The day before, there had been thousands of people demonstrating against the brutal stripping and beating of women protesters at the hands of the Military Police. But on Saturday, when I went to Tahrir Square for the first time since March of this year, it was quiet and somewhat bedraggled: tattered flag banners ringed the remnants of a tent city served by makeshift stands selling tea or roast corn on the cob. Of the people lounging around, not all looked like young protesters; there were some older men in farmer garb and some who looked like homeless vagrants. There wasn't a policeman in sight, but car traffic circled around the square unimpeded under the direction of Tahrir civilian volunteers.
Earlier that week clashes had resulted in several deaths and scores of injured demonstrators calling for an end to the military power grab and an immediate transition to civilian rule. It must be a bitter irony to the young liberals who spilled their blood for that cause that those who stood to gain most by their sacrifice- the Islamist parties- had been conspicuously absent from the struggle. A transition to civilian rule would inevitably mean handing over power to a parliament dominated by the Muslim Brotherhood who, together with the Salafis as a junior partner, have won the first two rounds of elections by a landslide.
There is that sense in Egypt today, of a revolution hijacked, gone awry. Some people shake their heads, speak of a lost generation, of emigration, if not for them, then for their children. Things will get worse before they get better, they say.
The anxiety over the economic crisis is the most acute and pervasive. A stark case in point is the Mena House Oberoi, the landmark hotel where world leaders once held meetings against the stupendous backdrop of the Giza pyramids. I had lunch there today, and it was sadly empty of guests: the vast expanse of hotel reception rooms and restaurants with their gorgeous Mamluke-style wood paneling and coffered ceilings; the pools; the annexes under construction: all empty but for a handful of tourists. Seeing me look around nostalgically at the familiar landmarks of one of the fabled hotels of my youth, the eager-to-please staff offered to show me the Churchill suite; they hope against hope for better days. But we were all aware that, with some Salafi spokesmen spewing the most ignorant and prejudiced propositions imaginable on the media, the tourists were keeping away in droves.
A final incident comes to mind. Traffic was bad on the way to the hotel via the Pyramids Road, so we decided to try an alternate route on the way back- the 6th October Axis bypass. In the middle of the fast-moving traffic on the busy highway, an accident occurred. The engine of the car involved was spewing smoke, and the man in the car looked in imminent danger of the engine blowing up. While we were trying to figure out how to call the police, we saw a man on a passing bus leap off and rush to the aid of the trapped motorist, smashing the window to open the jammed car door. Hard on his heels came two other rescuers. All three of the Good Samaritans sported the typical Islamist beard.


Salon.com
Comments
He was too corrupt in what was the remains of Nasser to build enough credible liberals, and divided them too, and then you have the Brotherhood patiently waiting all those years, never gone, even encouraged by Sadat, if fatally so in some ways, and what was one to do when the protests started?
Either way, just as an American, the potential for a loss was very high once the protests started. If the Army turns out like at Tiananmen, then we lose, and of course do does Egypt, even if he's in power, it's just sullen resentment everywhere. If we throw Mubarak under the bus,which we didn't completely do, we lose with some probability if the Islamits end up on top, which of course wasn't a for sure thing, but, not unlikely either. If there had been a peace deal between Israel and the Palestinians, that might have really helped per in Gaza, but... too far apart parties don't usually do that, and didn't do that. Still trying to be optimistic, but, it's not really looking so good.
In the end, like Hourani said in his History of the Arab Peoples, liberalism is too much associated with the West, and has always been more popular among "Heliopolis" than the mass. Sorry that's working out that way too, as it started out so hopeful, if always with that risk.
the young people in the square succeeded in causing enough trouble to dislodge the face of military control, but the army remained in control, so it was just 'plus ca change.'
the islamists deserve to prosper, in whatever civilian government is twisted out of the military, because they have been 'revolting' not for weeks, but for generations.
they have organization, they have ideals, they have roots in the nation built on service. how should they not prosper ahead of any disorganized mob?
Papa Johns Coupons