It’s hot. It’s too hot to do anything, so I’m bored. I’m cranky because I’m bored. I take no responsibility for anything that follows. Or I take full responsibility. Same difference.
There are a lot of things about OS that mystify me. One continuing puzzle is the people who use it as some sort of adjunct to Twitter, like the irritating Claudia Corrigan Darcy. Every time Claudia Corrigan Darcy tells me where she’s currently having coffee in NYC, I want to call in my airborne precision-bombing strike force to take her out, but the collateral damage would be too great, so for that reason, and the fact that I don’t really have an airborne precision-bombing strike force, she gets to live. Similarly, I’d like to eject Planet Russell from this solar system, but I am waiting on Nibiru to do that for me. I have nothing against these people personally, but I don’t see why they get to have post titles way in excess of the 60 characters doled out to the rest of us peasants, when they’re not even posting content. Pft.
Not to start anything up again (although if you do – I’ll be happy to watch, because I’m bored), but what I have been thinking about mostly of late is the persistent formation of new and longevity of old posses. I think there’s a misunderstanding by many that various corners of OS are ruled by cliques. There are no cliques, people. We are all much too disagreeable to form cliques. Cliques like each other, or they pretend they do. Cliques require a much more formal society, where people agree to behave by certain rules. OS is the internet, and the internet is the Wild West. So I like to think of OS as Dodge City, with a lot of people fighting over who gets to be Marshal Dillon, and who isn't speaking to Miss Kitty, and whether Chester should be fired. This is where the posses come in.
These days forming posses in the real world seems a mite too close to vigilante stuff, and/or idiotic, and as such, is not looked on with favor by people of couth. But you can become a member of a posse on OS, easy. You can even create your own personal posse, if you are willing to dedicate significant time and effort to rounding up people who may or may not respond the way you want them to, and that’s the trick. OS posses are mostly (not all, but mostly) self-forming, like that skin on milk that shows up if you bring it to a boil, or maybe the way iron filings clump up around magnets. There are few internal connections. As such, they are changeable, but there’s usually a core of filings that sticks tight to the magnet through the OS equivalent of hell and high water.
Posses form for one simple reason. The members of posses aspire to have posses themselves, and the quid pro quo system reigns here. It doesn’t actually work, but it reigns anyway, because hope springs eternal in the human breast (Alexander Pope).
The Benefits of Posses!. Posses give you unconditional love. No one in the real world will love you as unconditionally as your posse, except for your dog. Your therapist, your parents, your kids, your siblings, your various spouses – all of them know you too well. But posses don’t have to know the creepy stuff like that you’re estranged from your family not because they’re all raving lunatics but because you are, and you left town after you stole your mother-in-law’s heirloom pearls to fund your meth lab start-up. Oh, heck. Even if your posse knew that about you, they’d say that bitch put too much value on those lousy pearls anyway, and they’re so proud of you for following your business dream.
2. Posses will receive any posts as genius. You can slap up a youtube video of paint drying, and say “I like paint,” and your posse will drop by to say cheering things like “Great post!” or “Brilliant choice!” or “I know what you mean. Keep up the good work.” If you put up a slight different video of paint drying the next day, your posse will be just as enthusiastic! It’s a big time-saver. But if you actually manage to get yourself to tap out a couple of paragraphs, your posse will have conniption fits, weeping or laughing hysterically, depending on what you’ve specified in your tags. Your mom would never be half as obliging.
3. Posses will go out on their own looking for varmints who disrespect you, defending your name even while you are holed up in a cave in a read-only mode after making a complete fool of yourself about Darwinism or the New World Order or Joan Walsh being a Russian spy. They will say things like “Anyone fucking with my girl/boy is going to have to go through me first!” which – okay, I don’t really know what this means on-line, but it sounds good. This has to be very gratifying. Especially if they threaten to kill people for you. They won’t, of course, but it’s fun to pretend you’re the Sopranos.
4. Posses are a renewable resource. Even if your old posse gets disenchanted with you, a new one will come along soon. They won’t know about the meth lab and Joan Walsh’s restraining order, and you can start all over again. Although you need to find the ones who will stay amiable, i.e. the nice ones, or at least the ones who think of themselves as nice. Because otherwise they may drop out of your posse and join the anti-posse, if you do something stupid like calling them the spawn of Satan one time too many. But these are the not-nice people, so who cares?
The Drawbacks of Posses
For every posse that exists, there is an anti-posse, which by default is made up of the spawn of Satan. The anti-posse often riles up the posse so much they self-combust. This is what causes flame wars. Dust-ups if you will. What posses never understand is that the anti-posses are completely unregulated – just as unregulated as posses themselves! They are constantly shifting, depending on who dislikes whom more that particular day. Anti-posses are those people who can’t stay away from reading the posse’s magnet’s blog, but who would rather be eaten alive by weasels than rate or comment, unless the posse’s magnet posts something so egregiously crazy/dopey/offensive/ignorant/whatever they cannot resist taking a whack. Often people in an antiposse can’t stand each other, either, so they rarely present a united front. It just looks like it to the posse, which is the beauty of it all.
Posses and anti-posses act like the ions in an atom, repelling each other so they are in constant motion, until the nucleus can’t take it anymore and flounces or goes into hiding. And thus the phrase “getting out of Dodge.” Then everyone settles down again. It’s the mysterious circle of life.


Salon.com
Comments
Reckon what is next, the truth squads??
Owl - thanks. It would probably be best if it rained, though.
This must mean I am a member of your posse.
In truth: it was funny and right on the money.
Alas, too true. I've seen posts that were virtually void of content, and they get 50, 60, 70 thumbs up. And I can only think "rated for what???" Rated because someone hit the "publish" button?
That wouldn't be a problem except that such posts fill the activity queue with unearned ratings and worthless comments, thus depriving quality posts of the attention they should get. Bad posts drive out good posts and discourage good writers.
D Art - you can be in my posse or be a spawn of Satan. Your choice.
really i just came back to rate this. missed it the first time. it's sat. nite. My bottle of wine is calling. have fun.
I'd rather eat a bug than engage in posse stuff although, I guess, I could be accused once or twice of anti-posseism. I did always admire the fringe element in high school. What's that line...better to be killed as a lion than a lamb...? Either way, you get killed. It's a bit vanilla these days on OS. The flame wars, at least, keep things spicy.
hyblaean-Julie - mille grazie.
Estellar Expectations - Buffy fan boards, absolutely. I wonder if it's some form of internet mass hysteria.
(R)ated PG13...(you know who you are)!
Honest to frangipani, this has to be one of the Best Metas Evah and of course, it comes from one of the magnets around here - and I'm attracted to you. (ha!) This is going to my highly vaulted, widely lauded, hardly ever read LH homepage catalogue under How To Rock On OS whether you like it or not. It's no tiara, but a girl can tip her hat can't she?
OH!!!! Like that wasn't enough!!!! Now you got WarmDouche and TheJudge164 both just straight out calling me a p*ssy. Typical passive-aggressive bullshit!!!!! You think I don't know you put them up to it? YOU FUCKING THINK I DON"T KNOW?
NAMASTE!
Is that the anti posse thing you’re talking about? I originally got to commenting on OS because it was easy to pick a fight here, but the problem became apparent that too many of the people actually take what they post (or comment) seriously.
I’ve decided the “literary” side is more fun, if somewhat more prone to hurt feelings- Taken altogether, you are well meaning and caring people. I started to post here mainly as an incentive to make myself write and a way to “archive” drafts of stuff I mean to write a book about someday.(don’t we all)
Robin Sneed and Doug Socks were the two people with posses that I followed, and it seemed to me that the had their posses mainly because they are genuinely caring and intelligent people, who turned away snarks with humor. I look forward to the return of both and remind all to please stay aware of what is happening with Robin (See Poor Woman’s Retro Blog) and please help. That said I found them both by reading comments they’d made, and following them to their posts.
Of all the people whose posse I want to join, Yuselof the Worms seems like it might be the most interesting.
So Yuselof, please post something so that we can rally to your flag.
Great post, rated
Granted, a mediocre piece shouldn't deserve a four-hour placement on the feed if its success denies a slot to a superior posting. And this happens, I'm sure, far too often. And yet, there are constituencies that benefit from the better mediocre pieces, which they are less apt to find if the better pieces are bumped from the feed by those of lesser merit, thus depriving the mediocre constituencies from the challenge of something meatier than, say, an uninspired recipe for smoked hotdogs and sauerkraut.
This is where the claque companion to the clique can benefit both ends of the mediocre outlook - reader and contributor. I'll inject at this point a mini-argument that the traditional posse formed ad hoc to chase down a desperado, and, mission accomplished or bandit escaped, then disbanded. The modern posse, of course, as re-invented by the gangsta subculture, is more akin to the high school clique, complete with magnet and command structure usually based on a descending scale of personality strengths and little else. Members may squabble amongst themselves and struggle for advantages within the hierarchical relationships, but they present a unified front to outsiders and rival gangs.
Same as the OS coalescings, where members at a pinnacle of regard by his or her circle of "friends" are typically called "queen" or "queen bee." That these are female designations points to the fact that most of these groupings tend to be matriarchal. While men may align themselves with a grouping, I have yet to see any reference to a "king" or "king rat" in the unguarded banter.
Holy shit, it's 03:20 and I'm about to crash into my keyboard. What the fuck is wrong with me? Going to bed now. G'nite, my queen, wherever you are.
actually, that is exactly what happened during the last 'dust-up'. It was a group of people, not usually a clique trying to run off a troll. I was there, start to finish. The back and forth later on the 4 hr feed had nothing to do with the initial purpose, and actually had completely different people involved.
Nice with a cuppa coffee and calmer by a long shot.
@Julie - Your mentioning a specific incident here and relegating some poster to the dustbin of trolldom might strike folks who care about such things as passive aggressive. To my understanding, a "troll" is someone whose sole intent is to disrupt a discussion among others in a "fie on all your houses" manner. I recall no dust-up in the nearly 7 months I've been on OS where that situation existed. A dynamic whereby one poster offers an opinion that's unpopular with a certain group hardly meets the "troll" standard, especially if other members support the "unpopular" point of view - unless you are affixing the "troll" label on all who support the original offender. Then, I suppose, one might consider the dust-up to be a fracas between the Posse of Righteousness Indignation and the Merry-But-Despicable Band of Trolls, with plenty of bystanders making side bets and egging on their favorites.
Sounds like fun.
It is so true, and very frustrating for those of us who want critiques and validation on our writing and communication skills and strive to gain ratings for such to continually see our efforts surpassed by a wide margin (in terms of ratings) those posts devoid of content or individual effort...like youtube videos etc. Yet this is a social site and there needs to be room for all modes of connectivity.
It becomes a catch 22 because you may genuinely LIKE those folks who are simply not attached to or focused on writing necessarily and you want to let them know this, and the protocol for validation here is through ratings.
Technically, yes, there is the option to comment alone, but what does that say? "I know you are here, and I like you but not what you've posted." And we can all tell who has left a comment and not rated.
Perhaps if there were two categories for rating, those folks using OS as primarily a social site would find fulfillment and those aiming more specifically at improving their writing and creative expression could similarly find validation.
As for the whole posse phenomenon, I've noticed that factions exist with core members and then the casual 'guests' waft in and out of the comment zone. I suppose it falls back to the old adage of 'like attracting like'. Those core members are more in sync with one another while the others are either just curious or in search of variety.
I dunno....
Great post, though!
Really, Matt???? You're gonna say that after doing a whole post about The Thundering Thoth-baiters? Or maybe we should cull through your comments where you discuss Thoth / the Judge / stellaa / emma/ etc.????
@ Julie: No, Matt understands perfectly well. He just seems to have an issue with any woman that calls him on his occasional sexist / homophobic / misogynistic comments. That certainly would include Stellaa, emma and me (BTW, welcome to the "clique" you too, now!) That's why, in HIS mind anyways, he can tacitly support or at best disregard the attacks against others with whom he disagrees.
I don't believe that he philosophically supports trollism, he just doesn't see anything wrong with thinking that women should keep quiet and one step to the rear of the much smarter men folk and deserve a good smack if they aren't..
Bottom line is that you've got to understand that Matt sees himself as a "Posse of One". He doesn't want it that way, in fact he'd love to be included in a clique or a posse or better yet have one of his own. I'm guessing that things like that are important to him.
I don't like posses. there's no reasoning with them because they become a mega empowered, single organism, like a fast moving centipede in a mission of war.
it's easy to be in one but it requires an immense amount of behind the scenes work and shmoozing and paling and confessing and tippy tapping on the keyboard, late into the night and I just don't have that desire. the payoff isn't there.
someone gets a bee up it's ass and the next thing you know you're off and running and collectively being an asshole of sorts.
because face it, it's never never benevolent. unless it's about one of the insiders. so fuck that.
rated
Sorry about your trees. I hope they don't leave your yard looking too naked.
Bernadine - Dogpatch posse, forthwith. You don't have a chainsaw, do you?
Kellylark - no dispute there, but the underbrush has gotten a lot thicker. I don't have the patience I did a year ago, either.
Sheila TGTG55 - Alexander Pope also said "to err is human" just in case I'm wrong.
MAWB - I'd also like a front porch, sob.
lawyagurl - And then when you get comments and ratings you have to be all nice and respond, and try to do it in order or you look like a jerk. Who told you to use spell check??? Because it that's a rule, we got us a few scofflaws around here. Ever looked at the titles these people post?
"And yet, there are constituencies that benefit from the better mediocre pieces, which they are less apt to find if the better pieces are bumped from the feed by those of lesser merit, thus depriving the mediocre constituencies from the challenge of something meatier than, say, an uninspired recipe for smoked hotdogs and sauerkraut."
I'm confused. Are you saying it could be worse? I.e., there's crappy, there's crappier, and there's crappiest, and if it weren't for the crappier levees, we'd be awash in the crappiest?
I can't address this bee stuff, because I'll lurch into something about hives, and we've already got Dodge City and magnets and milk scum and ions and sausage running simultaneously, and it's TOO MUCH. I feel like I’m on a metaphorical Tilt-a-Whirl.
Mission - I certainly felt more peaceful at 5:24 A.M.
Kathy - tak so myket.
Nope. False alarm. Darn.
micalpeace - the magic words are "Great post!" but you're in anyway.
lunchlady 2 - give me another two weeks of this and I can prove you wrong. But thanks!
ThroughMyEyes - the better outfits are always worn by the group you're in, so you can pick either! I have a feeling both wear heels during flame wars.
(Maybe I should change that to the Lone Ranger?)
===== http://www.shopstrade.us ====
jordan air max oakland raiders $34–39;
Ed Hardy AF JUICY POLO Bikini $25;
Christan Audigier BIKINI JACKET $25;
gstar coogi evisu true jeans $35;
coach chanel gucci LV handbags $36;
coogi DG edhardy gucci t-shirts $18;
CA edhardy vests.paul smith shoes $32;
jordan dunk af1 max gucci shoes $37;
EDhardy gucci ny New Era cap $16;
coach okely Adidas CHANEL DG Sunglass $18;
===== http://www.shopstrade.us ====
Matt you "... don't recall ever visiting Kim's."...Then who left this :
"I almost flagged this because it was too good. I mean, OS surely doesn't want stuff here that's too good, that intimidates those of us who are striving for adequacy. I changed my mind when it occurred to me that if they banned you, that would be bad." ... ?
And what am I to make of any other comments ?
Meow.
PinpinLin - I'm having a hard time visualizing a bikini jacket.
Kim - hijack away. I don't mind. It's another intriguing OS mystery to me. The subject, I mean, not the hijacking.
Token Tarheel - I don't think posses or antiposses have the fine hand-eye coordination to succeed at an actual lynching. I have seen a lot of people shoot themselves in the foot.
Cindy Ross! Of course you can be in my posse after that. Yeah, Jonathan Swift - highly overrated.
Ablonde - yeah, that one's been run into the ground now.
Flame wars will look like birthday candles by comparison...
This is also why I will freely comment on and get in on the "dust ups."
This all serves a purpose, it's not futile and not as stupid as it seems at first blush. It is one of the ways we know people are not just robots on here: they are behaving like human beings, flaws and all.
"But these are the not-nice people, so who cares?"
Well I think that statement as sarcasm just kind of shows you might not have been privy to the joys of having 'trolls' obsesses over you and make you the reason they sign on to the Internet and they have serious mental problems and expect to project them on you w/o my fees being paid in advance (like I require for that level of insanity).
Because this is all online, we all need to learn to say "I don't care about you and you're stupid account can burn for all I care."
Progressive Liberal - bees again? Maybe I really should have gone with hives and killer bees and and die-offs. Eh, next year. I bet trolls don't pay when they miss an appointment, either.