Noahvose: Nea'ese

Noahvose

Noahvose
Location
Wisconsin, USA
Birthday
February 21
Title
History Teacher
Bio
A Great Plains guy living in the Great Northwoods and feeling Claustrophobic.-- Masters in Anthropology (I thought we could use some Indians digging up white people).-- I have an amazing wife and two beautiful boys.-- I teach high school history and at an Alternative School for at-risk youth.-- ...and I have a serious Jelly Belly problem

MY RECENT POSTS

Noahvose's Links

Salon.com
JUNE 12, 2009 2:43PM

What Crazy Horse Taught Us

Rate: 31 Flag

Crazy Horse 2 

He was the Lakota’s greatest warrior, and he is thought of by many to be the quintessential symbol of resistance. He never signed a treaty. He never allowed his picture to be taken, and he never quit. Even when soldiers were leading him into a cell, he refused to be held and was stabbed in the back by a bayonet to teach him what happens to those who question authority. But it was Crazy Horse that taught us the lesson.

 

Yet, Crazy Horse was far from perfect. He wore a gruesome scar across his cheek where a bullet exited, a daily reminder of the price for sleeping with another man’s wife. And in the latter days of his life, he was often blamed by many of his own people for bringing punishment on them by his refusal to lay down his arms.

 

He lived through the most turbulent, terrifying, and uncertain time of his people’s history. Everything they knew was changing or disappearing. The buffalo on which their survival depended was being hunted to extinction. The other once powerful tribes had been reduced to poor dependents on reservations and most of those who resisted had been killed. It would have been easy and understandable for Crazy Horse to follow the example of John Ross (Cherokee), Red Cloud and Spotted Tail (Lakota), Dull Knife and Little Wolf (Cheyenne), Chief Joseph (Nez Perce), even the great Sitting Bull (Lakota), so many chiefs who relented to the inevitable. But he didn’t.

 

Now, we find ourselves in turbulent times, ourselves, questioning many of the fundamental principles we were built on. We are fighting an enemy most of us can’t understand, and even the best military commanders can’t figure out how to defeat. Just as it was for the Lakota, we find even the future of our very environment and all we depend on at risk. And as in Crazy Horse’s time, our own people are deeply divided as to what to do. Whether it’s because I teach history or because of my own heritage, I find myself looking backward for some answers and examples.

 

So, I share with you one of my favorite stories from the life of Crazy Horse and the lessons, I believe, it holds for us:

 

After the Battle of the Little Bighorn, when Custer and his men were wiped out, the massive Indian encampment of Lakota and Cheyenne split up. Most were fully aware that their stunning victory would be followed by unending pursuit. Sitting Bull fled to Canada but Crazy Horse headed into the Powder River, believing he could be more elusive in the country he knew so well. But the cavalry’s use of Indian scouts took away his advantage.

 

One morning, Crazy Horse's village was camped in a valley. The Sun and the people were not yet up, and as they slept they were unaware that they had been spotted the night before and were now surrounded. The order had been given to sound the bugle and attack at the first sight of the Sun. The people awoke, some to the sound of the bugle, some to the thundering of hooves, and others to the buzzing of the bullets ripping through their lodges.

 

As quickly as they could manage, half dressed and half awake, the men ran out into the snow to gather their horses. As was the custom in battle, they formed a protective line between the soldiers and the escaping women and children. The soldiers took a heavy toll, and many brave men died in this line. The firing was so intense that many of the men began to melt away in retreat. But it was at this point, so the witnesses say, that they heard Crazy Horse begin to yell, “Brave men to the front! Keep firing! It is a good day to die!”

 

With that, Crazy Horse turned his horse toward the soldiers and charged straight at them, firing. Seeing his bravery, the other warriors turned their horses, as well, and charged. The soldiers never expected this kind of resistance and halted in fear. The memory of Custer's fate was still fresh, and that day their feelings of fear won out over their desire for revenge. Before the day was through, the warriors had not only saved their families but had pushed the soldiers back over the mountains, thus saving their village, as well. It was one final victory before the sad end that was to come.

 

I think of this story often and believe there are three very important lessons that Crazy Horse teaches us:

 

±      To achieve great things, we must have the help of others. They must believe it is possible, turn their horses, and charge together.

 

±      However, we must also be ready to lead by example. If the cause is worthy, we must be willing sometimes to be the one to charge alone.

 

±      Finally, Crazy Horse taught us that winning is not the goal…having the will to continue is. If we can do that in the face of all that is thrown against us, we’ve already won.

 

feather 


I flinched at posting this, for fear that some might relate its meaning to some of the misquided self-righteous acts we've seen lately in the news.

So, I add this one important qualifier that I believe more people need to remember:

 Being right puts you in the minority, but being in the minority does not mean you're right. Those who would confuse this to justify their violent acts should remember this. 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Bravery is always in short supply.
This post brought tears. The memory of a man so brave. I remember his stories and hold them dear to me.
He was a leader, one that could come again for us all.
Thanks for the reminder of a great man with vision.
write more like this
There isn't much I can add to such a remarkable post. Thank you for sharing this history, for the lessons of Crazy Horse and for your qualifier. Rated.
I recently read, "The Journey Of Crazy Horse" by Joseph M. Marshall, III. I highly recommend it to those looking for the "Lakota" version of Crazy Horse's life and times.

RATED
Thank you all for coming by and leaving your comments. There are so many heroes from that period, and I realize that many of those brave men were those who later compromised. I never mean to take away from their achievements and struggle, but sometimes an uncompromising figure stands out and is easy to admire.
An important story well told and deftly concluded.
As a kid, Crazy Horse was unabashedly my top hero. As I've grown older, he's still high on the list, joined by the men you've named, and many others. I think I grew to understand the reasoning behind the compromises, and what/who those compromises protected, and at what cost.

The warrior in me thinks it would be easier/better/more honorable to fight until the enemy killed me than to lead "my" people to an enormously depleted existance in captivity; easier for me, as a leader, because I'd end up dead instead of watching my people waste away - but not necessarily the right decision. Then again, it helps to have a hero - one who's willing to die rather than surrender.

God grant me the serenity . . . to know which hero's example to follow.

I may never know - and I pray that we find better, more cooperative solutions as we face the changes that seem inevitable.

Thank you for a moment of remembrance and lessons learned.
Thank you for a wonderfully told and meaningful post. And we whites referred to native people as "savages"...go figure.
Crazy Horse's example is still inspiring. His story magnifies courage and resolve. Rated!
A wonderful cautionary tale for our times. Brave men to the front, indeed. It is a good day to die.
You were wise to look at history and pick Crazy Horse to teach this wise lesson. There is no other culture in America that honors the land and the elements or treats them with as much reverence as the Native Americans. The majority of the rest of our nation is hell bent on destroying most of what remains.
Great story. A wonderful lesson for us all. Reminds me of the story of Kapwa Lamò. He was a soldier who is remembered by Haitians for his valor at the last battle that won the Haitian Revolution for the enslaved Africans of Haiti:

"At the battle of Vètyè, bullets killed Kapwa Lamò’s horse. He continued on foot. Bullets shot off his hat. He continued charging forward. French canon fire tossed him many feet in the air. He got up and continued on foot as the canon booms paved his advance.

Finally Napoleon’s Gen. Rochambeau raised a flag for a pause and sent his compliments to the “valiant general who has just covered himself in such glory.”
more
Owl - It's kind of like we discussed in an earlier post about growing older and, sometimes, wiser. Each one of the leaders has a brave story to tell, and each one teaches us a valuable lesson. Uncompromising people are easy to admire, especially when we're young. But even now, I wonder if his lesson to us, in an age when we like to look at the gray, that there ARE some things that are black and white and some things that should NEVER be compromised. As he said, "One does not sell the land on which the people walk."

AtHome - Thanks for coming by and commenting.

Walter - There's a famous story of a missionary describing Jesus to a group of young men. When they start muttering amongst themselves and not listening, he asks the translator what they're talking about. The translator laughs and tells him that they're positive that Jesus must have been Indian. Thanks for coming by.

Mr. Mustard - That's my favorite part of history...finding those truly inspiring individuals who are still teaching us.
In my basement rec room I have a prominent, large wooden mural with head shots of famous chiefs. Plenty of Horses, Taboonawasha, Sitting Bull, Crazy Horse, Two Kettle, Red Shirt, and High Bear. The last five were all at the Little Big Horn. They inspire me. Your story inspired me.

And since I have so few occasions to do this, I'd like to second what Behind Blue Eyes said up above: "Bravery is always in short supply." Native Americans apparently were lucky in that regard. It seems they had more than their share.
Noahvose,
I absolutely LOVED this inspiring post about Crazy Horse. Your students are very fortunate to have you.

I believe that despite the human flaws we all have, there was something truly special about the intuitive ways and wisdom of Native American society (although I realize that I risk oversimplifying the particulars of various tribes and individuals). Nevertheless, their wisdom (and the insightful proverbs and stories of other native peoples around the globe) shines in times like ours...where we mistakenly equate all the advances of modernity with good and assume that the farther we distance ourselves from the ancients the better.

I think the ancients still have a lot to teach us and may even hold the key insights-- that once incorporated into our own lives-- may reveal the fragile and adventurous path towards the continued progress and survival of our species.

I also loved your comment about the Indians claiming Jesus as one of their own. Ha!
Lonnie - When there is much to lose, we need them up front and we need to join them there. Thanks

Cartouche - Thanks as always. You are always so busy on OS that I'm always honored when you stop by.

ZenHaitian - Great analogy. Truly, every culture has these heroes. They might be different, but their message isn't. I look forward to reading more on yours.
Where have you been? Better yet, where have I been. This is EXCELLENT! pleas, please, please, can I be your friend?
Quality
I saved this for when I had time to really absorb it because I know there are always so many layers to your posts. About 15 years ago, I became really attracted to Native wisdom and started reading as much as I could - including several thick and daunting books on Crazy Horse which really altered my thinking. Thank you for reminding me of the lessons of his life and how they link to our world today. Do you ever wonder how he would respond if he were alive now? That would make a great ficitonal story!
Frank - That would be a great art piece to have, and they were all great men. There are soooo many interesting side stories intertwined into that battle. That might be a great post itself one of these days. Thanks for coming by and for the compliment.

Churchgoing - Perhaps the one light that shines through during difficult times are the individuals that put all on the line to do what most are afraid to do. You also make a good point about looking to tradition for our answers. It's somewhat like when kids always reinvent the wheel and think that they can always find better answers than the outdated lessons from their parents. They come to find out that often the truth is as simple as their parents said and that those new ways often lead us further down the wrong path.
Scanner - Thanks for coming by and for commenting. I could definitely use more friends. I'll look forward to reading your blogs.

Mamoore - I know one thing for sure...he would hate the fact that a mountain in the Black Hills was being blasted away to form his image. What a contradictory honor. If anything, he'd fight to have it remain untouched.
I've always looked up to Crazy Horse, flawed and human though he was. There are so many stories of bravery from that time, and I have to wonder if men like that are extinct in our time.

Thanks for posting this.
Charity - If there's one thing I've learned by studying history is that every age, especially those of struggle, have individuals like him. The problem is they are often so quickly silenced, in their time and by history, that we don't hear of them. Instead, we often force heroism on individuals who fall short. Thanks for stopping by. I always appreciate your comments.
Extremely well said....People who have chosen to do violence have stopped thinking critically....Violence can take place only in the absence of thought. That is why the educator's first responsibilty is to teach people HOW to think... If that is accomplished, we need not be concerned with WHAT people think for that is the province of the individual.......
Extremists and demagogues know this and exploit the failure of the system's capacity to produce a populace that has the capacity to think for themselves.......
I appreciate this so much, and I especially like the summary of the lessons you have included. Thank you.
Crazy Horse was indeed a special man. Thanks for sharing this story with us, Noah.
Crazy Horse never recognized the US Government as having any authority over native lands, and that alone drove his style of complete resistance. I have to wonder about your comment regarding the mountain sculpture. The story of its beginning (as I recall it a lifetime work of a Czech(?) immigrant) in response to Mt. Rushmore being all about the wrong things) is compelling. And the museum there is awe -inspiring to a city-boy like me. I have been there twice in the past five years, once with my 13 year old son, and he remembers it as one of the "coolest" places he's ever been.

I certainly am taking no serious issue with anything you've said and I respect that you know far more about all of this than I ever will. I enjoy reading your posts.
o'steph - Hello...and thanks

Ron - What you said has a lot of truth in it. That's the difficult thing about looking at someone like Crazy Horse's life. Are there things worth fighting for, or is that always the result of someone who stopped thinking? And what makes them different, so that we may easily argue against those who confuse themselves for martyrs?

scupper - Thanks, as always. You still have me thinking of your crossroads piece.

AshKW - Thank you for coming and your comment

Grif - Thanks for stopping by. I realize that my comment about Crazy Horse Mountain is not the most popular one, but it certainly is shared by many natives in SD. It is difficult, because as you said the motives were good. It's just that the project was misguided. It wasn't just that the presidents' heads were being carved into the sacred hills. It was that ANYTHING was being carved there. But, some natives back then thought as long as whites were carving monuments, they might as well carve their greatest hero. The problem is, Crazy Horse died defending that land that he considered the most sacred place on Earth. He also never let his image be captured. Why would he approve, the humble man that he was, of having one of those mountains blasted away in his "likeness"? He wouldn't. So, while I can understand and even appreciate the motives, I cann't approve of the method.

This would be something like demolishing a southern black church to put up a statue of MLK. If they really wanted to memorialize Crazy Horse and what he stood for, they should have made sure that that mountain remain untouched, despite all of the development of the Black Hills.

Thanks again for your comment. I do realize that there are two sides, and though it is awe inspiring, I want others to hear that other side, as well...even if it's unpopular and sounds unappreciative to them.
Explanation appreciated. Makes sense. Looking forward to more.
It is significant you mention the imperfections of this passionate human being, Noahvose. For he was, wasn’t he? Not deified, nor held to some unattainable lofty standard of behavior. To do so would set him apart as extraordinary, outside of the range of standards looked upon as achievable action.

What your story elucidates for me is how anyone of us might, in a given situation, make the simple choice to do the right thing, the necessary thing. Each time a man or woman chooses to do so it may be as uncomplicated as drawing the next breath, or as profound as a spiritual awakening when such moments of clarity come. One thing that is certain is, each time it happens, we can note with quiet certainty the individual was paying close attention. And? By evaluation made from critical examination, a choice(s) made. Because of those choices made, pages of history are borne, not from the actions of rarified Men, but of Every Man...men and women just like you and I. Each of us has the capacity for greatness. Even if it is only to identify, for example, a racist remark and say with quiet resolution: “No, not today. I will let this happen today.” It is about integrity. It is about caring enough for the world and those that populate it, beginning with each of our families, our friends, to simply step up to accountability and not back down in the face of backlash or reprisal… It is to be the change one wishes, one sentence, one action, one thought… at a time. Many have.

More are needed to do so. Change comes one clear awareness at a time. One unwavering decision, one resolute action at a time

We are faced with many challenges. How will we meet them? By believing those that would have the populace (which is, of course, you and I, personified) remain somnambulant, mistakenly convinced we have little or no choice about social, political, corporate ethics, thus no voice? Or by grabbing onto a bit of the Crazy Horse determination that lives within each, today... to say: “I don’t think so. Not today.”

Thought provoking post, Noahvose. Thank you!
This is such an excellent post. I'm so glad you let me know when you're posting. I'm in the midst of so many projects I might miss your writing otherwise. Rated and shared for my friends to read and learn.

Peace, Robin
like water - What a beautiful and insightful comment. I couldn't agree more, and that is exactly why this is one of my favorite stories from history...but there are many others like it. As you said, we are faced with decisions every day, some of them ethical ones. Crazy Horse just lived in extraordinary times and was able to focus his life on one unflinching cause, not to give up the land.

I've often wondered if life offers each of us a chance, maybe a few, to do something great. What if it warms us up by giving us smaller, daily choices to do what is right. When we make that right decision, as you said maybe it is simply confronting the racist comment or defending someone picked on, we are ready for the next one. Maybe, if we make enough of those and prove ourselves ready, life presents us with the chance to do something even more influencial. I've always wondered if I've faced that one, or did I blow it by not making enough of the right decisions daily (see my confessions post), or if it still lies ahead.

As you said, though, all that is asked of us, now, is to make those smaller right choices. The rest will meet us when and where we're ready.

Thank you so much for your thoughts and wisdom.
Sorry it took me so long to check this out.

Great line: " If the cause is worthy, we must be willing sometimes to be the one to charge alone."
A good reminder and I especially appreciated the qualifier for there are certainly those who need to hear it. Thank you! Another well-written, thoughtful post. Well done.
Beautifully written. Thank you.
Excellent! Thank you, Noahvose.
"Being right puts you in the minority, but being in the minority does not mean you're right. Those who would confuse this to justify their violent acts should remember this."

I'm afraid that most, students of history or not, refuse to consider this thought experiment.

Thank you for an evocative story about the astounding, brave, resilient Crazy Horse.
Excellent as always. May I use these lessons?:
± To achieve great things, we must have the help of others. They must believe it is possible, turn their horses, and charge together.


± However, we must also be ready to lead by example. If the cause is worthy, we must be willing sometimes to be the one to charge alone.



± Finally, Crazy Horse taught us that winning is not the goal…having the will to continue is. If we can do that in the face of all that is thrown against us, we’ve already won.