I met my first mean girls in grade school. I didn't know that they were mean girls. I didn't actually know what that was. I mean, I had a brother who called me a 'butthole' behind my parents' back and occasionally punched me in the arm, but I wasn't really acquainted with anything meaner than that.
I was lucky. Who knew?
Anyway, in fourth grade, the school I attended decided to separate the classes of students, all of whom had been together since first grade. It was done to "give us exposure to new friends and new learning experiences." You know, it was something done because the adults were bored.
All my friends were separated and sent to different classes, and I ended up in a class with all the "popular" girls. (Popularity starts in first grade. Well, heck, now maybe it starts in kindergarten, in daycare, in the womb.) The popular girls were not separated because the majority of their very rich parents were on the school board and didn't allow that to happen.
When I went to my parents, bless their hearts, and told them about my loneliness and worry, they told me to buck up!! That these girls were just people! I had so much personality! (And now, how many parents tell their children that? ha. I look back on that sentence with great fondness and some wry amusement/horror. It always sounded like I kept a Big Bucket of extra Personality on hand.) They would like me, and if they didn't, they didn't deserve to be my friend.
They were right, of course, generally speaking but does that make it feel any better when someone rejects you, especially at the age of eight and nine? Alas, no. Acceptance is so greatly desired, especially because, it is my experience, among girls that age, they are starting to discover their place in the world and are finding out that much of society sees their self-worth in terms of what they look like. Brains are not as valuable as beautiful hair in a young girl. I hate that THAT is still true, pretty much. Come on, y'all. You know it is.
But I took my parents' advice. I made friends with the popular crowd. At first it was great. They called me funny; they loved my hair. We had slumber parties and put shaving creme in one girl's bra, listened to Peter Frampton (my lord.) and had a good time. Well, mostly.
I mean, okay, well, there was that thing where they told me I shouldn't hang out with my old friends because they were ridiculous and lame. That was very uncomfortable. And there was that part where one of the things that they liked to do the most was to torment this poor girl who I can now pretty safely say must have been on the autism spectrum. She stayed by herself a lot, never really did anything in class but sit in the back and hum and rock, and she spent a lot of time with the school counselor and with the special ed section of the school. She was from a poor family and wore old sweaters with little tiny sweater 'pills' all over them. Her hair was rarely washed. Her face was already awash with tiny pimples.
My new friends like to throw their sandwich crusts at her at lunch and walk by her table and hold their noses as if she smelled bad. They tripped her on the playground. They got the popular boys to help them. They would corner her on the playground and push at her while the girls all laughed.
Where were the adults? Well, usually smoking off to the side or quietly eating, seeing it ALL and doing nothing. Rich parents. School board. Keeping their jobs.
It was kind of like a John Hughes' movie on mescaline. Without Molly Ringwald dressed in goofy but cute clothes. No one poor and weird got the rich, sensitive boy.
At first, I tried to participate in these activities. I wanted so desperately to fit in. But I stopped sleeping at night. I had awful dreams I couldn't really remember in the morning. I spent a lot of time in the bathroom crying. I didn't really even understand it myself.
Finally, I refused to do it. One of the girls, the ringleader, would actually egg the other girls on to do these terrible things, while she herself sat back and did nothing. One day on the playground, she told me to walk by and spit on the girl. I got up, legs trembling, stomach churning. I looked over at the adults, smoking on the edge of the playground. At the popular girls, all laughing, their faces so innocent and happy and lovely. They were so beautiful looking. I walked by the girl. I stopped. She looked up, her face, already scarred by those little pimples, her hair lank. She was rolling one of those little pills on her sweater back and forth in her hand. I looked back. The girls were waiting. I gathered the spit together in my mouth. And then I just couldn't do it. I'd like to say I met her eyes, and we connected, but no, really, something in me, something put there by my parents or by some mysterious lesson I'd learned in kindergarten stopped me. Who the hell knows? I just said, "hey." She didn't even respond. And then I ran to the bathroom and hid there for the rest of the afternoon. When I returned to the classroom to get my books, the teacher didn't even ask where I'd been.
When I came to class the next day, the popular girls wouldn't speak to me. They made faces at me. They passed notes. One girl screamed at me on the playground and pushed me. They started making fun of me. One of them spit on me. I spent a lot more time in the bathroom.
At lunch, they pushed my tray off the table. They had the boys come up and take away my food or pick their noses and spread it on my tray. They pretended once to re-friend me, saying they forgave me, then took it back, laughing in my face when I cried.
I never told my parents. Never.
When I got to the next grade and from then on, it was different for me in terms of making friends. I went to school. I did the schoolwork and did well at it. I was friendly with everyone. I even made a couple of new friends and spent time with them. But I pulled back from being truly close with anyone, a habit I still cling to somewhat. This made me mysterious, evidently, and I had tons of friends but no one I wanted to really know well.
I did find that, outside school, there were wonderful things, like theatre and music and I made friends there too and really enjoyed myself. But at school, I was marking time. I was horrified at the idea of a high school reunion. Why would I want to go to that?
When I went to college, I thought I was done with it. No more mean girls. We were here to LEARN. (Oh my lord. I really believed that. Bless my heart.) In my second week, I made friends with this girl from one of my classes and she and her roommate asked me to come over for dinner and a movie. After the movie, we walked back to the dorms, the girls oddly excited about something. They kept telling me, "You're going to love this! It's hilarious!" They got popcorn and sat out on the lawn in front of the dorms where we could look into dorm room windows. I was slightly scandalized by this act, but thought maybe we were going to spy on some half-naked boy. I know. Terrible but hey, I see the male chest as a lovely thing.
Instead, they pointed to a window high up on the eighth floor. In it was a girl, on the top bunk of a bunkbed. The light framed her perfectly. I met her later. She had some serious mental problems. I'm not sure what, to tell you the truth. She didn't bathe much. She had a weird thing her face did, contorting slightly when she spoke. Her hands shook a little, and she sweated a lot. Not very appealing, right? She also hallucinated later in the term and thought someone was trying to kill her. The police had to come, and eventually, she had to leave school, heading straight for the hospital.
Anyway, the light framed her perfectly in the window. She was rocking, violently, back and forth, back and forth. Over and over. Like a little child. The girls next to me started laughing hysterically. They sat on the lawn, ate popcorn and watched her. And laughed and laughed.
I got this weird metallic taste in my mouth as I sat there, transfixed by the girl, rocking back and forth, her hair flying around her face. I didn't tell them to stop. I told them I had to leave early and get some sleep. I walked around the corner and threw up in the bushes. Everything from grade school came back in this nasty rush. I went home and pushed it out of my mind. I tried never to think about it again. Not very noble of me, but there it is.
Later, I read the book by Cheryl Dellasega called Mean Girls Grown Up. And I recognized everyone in it, including myself.
I know now it never stops, no matter what my parents said about high school staying in high school. I'd like to say I've found a set of friends who don't do that, don't like to insult or dissect other people for their pleasure. But, it's not true. I still have friends who spend their evenings at the bar making fun of some other girl's outfit and hair, who say bad things about each other behind each other's backs. I don't participate, but stop it? Impossible. They tell me "You are just too nice." That's a lie, as you must know. I am not nice. I am a hypocrite and a liar. I just don't get involved, whatever that means.
I cannot ask for forgiveness of anyone. I never learned that little girl's name. I have blocked the name of the other girl from my memory or it's just gone, which is less dramatic.
I look at my child. She is so beautiful. I know. I'm a mother. They all think that about their children. But, she is. And she has loads of personality. And I get ridiculously maudlin and dramatic and think, "Which will she be? The bully or the victim or the sideliner?" Then, I shake it off. She's herself. I dream of her rising above all of it and being the most well adjusted person on the planet. That movie "Parenthood" comes to mind.
I don't know. I saw that article about that poor little boy, dead at eleven. Bullying transcends gender and is still largely ignored evidently.
I was lucky. I never wanted to kill myself, I confess. I just wanted those girls to go away. Just find erased them from the universe somehow. In my fantasies, aliens came and took them in the night or one morning, everyone woke up and they just didn't exist. But, that's pretty silly.
I still don't sleep much at night. I've really moved on from those times when I was little. I'm fairly well-adjusted. But sometimes at night, I think of the girl's hair, flying, as she rocked back and forth. And I sit up and try to think of something else.


Salon.com
Comments
Powerful story, Odette. Thank you for sharing. Rated.
this is an amazing post. thank you for writing it.
It's tough out there. I have a 16 year old. She is past the middle school years where it is the roughest.
BBE--oh my god. no way. I'd be dead in a week from exhaustion. The parasite is a wild woman.
It was disheartening to me to learn last year when I worked briefly in my grandkids' daycare center, just how young the mean gene expresses itself.
In my darling Scarlet's class were TWIN mean girls (and the slightly less mean one was often her sister's victim).
One night at my house as I tucked her into bed, Scarlet told me tearfully that Abby, Mean Twin #1, had told her that if Scarlet would be mean to a certain boy in class, Abby would give Scarlet some chocolate. "I don't want to be mean," said Scarlet. "But I want the chocolate."
How does a child get to be so mean, so young, and not only that, so manipulative and hateful? Almost enough to make you believe in things like "bad seeds."
Brrrrrr!
I did fine in high School and beyond. I never saw or heard from that bitch again especially since they knocked heads at our High School over racial slurs.
Time wounds all heels, I guess.
Excellently written!
Rated
No one has noted it , but the same sort of thing has been going on here, this past week. Lovely, glib ones taunting someone less fortunate, and rationalizing it like crazy. It is still mean.
I've got little girls not yet in grade school...already I see tentacles of this peculiar stuff within play on the figurative playground. It's not bullying but certainly competitiveness and teasing.
As a kid, I was at the receiving end of bullying a time or two and remember it well. I was rarely an aggressor because I found the experience painful...I guess its harder to live with oneself when one sucks than it is to live with the PERCEPTION of sucking (ie being told you suck when, in fact, you can rest in the knowledge that you don't). The true success of the mean girl is in the mastery of this limitation.
(Btw, did you hear that the "Craigslist" killer was a former high school bully?)
As for my attitude about "mean girls" now, I'm mixed. For one, the term has to be defined. You defined it well (sitting around with popcorn taking pleasure at someone else's pain), but not everybody is in agreement. For example, not everybody knows themselves well, and most tend to focus on injustices received rather than on those meted out.
I try to be patient, to not jump on bandwagons of the personal nature, and keep perspective since most misunderstandings around here (on OpenSanatorium) occur because bloggers assume personal slight when the slight is in the abstract--a slight of idea, for example--this is, after all, just a conglomerate of electronic pulses and circuits. That attitute works just fine in the parallel universe beyond the computer too...
June Jordan writes in Soldier, "Remember, it's a bully. You can't win," but you can make em hurt so they never want to fight you again. She says that, growing up in Harlem, she was in a lot of fights, but no one ever fought her twice.
No one ever forgets, nor really gets over what "crimes" were committed against them when they were young. Again, great piece, Odette.
I grew up in a different time and place - that kind of mean couldn't have happened.
That is not to say that children weren't mean or that some weren't bullies, but to me, the quality was different - somehow less caustic.
Mean girls will ALWAYS suck.
Lea--It was a rough week with behavior that got completely out of hand. There's a special type of bullying that happens on the Internet whereby friends come when someone is feeling attacked and a feeding frenzy ensues. Sometimes, even the most well meaning individuals get caught up in it. It has the flavor of the mob. To tell you the truth, it has yet to completely cease, and I wish we could all put down our weapons of choice (words) and move on from it. I wrote this after reading about that poor boy, but I guess, indeed, this does apply.
Let's concentrate instead on ways of stopping this behavior as opposed to denying its relevance or its existence.
Bullying does exist at all ages, pretty much. It still hurts people, I'm sure. It's great to want to rise above cruel and petty actions, or even declare yourself above it, but in truth, even the most self-actualized individual has trouble. I mean, look at what happened in Germany in the 30s. What is bullying if not the opening shot of a person filled with fear hurting others to feel better about him or herself. It doesn't usually end so dramatically, with concentration camps and death, and certainly, the Holocaust was much MUCH more complicated than that. I don't want to boil it down to school yard bullying at all.
But it was about difference, and socioeconomic factors were involved. Those are pretty striking similarities. We should be aware of the bully, and the victim, in all of us, all the time, I think.
I'll go for the very brief...I was a victim, but I would have never called myself that, because my reaction was anger and I didn't take it passively. In fact, I never self-identify as a victim in anything because it is weakening to do so.
If there is any chance of changing the apparent acceptance and acquiescence of bullying in our society...not just among children, but across ages and situations, we need to stop quietly standing by. To say that that's how it's always been and always will be is to perpetuate it.
It even sounds SEXY. the DELETE button. heh heh How erotic.
And you're not preachy. You don't need to pull back at all.
It's interesting; I tend to have more male friends than female friends, and it has ever been thus. The female friends I've got all present as more "guy" than "girl," as well. I think the reason for this is that I've always despised the dynamic you describe here; I have no patience for it, and I extract myself from social relationship with women who are All Claws relatively early on.
I think I've also said before somewhere, eons ago, that I cannot bear to watch film "comedies" that are sadistic/humiliating to the characters. The "Something About Mary" syndrome feeds the cruel streak in the dark corners of the human soul and I find it sickening.
Thank you for writing this.
odetteroulette
That is perfect Odette. If we could just do this. I know it's impossible, but if we only could
What a wonderful, wonderful piece you've written.
I call it the "elision" button, on those special occasions.
I think the awareness of this "mean" behavior was less---as well as the consequences of such behavior. I think your own awareness will mold the values you pass along, and your daughter will be neither a perpetrator nor a victim, passive or otherwise.
Thanks for these comments, you guys. I wonder, sometimes, what it would take to end it. In the John Hughes' movie, all it takes is one drunken night and some cake or a big dance. In reality, there must be a way to start the conversation in the classroom, as well as at home.
Thank you for being so open, so honest, and so brave.
Now that I am a parent, there is a dark corner in my mind where I sometimes wonder whether my kids will be bullied or ostracized. It's one thing to have survived it ourselves. It's quite another to have to watch our sweet little children go through the same cycle of cruelty (be it giving or receiving) all over again. When will this cruelty stop?
Rated for relating.
I can't help wondering if any of the "popular" girls or "mean" girls grow up to remember themselves as such? How many would see themselves in this story?
I think some women tend to rationalize the nastiness of their youth as just something girls do or maybe, in cases like this, they are too self-important to realize the human damage they've done.
I've always had the fantasy of finding every bully I ever encountered, just to straighten them out.
I wasn't going to read this (I was supposed to leave for home already - the wife keeps texting me, "when are you leaving?") but I felt compelled after the first few lines.
I was tormented relentlessly in high school, by one person in particular. My family moved a lot - almost every 2 to 3 years - so I never made any real friends. An inability to make friends is like catnip to a bully.
And I do mean relentless - every day, nearly all day, from gym class to the long walk home. After breaking down crying in my guidance counselor's office, asking him to please make it stop, it would abate for a while - he got his friends to pick on me until he felt it safe again.
Both physical and emotional torture. For the most part I sat there, pretending to ignore it (anyone else's parents ever tell you to do that? just ignore them?), paralyzed with fear.
Then one day he snagged my shirt out of my gym locker. There was no one there but us, and for some reason I felt the theft of my shirt was enough and I chased him. I bumped him grabbing it back, and he collided with a steel fire door, shattering his knee cap.
I'll let you guess who was reprimanded for the incident.
Still, it's hard to bully someone from crutches. He never bothered me again.
Made me cry actually. Well done.
it's troubling when I stop to think about what my son may go through when he's old enough. ...which is apparently now, as he's in daycare for about a year now. (Helen, they learn that from someone, you know) I have two nieces, the youngest of which is almost 4. They think it's pretty funny to say "poopie-head."
After reading this, I'm just as troubled that he might get bullied as I am that he might be the bully. Yes, I know all parents say this, but my kid is adorable (to the point that I'm still not convinced he's mine). What if he gets too popular? But then, I'm not exactly rolling in dough, so he's got that going for him...(?)
I may just tell him what my dad never told me: you only have to knock someone's teeth out with a bat once, then they leave you alone.
I hate 'numeric' rating, I think it is MickeyMouse (I do verbal, as above)
But this One Time I will rate!
Mean girls, Mean guys;
Cmon Odette! ----Tell us The Rest of The Story!!------
The mean girls & guys get smashed and fuck in the back of
a beatup Ford, (I dont mean 'make love', -I mean Fuck!)
-repeat that line 3x, so that I dont bore you by doing so
myself. The pain of a Dumb existance is beyond description.
So painful that the slo-suicide of drugs is often the escape
While the meanies were fucking their brains out in the beer
stink of an old heap, You were having a glass of burgandy
with that shy nerdy skinny freshman, while discussing Proust.
I dont have to describe the mediocre quality, or infinite quantity of fucking your brains out --We are suffocated with such descriptions.
I see you (yes You, beautiful lady) strolling through Chartres
or the Duomo in Florence, with a sensitive, intelligent, (also
recent graduate), companion. whose mind is a maze of Chartres (sp?)
exqisite, infinite, exotic, beautiful detail, and back at the hotel your
body vibrates to exactly those, infinities as his body enters yours.
You fall into the Abyss of hormones dancing to the infinite rhythms
of the fuge, arches reaching to God. The genetic complexity of
the infinity of the mind awakened to the others'.
Pity the meanies. They are condemned to a life of limited
curiosity and blunted sensitivity and they sense this, so become
hurt, lonely resentful and arrogant.
There is a spectrum of pain and joy
within which, the Renaissance of
self realization comes too late to be
expressed with the remaining joys of youth. The purgatory of the trivial
dominates like a silent virus.
Oh my! --Someone we Know???
The 'Age of Someone we Know'??
Pity them Odette, you magnificent, barefoot goddess: Their
pain is infinite; Your happiness is infinite.
Insert: as I write: a tiny (by European measure) Chinese girl (ok young lady)goes by beaming like the sun.
she stops, picks a flower, giving it
to her baby. Then beams to the
point of ecstacy.
At the same time a grantourisimo
xx5sex MeanCar goes by drowning the
scene with belching roaring dual
pipes. Poor guy, he missed the
mother baby and flower.
Smiling dragons ward off evil and purr
Argonne
I've never read your particular perspective before. I've heard from bullies, from victims, and from rescuers. But not from someone like you, one of those who swell the crowd of hangers-on. Thanks for sharing this, how it happens, because before reading this I had no idea what such people were like or what they could possibly be thinking.
Is it really true that your friends today are the same way? Because mine aren't. I mean, I have very few friends, and they have to do a lot to be called that, but they really aren't. I can see that my mom's friends are, though, horrible women who have contests about whose children are best and whose husband is worst. And yet my mom says her friends are wonderful, even as I watch them eat her alive and try to ruin her relationships with her family.
Why are so many women like this, do you think? My husband says its because women don't hit hard enough, because any man who acts the way these mean girls act wouldn't live past second grade, so they've been eliminated from the gene pool. But that sort of points out that men do the same thing, only they usually do it with fists or slamming each other around in trash cans instead of with mockery. Which he does not deny.
I can so relate to what you are talking about here by time I was in high school I got to what the point where i had lots of friends but no one I would want to know well and keep around forever. Kind like you talked about closing off. By college I was a single mom so I just kept to myself and didn't make friends in college not like when you stay in the dorm and all. It doesn't change I had to see it all over again with my girls who are now 23 and 24. Parents, Teachers, School Broads do have a lot of role play in what goes on, I think more then some people want to believe. They should start teaching about bullies at an early age.
Thank you very much for sharing this.
-Is the seeming isolation of child hood
bullying from earlier influences, and
later consequenses. I also got a little
too rhapsodic for a response to an
article describing the reality of the personal pain of mean kids. Odette
must have rolled her eyes: 'I slave
over a tight essay, and Argonne
just wants to flirt and play!'
Culpa Culpa!
However as with serious
abusers there is a parent-
to child to parent cycle.
My suggestion was (unremarkably),
that unhappy parents make unhappy
children. My particular (poorly
expressed) observation was that
the pains of adolescent 'boot camp',
often drive the child toward a search
for a refuge: in books, music and
art. And that was My experience.
(which adds a bit more credibility
to my observations).
Further, (in discussion), and age, of
the individual, this can progress
into a continuing personal growth,
-because the individual discovers
the Process. None of this is new,
and it is greatly encouraged. To
say that all our social problems
are child problems grown big is
not wrong, but I see it going on
forever unless more thinkers stand
up and identify crap as just that.
So I end up saying nothing...
I should stick to outrageous satire?
--at least it calls crap what it is: Crap.
-which perhaps is step 1: Identify the
problem. Cheers.
,,
this can be the start,
..
Argonne--That's very astute, about the causes. Perhaps unhappy parents do indeed make unhappy children. Really astute. And thank you for the nice things.
JK--Being distant, yet friendly is a great defensive maneuver--although I have a feeling that by not committing myself fully emotionally, I missed out on wonderful, wonderful experiences and feelings.
But it still breaks my heart to look at my college students and see all these sensitive, intelligent, original young people who are made miserable by other kids who are dumb as hammers and bile-nasty. Sometimes I get the chance to take those lovely kids aside and repeat the speech that one of the South Park guys made in "Bowling for Columbine": pretty much all the most interesting, unusual, impressive people in the world were tormented by "popular people" when they were young, and most of the "popular people" end up permanently selling used cars or in dead-end office jobs or in jail, dreaming about the "glory days" of high school.
Well, you have a spot on my own personal cover, girl. Sending you a PM.
Thumbed big time.
As for my memory of being abused by the mean girls, I've forgotten none of it and remember all the names involved. I envy those that can block such unpleasant memories and leave them far behind.
Great post!