:

  

Monte Canfield

Monte Canfield
Location
Newcomerstown, Ohio, USA
Birthday
December 28
Title
Rev. Dr. Monte Canfield
Bio
Retired Protestant Pastor and Theologian, jointly credentialed in the United Church of Christ and the Moravian Church. Education: BA, MA, M.Div, Thd. Public Service: NY State Office of Executive Development; Federal Exec. Branch: Executive Office of the President, BOB; Interior, BLM; Non Profit: Ford Foundation, Energy Policy Project; Congressional: General Accounting Office; Private industry: Grow Group, Inc.; US Paint; Owner, the Energy Center, St. Louis. Christian service: Pastor, First Congregational UCC, Ottawa, Illinois; Pastor, St. Paul's UCC, Port Washington, Ohio; Pastor, Moravian Church, Gnadenhutten, Ohio.

Editor’s Pick
AUGUST 10, 2009 1:05PM

Permission to Die

Rate: 61 Flag

 

dove_flying_left

 


This is a true story. The dialogues are reconstructed from memory of events that happened 18 years ago.


"So how many are there?"

"Right now there are six.  It changes from week to week."

"What exactly am I supposed to do?"

"Just drop in and see them for a few minutes each day you are here. Talk to them. Say a prayer before you leave. I think one or two of them are in comas, but check with the doctor. With the heavy pain meds sometimes its hard to tell if they are sleeping or in a coma."

"You say that none of them is expected to last a month?"

"That's right. They are in our in house hospice."

"I don't think this was in my job description when you interviewed me."

"Job description is your term.  I never use it.  This isn't a job.  Its a calling.  I can't tell you what you will be doing in any detail. If you don't think you are called to do this particular thing, then don't. One thing you learn in your 'in field' training is what you are called to do and what you are not. Hopefully you will find that you are called to do whatever needs to be done."

"I know that. I wasn't saying I won't do it.  Of course I will.  I was just saying that I didn't expect this."

"When I started chaplaincy 15 years ago I didn't expect most of what I have been called to do.  You can't really program it and you surely can't plan it. Its day to day.  Eventually a kind of pattern will emerge, more by instinct than anything else. Go home for the rest of the day and think about it. If you don't do it, let me know.  There are lots of other things that need to be done, but I think you should try to do this."

The Chaplain of Good Samaritan Home smiled at me and picked up a chart on his desk, a signal that the discussion was over. I thanked him and walked down the long main floor hall to the small office behind the chapel that I was given to use the three afternoons and Sunday mornings per week I was to be there.

I learned soon that the closet sized office was a place to hang my coat and set down my briefcase.  My real "office" was to be the entire 6 story, three wing, 400 resident retirement home.

 "Good Sam" occupied a full city block and was perched high on the west bank of the Mississippi in South St. Louis. It was affiliated with the United Church of Christ. It has since been torn down for development. I can not bring myself to say for "progress."

I was a 52 year old second year seminarian at another UCC affiliated institution, Eden Theological Seminary, located in the suburb of Webster Groves, 6 miles northwest of Good Sam. "Student Chaplain" was my second "in field" education assignment.

Field education was important at Eden. It was a key part of securing the Master of Divinity degree necessary to become an ordained pastor.  Three years of field education, plus at least one summer of full time Clinical Pastoral Education in a local hospital, was required to graduate.

It was a bit of a plum to get an assignment to Good Sam. It was one of the few remaining total living facilities in the area and included everything for the residents from assisted living apartments, individual rooms, rehabilitation, an infirmary with a hospice ward, a secure dementia wing, plus dining room, coffee shop, drug store, lounges, recreation rooms, chapel, library, and several commercial services available on site. It was a self contained urban village for the elderly.

After my Monday conversation with the Chaplain, who was my field supervisor, I returned on Wednesday and made my way to the infirmary on the 4th floor. I introduced myself to the nurse supervisor who would soon become my friend and a mentor.

"Hi, I am Monte Canfield."

"Glad to see you, Monte. I'm Mary. Dave has already filled me in.  I am very glad to see you. Last year the student wanted nothing to do with the infirmary, to say nothing of the hospice, and it put quite an extra load on Dave. I don't imagine he told you that, but he spent hours here that meant working extra hours to keep up with everything else. 

This is far too big an operation for one Chaplain to handle. Let me walk you through the infirmary, introduce you to the doctor and some of the nurses and then I will show you the hospice."

After the tour and introductions, she took me to the back of the infirmary, down a small hallway and into a small ward that was decorated more like a large home bedroom than as an infirmary. 

The lighting was subdued.  A chair was available beside each bed; and soft music played in the background. It was a pleasant enough place if you didn't think about what it was for. A nurse sat at a small desk near the center of the room. We talked to the nurse a couple of minutes.

Then Mary walked me to one end of the room. "There is room for ten beds here without crowding things. We want the patients to feel as comfortable as possible. When beds are not occupied we move them out of the room to give it a feeling of greater spaciousness.

People are moved here only when two doctors, the staff doctor and their personal physician, agree that they are not likely to live more than another month.  Of course we have a few that surprise us and get better for a while, but it is only a matter of time even with them."

"And most of them are Christian?"      

"Well, yes, if you mean that they belong to the church. UCC membership is required for admission to Good Sam, as is the recommendation of their pastor.  But their faith varies.  Some have not set foot in a church in decades. Some married into a church going family but have little or no faith.  And some, mostly men, simply do not share what they think about religion, considering that a very private matter. Most are from a generation that sees religion as a very personal experience."

"Dave told me that some may be in comas already."

"I will take you around in a minute and you can see for yourself.  Of the six here now, one is definitely in a coma but seems to be stable for now, and one is kind of in and out of consciousness, partly due to his condition and partly due to the heavy pain meds. But I suggest that you always assume that they know you are there and can hear what you say."

We walked to each bed and I was introduced to all, not just the ones who could talk to me and clearly recognize me, but to the one who was in a coma and another who appeared to be sleeping.

After the tour I went back and spent a few minutes at each bedside, learning about the four who were clearly aware and saying prayers with them after asking them if they would like that and asking if there were any particular things they wished me to pray for. 

None wished for their own healing, understanding exactly where they were in their own journey.  All of them asked for prayers for family members.  All said they were glad I was there and looked forward to seeing me again, asking when I would be able to come back. I told them I would see them on Friday.

I spent some time at the two beds where the patients were not responsive. I read some short passages of scripture to them, and said a prayer with each, out loud. I told them I would be back on Friday, although it appeared clear at the time that they did not know I was there.

Over the next two weeks I spent a few minutes with the hospice patients each time I was at Good Sam. I got to know four of them much better and even managed some cognitive contact with the one who was sleeping the first time I visited. He was very much "in and out" but I was sure that he was aware of me. 

At the end of that third week I was told that the doctor thought that none of them would last more than a week longer.

That upset me more than I thought it would and, because I was scheduled for a week off the coming week, I went to Dave and asked him if I should come in to be with them instead.  He said, "No. You told me before you came here that you needed the week off, so go."

Before I left for the day that Friday I went up to see each one and explained to all, including the one man who was asleep again and the one in a coma, that I was going to be off for a week, but that I would be back to see them a week from Monday, ten days later. I felt I was a bit disingenuous saying that while knowing their prognosis, but I wanted them to know that I was not abandoning them, because that is what it felt like to me.  

I felt very badly about the whole thing and wondered if I was just in way over my head.  I talked to Mary about it and she nicely reminded me to remember who was really in charge, pointing upwards and giving me a quick hug.

Ten full days later I returned with real trepidation to the infirmary. Mary called me to the side to bring me up to speed.

"I hope you had a good week, Monte.  We held our own here, but missed you a lot."

"Just tell me how many died while I was gone."

'Why don't you just come down to the hospice ward with me?  You really can't avoid it, you know."

We walked into the hospice ward, my heart heavy.  There were now eight beds occupied. I could not believe how many were dying in such a short time span. In less that a month first six, and now eight more.

Mary went to talk to the duty nurse and I sighed and headed to the first bed in the row.  It was a man I had not met before.  I introduced myself, and went through the pastoral care routine that I was developing without being conscious that a routine was emerging.  The new woman in the second bed was asleep, but I went through the same routine as if she were not.

At the third bed I recognized the man in the coma.  I looked quickly at the next bed and the familiar face of a lady I had come to admire smiled at me.  Quickly I walked down the aisle looking at each bed. Each bed had the patient in it who was there when I left ten days before.

At the last bed the woman raised her head a bit off of her pillow and lifted up her shaking hand to me.  I took it and she smiled and said, "Welcome back, Chaplain. We have been waiting for you."

I talked to her for a couple of minutes and told her I would be back in a bit after I talked to the others.

I walked quickly to door where Mary was waiting with a small smile on her face.  We walked down the hall a few paces.

"What happened?  Surely Dr. Lewis could not have been that far off. He does this kind of prognosis all the time."

"His prognosis is based on reading the body. He doesn't factor in the determination of the spirit that stems from love."

"Love?"

"Yes, love.  These folks love God and they have come to love and rely on you."

"But they hardly know me. And why did they not die?  They would then be in a far better place than this. They don't need me around to do that. That is between them and God. And what about the one who is seldom conscious; and the one in the coma?"

"Monte, listen to me. They all know that they will soon pass over.  And obviously the ones that you thought were simply out of it were not. On some level they heard you talking to them.  Look, Monte, you told them that you would be back in 10 days and they took you at your word."

"But that shouldn't affect whether or not they would die when I was gone."

"Don't you see?  They were waiting for you.  They were waiting for permission to die."

I was shocked; completely baffled, confused, and repelled by the thought.

"I have nothing to do with giving them permission to die. That's not what I am doing here. I never mentioned dying to them.  Never."

"Well, maybe it is time that you did.  You are their Chaplain. Their own pastors almost never visit them and none of them have been here since they have been in the hospice ward.  Dave was able to visit once toward the end of last week, and, like you, he told them that you would be back today. I fully understand why he told them that."

Mary continued, "Don't you see, Monte? To them you are their vicar of God.  Whether you want the role or not, or, for that matter, whether or not they are right to think so, these older people need to know that it is OK for them to die. They want permission to do so.

There is no one else who is as close to them spiritually right now as you are; not even their family members, although most of them can't bear coming anyway, and so they don't.  But you can give them that permission. They are ready to go.  Let them."

I was still confused.  But mostly I was in denial.  I wanted no part of any such power, real or imagined.  I had never asked for it.  I did not seek it.  I did not think it was good theology. I did not see it as part of my call.  And I certainly did not think I was worthy to offer such permission.

I simply did not know what to do.  But, almost instinctively, I trusted Mary.  After 30 years dealing with people in situations like these she had learned much and had kindly shared that learning with me. I was learning something that I did not want to know. But I had to learn it.

I walked back into the ward and went to each bed, picked up a listless hand or held the thin hand of one who was awake and smiling at me. With great emotion welling inside of me I told each of them, "I am very glad to see you. I missed you, and want you to know that I recognize how hard it is for you to go on day by day."

I continued, "But I also want you to know that you will soon be going to a wonderful place, a place too beautiful for mere words, a place where there is no more pain or exhaustion; a place where you will be with God and where you will be again with your loved ones who have gone there before you."  

And finally, I told them, "It is OK for you to let go of this place now. I can imagine how hard it must be to hold on here.  So it is OK to go to on to that life where you will be in the the much closer presence of  our Savior, the place we have all dreamed about since we accepted our faith.

I will miss you when you go, but I promise to look you up when I get there. It will be good to see you again when you are strong and happy, without pain and surrounded by love."  

I then said a simple prayer. "God, this is your precious child who will soon be coming home to you. Please welcome this loved child with the same open arms with which you welcomed you Son."

Then I kissed each on the forehead, women and men alike, and walked from the room, tears streaming down my face. I knew the glory that awaited them, but I knew the sorrow of the coming loss to me of these who were strangers only a month or so before.

By the end of the week all had passed quietly on to be in the closer presence of the Lord. As each passed on I said for each the prayers for the dying, or for the dead if they died when I was at school and not at Good Sam, and I found comfort in those ancient words.

It was a hard lesson to watch how death was an integral, inevitable part of life that each of us must learn to accept in our own way. My lesson came unbidden, but proved to be the necessary lesson for me.

Through the years of my ministry, and through hundreds of bedside vigils and funerals, I always had misgivings about the authority that most members of the church place in the hands of chaplains and pastors. I still do. But I never again doubted that they do trustingly give us that authority.

And I finally accepted that, if they believed that I was the one whom God had given to them to help them through some of the hardest times of their lives, and even through their deaths, then I would do the best I could to serve them with love, compassion and hope.

From that time forward until now nothing in my ministry would ever be more humbling than this unwanted calling.  There has been nothing that I consider myself both more burdened by, and yet more privileged to do, than to be there for them when they need God's love the most. 

 

 1802 page views as of 11 15 2009

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I don't plan on going anytime soon but when I do, I know you will be by my side, and I'm comforted by that thought.
You were then are are now, one of God's chosen servants. He has blessed you and you have shared, as He would want. Really tough stuff, Monte, but who better equipped than you! Wonderful sharing. Thanks so much and have a wonderful day!
Monte
I witnessed those near death wait for loved ones to accept death's finality and the soul's rebirth. Bless you for the comfort you brought and still give. rAted!
Monte, this is beautiful. I was in tears along with you at the end. This is a post that many should have access to when dealing with a terminally ill loved one. Not everyone has the benefit of a chaplain to give them permission. What a wonderful gift you have been given to be able to administer to these people in their time of need.

Namaste
The individual "will" is amazing -- that people will hang on as if waiting for permission, but really, here (I think) they were waiting less for permission & more for reassurance. Someone they trusted to get them through & tell them that it's alright to go, that they aren't alone. We always wait for defining moments, I think -- clues to the right path. We need a word or touch from our loved ones, or maybe the calm demeanor of a caring pastor -- to walk us through death & help us move on to peace.

Monte, I like that you take us through your own fears & doubts about helping people through the passage & that we see your growth as a pastor & as a human being through this "calling." Lovely & moving post about a "hard lesson."
This is so beautiful and so right that I have nothing to offer, Monte, except thank you for writing it.
Terrific. This deserves publication beyond OS.
Monte, this one hurts. Permission to die! God Bless You, my man!!
Death is a hard fact to face, but more so when you perceive you are alone. I've had my doubts throughout my life, and I decided long ago that I was going to believe what I felt was right and not what a bunch of people who read a certain book told me was right (and I'm not referring just to the bible here, Monte, I was raised Jewish). I'm not sure what happens next, if anything - but I am sure that there is some higher power, and that there is meaning in my life so conversely there must be meaning in my death as well. I sincerely hope that it is a long time before I discover the answer.
Bless you, Monte, for so freely giving of yourself and your heart.
As you know I am not Christian, but you do fill me with light. :) tears are streaming down my face ((Monte))
Monte- As the former Bereavement Services Coordinator for Hospice, I admire and bless you for your compassionate, spiritual assistance, administering to those near the end of life. Many need this "permission," for a peaceful death journey and often family members are unable to offer it for a myriad of reasons. You truly do holy work.
--rated--
Great story Monte. I don't know if I told you but one of my previous jobs (only for about a year) was as Marketing Director for a LARGE national private hospice service. I spent A LOT of time with the Chaplain in this region as well as with caregivers that worked for us and caregivers at nursing facilities. I was like you, even more so when I used the phrase, "this WAS NOT in my job description!" Having to deal so closely with the families and the dying. I know that for many the Chaplain is the most important aspect of end of life. I can only say thank you for your service and I'm certain you made a difference in many, many lives.
P.S., E.P. and Cover as it certainly should be. Congrats and well deserved.
Beautifully expressed. Hope we are all so fortunate to have a person with this kind of compassion sitting beside us at the end.

My minister often says, "God does not call the equipped; He equips the called."
So, so true. What a blessing for them to have you.

I took over a congregation so small it had been served only by pulpit supply for nearly three years. It had several older members who appeared to be holding on for no discernible reason, and about three months after my installation, they began to move toward death. After the fourth one, I mentioned to a colleague that I was afraid I wouldn't have any congregation left soon, and he shrugged and said, "They were waiting to die till someone knew them well enough to recommend them to God."

As you say, ministering to a literally dying congregation wasn't in my job description, or the one I thought I had. If any of us ever knew what our job descriptions really would be, the ranks of the ordained would be thin indeed — and you and I knew better than most, because we were called as adults.
A beautiful and wise piece! Well-deserved EP.

On a few occasions, my husband or I have been in the position to say to a parent or aunt or uncle, "It's OK, you can let go now." It is a privilege.

I hate it when people say of someone who has died that they "lost their battle" with cancer or whatever the cause of death. Dying is not a defeat.

By the way, annette, I love that expression you shared. I'll remember that.
Great post, as always, Monte.

Both my mother's parents had Alzheimer's disease and spent their last few years in Hospitality Hall, the nursing home section of Margaret Mary Hospital. Grandpa made it to 90, Grandma to 82.

The local parish sent one of their semi-retired priests to the nursing home a couple times a week. The nurses jokingly called him the Angel of Death because he really, really liked giving people the Last Rites. Actually, it was about the only sacramental thing he was still able to remember how to do. (I know that it's not called Last Rites anymore, and you don't have to be in danger of death to get it, but that point was lost on both the priest and most of the elderly residents.) The priest was pretty senile himself, and he'd forget who he'd already gotten that day. Once Grandpa got the Last Rites three times in one day.

The priest would spend whole days making his way around the ward, anoiting pretty much anyone and anything that was willing to be anoited. Since no one was being harmed by this and both the priest and the patients seemed comforted by the situation, the nurses let it continue.

I think of him when I think of someone who really did hear and respond to his calling.
This is magnificent Monte. :)
Monte, you've brought some light to one of the most difficult moments in life and in faith. Thanks.
I was going to say I wish I hadn't read this today, but by the time I finished it I realized how truly happy I am that I did.

I will always be grateful to the minister who helped my mother when she was dying. I hope I am fortunate enough to have such a compassionate person do this for me when the time comes.

Thank you Monte.
Thanks to everybody who has read, and thanks for the kind and insightful comments.

dcv: thanks, and I do hope that others get comfort from knowing that someone can be available to them when they pass on.

Cathy, I think now that doing this type of ministry is indeed a blessing. At first I was far from sure.

Chuck: it is never easy, and we miss them. There is a selfishness in that grief, but I fully understand it and accept it because I have gone through it so many times in my own heart. Sometimes it takes one a bit removed from the grief to offer the the approval of moving on to the next place in our journey.

JK: it was hard to remember and write but worth it if it helps others. Your comments are very kind to me.

Suzie, I agree with you. We cannot know what is going on in another's heart and mind at times like these. Some have clearly sought permission since their family members would not give it; others only need reassurance as you say. Still others may have other needs. But in the end a ministry of presence is at the heart of it all. Then they know that someone cares.

Thanks, Lorraine, I am so glad that you got to read this one.

Hells Bells, I appreciate your comment. We will see how well it gets picked up beyond OS. Often lately they have been, but I can never figure out exactly by whom.

scanner: it is never easy, but we can make it a bit more easy than it otherwise would be.

Bill, you are a fine person and whatever path you take I know that God is looking after you. It does not matter whether you believe it, or whether I do for that matter. But you embody the characteristics of love that God so much calls us to have. Thanks for your perceptive comments.

Julie: you know that it matters not if you are a Christian, for you are loved regardless. I am so glad that you come to my blog and get something from my posts. Bless you.

Mothership, you are most kind. I am glad that you were able to be of service in the Hospice movement. It is a wonderful gift we can give to others.

Greg: I do remember that you had that responsibility and I have no doubt that you grew enormously during that time, and, like me, may have rather not. But in the end it made us better persons.

Beautiful thought, Annette; "God does not call the equipped; He equips the called." You have a wise minister.

HL: your comments are so welcome. We, in whatever form of ministry, have to do what the both of us have done and take up the call regardless of where it leads. I am proud to have you as a friend who has done that. And I do think that it is better that we did this as adults, when we could also apply our already substantial life experiences to what we were taught and what we learned in the real life situations our calling places us in. Thanks so much for your comments.

Faith: your comments are important. I too do not see dying as a defeat, but rather a part of living, and, for me, but the next step in a journey that is only beginning, not over.

What a marvelous story, Leeandra. It would, fleshed out just a bit, make a wonderful post in its own right. I hope you take that idea and do that.

Thank you, Miko. It always makes me smile when you come and read my work. Your kind comments are much appreciated.

I will get to other comments as they come along later tonight. Time for me to start supper and there is a huge thunderstorm coming that hopefully will help break this 90+ degree heat and high humidity after this front rolls through. But I think I will shut down the computers until it passes.

See you all later in the evening. God bless you for your comments and your love.

Monte
When it is my time to go, I hope there is someone like you to remind me that it's ok to go. And if not, perhaps I will remember this post. Thanks, Monte, for following your calling. And thanks for sharing it with us.
Yes. And bless you. I could never do the work I do in palliative care without a chaplain by my side.
Monte,
The previous commenters have said it all, and said it well. This is just a beautiful, beautiful piece. Touching, compassionate, human, forgiving, honest, raw, loving, - I could go on and on. Every now and then I read something and am simply and profoundly struck by the thought that I have just been changed a little myself by what I just read. It happened here. If you never write another post (which of course I trust that you will write many more) this will stand as a testimony in my eyes to your empathy and compassion for humanity. Tearfully rated.
This is a really lovely post, Monte. It reminds me of when my Swedish grandfather died at age 95. He was the last of my grandparents to pass on, and my favorite of the four, although I loved them all, each in their own way. The others died at 87, 92, and 93 respectively; and I knew them each intimately as an adult, with children of my own.

My Swedish grandfather was a man's man, a barrel chested athelete who had been on the Swedish Olympic team, serving both as a ski jumper and on the Swedish hockey squad in the Winter Olympics held in Chamonix in 1924. I remember stories his friends told me of his ability to kick a soccer ball the entire length of the field. He was one of those men who was good at everything he did, and if I emulated anyone on Earth, I wanted more than anything to be like my Morfar, Lars Gustav Selander. Morfar taught me how to fish. He taught me how to listen. He showed me what it was to be a man. He was more of a father to me than my Dad, who would himself pass away not long after; and his death was a sore blow to me at a time when I was already reeling from the loss of my three other grandparents in quick succession, and my wife, from whom I was only recently divorced. I was an emotional mess at the time. I remember sitting at Morfar's bedside (Morfar = mother's father in Swedish) and knowing that he was hanging on to a thin thread of life and consciousness for no apparent reason, unable to eat or talk or respond for days at that time, and so close to death; yet for some reason unknown to me, he stayed on in that comatose world and his shrunken, shriveled body in the hospitol bed.

And one night as I sat there with him I said to him, 'Morfar, it's OK for you to go now...' I am shedding tears just thinking of that precious moment when I sat alone with him at his bedside. I went home and in the morning I was told he had passed away in his sleep that night.
Thanks for making me cry, ya big lug. Monte, this was powerful and beautifully written. Cover material all the way.

I once had a friend who worked in hospice care and we would talk. I would often mention that in no way could I work such duty as it must take a terrible toll on a person and how could she possibly do that day in and day out. She always answered the same way. "I can't explain it, but it's not like that at all."

Thanks to you Monte, I think I finally understand. This was beautiful in every way.
HaHa! This sat half read on my monitor all afternoon as I had many errands to run. I just posted the above comment and the editors pick popped up so a went to check the cover. Congratulations! I've always felt you deserve more coverage than you get. This piece should help anyone who reads it. I know it's helped me. Thank you.
Submitted to Reddit and Dugg it.
I watched my aunt interact with a priest she didn't really know a few days before she passed. She was a devout Catholic and she needed him, as she was terrified to die and it was coming. He prayed with her and I felt a kind of electricity in the room that was beyond description. Beautiful, peaceful, so touching.

I'm agnostic, but I will always remember that moment. I have always respected the clergy. It's such an important service that you all provide. Beautiful post.
Beautiful story, Monte. Thank you for sharing this with us. A responsiblity that cannot be laid down..
Oh Monte,

This piece so moved me, the words streamed from the page straight to my heart. The inevitability of death is in such conflict with our struggle to survive, with faith or without, it will always be a hard fought peace, and one not always one.

When my father lay dying I was struck by the sense of calm that seemed to envelope him a few days before he passed away, calm with a degree of euphoria and then this trance-like peace. The moment of death was like a curtain slowly descending, it was strangely soothing. I miss my father every day and am grateful for the honor of spending as much time with him as I did. Grateful too that he was driving his own car and doing what he loved a mere two weeks before. I realized later that sheer force of will kept him going those last few months, Force of will and a sincere sense of dignity.

Thank you Monte for once again sharing your brilliant, spiritual guidance with us here, in ways that all of us can relate to, regardless of our particular religious affiliation or lack thereof. You are a prince.
I had no idea abt such things. "permission to die" is new to me. am not Christian. What is hospice?
Extraordinary. I've watched lots of people die at the hospital, but I've never witnessed the process through the eyes of the chaplain. Very moving and uplifting. Even death has its own beauty.
I am finding it difficult to write through the tears, but I wanted to let you know how profoundly this beautiful contemplation moved me, Monte. And for so many reasons, most of which others have already written about eloquently here. I felt I came to know each of these precious, patient souls through your loving eyes, just as I came to know you more deeply, as well. You are a rare witness on behalf of a God whose name so many have disgraced by their hypocritical and hateful behavior. Your authenticity and open-hearted compassion are light and salt in a dark and tasteless world.

When my grandmother (pictured in my avatar) fell into a coma following her stroke, I asked my uncle, who had been living with her, if he would be willing to sit and talk with her, as I knew that was supposed to be of some comfort to coma victims. They had a dysfunctional relationship, and he clearly had no interest in doing so. We couldn’t bear the thought of her dying alone, so Michael and I made a four-hour trek in the middle of the night to the hospital, where we found my grandmother waiting peacefully, the dim night light casting a glow on her silver hair and unwrinkled brow. I sat and talked to her for hours, holding her hand and caressing her soft hair and delicate skin. I told her my mom would be arriving in the morning. I repeated the names of those she loved over and over again. I told her she had to wait for my mom. Even though the doctors had predicted she wouldn’t last the night, she did indeed wait for my mother, who arrived in time to spend the day with her. And my grandmother continued to outlast their predictions, giving up her last breath nearly two days after she was expected to depart.

Because she had been unable to speak her last words, I uttered for her the last words she had heard her father speak. Eight years old, she joined her mother and four siblings in surrounding her beloved father’s bed. He stretched out his arms, looked upwards, and uttered, “Father, I thank Thee. Father, I thank Thee. Father, I thank Thee,” and was gone.

—Melissa
That was one emotional ride, sir. What an obligation, what wise words from Mary, and they all went, after given permission. I have no more words other than thank you for opening up an experience so precious to us all.
This is so inspiring and so heartbreaking, all at once. I'm not a chaplain (never did CPE) but I am a non-stipendiary Pastor (of a very small congregation.) I do visit people in both hospital and hospice (as well as homebound) but am aware that it's not the norm. Blessings, blessings and more blessings, on you and those you serve!
thank you for this post.
Oh Monte, I'm sorry I hadn't read this sooner. I don't have much to say or to add to this beautiful post....my tears tell it all. God bless you and I wish we could meet in person...
Thank you, Liz, it is the difficult moments that we need to shed light on most often; I am glad you found some of that light here.

Buffy: I am so glad that a minister helped your mother at her time of greatest need. We all need people to lean on when we go through trials, and our death is often one of the greatest for most of us.

Hello, Owl, I too pray that there will be a compassionate person with you when the time comes, for we deserve to go forward into what looks so like a dark night knowing that there is hope for a better ending than what we may imagine.

Risa, I did not know that you work in palliative care. It is a wonderful if difficult at times profession, but one for which you can be grateful to be a comfort to many. Bless you for that.

Thanks, so much, Grif; your kind comments humble me and they are much appreciated.

Cap'n and Tai, thank you both.

Bruce that is such a sweet story about your beloved Morfar. I am so glad that you were able to be there for him at that time. I know how hard it was, but you know that he appreciated it and loved you very much.

Michael, sorry for making you cry, but, you know, don't you, that is one of the things about you that makes me care so deeply for you. I have no doubt at all where your heart is, and of your love for others in this human condition we all share.

hrndnwmn: Thank you for your comments. They are much appreciated and i am glad that your aunt found one who cared enough to spend the time necessary to ease her passage. It matters not to me that you are agnostic; your heart shows your compassion.

Thanks, Stephanie, wonderful to have you here again. I am glat you found this post helpful.

Blonde, I am so glad that your father went with peace and dignity, and happy that you could be there to provide him with comfort and assurance. I know that he appreciated that very much. Your kind words mean much to me.

Rolling, yes such things happen. Hospice is the provision of palliative care to one who is dying. The idea is to do everything possible to give comfort and avoid pain in the final time when further medical care would be futile. It can be either in an institutional setting or in the person's home. Dignity, respect for the person, and compassion are the hallmarks of hospice care. Here in rural America most hospice care is done withing the person's own home, where they are comfortable and surrounded by the things and persons they are familiar with and love.

Steve, I am sure that you have seen many deaths and knowing your personality I know that your own sense of care and compassion not only with the dying but with their relatives and loved ones would make you a fine doctor to have near in those circumstances.

Melissa: I know your compassion and how this must have moved you. But I am so glad that you decided to share the story of the death of your grandmother. It is a beautiful and tender story of love and caring, exactly what I would have expected of you. I hope that many people here read your comment. I thank you for your kind comments about me, and I treasure them.

Dr. S, so good to find you here! I am honored. I thank you for your kind and encouraging words.

Eva, thank you. You do important work. And I am so glad that you are comfortable visiting people where they need you. Unfortunately, you are correct and that is no longer much the norm. But I found that visiting the sick, shut-in and dying of the highest calling when I was a pastor. Helping the families through these difficult times was something I took very seriously as well, as I know you do. thanks so much for commenting.

You are more than welcome, Jimenace, I appreciate you reading and commenting.

Patricia K, you are never late and always welcome. I always look forward to knowing that you are reading my posts. Blessings, good lady.

Thanks to all of you, readers, commenters, and wonderful friends all. If there are more comments yet tonight I will catch up with them tomorrow.

If you believe that this post can be of comfort or educational value to others, not just on OS, please feel free to give them the link to the post. I write these posts for all those who might learn and grow and understand the vital necessity of showing compassion, care and hope to one another. We are all on this ride together, and we can lean on and support one another along the way. Spreading that word is vital to the improvement of how we grow as human beings.

God bless you all. And thank you so much.

Monte
Monte, I didn't read this yesterday because I was rushed and was certain that it needed to be read slowly and with concentration; hence, no comments before now.

This is a very moving and wonderful recollection of your education as a minister. It reflects your great wisdom and compassion but also your wonderful humility. I watched someone struggle for months with impending death, so I understand the will those people showed that kept them going while we were away. I saw her finally accept it and understand the sense of relief for the sufferer and sorrow for oneself that one feels when witnessing it. And I am impressed--moved--awed by you.

Bless you for accepting this calling, not just back then, but countless times since. And thank your for writing this.
Monte, you are a human being of the first order. Thank you for the work you have done and for the work you continue to do. God knew what he was doing when he called you.
"And I finally accepted that, if they believed that I was the one whom God had given to them to help them through some of the hardest times of their lives, and even through their deaths, then I would do the best I could to serve them with love, compassion and hope."

Thank you so much for accepting this responsibility. I'm not able to read the comments above because my eyes are currently filled with tears but I will come back. I promise.

When my mother was dying God sent us an Angel. Who understood what my mother, and her family, needed in order for her to pass on.

Maybe someday I will be able to write about our Angel. Until then, she walks in my heart.

Beautiful, Monte.
Monte I had to wait 24 hours after reading your essay to respond. I worked as an oncology nurse for years and eventually began to understand that those who had permission seemed more peaceful and those that did not were not so happy. A quick story: Pediatric oncology nursing has got to have the highest burn out rate in the world, because babies and small children are not supposed to die, right? Chaplains had a hard time with this too.

AudraLynn was 4 and a HALF years old as she liked to point out. The first and only child of a fine young couple, she had been tested, prodded, and poked till she looked like a purple pin cushion. Finally they told the parents there was not anything at this point they could do but would keep on with palliative chemotherapy. At that point a DNR order (do not resuscitate) was placed on the chart. The parents were more than a bit crazed at this point and were looking for anything and everything that would save their little girl.

One morning as I was making morning rounds, I poked my head in and asked how she was feeling. (There was a time gap at that time when both parents had to leave to either go to work or take care of tasks before returning). She looked very downcast, pulling on her ragdolls hair and replied, 'Not too good...my heart is sore today, very sore today.' I took her literally thinking she meant she was in physical pain. She shook her little bald head, 'No my heart is sore because each night Jesus and some angels visit me and tell me they are ready for me to come home when I"m ready. But my mommy and daddy won't let me be ready and say over and over again that I have to keep fighting. I don't know what that means.I'm so tired and I keeping seeing me sleeping in Jesus arms.' Some little girl huh? And I'm talking in my head to G-d: 'Jeez thanks a lot! What the heck do I do now?' So I picked her up, sat down slowly in the rocker and told her she should do whatever she needed to do and not to worry about Mommy and Daddy, because G-d made us nurses there to help them too. ' I held and rocked her for the next 15 minutes as her soul left her body. I was still holding her when her mom came in. To my surprise she just stood there silently, tears streaming down her face. I changed places with mom and went to the desk to call the doctor and then called Dad.'
She was an amazing little girl who's memory has remained with me for the past 30 years. G-d Bless you Monte.
Monte, this is stunning.

I'd never stopped to think about how it must feel for you (priests in general, I guess), to have to shoulder so much responsibility. To me, Priests are second to God, and your final blessings in our family mean the world. Just like we have our babies baptized, the final rites mean a spiritual sending off to heaven with blessings. But what an extraordinary duty to be the one to help the dying to pass in peace.

This is such a touching piece of writing. God bless you Monte Canfield.
Beautiful piece. Teary. Thank you.
Great. Now I am actually sitting at my desk trying not to cry. We have a close friend who is entering into a chaplaincy at a hospice. He tried to explain how he felt it was a different type of a calling than pastoring at our church. Now I understand better.
What a beautiful post. Thank you so much for sharing this memory. I hope when my time comes I have someone so gracious and caring as you to help me let go.
This is very beautiful. I invite you to go to the website of the Buddhist Society of Western Australia. (www.BSWA.org) the Abbott, Ajahn Brahmavamso does all kinds of outreach to areas he also never anticipated! I think you will see some resonance there. I admire and respect your path and your journey and thank you for sharing it.
Thanks so much for the additional readers and commenters. I am humbled.

Pligrim, so glad that you were able to find time to read this post. Your compliments are most appreciated.

Hello, COS, dear friend. I much appreciate seeing you here again.

Gracielou, I would love to read about the one who was there for your Mom and your family when your Mom died. But I know how very hard it is to write about something like that. Still, you know in your heart and that is such a comfort for you.

Patie: your comment is heart rending and heart warming. Little AudraLynn was very blessed to have you there when she needed you the most. I bless you for that. And I do hope that those who read this post will take the time to read your comment as well. It was such a difficult thing that you had to offer, but that peace meant so much to that girl. God bless you.

Karin, I always feel good when I know you have read something of mine. You were one of my very first friends on OS and will remain so to me. Thanks for your kind comments.

Thank you, Beth. I am glad that you like this post.

Blue in TX, I shed some tears as I wrote this so there is no reason to worry about shedding some when reading it. I am glad that this post helps you better understand the very different kind of ministry hospice chaplaincy is. Since most hospice situations here in a rural area are done in the home I have been a hospice chaplain as well as a pastor for many years. Always it is a very difficult but important ministry.

nofrillsmonkey: you are more than welcome.

Poet LS: glad to have you reading. I shall look up the web site you recommend.

God bless you all, and thank you.

Monte
I always felt I received more from being with someone dying than I gave. What do we have to give, after all, but thoughtful words and prayers. I felt like I had felt after witnessing a birth, that I had been allowed to be part of something sacred.
Thank you, Jim. You have captured the essence of what it can be like when we share that time with someone. God bless.

Monte
Very powerful. Due to my past chaplaincy experience and present family situation, this really hits home.
Thank you, Mama Lou, much appreciate your comments.

Monte
This is more than WOW, Monte ~~ a piece that was difficult for me to make all the way through knowing that the process will be hitting close to home soon.

I am thankful *you'll* be there.

BR
Thanks so much, BR. I will be here for my OS friends if I can be of any help at all through troubled times. So always know that I am as close as a PM.

Monte
I smiled at Rolling's question. It baffles us from India. Most older people stay with families and each has their own intricacies of relationships which decides what their deathbed situation will be. But there are so many living who need so much that palliative care during the final moments "seems" a luxury no one has thought too much about yet. There was a time when just getting to Kasi Viswanath was enough. Now not so.
Dying with dignity is important but I still do not get the relevance of having to be UCC membership-ped and recommended by pastor to get the care and love? Does religion have anything to do with this? I would have thought being human would be the criteria. But I may have missed something.Too distracted.
Good work Monte . Good work.
Hi, Traveler. Customs vary obviously. At least I think it is obvious. What is not so obvious is which customs are necessarily superior to others. That becomes an opinion.

Palliative care is a fairly modern concept in the US, adopted from a Brittish model. It arose because, again an American custom, our medical profession has been intent upon taking every conceivable step necessary to try to prolong life, of whatever dubious quality, long after there was any real chance of a meaningful existence.

And loved ones often want that done because they want to believe that they have done everything possible to "fight" disease and death. Some have, lately, in the last thirty years or so, realized that dying with dignity, with love, compassion and pain management, when there is very little chance that further extraordinary measures would be of any benefit and only make quality of life worse, turned to hospice options rather than intensive, emotionally sterile, hospital care.

As for the need to have UCC membership and recommendation of a UCC pastor for admittance to that particular retirement home where I served, that has nothing to do with getting care and love. It has to do with the stipulations of the endowment of the Home. None of these homes could exist or operate without private gifts from wealthy benefactors. There is no government subsidy of such places in the US.

Similar, essentially identical, care is available at private secular facilities. In the US there are Methodist homes, Catholic homes, Presbyterian homes, etc. and there are far fewer Christian homes than there are both public and secular homes. And most people cannot afford to go to a retirement home at all.

Perhaps you do not also realize that those denominations operate hospitals, open to all, as well as retirement homes. Such denominational hospitals were, in fact, the original hospitals within the colonies, before we became a nation. But almost all religious retirement homes, as opposed to hospitals, in the US have some restrictions since they were founded by and for the churches they are affiliated with. And none could operate for long on the income from the residents, most of whom have little or no assets.

I know it is hard to understand these customs, and there is no need to agree with them. I feel that you think that there is something inferior in the way we do things here compared to the ways to which you are accustomed. Perhaps so. I have no way to judge, nor would I if I did. And, perhaps things are perfect nowhere.

Thanks for commenting.

Monte
((Monte)) - another reader with tears in her eyes. Your story and Patie's have touched me deeply today. Glad that you were able to hear and respond to God's call and to be present to those in the hospice. I have to wonder about a seminary student like the one before you who would not work with the sick and the dying.
Hey, Dusty, thanks for your kind comments. Increasingly today seminary students are not inclined to spend much if any time visiting, going to hospitals, shut-ins, etc. So many pastors are ill equipped to do such things in their ministries. I know many pastors who do the absolute minimum of pastoral care in the hospital, rehab centers, retirement homes, etc. I think it is a real shame that happens, but it does, and all too often.

Monte
Actually quite the opposite Monte. I think the loving care of family is getting to be rarer all around the world. I smiled only because I know the feeling of confusion about the issue back home. One is such a quandry as to what is "right" . People do deserve end of life in dignity and I absolutely agree. No arguments from me there. I only wondered about the role of religion in that. But you have explained it quite well and I applaud you. We are in agreement as usual.
Shall visit again and again......
Its simply my curious nature. I question everything...........
What's that saying, "God never gives us anything we can't handle"? I have all the admiration and respect for you Monte, and I was very happy to see this on the Cover.
Thank you, Mary. I was actually very surprised to see it on the cover, but am glad that it got that extra exposure.

Monte
Oh Monte, this was beautiful. Thank you so much for sharing the difficulties you had with this "job." I gave my mom and my son..."permission" and it was both heartwrenching and humbling. But there was an extraordinary peace that followed. The Lord gave me the strength as he gave you. Hospice is a godsent service and this proves it, once again. You (and the insightful comments that have followed) have given everyone that reads this a better understanding of the peace that can come with death. As always your words inspire and educate. Bless ya, chaplain! Now I must go wipe the tears. This post will stay with me for quite a while!
Monte, this has really broken me down, but in a good way. I cried when you got back from your time away and they were all waiting for you. I cried with you as you left each room, telling them it was okay to let go. That must have been so difficult to do. This was really an incredibly touching and important story to share. I have never read or heard a pastor talk about this aspect of their calling. So well-written (as usual). Perhaps you will consider submitting it to a magazine for publishing.
All the best to you, Monte.
Nothing I say will completely describe what my heart feels right now. Just know that it's all good and I feel blessed by what you've written and shared. God bless you!
I am really sorry that I have not replied to these comments until now. I usually catch later comments when OS notifies me by email, but these slipped through.

Thanks so much, Fab. It must have been very hard regarding your Mom and your son, but in a very real way it was a gift to them knowing that they did not have to "hold on and keep fighting" out of obligation to you. Yours was an act of absolute selflessness.

Thank you, Kay. The funny thing is that in all the years since it has never gotten easier to tell someone it is OK to let go and let God take care of them from that point onward. But I know that it has to be done. I will let this be the only publishing that gets done on this. I do not have any interest to try to publish anything I write for profit. In fact, I don't even copyright any of it and have told several pastors through the years that anything I have is theirs for the taking. Many have taken me up on that since they find it hard to write, or to deliver sermons for that matter. So if I can help them get the point across so much the better. I do ask that they acknowledge the source, either from the pulpit or in the bulletin. I am so glad that this spoke to you.

Thanks so much, WWings, that means a lot to me. It is nice to see you going back and reading some of my earlier posts. That is much appreciated and I hope you get something out of all of them.

God bless you all.

Monte
What a great post! Talk about making a difference....
Thank you, Kathy. Much appreciate your reading of this post.

Monte
What a moving post once again Monte!
Hi, Anne. Thanks for reading and commenting. It was a very moving and humbling experience that I will never forget.

Monte