
Secondly, until an article in my local newspaper today, I’ve had no particular interest in exploring Scientology. In fact I don’t know a single Scientologist—remember, I live in Africa where it is a relatively new phenomenon, and it does not have the high profile it has in the US. What I do know is that Tom Cruise is a scientologist, and I can recall the very public incident between Cruise and Brook Shields where he lambasted her for taking Post Partum Depression—a very debilitating disease where the consequence for those so afflicted very often are that they feel driven to kill their children—and that she rather have toughed it out. The other is the furor over the death of Jett Travolta, where an accusation was made that his belief in Scientology largely contributed to Jett’s death. This supposedly because of the church’s ant-medication stance, and that the Travolta’s—because of this belief—may not have provided Jett with life saving anti-seizure medication. However, all indications are that the Travolta’s did their best in giving their son a joyous and happy life, so certainly, there’s no judgment on them, but that the belief system may well have contributed to his death if it was so.
Now for my reason for bringing up this contentious issue.
Well, it’s because I found an article in my local newspaper titled Controversial Scientology under fire again: Ban looms after lawsuit in France. Essentially the article was about a French lawsuit against the Church accusing them of committing fraud, and luring vulnerable people into buying their numerous offerings under the guise of its religious mantle. In France Scientology is viewed as a religious sect, and the court case could result in the outright banning of the organization.
Kyalami Castle in Johannesburg South Africa
Again, I have no particular opinion except that many modern day religions do tend to have this very strong profit motive underlying them—whether it be eastern based new age religions, prosperity and charismatic Christianity. What did however catch my attention was that there are about 15,000 practicing Scientologists in my country, and that they recently acquired an exclusive 22 acre country estate and castle as one of their portfolio of acquisitions around the country. A mean feat for any religious community of any size.
For me it seems that it is more of a profitable business than being an uplifting religious or spiritual path. Maybe I’m wrong.
What are your thoughts?


Salon.com
Comments
I have never seen it as a religion, but as a huge money-making entity with large profits for the few at the top.
Just another business essentially, except, the "workers" receive nothing for all the years they put in.
A classic american nutcase religion for profit, like mormonism. Well, not exactly. But just as nutty.
Started by a sci fi writer. Hubbard. Wrote dianetics, big best seller in 1950. Then 1952, cahnged name to scientology. Cultish phenomenon. Some of their beliefs are interesting in a metaphorical way. Like: we a re "thetans", perfect beings who once created the universe just for our pleasure, then became too enmeshed in, identified with, their creation, lost their memory. Basic higher mythology.
The interesting thing about it is the celebrites. I dont see what they like about it. Maybe i do. It says they are special beings. Which is what they are "missing" in their daily lives, i guess. All those stalkers & unfair media portrayal,, etc.
Hubbard wasa charismatic geniuis, like joseph smith and a buncha guys and gals before him. This particular cult had what it took. Nobody takes it seriously except them. But why not make it a religion? It serves as a living parody of organized religion itself.
Jim
And it ends with a spaceship.
oy
rated
The same could be said about televangilists who get people to fork over their money in hopes of salvation and the money is spent on prostitutes and building large empires for these so-called spiritual gurus.
Scientology is a religion and while it may seem absurd to some it has worked for others.
Personally, I go by the saying, "Live and Let Live". It works for me.
scientology is very secretive, & aggressive, something that is a red flag for me.
look at the origin-- a science fiction writer named hubbard. interesting guy, but yew.
yes, it does have the feel of a business pyramid scheme to me.
Sadly, I think religion in general has lost its way. Its suppposed to be about bringing people together and lifting the human spirit, not making a quick buck.
Regarding Scientology, I think its just a "fad"
Rated for getting the discussion going!
The case can be made that he was psychotic, at least at the time of his death. The coroner's report revealed that he had been injected with Vistaril, a powerful anti-psychotic drug.
The 1983 edition of the Physician's Desk Reference states that Vistaril "is useful in treating the following type of patients when intramuscular administration is indicated:
1. The acutely disturbed or hysterical patient.
2. The acute or chronic alcoholic with anxiety withdrawal symptoms or delirium tremens.
3. As pre- and postoperative and pre- and postpartum adjunctive medication to permit reduction in narcotic dosage, allay anxiety and control emesis. "
It is also interested that he was a patient at the Naval Hospital in Oakland, CA at the time of his separation from duty. His medical records from that stay have mysteriously disappeared. He later (1947) wrote to the VA requesting medical help for a mental condition.
At the time of his death he was reported to control hundreds of millions of dollars. Some (this writer included) see this a a possible motive for murder.
Jl, Go figure, I’m just as dumbfounded.
Trudge, I also go by the “Let the Buyer beware” and “Live and Let Live" approach, but there is a point where such manipulations is downright criminal. And that is what the French case wishes to prove, thought it is very difficult to draw a causal line between the followers stupidly, and the con artists inducements, and its emperors new clothes stuff we’re talking about. And then there is the issue of the innocent victims, as Jett may well be.
Brie, indeed, but I think formal religions still have something to contribute to society, it’s the money making aspect and how the followers make their gurus fantastically rich that really floors me.
Vzn, I thing he does seem possessed. I feel sorry for Katie and their kid in having been roped into this quagmire, as I really like her, particularly her grounded ness. I think a case can be made that The Secret was responsible for the decline of Oprah’s career as well. Since airing it her ratings decline, she gained significant weight, girls were raped at her exclusive shool in South Africa, she indicated she may be suffering from depression, had thyroid problems. This while having a full entourage to take care of her, including world famous sports physiologies Bob Greene and The Secret’s very own Michael Beckworth as her personal spiritual advisor—interesting, Beckworth being a former drug dealer, now rather purveying the more sociably acceptable opiate of religion.
Dbd, I agree with you fully. It sounds more like a con which ended up having a life of its own.
And Wayne, I do think religion has lost its way, and the sexual abuse crisis in the Catholic Church is not helping formal religion either.
I have spent an exhausting day just thinking. and writing in this damn snakepit...
i guess we could come up with a fine little religion, if we wanted to...
except we have no desire to...
we wanna live a free, individual life...
in any new religion, like...Blakes...whichis not exactly new, its as old as america itself, and by the way, he wrote a little poem called "america" that you might like to read the next time you eat mushrooms...
the Individual is Holy.
The individual is the whole point of God, Nature, the Universe, Everything...
It is the creation of a living "point of view of the Universe , by th e Universe itself, individualized"
that is the whole pt of Creation. That puts us, alas, at the crown of creation, but what can you do...
but take the Responsibility SERIOUSLY...
and oh yeah, the "CHildren are our future"...blah blah....i am a Child in the Kingdom of the lord,
do i rate some help? No? then fuckyou & go blow yrself up
for all i care...
It is the death instinct, Newton, freud's thanatos, that rule s
them. they want death, to escape the unbearable confines of their egoic self, which is indeed hell...
so they figger: blow up the world & get some relief fro htis madness. Except there are a few of us left who love Eros, the life instinct..
sounds like the script for a handy-dandy little religion, eh bud?
ha..jme
Scientology is quite similar to Mormonism, which I researched in depth. These are not religions; they are in fact cults, and I can support this statement with facts. Mormonism was founded by a known con-artist (Joseph Smith) and the Book of Mormon is a veritable fairy tale. Members have "secrets" and a secret temple and wear "special" underwear that protects them from harm. Scientology is also highly secretive. This could be said about many of the world's great religions, naturally (rituals, mystical events, confessions, etc.) so perhaps, as a segway to this discussion, we might further explore and define what is a religion and what is a cult, and are there differences between the two; also, how is the religion or cult "marketed," who is the "target audience" (ideal prospective member), and who profits most financially. Then we can perhaps more clearly see where Scientology falls on this continuum.
The issue of "live and let live" is a very interesting one and is an approach favored in the US, but not so in many European nations as the current case in France indicates.
The following is interesting in this regard and thought I’d add them for your reference.
Firstly, what many don’t know is that Nazism was also based on a new age religious cult – refer to New Religions and the Nazis by University of Calgary social anthropologist Karla Poewe. Firstly, according to professor. The difference being that Hitler used it for his political ambitions, but that modern cults are mostly motivated for financial gain or personal acclaim.
Secondly, according to the author of the Lucifer Effect Professor Philip Zimbardo, the rise of cults and sects have taken epidemic proportions in the US. About this he writes:
The cult epidemic is diagnostic of where and how society is failing its citizens…
In general, cult leaders offer simple solutions to the increasingly complex world problems we all face daily. They offer the simple path to happiness, to success, to salvation by following their simple rules, simple group regimentation and simple total lifestyle. Ultimately, each new member contributes to the power of the leader by trading his or her freedom for the illusion of security and reflected glory that group membership holds out.
Cults promise to fulfil most of those personal individual needs and also to compensate for a litany of societal failures: to make their slice of the world safe, healthy, caring, predictable and controllable. They will eliminate the increasing feelings of isolation and alienation being created by mobility, technology, competition, meritocracy, incivility, and dehumanized living and working conditions in our society.
It seems like a "win-win" trade for those whose freedom is without power to make a difference in their lives. This may be especially so for the shy among us. Shyness among adults is now escalating to epidemic proportions, according to recent research by Dr. B. Carducci in Indiana and my research team in California. More than 50 percent of college-aged adults report being chronically shy (lacking social skills, low self-esteem, awkward in many social encounters). As with the rise in cult membership, a public health model is essential for understanding how societal pathology is implicated in contributing to the rise in shyness among adults and children in America.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aoASMyv9Cek
I have decided to commandeer newton's fine blog for a minute. executive decision. i have picked up ms simon-etta's challenge here...
1.whats areligion, what is a cult? A religion today is some damn thing you are attached to, who knows how,r eally & it is
just a social category for yr lonely little soul
you can feela allegiance to, etc...develop tis line...
2. A Cult is a n actively seeking organization. Seeking some experience of more powerful connection with....well...the Christ started a cult and it prospered. Use Him as a model. Him being God & all. He was, but
his Message really gotta be updated, fast. These cults play at that. Moromonismis a fantastically successful Cult Phenomenon...the members are in thrall to a Charismatic Leader, a man plugged in cosmically somehow, hopefully in not too weirdly symbolic way...
3. best person to get = person having nihilistic flirtations...
person who most benefits= the Founder, I guess...he gets a big life, an important one....wouuldnt that be nice....hey, should the 3 of us start a cult? i shall let Newton be the Charismatic leader.......
4. the people who also benefit well are the ....um, call them the Smart people around the founder & later in the structure of the Administration of the Cult.....like the communist party.......suck the life of the young raw religious yearning......but...well,
Deprogrammers should just do a buncha reductio ad absurdims on em. Reduce the mythology to shreds. Show em the kinda life they say they want.....itll be in human, and they will "see" in
an epiphany...
thank you, newton..i yield the fucking floor..
Jim, in a savage beast mood over trouble with his wummun
l
Excellent points concerning the religion 'cookie cutter' mentalities that seem to abound here in the states.
Newton - The epidemic you speak of is a perfect example of society's ills come to roost. Everywhere there is a 'crack' of need, there is someone or some-thought to fill it. Raging watery and watered down spirit...thought...life...love...lost. It's like we are all drowning in the waters spewed from the dragon's mouth as it trys to find and vanquish...what? Don't know that answer, but it feels true lol.
peece,
dj
http://exscientologykids.com/storiesindex.html
James, yep, you can say Christ started a cult as well, but the real thing about this bunch is the absolute voodoo behind the belief, but also the absolute profiteering which one cannot associate with early Christianity—indeed the opposite was the case.
Jim, the only thing I can say is that you’re a word magician. Thanks for the input, I found your summation exquisite.
Undertow, I fully agree with you on this “From a sociological point of view, it's fascinating. From a humanistic one, however, it seems tragic”. I’ve printed out some of the stories to get some idea, but I had no idea how egregious this organization actually was.
Hmmmm...What sort of cult would attract as many men (or more men) than women in this day and age? I know! A cult led by...ME!!!!! Therefore, I now must kindly ask Newton to graciously step aside so that I can take over as the new leader of this Cult; naturally, this means I now hold a 51% share in our little (but I am sure soon-to-grow) organization. James and Newton, you now can divide up the 49% that's left (I think this is most generous of me) - And you two do the math on that; my math career ended at Calculus (I don't even think I can spell the damn word right!)
OK, what's next???(!)
A little rushed for time now but i shall make preliminary comments ...
A: ok, yre the leader...especially after the "pristine sexuality mixed with innocence" thing. Actually, that kind of describes me, too, i think..and this only makes sense, really, because founders of cults MUST be charismatic as well as...you know.......i dunno about you, newton, re. yr pristineness etc....
A committee of 3 running a cult...hm...never been tried to my knowledge....simple "2 out of 3" voting on important matters, like Angie doing her sermons in the way she described...i preliminarily
vot e YES...just for financial reasons of course...we DO need a draw for men...and i believe with angies's sermons & whatever she will be doing on non-sermon days, representing the Divine Feminine & all....PLUS my natural (or acquired is more like it) profane & instinctual way of speaking , in MY sermons, which will be barnburners, we got that area covered....(ps in future if i call you marilyn yl know the reference..)
Newton: you bring your keen and analytical mind to the table, plus yr calm and noble spirit. It will be a godsend i predict, considering yr partners...Plus i bet you know a hell of alot more about finances than me, though i cant speak for angie about this, but she DOESNT have calculus, remember...tell her what she missed, newton...as you are the namesake of the inventor, or the sort of inventor...right? didnt he invent it??
First business to discuss obviously: What the hell do we worship? Like, maybe...the Divine Two, the Eternal Mother & Father? Does that measn it just takes Angie to represent the Feminine, and two of us to be the Male Aspect of the Divinity? So we have a ...HA...bipolar male god?
Please atten d to cult bizness at yr convenience....we are off to a fine start, i think....James e.....
They are following the religion of a man who once joked that the best way to earn money would be to start his own religion. Well, he did... and it continues to earn a lot of money.
I'm almost jealous I didn't think of Scientology first. ;)
But seriously, yes, I suppose the motto " if you were silly enough to fall for it..." applies. The thing though is the blatant intimidation as pointed out in the 60 minute video spiritman referred to and the innocent kids that are exposed to it because of their parents indiscretions/stupidity/weakness as undertow's link pointed out.
I think the only way one can counter this kind of thing is if we wisen and toughen up to it, and if we get caught up in it, that we've all but handed over our common sense to these manipulators on a silver platter.
To: Blessed (Bald!) Newton and Apostle James
From: Angelique Simonetta - Leader of the Divine Feminine (NOT feminist!)
My Dear CULT Colleagues,
I have come up with a solution regarding our leadership dilemma (the only REAL dilemma is my not being immediately recognized as the rightful leader), and it is as follows: We shall divide our CULT into three factions, these being:
1) Logos
2) Eros, and
3) Mythos.
Newton, you will take Logos (you are the obvious choice, let's face it). I, Angelique, will (naturally) take Eros, and James, with his penetrating insight into symbolism, will take Mythos.
There, that settles it. And, according to my mathematical calculations, based on this new arrangement, I still get 51%.
What say you both?
Lastly: I bet that Jimenace would be happy to become our honorary first CULT member. Should we ask him?
My first act as head of the Mythos aspect of our CULT will be to examine the significance of Marilyn's birthday being today of all days, with the cult getting started today, and her (seemingly) inadvertent connection with it...i may need advice from Eros on this...i dont think Logos can be of much help with...instances of synchronicity like this...tho i could be wrong...
By the way, you two...be on the lookout for synchronicity. I will need to know about it. As the CULT get s of f the ground, there wiill naturally be more & more instances, as the symbolic constellations form around this grand new thing in the universe:the CULT...
oh, & absolutely on jimenace...i vouch for him...known him quite awhile..
(For someone who stopped at calculus, Angie, or..eros... your math seems...proficient...ms. 51%...!)
james m. e., aka "Mr Mythos"
So do we pass out little blue pills at the beginning or what?
peece!!!
dj
I am honored to be the first - canI read the ToS please? I just want to make sure to free up a month or so for the grueling inculcating phase. I look forward to serving the feminine. :)
So do we pass out little blue pills at the beginning or what?
peece!!!
dj
Jim, of course I most certainly be of assistance on this subject, my initial vacillation on the subject was cleared by the Merriam Webster online dictionary which clarified it as “the quality or fact of being synchronous”. The significance, therefore, is that embryonic duplication to the point of organismic viability outside of a semi aqueous substance was completed exactly 83 years ago for the then fledgling miss Monroe who has embed the sexual revolution which has resulted in the perpetuation of her initial profanous incidences of undress, to the outrageous pornography of thought of our troubling times. A truly troubling significance. I hope that clears up any confusion you may have had on this subject.
As far as young Jim (Aka Steel—is that as in metal, or the otherwise nefarious activity) is concerned, I’m not certain whether such a duplicitous character could advance the noble tenets of our esteemed organsiation, though I’m willing to give him a tentatively circumspectfull opportunity to prove me wrong. I certainly don’t wish to jeopardize our ordained unity so soon after its immaculate consummation by opposing you dear James.
Next: I am please to report that I had a dream early this morning that is loaded with synchronicity and symbology. Therefore, I now offer this dream to Jim / Mythos for his examination and analysis. Newton / Logos, you will no doubt want to jump in on this too, and perhaps Jimenace too (if Logos will allow such input). I believe it is possible the dream itself describes the underlying, "true" nature of a CULT - but that is just a suspicion I have. And I assure you, this was a REAL DREAM:
In the dream, I walked into a house I was thinking of purchasing. There were two or more middle-aged men there, showing me the house. I saw a pathway leading up to the fireplace (this is all indoors, mind you) and the path was lined on each side by small, rounded bushes (about 2 feet high each). In the center of the pathway was a square pond, about 3 or 4 feet wide. The men were very excited to show me that the bushes could be lit up via some strange electrical system, just like (gas) fireplace, and one could turn these on all at the same time. Like mad scientists, they threw the switch, and suddenly the fireplace went on, and the bushes began crackling and sparking with electricity. However, the bushes were made out of some kind of cheap, flammable material, and they quickly caught on fire and began smoking and burning...Becoming (you can see where this is going now, can't you?) BURNING BUSHES, but "man-made" (electrical, "low-tech") burning bushes. The house was in danger of quickly catching on fire. Suddenly, a 'helper' (Asian male) appeared by my side, and he began throwing water on the burning (artificial, sparking, electrified) bushes, until they were safely put out. It was only then, when I walked up to the bushes, that that square pond was revealed, and the water appeared unfresh and tepid, more like a swamp.
There was more to it after that, but that is the core of it. Burning Bushes, pathways, squared (possible) non-flowing water mandalas, manipulative, dangerous "sellers" of "houses" (Jung proposed that houses symbolized oftimes the "house" of the soul) - I think this should keep Mythos busy for sometime!!!
Also, interesting to consider the following: "On another level, Rabbenu Bechaya suggests that the image of the Burning Bush is a paradigm for all physical reality. Since the physical world is a product of Godly, spiritual creation, it is logical to assume that the physical universe should be consumed by the overwhelmingly powerful spiritual flow emanating from God. The continued existence of the entire physical universe, therefore, is very much like the continued existence of this Burning Bush. Through the symbolism of the Bush, the Almighty gave His reassurance to sustain the world." (This quote, along with further explorations of the symbology of the Burning Bush, can be found here: http://www.aish.com/torahportion/appel/Moses_at_the_Burning_Bush.asp) - Okay, Mythos, how much more synchronicity do you want? Now get cracking on your symbolic analysis and let us know what this means to our newly formed cult!
(p.s. - I think Jimenace, once properly brainwashed, would make a good recruiter - Think how many ladies he could woo in to our organization with his [cult-approved / sanctioned] poetic offerings???)
Sorry, just had a logos moment, now for the eagerly awaited mythos interpretation.
peece,
dj
N:Burn those bushes indeed...then let some damn Moses come & dephicer it while you go along on yr merry way, with the spiritual EASE of knowing that you are heading in the right direction, and that every day bring confirmation of that...
A:I am seriously grateful for you turning to face us men, if only for too brief a space...
JIM:What can I say... a constant beautiful companion in this absurd joyous journey...Dont believe the Lies Out There, and dont take em seriously or personally...they aint worth investing yr energy in...(and it's what they want...)...
keep up yr LOL'ing , friend..
(Jim..you'll like this:
Long Prosper the ELM Tree...get it? eros,...etc)
jim e, vanquished temporarily by contingencies,
but willing to take another shot,...and another...etc
This would allow us to attract entire families - especially children! We could give the Fundamentalist Right-Wingers a run for their money then - get 'em while they're young! (to see what those fundamentalists are up to, see 'Using Children as 'God's Army', A documentary By Kirsten A. Powers: A new documentary chronicles a summer camp where children, as young as six, are trained to become devout Christian soldiers.
Tenants = people who rent property.
Tenets = a principle, belief, or doctrine generally held to be true; especially: one held in common by members of an organization, movement, or profession.
Thank youQ
And Emma, thanks for stopping by, and I will watch out for that. Indeed it is quite a common oversight.
I miss the Eros Dawning avatar you had before, personally.
peece!
dj