
This is a little long; but I don’t want to drag this out, so please bear with me.
After the incident when I was ten when I killed the red winged blackbird using the bb gun, we have to flash forward to a time in my mid-teens when I was hunting with Dad for doves just after the season opened in late October. I said earlier that I only hunted doves once and quit because I didn’t like the taste of them. Which is true. But thinking about this incident more carefully I now see that the incident itself might have been the main reason I no longer hunted doves. It could have been an unconscious effort on my part to avoid doing something that would bring the incident to memory.
Doves like to feed in newly harvested corn fields. But if you approach them they will fly before you are close enough to get off a good shot. We were walking along a hedge row beside a partially harvested corn field and scared up a dozen or so doves feeding in the open field. As we approached they startled and flew for cover into the rows of corn that had not yet been harvested.
We decided to walk back to the edge of the field and walk the rows, so we spread out about 5 rows from each other and walked hoping to get closer to the doves before they flew, using the cover of the corn stalks. I was closest to the cleared harvested part of the field. Dad always gave me the best location for getting a good shot off. We were just approaching the end of the field and since doves will run along the ground similar to quail before they have to fly we figured we would scare them up soon as they were running out of cover.
Then there was this huge commotion and a large gray object was taking off not 25 feet in front of me and it was coming right at me, almost directly overhead now. I didn’t think. I just aimed and shot.
At that distance the object exploded in a rain of feathers from the small pellet bird shot shells we used. The object fell directly in front of me, at my feet, as feathers and down continued to slowly drift down over me like some bizarre snow fall. I looked down more closely and saw that it was a crane which must have been feeding on the dropped corn missed during harvest.
Dad ran over to see what I had shot, looked at its head which was about all that was still identifiable given the close up shot. “Sand Hill Crane,” he said. He mentioned something about there not being enough left to eat and just walked away heading for the car. There would be no more doves nearby after all that commotion. While I knew that Sand Hill Crane is considered a hunting species in most states, including Kansas, I always thought they were too elegant and beautiful to kill. And I had just killed one.
Tears were welling in my eyes and I looked down one last time at the bird and softly said, “Sorry,” and walked back to the car. Dad suggested we try again over by a recently harvested milo field, but I asked if we could just go home. Dad knew me better than I did. He lit a cigarette, never said a word, and we drove on home.
The third, fourth and fifth events took place about 15 or 16 years later and they occurred within a couple of months of each other. I know that I said there were four events but I remembered one more. Maybe there were even more than that and in the fog of the decades between now and then are not yet revealing themselves to me.
Regardless, It was as if God was trying to say something to me, had been trying to get my attention since I was ten years old and I wasn’t listening so he just tripled up the pain and shortened the interval, planting some good licks with a spiritual two by four right up the side of my head.
I was still working in the Executive Office of the President and each year I got a promotion. We finally had the money to buy a better place, way out in the country where my then wife insisted we live. It was a 50 mile drive one way to my job and eventually that would take a toll on me and on my marriage, but that is another story.
The place we got was a relatively new ranch house situated on the side of a hill surrounded by 9 acres of woods. It was a beautiful area, not far from Camp David, outside of Frederick, Maryland. The only entrance to the property was down a mostly graveled drive that was almost a half mile long. Half way down the drive in the hollow was our only close neighbor, a nice country couple living in a mobile home. His property adjoined mine and added another 30 acres of mostly woodland and scrub brush fields for hunting.
I am ashamed to say that I don’t remember his name because he was a good friend for a couple of years until my marriage was shot and I moved out.
One day right before squirrel season started he called and asked me to come down and check his new .22 squirrel hunting rifle. It was a big deal to him because they had little money and he had spoken about how he was saving $5.00 a month to buy the gun.
I went down and we were taking turns shooting the rifle, shooting at fence posts and what not. I told him it seemed to shoot very true and he disagreed saying he though it shot just a bit to the left of where aimed. We were about 40 yards away from a bare apple tree that some sparrows were bouncing around in. So I said, “See that tree with the sparrows. You aim at one and see if you can hit it.” He identified one sparrow and shot. Missed.
He handed to gun to me and I said, “OK. Now do you see that sparrow on that top branch to the left of those apples hanging on that branch?” “Yep.” “Then watch.” I took aim, fired, and the bird exploded. Instead of being happy at the good shot I felt like I had been shot in the stomach. Gut shot. I handed the gun back, mumbled something about having to go home and walked up the lane feeling half sick.
A couple of days later. I think it was on a Sunday morning because I had quit going to church at the time, being pissed off at the new priest of the Episcopal Church we went to. He was a conservative somewhere to the right of Bill O’Riley and I could not abide his sermons.
While everybody else was at church I took my .22 and headed to a spot in the woods where I knew there were several squirrel nests, sat down on a large stone, took out a pouch of Red Man tobacco and stuffed some into my cheek. I smoked about 3 packs of Chesterfields a day back then, but if you were stupid enough to light a cigarette while squirrel hunting you deserved the nothing you got.
After about half an hour the squirrels started to move, convinced that any danger was gone. I was watching one squirrel fairly high in a walnut tree that was in plain sight and did not seem to be as jittery as the others. When he stopped altogether, just sitting on the branch looking around, I took aim and fired. He started making these high pitched screeches and running toward the trunk of the tree. He got into to crotch where the branch came out from the trunk and could go no further. He was still screeching but not quite as loudly, but it was the only sound in the woods except for my own heartbeat which tattooed rapidly in my chest.
I had never in my life heard a squirrel make that kind of noise before and it was simply awful. At this point I knew the squirrel was dying and in enormous pain. I could barely see him so I moved around to where I could get a reasonably clear but not totally clear shot. I just prayed that I could hit him again. I aimed and missed three times. I was hyperventilating and shaking a bit. I steadied my front hand on the rifle against a small sapling took aim and shot one more time. The woods was quiet. I walked home and never told a soul.
The final event occurred about a month and a half later after the first snowfall of the season that stuck. There were about 4 inches of snow on the ground which made it easy enough to walk in and showed rabbit tracks easily. I took the light shot gun, the 20 gauge, and headed up to a hedge row that separated my neighbor's property from an adjoining farmer’s alfalfa field. There was good cover in the hedge row with lots of blackberry brambles. On the side of the row where I was walking was a neglected field that sloped down towards my neighbor's trailer.
I started walking the line and saw lots of tracks going mostly out toward the alfalfa field and back. If a rabbit broke that way chances are I could not get a shot, but I did not have permission to hunt there so I stayed on the side of my neighbor’s field. Whenever I would hear some scurrying in the brambles I would shake the bush. The first two rabbits I rousted headed for the alfalfa field. No shot possible.
I walked another couple of hundred yards and there would soon be no cover left as the hedge row ended at the property line. Almost at the end of the row a big rabbit bolted out about twenty yards in front of me and headed for the field and some scrub brush about 40 yards away. I knew he was dinner. I took aim, lead him just a bit and fired.
The rabbit was wounded but not dead. He was hobbling toward the scrub patch and screaming like I had never heard any animal scream. Compared to the rabbit the squirrel was hardly making a noise. The screaming rattled me and I did not take the second shot that I normally would have taken.
The rabbit headed to the small scrub brush patch and ducked into it for cover. All the while it was screaming and screaming. I kept looking for the rabbit but it was hard to see into the briars with the snow, a cloudy day emitting little light, and because I was on edge and couldn’t really concentrate. I though that you could hear that screaming from miles away.
Finally, after several nerve shattering minutes I saw what I thought was the rabbit dug down in the center of the bushes. To get a shot I actually had to get down on my knees and take aim. I shot, and finally there was silence.
I placed the shotgun across my knees, leaned back on my heels in the snow, looked at the blood trail that was grossly red against the white snow, bowed my head and hugged my knees and started crying. A thirty something man was crying his heart out. Softly at first and then in hard uncontrolled sobs. I felt that I couldn’t breath, that my lungs were being squeezed in some giant vice. Tears ran down my face.
After a long while I was too exhausted to cry anymore. I got up, walked home and went to the front closet. I got the 12 gauge and the .22 rifle, and, along with the 20 gauge, walked down the drive to my friend’s trailer. He let me in and I followed him into the small kitchen. He asked if I wanted a cup of coffee. I shook my head “no,” and laid the guns on the table.
“They’re yours. I quit.” He said nothing. Asked no questions. Just looked at me and then turned and poured himself a cup of coffee while I just stood there. He took a sip, turned back, looked at me, and nodded.
I turned and walked out into the snow. More snow was starting to fall. It would cover the blood trail of the rabbit, but could not cover the blood trail in my soul.
Monte
938 page views 2010 02 02

Salon.com
Comments
Like many others who have commented on Part 1, I too have a "hunting" story that involved a BB gun when I was 11 or so, but I won't waste anyone's time with it here; after reading what you wrote, words pretty much fail me anyway.
Suffice to say, in my teenage years I was a competition-level shot with virtually any weapon the foolish Reserve Army let me handle. I also taught hunter safety. I never shot a living creature again.
It is a dilemma Monte'. Gave up hunting long ago, when my dad had shot a small dove, picked up the wounded bird to knock its head on his gun barrel (he taught us never to let our prey suffer), and he hit it so hard the head flew off. I was horrified.......but I held it in. I could not kill anything after that.....not even insects.
To this day, I struggle with the idea of consuming meat......contributing to the suffering of living creatures.
Elizabeth, the old woman I mention in my "Middlelands" story, once told me, "Everything that has eyes wants to live!" I was struck dumb......
She used to catch rodents and insects in her flat, releasing them outside. thanks for a compassionate story my friend.
Bel well, G
(rated)
Thanks Monte...
G
You wrote the perfect ending line: "It would cover the blood trail of the rabbit, but could not cover the blood trail in my soul."
This was a truly worthy post. Thanks.
RATE (again). You know, it occurs to me this is good way to more ratings per story.
;-)
I don't even like fishing. I watched magnificent sports fish flopping and suffocating on the floors of fishing boats as a child in Miami Beach. All creatures deserve dignity, even as they are killed for human needs.
I haven't gone hunting since I returned from Nam. It just was much of a sport to me.. at least not with a gun. I figure when the animals can shoot back then you have a sport.
I'd rather go to the beach bars and hunt two legged squirrels. That way only an occasional heart would get wounded. Usually mine.
I took up spear fishing or underwater hunting. Thankfully fish have no vocal chords. It's far more difficult than one would imagine to get a kill shot on a large fish. I have some stories of getting drug around the ocean bottom by large fish, but that can wait for another day.
I no longer even spear fish. For many of the same reasons you so eloquently described above. (Although I still enjoy the occasional two legged squirrel hunt.)
Ohio literally has the best deer hunting in the country and our county has the highest deer kill count every year. The surrounding counties are numbers 2, 3, 4 and 5. It is almost a requirement to be a hunter here. Every pick up truck has a gun rack, and it is seldom empty.
But there are actually more urban deer hunters who come here every deer season and spend a lot of money. It is a very, very big economic benefit to us. The price in deer is high too.
I am about worn out having done these two pieces in a stretch of fourteen hours, so please forgive me for once more not addressing each of your individually for your kind comments and simply for having read what I have written. Thank you. Your support of my OS efforts never goes without my thinking how lucky I am to have found OS, and you.
Monte
Later, G
"I placed the shotgun across my knees, leaned back on my heels in the snow, looked at the blood trail that was grossly red against the white snow, bowed my head and hugged my knees and started crying. A thirty something man was crying his heart out. Softly at first and then in hard uncontrolled sobs. I felt that I couldn’t breath, that my lungs were being squeezed in some giant vice. "
This is so visually powerful. I feel it myself as I read these lines.
Thank you.
Re: the ethics of hunting. I've done some deer hunting, mostly bow hunting. I really like venison and it's not possible to buy it here. I don't think there's anything inherently more wrong with shooting a deer than with slaughtering a cow, and I don't think there's anything wrong with slaughtering a cow. Cows are not immortal; if not slaughtered they die eventually of illness and infirmity. I think a cow's life has value, but I don't think the life of a cow is equal to the life of a human. Cows write very few operas. They have beautiful eyelashes, but they are also food. I've never hunted rabbit, but I've heard a rabbit scream when our fox out back took it home for dinner. It's the fate of pretty much all rabbits to be eaten by something.
So that's where I stand. But. I also think it's possible that what's right for me isn't right for everyone. Someone under part one of this posted that every boy has taken aim at a little bird - I'm not a boy, I guess, but I can't imagine ever aiming at a red-winged blackbird or a sparrow to see if I could hit it. That's just not a drive I have ever had. There are things that other people can do perfectly happily that I know I shouldn't do - I can't play online video games without neglecting my life, for example.
I don't know if anyone is going to agree with me, but I think it's perfectly possible that some people can't hunt without hurting their own souls, but that's not the same as saying all hunting is evil.
This was some powerful stuff. Thank you so much for sharing.
I hope I never said or implied that I am against hunting. Most of my best friends are hunters. They often ask me to go with them but I no longer have any interest in it.
Hunting here in this county is essential to maintaining a balance between people and deer. Man is the only natural predator here. I was almost killed in 2005 when a deer ran directly into the front wheel of my motorcycle and totaled it and almost totaled me. I could argue it was the deer's fault and the deer could argue that if I was walking or running he would never have hit me. Both are true depending on where you stand.
For me, after that final hunting episode with the rabbit there was no chance at all that I would ever hunt again. Yet I eat and enjoy meat and am fully aware of how that gets to my table. Knowing that, I have no defensible position against hunting. But I will not do it.
As I said before, each of us must wrestle with our own consciences, or demons, however we see that, and come to a very personal decision. At 32 I could make a decision that I had been ignoring since I was 10. That was part of my personal growth.
To someone looking at it it could appear to be giving in to emotion. But whatever it is called, and I really don't care what anyone calls it, for me it was an important decision.
Thank you all for your comments. They are ALL appreciated. Those of you who know me, and I hope those of you who will come to know me through my writing and comments, know that the last thing I want in comments on anything I write is for anyone to think that there are "right" answers that I want to hear, or that I believe that what I think is the only way to think.
Hardly. I have in 70 years been wrong countless times. And I will be again. But if there is any one thing I hope people will take away from my writings is that we are all obligated to take personal stands on the things of life, and not to simply drift with the tide, or sway with the winds.
Opinions and beliefs matter. They really do. After all, we can always change our minds if the circumstances and the situation teach us something new.
Good night, everyone.
Monte
From the sounds of it many of us have had the same epiphany. Maybe epiphany is not the right concept for this. Some would say we had a come to Jesus moment. Whatever. I like many here hunted as well and decided over time that I just can't do that any more. Maybe if it was the only way to survive. We no longer live in pioneer times, covered wagons, our horse as our only friend, a gun at our side and all that.
It also sounds like many of us arrived here around the same age in life. Maybe there is something to this growing up concept. I think I'll keep trying to move forward along that line. Thanks for the reinforcement.
i abandoned a beloved kitty during my move/drive up to portland -- she leaped out of the car in no. california -- for good and understandable reasons, i'm told, but i will never ever forgive myself for what i did. i did everything i could to find her and get her back but there is no excuse. i feel such shame and self-loathing just mentioning it. so i know how you and others feel about maiming those animals.
i do wonder what you think of palin's alaskan policy of shooting wolves from planes. i understand population control of various species, but should it be so mechanized? sorry if i'm way off base asking about this. you just got me thinking, man, after my long nap, as you always do.
love, light and gratitude,
teddy and the wonderpups
Take care.
Three packs of Chesterfields a day?!?!!
And yes, Jim, three packs of cigs a day, often more, for over 25 years. It is a wonder I have any lungs left, but recent xrays and cat scans indicate that my lungs are the least of the worries. I stopped smoking in 1983 so I guess it is true that our lungs can slowly repair themselves in some cases. In my mother's case not so. Her smoking ultimately resolved into lung cancer, emphysema, and death by pneumonia. At 59. No happy ending there.
Monte
That is nothing to be proud of but is certainly proof that God can change us and even use us in God's service. Cracked vessel that I am.
Monte
It wasn't.
The little animal was clawing its way along the ground, its intestines splayed out behind it. It was a wrenching site, and since we were unable to bring ourselves to do the necessary, we ran to my grandfather, gave him the rifle, and demanded that he shoot the chipmunk and put it out of its misery.
My granddad looked at us, and at the little agonized creature – and then stepped on its head.
All I could do was flee. But I could not flee the memory of it, and cried myself to sleep for many months afterward. I told my parents about it, but no answers that they could give me, helped.
Finally, in the middle of one of those tearful nights, and though I cannot say I was particularly religious at that age, I got down on my knees at the foot of my bed and prayed. I asked God to forgive me for being there, for being a willing accomplice in that horrendous act. I didn't know what to expect – but what I got was something of a miracle.
When I had finished the prayer, I experienced, what I can only term as grace, literally pour down from above. It felt like cool water bathing my head. And it washed away my guilt. Completely.
I don't understand it. I don't think I need to. But it was real, dramatic, and perfect.
Thank you for sharing your story, and my hearts gratitude to those animals that taught us so much.
These lessons are so hard on children. You were indelibly affected by your traumatic experience and I am glad you found relief in prayer. I have no doubt at all that you were relieved of your guilt by an act of pure grace. Children are able to realize such things much more easily than jaded adults.
I certainly wish I had learned what God was telling me at ten. It would have saved a lot of suffering in the ensuing years.
The piece seemed easy to write when first it crossed my mind. Part One went fairly well but I was starting to have trouble with it at the end, and then Part Two was pretty painful to write. Now being a couple of days away from it I can see that it was good to get this out in the open, for me as much as for the reader.
Good to hear from you and thank you for that real and painful verification of the difficulty of moral issues like this.
Monte
Thank you, Monte for sharing this.
Today I don't own any guns and have zero desire to own or shoot any. I think once we get past the juvenile obsession with gun play and the power the gun projects- truth be told it it really isn't all that fun. The most thrilling part- the thrill of the hunt and the thrill of the hit- are best captured by paintball guns (ouch though!)
I do think that there is a certain aspect of maturation in my decision to not to use guns or hunt. But I think that is completely within the individual. Those who decide not to hunt need to make that decision to be true to their own values.
But that does not need to mean the same thing to someone who continues to hunt and is perfectly at peace within his or her self. That happens to a lot of people around here whom I consider to be mature and well adjusted adults.
But it is people like me who know that they keep being upset by aspects of killing who need to get their values and there actions in alignment. That surely took me a long time, didn't it?
Monte
One thing I did not talk about here is the fact that I still kill, accidentally, but the result is the same. It hurts when a bird flies into the car, a rabbit runs right into my path, a ground hog or a squirrel run the wrong way. It makes me sick.
In June, 2005 when Sue and I were riding our motorcycles in the mountains of West Virginia a deer ran into the front wheel of my motorcycle and caused a terrible high side with me sliding down the road and into the side gravel for over a hundred feet. Totaled the bike and almost totaled me. I spent three days in the UVA hospital trauma unit in Charlottesville after a helio flight out.
Immediately after I tried to sit up after the crash Sue came running up to see how badly I was hurt and the first thing I said was, "How is the deer?" So there is always a trade off between our technology that allows us to go fast enough and be places where animals can get hurt or killed. Do we walk so we never hurt anything? Obviously we choose to ride or drive and so risk hurting animals. That is the kind of moral ambivalence that I have a hard time living with still.
Thanks for sharing your own story. I am glad that you and your husband found the balance in your decisions where you are now comfortable with them.
God bless,
Monte
I think of the few things that I would like to ask God one would be why did s/he design our beautiful planet where species feed upon one another to live?
Yet I am obviously ambivalent in that I continue to eat meat, knowing full well where it comes from. I can't just shut that away and pretend it is not so. I was a farm kid and I know how to slaughter and dress all of the domestic food animals. I've done it.
I don't have any answers. I am glad that I did finally quit killing game animals. The other killing that I indirectly participate in, not so much.
Monte