Moderates of All Nations, Unite!

We Have Everything to Lose.
JANUARY 8, 2011 6:09PM

The Poisoned Fruit of Right-Wing Hatemongering

Rate: 1 Flag

Following is a comment I posted elsewhere.  Sorry for the hasty post...

I'd be extremely surprised if there were not a demonstrable connection between right-wing Republican (and, yes, libertarian) anti-government and anti-liberal rhetoric and the recent shooting of Democratic Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords of Arizona.  (BTW, the last report I heard on NPR was that Giffords was out of surgery and in critical condition, but doctors seemed hopeful; and a previous report that she was dead was acknowledged to be wrong.  Unfortunately, some of her aides, and a ten-year-old child, were not so lucky.)

Republicans, some libertarians, and a lot of loonies have been portraying Big Gummint as an evil implacable alien entity that had to be starved and drowned in the bathtub, ever since 1980. Right-wingers have been attacking the very legitimacy of our elected government, and calling liberals "baby killers," for almost as long.  Sarah Palin has been raving about "death panels" that want to kill our grandmothers. Add to that the innumerable instances of misdirection, scapegoating, religious fanaticism, and outright bigoted lies we've been hearing from the Republicans (not to mention those orchestrated mob-disruptions of Democratic public appearances that started the Tea Party movement), and you'd be an idiot not to expect incidents like this.

If Sarah Palin recently removed her "targeting" crap from her website (example here), that's pretty much an admission that her camp knows full well there's a connection between this incident and their rhetoric.

More on this on this Dispatches from the Culture Wars thread.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
You are so right that you can't discount this hate speech as a contributing factor in this shooting.
I think you are establishing a rather problematic, certainly very superficial link between reactionary politics and the bloodbath in question. You have completely discarded the fact that the man who is responsible for this incident was indeed a very sick one. Had this not been the case he would scarcely have been affected by the nasty propaganda which shows that hateful propaganda hardly matter as long as people don't descend into madness. You are proposing treating the symptoms not the origins of the problem. What really needs to happen is that people must learn to responsible for their own lives and not to blame bad fortune on those who aren't responsible. This would mean that in the case of the young man, I'm sure that some pretty nasty things happened to him on the way but that these were purely coincidental. But instead of acknowledging this, he blamed liberal America, which might be nasty but is not responsible for whatever it was that drove him into madness. In your case, I think this means that you should acknowledge that incidents like the shooting sometimes occur and the reasons for why they happened are very deep-seeded. By blaming the reactionaries, as narrow-minded as they might be, you are adopting a scape-goating mentality, the very same thing that the young man did, if an opposite and not nearly as damaging way.
Adrian:

Extremely good rebuttal. However, considering the fact the right-wing wears NRA emblems on their cars, and this very sick young man (as you correctly pointed out) was able to gain access to the firearms he used in his attempted mass murder.

Last I read he was deemed mentally unfit to stand trial. That is quite rare in Arizona, and reserved only for the truly mentally ill.

But he is as much of victim of the rhetoric discussed in this post, as are the protesters being tased and maced for exercising their right to free speech. It's only free in this country if you're conservative, the rest of us have to pay their bills.