Norman Nuveaux

Norman Nuveaux
Location
Chicago, Illinois, US
Birthday
December 31
Title
Assistant Professor
Company
Private
Bio
I'm an assistant professor and deputy chair of an anthropology department at Williams College in Chicago, a college I helped found in 2004. I like red wine, Bach, bicycling, and thinking freely.

MY RECENT POSTS

Norman Nuveaux's Links

Salon.com
DECEMBER 18, 2009 3:12PM

Right or Wrong?

Rate: 65 Flag

For the past week, a group of Cleveland's less cerebrally engaged have taken to protesting outside my research suite at Case.  (I can hear them once in a while from where I'm sitting and writing this.)  It's been a mix of locals mostly, but a few students have brought placards on their way to class as well.  One of my colleagues snapped a few photos yesterday.

don't mock
 

The groups haven't been especially large, maybe a dozen or so people at the most--and today there seemed to be a few fewer than yesterday--but they've been pretty vocal and confrontational.  On Wednesday, one threw his shoulder into mine as I tried to pass on the sidewalk leading into the building's entrance.  This guy below, whose shirt pretty much sums up the general message of those assembled, occupies a special place in my heart--it's too bad the image doesn't show you what his sign says, as my name assumes a bold font near its top.

  man in shirt

The genesis of the brouhaha kicked off about  a year ago, when I had an article published  in the journal Nature about some of my research on primate genomes.  My statistical modeling turned out a wrinkle in the mutability of their sequencing that suggested a great deal more change were occurring than what a gradualist model of natural selection suggests.   I really wasn't sure what was behind the genetic mechanics of it at the time, but I hypothesized it had something to do with somatic mutations splicing into the germ line and getting replicated for subsequent generations.  I described the process as 'catalytic evolution', and presumed I'd give it a better name under better light.

Little if anything would have likely come of the article, certainly not in a popular sense, had it not been for the creationists' knack for picking out what they wanted from it and distorting my statements to read like an indictment on Darwinian theory.  But pick they did.  Rick Warren even mentioned my research in a footnote to his latest edition of A Purpose Driven Life, as part of a "...[b]urgeoning body of science in support for a young earth."  (No, I haven't read it--and it's a veritable miracle I even heard about it.) 

Then an article in Time magazine came out on some of my research, for which I agreed to grant, what later became, a truncated interview.  Oh, those brights at Time are something else.  Having read it, you would have thought I were advocating that the earth is 10,000 years old and that Genesis has been taken as fact by any and all sensible scientists.  As you might imagine, the blogosphere of the right lit up with this nonsense, and I've burned through three email accounts just so I could communicate professionally without having to filter through the three or four dozen emails I'd been getting every day from people (the less cerebrally engaged) congratulating me on my research.  I've received at least a dozen emails from students and faculty at Bob Jones University...how endearing. 

Now it seems every yahoo with a bible tucked under the bed is qualified to speak about my research.  Here's a little video from a pastor in Lewiston, NY--where?!--who worked in some of my research to "support" his laudably cogent understanding of geology:


Particularly after the Time article, I thought I should do something about the way my research has been abused--and the papal colors in which I've been painted.  So I fired off an essay to the Cleveland Plain Dealer, Toledo Blade, and a few other local papers, and did a short interview for the Channel 5 evening news.  When I made it clear in these media I didn't buy into the whole rib and resurrection farce, the same fanatics who had been cheering me on turned on me pretty abruptly, and hence the amicable flocks presently congregating on the sidewalk outside my building. 

Now, instead of getting notes that read--and this is an actual one: "...it's about time a respected researcher called out the psuedoscience [sic] of geologic dating.", I've been getting hatemail the likes of this--another actual note: "...you ought to slither back into the pit of vile from whence you came."  Whence, wither, art, thou...is archaic diction any more attractive when it's spewed from the right?

Anyway, I'm hopeful the ruckus outside my workstation simmers down soon, but I have a feeling it won't.  I'm scheduled to speak at the Freedom From Religion Foundation's annual meeting next month in Madison, WI, and I'll be on 'Speaking of Faith' on NPR next month--to the latter, especially, I'm looking forward.  More fuel for the fire in all likelihood.

Only in America.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
To quote the late Yakin Smirnoff "What a country". If they're protesting you. If they're villifying you. If you're inundated with gobbledegook that probably means you're doing something right.
Rated
All I can say is why can't they just slither back into that vile pit from whence (whither?) they came? Yikes, your 15 minutes has arrived and this is what you get. Best of luck on all that. And if you see a miniature cathedral headed your way, duck!
Oh sure, I spend years trying to purposefully piss those people off and not so much as a peep.
Next time they ask you "from whence you came," you can tell them that proper grammar is "whence you came." That should piss them off more.
Ass hats. Good luck with them.
Stupidity is in ascendance and intelligent people will always be its target. What I don't understand is, why do these people whose religion tells the not to lie, lie so much to support their religion? Isn't that like fucking for abstinence?
Fellow Casie here... Hope you are able to talk some sort of sense into them, but I'm sorry to say that this will likely remain be out there, forever more, as one of their arguments. They're not interested in what you meant, they're only interested in what they "heard".
"less cerebrally engaged"

that is a very kind way of putting it
Wow. This is fascinating! Please keep us posted. Also regarding your favorite placard carrier, I love that "church gossips" are in the same category as atheists and gays! Oh, and does the size of the font indicate the severity of the "problem"? Because I would assume that atheism is more of a threat to the zealots than homosexuality, but according to this dude, gays are way worse than druggies, atheists and abortionists... See, I would have made a terrible christian crazy by picking the wrong hot button topic. Damn.
The need to be right in knowledge, worldly and temporal terms, and the level of self-importance that drives these people is antithetic to anything truly spiritual or what Jesus teaches.
Someone should send a Gorilla-gram to these yahoos. Millions are jobless, our schools are a mess, and men and woman are risking their lives over seas. Don't these mouth-breathing zealots have anything better to pester their "God" with? Crikey. Good luck. Please post your airdate on NPR; I'd like to tune and catch that.
The only "god" thingy I've ever really liked was a bumper sticker that read:

Dear God, Please protect me from your followers!

Other than that...they all suck.
That guy's wig is certain to send G-d into a tizzy...great post! xox
ah...popularity is a fickle bitch.

well...at least their attention span is probably fairly short and they'll find something else to express umbrage at shortly.
Incredible post! ~R

What I find to be so miraculous is the authority this man takes in declaring evolution and spirituality "can not mix." When did God get hijacked by clergy? Science is a part of God's plan, and the religious fundamentalists are about law-keeping, status quo, and not having their beliefs challenged usually out of fear of what they will find. What I love is how simple the solution is...they're both right. He said it himself, the stories in the bible are fables, METAPHOR, if you know how to properly interpret them. Any mystic from all 3 monotheistic religions, or a Hindu, Yogi, Zarathustrian, Buddhist, etc. will read it this way as well. They masses no longer do the hard work of reading their saints or mystics, they just follower their preachers and abide by the law keeping to insure their own beliefs remain unchallenged. It is a vicious circle.

Here is how I interpret Exodus 20: 1, 11: "I am the God within you which brought you out of Egyptian slavery and into your present circumstances. It is wise to not put any person, place, or thing in front of your highest good. For when you do so, jealousy will prevail and the hate within will continue to be a burden for three or four generations; if you place your highest good first, a thousand lives will be altered by the love you find within. You shall not preach by claiming the name "Lord" over another, in doing so, your own guilt will be damning to your own spirit..."

I will not go on to give my lay interpretation of the rest of it, as it speaks to evolution and I am not trying to rock the boat. However, when a mass of people's beliefs become challenged about the very foundational beliefs they have built their lives around (in your case, starting with evolution hinting at discrediting the literal story, and then later when you discounted the Adam and Eve fable, making it an all out mad scene) the psycho-dynamics which ensue are quite overwhelming for those people. So, I know they are making your life miserable, but I hope you can find some compassion for how terribly narrow their lives are and what a blessing it is for you to live with a free and wondrous mind. It certainly shows here.

In summary, I am deemed blasphemous by some Christians for even coming up with my own interpretation (based on many years of study within many religions, thousands of hours of meditation, and so on) and the only person in my view who is what Christians would refer to as a "sinner", not something I personally believe in, is the preacher claiming the name of the Lord to enhance his own personal agenda - perpetuating the lie of the literalness of the fables in the Bible going to enhance his own personal point of view (never mind to get $, make judgments about people's social/physiological choices, etc.)

Great piece - enjoyed thoroughly. Best of Luck!
Props for the pub in Nature! If I'm remembering correctly, I think I remember reading that... from the same team that did all that great segmental duplication work if it’s the one I’m thinking of... Very well done indeed! Good luck with the crazies, though. I've never had to deal with the religious types, but once we had PETA nuts throw a pipe bomb through our lab window. Ahhh… good times.
Christians like to portray themselves as persecuted, and they freely to push their religious views. Yet these same people persecute atheists. It's particulary disturbing that they attack scientists whose research disproves their religious views. This has happened throughout Christian church history, and it's time it stops.
"Only in America"—I wonder if it would be fair to say "Only in Ohio," I've heard similar stories from other states as well. I live south of you about and hour and a half (on the fringes of Amish/Mennonite country). I write an innocuous column for my local newspaper, steering clear of anything with too hot a button, but even I catch hell from the locals. It's even been suggested I won't be included in the Rapture, although I have no idea what that has to do with opposing capital punishment.
Right on! Damn that new geological dating hokum. You rock.
Plagued by a gruesome collection of gargoyles and harpies! Joseph Campbell might say you were a hero - lost in the labyrinth!
I see what you mean about the national nature of religious nutcases! Terrible to be in their sights, but congrats on pissing them off!!! And, glad you are here on OS. Please do post on the date of your interview on Speaking of Faith. I'd like to listen to see how they treat you.
Thanks for sharing this. Fascinating. Hang in there.
so sorry for your tsuris. I feel your pain.
Wow. Just wow. Don't these people have jobs?

"Judgment Coming". From the looks of all that crap on his shirt, it already has in the form of him. But, I especially love the "church gossips" part. Damn you little old ladies!
So glad you spoke up to clear the record, but sorry you are having to endure these bozos - hope your sidewalks clear off soon. I look forward to hearing you on Speaking of Faith - that is usually an interesting and intelligent show.
Get you bumper sticker: Don't mock my science!

or

Darwin Rocks!


Proverbs, Chapter 6

[6:16-19

"There are seven things that the Lord hates and cannot tolerate:

A proud look,
a lying tongue,
hands that kill innocent people,
a mind that thinks up wicked plans,
feet that hurry off to do evil,
a witness who tells one lie after another,
and someone who stirs up trouble among friends."]
Keep free thinking and don't let the crazies god hordes get you down. monkey fingered.
Oh come on. Everyone knows the Earth is only 2,000 years old. It is flat. The sun orbits the Earth. God created trillions of forms then rejected most in a period of six days to settle on the ones we see now. This is the truth because men who spoke to God 2,000 years ago tell us so. Sit back, have a lukewarm glass of Kool-Aid and relax.
I could not listen to that used car salesman voice, but I believe that he misquoted you. How anyone can grant such an obvious huckster any credence is beyond me. It seems to me I've heard something about this theory. Unless you're completely uneducated, the idea that genetic change can be rapid or extensive does not conflict with the theory of evolution nor does it say anything about the age of fossils. Education is really sad in this country.
You should amend a few more facts to any response to the abusive emails: viruses have been evolving for many more eons than any living thing that can walk, and appear to be much better at it; recent archaeogenetic research suggests that chimpanzees are more closely related to us than many of our extinct hominid relatives ever were; and, since the human brain takes longer to mature, human infants are only slightly smarter than young chimps, and, in some ways, less so. I mean if people are going to be angry at you anyway, you might as well have some fun. Rated.
To me, it's amazing you had the fortitude to not only sit all the way through the Rev. Glenn Beck's harrangue, but you took the time to post it. I got up to 7:00 before I gave up. How people can be such sheep as to fall for a two cent demagogue like that is beyond me. And since they're such damn good Christians, why aren't they taking time to work in a soup kitchen instead of picketing your office. Sounds like a combination of small brains and too much time on their hands. Rated, and keep us posted.
I'd just like to point out the complete absurdity of their logic, all too well summed up by this quote:

"...you ought to slither back into the pit of vile from whence you came."

If you slithered out from a pit of vile, and are now currently walking with bipedal locomotion, does that not mean they want you to devolve? And if they DO want you to devolve, doesn't that mean they have to believe in evolution (from slithering to bipedal locomotion, and vice versa) in the first place?

Seems like problem solved right there
Ideally, I'd like to say 'wear their scorn like a badge.' ...But I don't have a bunch of the pin-heads on my front lawn like you do. I'd also like to say the next time one of them bumps you, punch their teeth down their throat and say you felt threatened. But the last time I was in a fight was the sixth grade.
The best I can offer is 'be patient and do an inward eye-roll' as you pass them.
And please: The date and air time of your NPR segment.
A Montana Supporter
I wonder how their errosion theory would apply to the Grand Canyon. Something tells me it's more than 5,000 years old.
Unfortunately, this type is evidence that man evolved from apes, and hasn't progressed all that far.
Most of these fundie protest types are obese and ugly! Poor them.
You know, these ignorant zealots can be pretty nuts if they think they are working directly for GOD. It sounds like you were drafted into this conflict. Are you sure you want to become a soldier in this particular war? There's a lot to be said for keeping a low profile.
ps. At the head of shirt-guy's list is "church gossips", presumably with reservations for the seventh level of hell. These folks can be very contentious, constantly changing their "home church" due to politics and infighting. Can't even get along with each other...
Your research is important, and I'm so sorry that you were hijacked by the crazies. Hang in there . . .
I don't normally advocate violence but...

~Hands over a cricket bat~

It's a handy little tool for encouraging idiots to leave you alone.
Great post Norman. Be careful out there. Should-bumping is just a way of “accidentally” being aggressive.

If you consider the psychology of it all, it's nothing more than fear showing in their "cerebrally challenged" grapes. That's what religions teach after all - FEAR. Fear other's beliefs, cultures, science, the fear of a world they don't understand, of a world outside their spoon-fed bullshit that makes them all warm and fuzzy in their cobweb-clogged cerebrum.
Oh, boy. I'm so sorry. It's too bad you can't just do your research without being involved with the religious right.

Good luck to you and stay safe.
Believe it or not, for some of us this abuse is a badge of honour! I find that when ignorance like this gets to me a visit to my friends and fellow-subversives at this site helps: http://www.venganza.org/
What else can I say, except you've got better hair!
Rated in support.
Wow. Yup. I'm just gonna stick with wow. It's always the cool kids that get protested.
Hi Norman! I live in Cleveland too :)

Great post. What I wanted to say here is that most people on OS probably have no idea--zero--what a prestigious thing it is to work in anthropology in Cleveland. Kudos to you. To all my friends on OS: It's a big deal. And I mean, it's the hottest city in the world when it comes to contributions to the field. Weird, I know. But true. Lucy and Ardi are closely linked to Cleveland re their researchers.
If I had a dollar for every time one of our editors purged statements to fit the theme of the magazine...
You might wanna consider retaining an attorney over the ordeal with Time. The ACLU may be a place to start, though I'm sure they can direct you to another legal source more fitting your circumstances.
Shirt-slogan guy looks really familiar. Not in a Cleveland nut-case way though. I'm thinking "southeastern Republican"...as if that narrows it down--but I've seen that face, and it wasn't launching any ships.
I take offense of all of this too!
Best of luck with the less cerebrally engaged, Norman!

Rated.