaws and our belovedness.

Bless you for you faith. It is not my faith but bless yours. I'm a UU and would say something similar to the Dalai Lama but I'm not conversant enough to know if in his case it's more appropriate to say faith or understanding. I say 'bless you' to all people of faith and of doubting everywhere. Bless us all.
I could never understand why Easter is overshadowed by Christmas to such a large degree when really, Easter is the "big deal" in Christianity. Thank you for reminding us of that connection as we prepare to celebrate Christmas.

I've only known you a short while, Monte, but it seems you inspire me, as well as others, at every turn. Everyone should be lucky enough to have a human being like you in their life and I'm most grateful to have you in mine.

I hope you have a blessed Christmas.
Thank you so much for this Monte. I got REALLY sick last night and had my first allergic reaction to a flu shot. I didn't get to read it til this morning. Still sore and achey, will comment further later.

Happy HOlidays
Greg
Monte - thank you for this and for your Advent post. I found tears coming as I read of your trip 16 years ago, and loved that you connected the Christmas and Easter stories so beautifully. I needed to read this today, and think I need to spend some time re-reading it in days to come. Christmas blessings to you and your family!
I really can't do anything but second everything that's been said. Pax vobiscum, you and yours.
Hi, again, everyone. I'm not ignoring your kind comments and will get to each of them now. I went to bed about 2:30 am (night owl that I am) and woke about 9:30, decided to sleep until 10 and that turned out to be 12:20 pm instead! I guess that is the joy or bane of being retired, however you look at it! In this case it was because I took a new med for pain right before I went to bed and I guess it has a sleeping pill effect I wasn't aware of. So from now on I will take it 2 hrs before bedtime and snatch back the 2 to 3 hrs of waking time it took from me. The Cleveland Clinic is good for many things but I am starting to think that pill pushing is one of them. I am grateful for the reduced pain but will not agree to pay for that by being a zombie. A little pain at least means you are alive.

Enough of that. You all are so kind and warm hearted that it really humbles me. And I thank you all for that. It means much to me.

Monte
Laurel:

Thank you for reading and for your insightful comments. Chances are that I will not make the Christmas Eve service this year either. It is the most attended service of the year. It beings out once-a-year Christians and packs the church to about 400 people, stuffed everywhere, filling the balcony, the narthex, and sometimes over flowing to where we have to put some of the folks in the undercroft Fellowship Hall where they watch on a TV monitor and speakers. I'd stay home if I had to "experience it" like that.

People come an hour or more early to get a seat. My feet can't be down for three hours or more like that without flaring so I will likely miss it. The pain of a full flare is just too much even with my meds. So Sue will go to raise the family flag so my dear friends there will know that I would have come if I could have.

I think God won't mind so much my missing it. As lovely as a Moravian Christmas eve service is, to me that service always has seemed more an entertainment than a worship event. We have a brass choir, handbell choir, soloists, string quartet some years, chancel choir plus sermon and love feast, followed by a candle light finale.

It is breathtakingly beautiful, but I imagine 90% feel like they are the audience and the folks in the chancel are the players in the play. Proper worship is never for us, but is for God. God is the audience, the congregation are the players, and the folks in the chancel are the directors of the play. On Christmas Eve that concept is lost.

Your insight into the social leveling effect of the hospital setting is so very true. Nurses often play the role of chaplain and are privileged to hear some of the patients inner most fears and concerns. It is a role that they do not teach much in school.

A pastor is also privileged to hear these things, to hold them in total privacy and trust and to listen with an open heart. Sometimes that is a great burden to carry but is also the most humbling thing about the pastoral office. People will pour out the secrets of their hearts to you and that is a precious gift of trust that cannot be abused.

God bless you and yours this holy season, Laurel.

Monte

PS : I will pass on the Chaplain tag, but it is kind of you to think of me that way. I do try to help where I can. But the truth is that there are many, many ministers here who don't have any titles and who go about helping one another is small and large ways.

That is one of the undiscussed blessings of OS that goes on here. I am sure there will be no pastors, preachers, chaplains or evangelists needed in the afterlife where we will all be like the folks in the hospital, stripped of all titles and equal in the eyes of God.
Nada, my dear new friend, thank you for reading and commenting. I am not sure how you celebrate the holidays over there, but it is likely not too different than here. May these days be blessed for you and yours as well.

Monte
Mike: thank you for the kind note and the blessing. I wish the same for you this holy season. I do know something about the writer's block known as "the cat who types." Perhaps that problem is ubiquitous. Two of our cats, the female calico twins, are intimidated by the laptop. But, Jake, the grey tabby, the youngest and most daring half brother of the calicos knows no bounds and will jump in my lap on a whim, lay down on the keyboard and dare me not to pay attention to him "Look and me, dammit! I'm the most important thing around here!"

It is interesting that we do get those epiphany moments in our lives when we suddenly see things entirely different and more clearly than ever before. If we are lucky we will remember then and change our lives to fit their message. I am glad you have had such moments in your lives. I know many who have had them and have chosen to dismiss them, especially when to act on them would change the comfort of their status quo. For all our talk about being risk takers, most of us are comfortable not acting on insights.

I wish you the very best this Christmas, and want you to know how how glad I am to have you here with us on OS. Your contributions have been immediate, open hearted and genuine. People can feel that in your writing.

Monte
Thank you for reading and commenting. I share your hope that we will turn to peace and be able to move beyond hate and injustice to help build a better world. Humans do not have a good record doing that, but we can try. A sad world this would be were there no hope, no vision of improvement, and none who would try to rise above our lowest instincts to seek something higher and greater than what we see all around us today.

Have a holy and blessed Christmas, SM.

Monte
Penrose, I am so glad that you read this reflection and got something out of it. It is hard to get most people to the place where you now are, to recognizing that being rich has nothing to do with earthly possessions but has everything to do with things which are eternal. Few learn that it is both more rewarding and more true to God if we are rich in love and compassion and assistance to others who have so much less than we have.

No, God is not male, has no testosterone and does not prefer one sex over the other. The Church has for too long allowed that lie to stand because it helped the Church to maintain its power and keep everybody "in their places." Hogwash has too often been substituted for truth.

Monte
UK, thanks for reading and a very Merry to you and yours as well. I am so glad you are posting again and I continue to pray for your family, and, of course, for you.

FT, thank you for dropping by and commenting. The UU have had a large and profoundly positive effect on the development of organized religion in this country. Your willingness to be open, welcoming and tolerant of those of other faiths, or no faiths, is a voice of reason that the UU have been interjecting into stupid and heated arguments over religious beliefs since the founding of this country.

"Bless us all" may well be the best prayer we can offer in this holiday season.

Monte
Lisa, I know how busy you must be getting ready of Christmas, so it is especially nice that you took the time to read this reflection and comment on it. I am humbled by your kindness and hope our relationship will continue to grow. My very best to you and yours in this holy season.

Greg, my friend, I have been sick at Christmas and that is a total bummer. I hope your reaction to the shot will be short and you can get back to your normal self. All my best this Christmas. Give your dear family some hugs from me.

DBD: so good of you to come by and read and comment! I am very glad that you found something in this reflection that spoke to you. May you and yours have a blessed Christmas.

Boanerges: It is more than enough that you came here and read the reflection. I really appreciate that. Have a Merry and Wonderful holiday. Blessings to you and yours.

Monte
thank you Monte for this wonderful piece. I read it and it moved me.
Thank you, Edgar. I am very glad that you were able to get something useful out of this reflection. Have and holy and wonder filled holy season.

Monte
Monte,

Thanks so much for a wonderful gift for all.
I'm so glad you found this forum........
Merry Christmas!.........
Bump, appreciated and as Joan said, thanks from us all. We are liberals, and we are all different, but many of us find this very relevant and much needed. Speaking as one of "those" who do, I thank you...

God Bless and Peace and Love to you and your family in the Holiday Season and into the New Year
Thank you for reminding us that Christmas is so much more than a manger, and shepherds, and wise men. Thank you for reminding us that the true celebration of Christmas is a celebration of life, death, and resurrection. Thank you for reminding us the true celebration of Christmas is in how we conduct our daily lives.
Merry Christmas, Monte

Peace.
Merry Christmas, Monte. Your open-hearted, open-minded spirituality reminds me of that of my late husband, Chaim Stern. A gift, really. You help make this site a better, kinder one.
Gary, I love it when the thank yous are mutual. You are such a feeling and kind hero of mine. I really love the way you mold your many talents into the ability to communicate them to us in as confined a medium as blogging is. It seems not confined because we have control of what we post, when, etc. But it is confining in that both you and I know that if we go on too long, and this reflection almost did ;-), we won't be read. Blogging is more than a sound bite, but not all that much.

God bless, Gary, and a very very Merry Merry.

And I am glad I am getting to know YOU.

Monte
Thank you, Greg for returning for further comment. I am hoping that means that you are more over that 24 hour thing you had than not. It is miserable when you are sick at Christmas! Been there, done that, and never want to repeat it.

Hugs to your family, and a "man hug" (whatever the hell that is) to you, my good and caring friend.

Merry Christmas.

Monte
Procopius, it is good to see you back here on my blog. Your comments are always so concise and so clear. I am glad that you were able to glean from my wordy reflection the essence of the piece.

Have a wonder filled and holy holiday season.

Monte
Merry Christmas to you also, m.a.h. It is always good to see you here on this blog.

Lea: Thank you so much. I find that it is not hard to be kind and open and willing to hear all sides of an issue and to honor the one who holds positions differing from mine. After all, I am not privy to knowing either how or why they got to where they are. Your late husband, who you must think about a great deal at this time of year, knew something many, maybe most, men usually fail to see: that bluster, and loudness and feigned or real anger simply turn people off, which is a horrible thing to happen if you actually had something that you believed was worth while to say.

May these days bring with them good memories of happy days past and a sense of present peace within you.

Monte
"But the truth is that there are many, many ministers here who don't have any titles and who go about helping one another is small and large ways. "

I say amen! Monte, Happy Christmas to you and Sue. Breathe some salt air for me.
Thank you, VG

I hope the drive to Indiana and back home will be without ice and related problems. Be safe and enjoy your family.

We will take it pretty easy going down, taking a day and a half. Sue will probably do all the driving with me draped across the entire back seat and my feet elevated on a cooler. We got a good hotel efficiency with a oceanfront balcony so I can watch the waves and smell and hear the ocean. And I imagine I will be able to walk a bit on the beach. Surely it will be better than being mostly stuck in the house all the time.

Christmas blessings,

Monte
Dearest Monte,
The tragedy of life is the apparent butterfly-like transient nature of our existence; all paths lead to the denouement of individual life stories – sometimes a punctuation mark as profound as the life of the person. However, each life story is a book of stories and each of these a parable with a profound proverb. Jesus Christ’s suffering for our sins is a story of sacrifice, the sacrifice that any parent would make to protect their children - - the same sacrifice is seen in other faiths and for the same righteous reasons. Your grandfather, by blood or not, took the role of parent to heart and his passing from your sight must’ve been painful, but you should rejoice in his life, no matter what missteps in his life were made he surely redeemed himself in the eyes of his beloved ones. I understand the loss you felt when your grandad died, but, you can be certain his reward was great.

The birth of Jesus Christ is rarely celebrated as a celebration of hope, but it is in the hope of his resurrection that many will sacrifice or pledge their own life. Much has been pondered on the nature of God, in some religions he is a he in others a she, in some they are a pantheon of gods with a host of various qualities. Some qualify their god’s nature as one of vengeance or forgiveness; some are destroyers and some creators, others represent every quality or imperfection that a person may embody. The truth is that all that is is God, and, anything in creation is the embodiment of a facet of the creation that is the creator. If we can forgive God for all the travails on our travels how can God not forgive us? If Jesus were born today he would be no more innocent than any child born anywhere at any time – consider this when a baby dies as collateral damage in a war between adults over the truth of one religious belief over another. The sins of the fathers are certainly passed from generation to generation, and innocent children (descendants) suffer for their birthright – go back far enough and the original sin was engineered to seduce, through temptation, the first children of God. The good news is that God prefers happy endings and can’t be angry with his children for the traps he set for them. (Steel must be tempered in fire, and gods, when they reproduce, have a very long gestation period and a very painful birth.)

Jesus was absolutely not God’s only begotten son, but he did represent all of God’s finer qualities. Others have reflected many of the best aspects of God when they’ve had the opportunity, potential Messiahs are everywhere, including you, Monte. Soon there’ll be an awakening that will herald a new dawn… The signs of portent are everywhere, revelations are coming thick and fast… and prophetically. I hold great hope, Monte that you will find soon that the valley of the shadow of death is nothing to fear at all, for death is an illusion created, like the bogey man, to frighten young gods and small children, both of which are the self-same creature.

By the way, Monte, your tolerance of other beliefs is more than commendable, it is godlike.

Have an interesting Christmas, and God Bless Us All!

your antipodean mirror and avid fan, billy

p.s I did that travelogue I spoke of, coincidentally much of what I might have written spiritually here in comment managed to find its way into the descriptive that went with the photos. It was a very spiritual trip into the Blue Mountains. I hope it's not too long, though I could've expanded it a great deal more with hundreds of photos and hundreds of thousands of words... I'm not sure what counts as garulous anymore... more is the pity.
Hi, Bill: Happy New Year if we don't communicate between now and then.

I can't imagine two people with such differing theologies getting along as well as you and I. But we do and I am grateful that we can. I believe that it is a little late to win me over to a wider theological expression than the liberal Christianity I wear as well as I wear skin. It took me 70 years to get as comfortable with my faith as I now find myself and I have earned the right to enjoy it. I struggle enough just to get these old bones to do the humble thing of getting me from one day to the next content to be a guy who is trying to help a few others.

But no one person is essential to the growth of any theological or intellectual idea. If the idea is good "they will come." I do not envision myself as a messiah, let alone some sort of god, and I always see a clear and essential distinction between Creator (God) and created (me). I think Otto's distinction of "The Other" is valid and essential to my understanding of theology.

But you also make an interesting case; and I have heard several others here on OS make similar statements relating to the idea that "all that is, is God." I do think that if you start publishing some of your ideas you may find a ready and receptive audience from some members here.

Meanwhile, as you know, I always will defend your God given right to express your theological views and, as you know, I will listen to them with respect. One thing I can count on, friend, is that you will force these old gray cells of mine to work through some new gymnastics whenever you write.

With affection for a man from down under who is never afraid to express what is in his own mind,

Blessings,

Monte
Ah, my humble apologies Monte . .I found this piece a bit late.

I found myself wiping a tear from my eye as I read this, it is wonderful, thank you for sharing such a big part of yourself with us.

Happy New Year my friend!

Rated
Ah, my good Lady, it is never too late until they close the door, and my door is always open. I am glad that this reflection spoke to you and appreciate your taking the time to read and comment.

Sue and I are in Myrtle Beach now, just arrived a few hours ago. The temp is mild this evening, low 60s and the surf sounds so good filtering in through the open door of this efficiency we rented for a week. So we are looking for a good rest tonight and I imagine Sue will be out bright and early in the morning for a walk on the beach.

God bless,

Monte
This is beautiful, and as someone who identifies as a lover of humanity I loved your idea that we share a common human story
Thank you, Jason. I was wondering if you would get around here during the holiday season, I miss your posts and your comments. Hope this is a good time for you. And I always welcome any comments you have. Love your mind and the way you are able to cut to the essence and throw away the shells. Glad you liked this reflection.

Monte
Hi Monte, Happy New Year, and hey, a Happy Every Year!

I don’t think our theologies are different at all, what you believe I believe - it’s just that I believe every other theology is correct too, with a lot of qualifiers that happen to co-join the different faiths. For instance, the story of Adam and Eve is to me a metaphor that describes the scientific explanation of the origin of life – I have great faith in science too as pragmatic and practical as I am. To understand this metaphor I return to the age-old question of “what came first, the chicken or the egg?” Evolutionary scientists would have us believe that single-celled creatures suddenly appeared spontaneously when conditions were amenable to genesis, a miracle by itself. Considering this I wondered what the first priority of that first life would have been, beyond immediate sustenance and shelter; I assumed that priority would be procreation because therein lay a type of immortality - all life is fleeting and all creatures great and small cling to it because of the prime directive (commandment) which is simply “live!” A single-celled creature must of need divide into two to survive the ravages of time and circumstance through procreation, so the metaphor of Eve coming from the rib of Adam is scientifically and fundamentally sound. Jesus spoke in parables and it is clear to me now that he did so not just with the intention of illuminating a proverb, but also to maintain the message, as long as the story remained intact any translation into any language would not lose the parable’s proverb; earlier stories from the Old Testament are also parables – Jesus would’ve been acutely aware of this before he began to preach the word of God.

As for us getting along despite our differing theological beliefs, how could we not? You are a gentle man who came to this state of tolerance through experience; I am also a gentle person but the experiences that brought me to that place are completely different. Your life was structured uniquely, as was mine, yet we found many of the same truths - even though you were brought up to have a faith whereas I was brought up to have none. You may never have been cruel in your entire life but I had to learn the error of cruel reprisal. Tolerance of others of different beliefs, Monte, is the truest example of Charity, and of the three greatest things Charity is the greatest (or so sayest Paul). I understand how difficult it would be to change your theological stance, especially having struggled through dogma for so long to accept at face value the tenets of your faith - I wouldn’t consider trying to convert you away from your beliefs, besides, to me the best aspects of every faith’s bible is that each represents a path to godlike enlightenment and revelation, none more so or less so than yours. As for the various churches, I ‘m not (here) for reformation, rebuilding or revolution, I’m for consolidation, construction and conviction. Vengeance no longer interests me as it once did, forgiveness does.

A parable of my own would be appropriate here. Consider your own path to teaching when reading the following - a preacher is a teacher too, as I’m sure you're aware - because my parable will describe how I began being a teacher of sorts.

By the time I completed my first formal period of learning when I was 13 (I left in the second year of high-school to go to work because I was big for my age, bored with the too-easy work, and my parents were financially stretched.) I‘d attended 13 different schools because my father constantly followed construction work around the country. Being a red-head with freckles and always “the new kid” in school set me up to be bullied by other children, and though it wasn’t until I was 9 that someone actually attacked me I managed to attract a lot of verbal abuse up to that point. An older and bigger boy put me in a headlock while I was at a drinking fountain, his face was nearby and I threatened to punch him on the nose if he didn’t let go. He didn’t let go so I punched him - his nose bled and he cried. The headmaster caned both of us on the back of the legs when he was informed of the facts, I felt this was unfair and didn’t cry until I got home. My dad decided to teach me to box so I could defend myself; he’d been a boxer but only ever had one professional fight, the man he fought beat him soundly and he retired from the ring early. He told me of this history even as he taught me to box, the summation being “boxing is a mug’s game, no matter how good you think you are there’s always someone better”. It was a lesson in humility I never forgot, and though I never lost a serious fight I had some teachers who were very near impossible to touch when sparring. (Once, a Kung Fu master lost my fealty when he refused to spar with me again after I finally found my way through his defence. There was a different lesson to learn from that experience.)

At the same primary school (elementary school) I’d suddenly gained status as one who could and would defend themself, so the bullies left me alone. Being the new kid meant that I had little time to make friends before I had to move on and the idea that I might join with the bullies, just to belong to a group, came to me. So, to join I had to demonstrate my superiority over the weak. I chose Franky Keidel, a boy of German descent whose immigrant family also copped a lot of flak - WWII was still fresh in everyone’s mind. I just walked up to him and punched him. He didn’t fight back he cried instead, and I felt like the lowest of the low for doing it. I apologised and comforted him - it was something that had never happened to him before and he cheered up quickly. This didn’t impress the other bullies who’d been watching (I needed their audience) and they decided to step in - I taught them all a lesson for trying (even then I punched way above my weight). I became a friend of Franky and protected him and others from the bullies in my stay at that school, by the time I left both Franky and I had a lot of other friends so I didn’t feel I left him set for reprisal. I realised that because I was very good at fighting I could do this at every new school I went to, making friends became simpler and quicker - beat the crap out of the biggest and scariest bully at the first provocation, step in and protect the weak, and everything else would fall into place. I got hooked on being the hero.

I returned to complete high-school in one year when I was 20 while living with two sisters who were doing part-time university courses. My studies were easy even though I’d missed the bulk of high school; I lied about my previous education and passed the entrance exam so no-one bothered to investigate my past educational claims – I passed all subjects with straight A’s. The two lady housemates were doing anthropology and archaeology as their main focus and both had chosen psychology and social psychology as secondary subjects. As I was on top of my study and my day-job was steady I had a lot of free time at home, this did not go unnoticed by the two ladies, both of whom asked me to summarise their excess reading. I gained a great deal of insight from the data I had to summarise and learned very quickly how best to contract wordy explanations into short and direct instruction – I remain avidly interested in those particular subjects to this day. Though one of the sisters quit uni to follow a different path the other is now a Doctor of Anthropology at Armidale University - I remain close to both of them 34 years later. (I’ll be seeing them and their families on New Years Day – we do it every year. I might blog the photos in a travelogue.)

There are many proverbs within this compacted story and much has been left out, but not all of what I believed was proverbial from this period panned out. Recent revelations have caused me to reconsider earlier lessons and reread different truisms into the matrix that completes the picture - life imitating art imitating life imitating art. The Intelligent Designer was also the supreme artist, poet and scientist it now seems to me. I might add one little additional story from the same time and school that I’m still trying to fathom.

I’d suddenly become popular, and, the most popular boy in my class decided we would be best friends, his name was Richard Cotton and he loved bugs and lizards and frogs, and he especially liked butterflies. I was happy to be his friend and we often went hunting for stuff in the school yard, which was located in a semi-rural outskirt of Sydney and was surrounded by bushland (Woronora River). One day I saw a rare gold and black butterfly called a “Wanderer” at the bottom of the schoolyard. I knew my best friend would love to have it in his collection so I slowly crept up to it when it landed. My right hand, cupped so I wouldn’t damage the butterfly’s wings, swept down just after the butterfly flew away and was pierced through to the back by a piece of glass from a bottle that’d been recklessly thrown there from a public footpath. It didn’t hurt at all but the blood flowed freely and so, with me cupping both hands to “save” the blood (I was only 9) I went to see a teacher for help. My teacher was horrified when she saw the amount of blood I’d “saved” splashing all over the floor and she called an ambulance to take me to hospital. I thought all of this would only enhance my reputation as a “tough” kid and until they administered the anaesthetic by needle directly into the wound, the most excruciating pain you could ever imagine, I was quite happy about the whole thing. I still carry the scar with six stitches to match the one on my right foot I managed to gain when I was 15, but that’s another story.

You say that no one person is essential to the growth of any theological or intellectual theory but I must disagree on this one point. Original thought is unique until it is accepted as valid or true, without the original thinkers’ first input, no religion, philosophy, concept or idea would ever have taken hold. Every story, factual or fictional, has its roots in original thought and every scientific breakthrough has been previously imagined in the fiction of the day, long before it became a fact – Jules Verne leaps to mind - life imitating art again (Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.)

The first novel I ever read was called “First to Mars” by Captain W. E. Johns, the same author who wrote the Biggles Books. It was given to me on my 10th birthday by our reclusive and nearest neighbour, Professor Beams – he lived a half-mile up the road in Linden in the Blue Mountains and owned the largest privately owned observatory in the southern hemisphere at the time (he let me see the moon through it as another gift and it sparked my imagination). He gave me the rest of the series and I was suddenly hooked on not just science fiction but reading as well. Without the original thoughts of Captain W.E. Johns and the thoughtfulness of an old and lonely professor my entire life would’ve been completely different.


You say you “… do not envision yourself as a messiah, let alone some sort of god, and always see a clear and essential distinction between Creator (God) and created (you).” But, in the conviction of your belief you imitate the true essence of Jesus Christ in your tolerance and kindness, which makes you Christ-like, to me that is all the qualification required to assume the mantle of a messiah. You believe in the resurrection of Christ, so you must pay respect to the concept of reincarnation, and, the day of judgement when all are called to account. You believe in the afterlife, a heaven or hell in which to eternally consider your success or failure in life – if you believe you have an immortal soul then you believe you are immortal – only gods are immortal, Monte. (I’ll explain the Holy Trinity as I see it in a post some time in the near future that might be helpful in explaining my position on many things, including the procreating habits of gods.)

Everything you have said in your postings has inspired deep thought on my part and led to revelations unexpected. Monte, my good and gracious friend, I’m essentially a team player; sometimes I bat and sometimes I pitch, sometimes I’m best when out of left field, but without a good team it’s just another dream - I need players who also can field (\;-}]>


Your friend, with much returned affection, bill (I consider myself blessed to have found you; restoring my faith has been largely in your hands since we met.)

(p.s. We got the computer for the kids today but I couldn’t set it up without a little more hardware, a router for the network I have to create so they can have access to the web, so I ended up with a little more spare time than I thought I’d have. Lucky me! But I may have been a little too effusive and long-winded with this comment, sorry about that... chief.)
Monte, this is just stunning. So heartfelt and deeply profound. Thank you very much for taking the time to post this.

I'm sorry about Sam, and I'm so glad to know that you could find some peace around his having passed. I'm sure he is as relieved as you about this.

As for the Christmas and Easter holidays, I always found Easter to be a bit....scary, as a child. I didn't like Palm Sunday, and I just felt so small and inadequate in the face of the celebrations around Jesus and all that he embodied. I always felt like an imposter. Christmas, on the other hand, with the baby Jesus in the manger, and the animals, the star, Mary and Joseph.... it just felt so much more comforting. (I always wished I could have been the drummer boy - except I'd have had to play the b-flat clarinet).

Finally, Monte, I really want to thank you for the message, the gift that pervades this story. I've always tried to live by the following:

Whatsoever you do, to the least of my brothers
That you do unto me.

And I felt a bit of this in what you wrote, renewing my resolve to see God in everyone, to be more generous with my time, and to live with love in my heart. I needed this.

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to you. I hope your vacation was a great, festive, loving and peaceful success for all.
This was wonderful Monte. Peace to you this holiday season.
Karin: thank you for your kind comments. I too think that Easter has to be a very hard time for children to understand, especially Holy Week with Palm Sunday and all the adulation, etc., then Maundy Thursday, with a name that even adults don't quite understand, followed by Good Friday and all the scary aspects of that, death, entombment, then all the joy at Easter that celebrates the resurrection. It is just so much to absorb in one crammed together week. Holy Week and Easter are very much times that are mostly for adult believers who can grasp the meaning. Unfortunately far too many adult Christians really don't understand but go through the motions because they feel it is what others expect of them.

That you found as a child Christmas to be something you could grasp is something that many others share is very natural and understandable. And in a way it is that natural "being like us" aspect of Jesus that is the best thing that God did at Christmas, because we can now see how much God cares, so much that he would send his Son to live among us, to feel what we feel, to go through what we go through. For those who believe there is great comfort in that belief. And even for those who are not believers they can see the importance of seeing God working through others.

Blessings to you and yours in the coming new year.

Monte
Americain: Thank you so much for finding and reading this reflection. I am glad that it spoke to you in whatever way you needed at this time.

Many blessings to you and yours in the coming year.

Monte
Monte,

What a wonderful way to share the heart of Christ's life. Thank you so much for this tender offering.

I want to share with you that I had my own "Sam." He was my grandmother's second husband and he was always my Grampa. I had no other and I needed no other. I had no idea we were not related until I was 14. He was everything that a man was meant to be as far as I was concerned and my current husband is as close a facsimile of his generosity and kindness as I ever found. It is often said that girls marry their father, or someone like him. I didn't have that paternal contact, but I did have a man who was related to me only by marriage who demonstrated to me as deeply as can be done that love is a choice, and he chose me. I think his love truly saved my life and gave me the courage to be the kind of step parent I am today. His name was Charles Carleton Cavanagh, he was born on the Carissa Plains in California on July 21st, 1899. He worked with his calloused, battered hands all his life and he was the tenderest sweetest example of God's love that I would encounter as a child.

It's still the twelve days of Christmas...enjoy them!
Thank you, Suzanne. It is interesting, isn't it, how many of us have had our basic and most memorable nurturing and love from fathers and grandfathers that were "step." Both my mother's dad, my grand dad on that side, was a step grandparent; ditto with Sam on my father's side. And I was raised not by my biological father but by my step dad, Al Galemore, who treated me like his own and was a wonderful father to me.

There is no doubt that you are a better step mom today because of the love and support given to you by one Charles Carleton Cavanagh, who not only has a wonderful name but was a wonderful person.

Many blessings and much peace to you and yours in the coming new year.

Monte