and if my thought-dreams could be seen

they'd probably put my head in a guillotine

Natalie Not Pedantic

Natalie Not Pedantic
Location
Australia
Birthday
November 01
Bio
“If I lose the light of the sun, I will write by candlelight, moonlight, no light. If I lose paper and ink, I will write in blood on forgotten walls. I will write always. I will capture nights all over the world and bring them to you.” Henry Rollins ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

MY RECENT POSTS

Natalie Not Pedantic's Links

Fabulousness
MAY 14, 2009 9:05PM

Slumdog Millionaire Stars Homeless

Rate: 22 Flag

 

azharuddin

Photograph of Azharuddin Ismail in the ruins of his home taken from the TimesUK online

When I watched Slumdog Millionaire, I was inspired. The story was touching and the actors did such a fantastic job of bringing the characters to life. You may have heard about the recent outcry at the children that starred in a movie that won 8 Academy Awards and took in over $326,000,000 have reaped none of the benefits. They are still living in poverty in the slums they resided in prior to their 'immense good fortune'.

Today I read that Azharuddin Ismail, who played Salim as a child in the movie, has had his shanty demolished. Prior to the demolition, the tarpaulin-covered home provided some sort of shelter from the elements, but had no running water and an open sewer running along the side of it. Azharuddin is 9 years old and now he and his family are homeless. They have a couple of broken suitcases of clothing and utensils. The government in Mumbai promised housing for Azharuddin and his co-star Rubina Ali months ago. It obviously hasn't materialised.

From the Times UK:

"A police officer took a bamboo stick to hit me, and I was frightened," Azharuddin said. “We have nowhere to go. All our belongings and other household goods have been thrown out or damaged. We don’t know what we will eat today,”

It is thought that about 20 other children who appeared in the Oscar-winning film were also left homeless by the demolition drive, which was carried out to clear drainage paths before next month’s monsoon.

Slumdog Millionaire dazzled audiences around world and won eight Oscars, but its makers have been criticised for not sharing more of the profits with the two child actors that they plucked from shantytowns.

Fears were raised over their wellbeing last month when another child star, Rubina Ali, 9, was allegedly offered for sale by her slumdweller father for £200,000. The father denied the story and police said that they found no evidence against him.

Slumdog was made for £15 million and went on to gross £225 million at the box office. The leading child actors are thought to have been paid about £2,000 each, but Christian Colson and Danny Boyle, the British producer and director, have denied being unfair.

Azharuddin and Rubina were found places in a school — the first they had attended — that specialises in educating disadvantaged children. If they remain in school until they are 18 they will receive a “significant lump-sum”. The families are also given a fixed monthly amount towards living expenses. The filmmakers have also pledged to buy the children houses, as has a local Mumbai politician — promises yet to be fulfilled."

 

This is grossly unfair. While Colson and Boyle are living large off the fame and the money that came from this movie, the people who are living it's reality are suffering.

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
this is unbelievable. they made $326,000,000 and they couldn't set these kids and their families up somewhere in real houses? real classy.
it's foul, natalie. i am glad you posted this. i have thought about it many times, but people tell me it is not the director's fault, but the producer's fault. but those producers should be shamed into helping those kids.

of course, shame is in short supply among those who most deserve it.
somebody told me just this evening about these kids, and it seems pretty shitty they can't find the time to do right by them.

i love your new banner btw:)
Nana, it's a joke isn't it?

Jane, I love what you wrote there about shame. It IS in short supply. These men think they've done their bit to help the kids, but promises of a significant amount in 10 years doesn't help kids who might not make it through the month.

Drew, thank you. Nana made it for me.
"art imitates life"
"life imitates art"
looks like hollywood is a mirror for the exploitation in india.. in more ways than one, eh?
ps freida pinto is HOT
I heard that a trust was set up for the kids, but this indicates some pretty stupid mismanagement of affairs. The Producers had to know that some due diligence would be required in a foreign country where uneducated parents and corrupt officials would just about promise problems.

It's too bad that they already have their money!
by the way, dont forget-- for every Azharuddin and Rubina there are thousands, tens of thousands, of others.. who are not as photogenic. and have suffered much greater tragedies and hardships.. why are you focused on whether they in particular get a house or not? if they did, would your conscience be soothed?
As a veteran of the film industry myself, I can't say this surprises me. It does however leave me wanting to punch somebody.
Can those film-makers sleep at night? Can they enjoy their comfortable lifestyles without feeling any remorse? How can film-makers accomplish a great film, being at the same time be such bastards? Very good and timely post Nat, congrats.
The film concluded with a happy ending. For your $7 (or $9 or however many dollars you spent, plus popcorn), did we really expect anything else? Think about that every time you walk into Walmart or any other big box store and "think"you got a deal. The producers and directors sure did. *That's* "entertainment". It's abominable.
yes, it is sad.
Good for you, I hate the idea that this story is just going to go away. It was totally exploitive to use their images to sell movie tickets and than toss them back into the streets. The BBC should check on these kids every six months and produce biannual documentaries like they did with those kids in the 70's.

Then again, if they were American child stars they might have ended up with Danny Bonaduce's life.;)

And the banner is Bettylicious!
It is grossly unfair for any child to have to live in this kind of poverty, and sickening not to be able to help them all. However, we do what we can, and one thing certainly in the grasp of these filmmakers and producers is using their profits to improve the lives of their young stars. Leaving them homeless? Immoral. Keep at it Natalie; rated and dugg.
vzn, I'm not focused on anybody in particular. The children in this movie are a part of the story, and should therefore be a part of it's success.

Zuma, I worry that the kids won't make it to the age where the trust fund could help them and what they will go through in the meantime. The cynic in me also wonders if promises of a trust fund will actually come to fruition in 10 years time when the movie is a distant memory for most.

Trey, me too.

Thank you, Marcela

Cartouche, it really is abominable. Enough money was made for everyone to be rewarded for a job well done.

Jeremy, I think that if the media made a big enough deal about this, the guys that made the movie would be shamed into doing something for the kids. Maybe they will. I hope so.

Annette, thank you. Morality seems to get left behind in the pursuit of the almighty dollar.
Okay - for lack of more eloquance, and because it's getting late in my time zone: god-damn stupid fuckheads - this is fucking shitty! Eh-Hem - I think I meant to say, this is wrong, and should not stand. I am apalled at the idiocy and lack of compassion. Thanks for posting this!
Life is hard. What entitles these children to any more than the children living in the street next to them? Because they were cute children and could be cast in a movie makes them more deserving of a decent life? Ask the other children their thoghts on the matter. It's sad that children have to live this way at all, but to say the children in this movie are more deserving than any other child is what's shameful. Perhaps every movie should lend its proceeds to helping the children of the world, but that's just not the way things work. I have always been of the belief that our celebritites are overpaid. This is just the example of the time when they weren't. Fair? No. But that's the reality of life.
Owl, that's more or less what I thought when I read it.

David, no child deserves to live in poverty. I'm sure we all agree on that but as I wrote in the comments section, these children worked on this movie. Not just the two main characters, but the 20 or so other kids who lost their homes today that were in the film. If they were a part of the movie, then the producers should have given them more than 2k and a promise of more at adulthood. I get you're point and I'm not saying these kids are any more special or 'deserving' than their neighbours. I also agree that celebrities and others are paid way too much for the jobs they do.
imho its a systemic problem with capitalism. it seems to be inherently exploitive no matter what country or industry. what are we gonna do about it in the 21st century?
I saw this on the news. The filmmakers said they would help these people -- now they have to.
Nat, thanks for bringing this up. It shows how "far" we've evolved as a species, and it seems that conscience is in short supply during these troubling times.
Natalie,
Looks like India, with its rich spiritual cultural legacy, is just chucking it all away to become more like us. Well, congratulations. Yahoo. Helluva lotta productive bodies to exploit. China too. So much for "widsom of the East". Kentucky Fried Chicken is way big in China, the boob tube informs me. Yum, they all say. Eat yer damn chicken then, crunchy, munchy...

Yikes, your posts get me going, my conscientious friend...well..except for that last one...in the shower, etc....!!!!....a deeply erotic woman with a heart of gold & the biggest conscience in four counties....keep bringing this crap to our attention...maybe somebody somewhere will do something...sad that's all i can say at this time...email gates...or...hey! hanks & howard! with their goofy new movie....angels & demons...Christ had a wife! oh boy, things sure are weird today, no..


Jim, in a goofy loosey-goosey mood...rated
Abominable - It seems sometimes we are still cannibals...

We feed of off each other, so help me - this is almost surreal... but all too real.

peece,
dj
I really appreciated jane's "shame is in short supply" comment. so apropos here. use 'em and dump 'em, Hollywood style.
hi all/NB I saw this movie today & was reminded of this post. its in vending machines here in the US called "redbox".. check out the site sometime if you're curious.
the movie was very intense as I thought it would be. I had read many reviews. the brutality of the movie is strong and dark. its definitely a sort of Cheneyesque "dark side" feel to it.
cinematography was outstanding. really liked the scene on the top of the unfinished bldg.
I think the movie was showing the thin veneer of modern civilization. with our cars, buildings, planes, etc-- how civilized are we if children/adults live like the ones in the movie? the movies inhabitants behaved at times like cavemen, barbarians in modern clothes. the movie was about human inhumanity. about tolerance, indifference, and perpetuation of violence. it had a lot to say. its message was not clear. I couldnt help thinking it was satirizing the people/throngs/crowds watching the winner, the protagonist, on tv. as somehow, somewhat complicitous in his dark journey and suffering. it could be taken as a satire/indictment of the sheer fraudulence of hollywood. the scar on the woman's cheek is like the scar on our own soul. violence anywhere leaves a mark on all of us, everywhere. I might be inspired to do a whole blog post on the movie sometime....it deserves a long essay/analysis but I guess the time is past. I think it echoes the reverberations of torture that are rippling through the mass consciousness lately.... the scene with the protagonist being electrocuted with the battery-- who could not think of abu ghraib?
some posts on the topic of torture in my blog
And we're surprised why?