At every point in America lately, when there's even the possibility of a lull in the conversation, things turn to Penn State. The story is certainly gripping and fascinating in an extremely unhealthy way, and it has been on everybody's minds. The story has a feeling of some very creepy Steven King novel that you're only halfway through, and you don't know the ending yet.
I remember watching the 1997 Rose Bowl when Penn State beat Oregon. Even though my team lost, I was incredibly impressed by the quality of the Penn State football team and the quality of their fans. The whole outfit was extremely classy, with its aura of sportsmanship before anything, graciousness in both victory and defeat. And yet, this was the very time when Jerry Sandusky was doing his thing with hapless little boys under the auspices of his charity.
I told Jeffry today that if the entire Penn State football team had been lost in a plane crash, that wouldn't have done the damage that Jerry Sandusky and the mendacious system of the Penn State administration did to not only their football team but to their entire university. Jeffry's a humongous sports fan, and he agreed. Think of Larry Craig. Think of Jim & Tammy Fae Bakker. Think of Reverend Ted Haggard. Each of these people are and will be eternal jokes and punchlines for their sexual pecadillos. They're still good for a slow night on Letterman or Leno. Drum roll, please.
Now think of Penn State's damaged reputation from this incident. A hundred years could go by, and Penn State will still be remembered for this horrible, tawdry incident. And here we come to the solution -- what really must be done if Penn State is to do anything to salvage its permanently damaged reputation. And I call this the University of Chicago solution.
In the 1930s, the University of Chicago was a Big Ten school. Matter of fact, it was a powerhouse with the immortal coach Alonzo Stagg. For a time, Stagg not only was the UC football coach, but he was the UC basketball and baseball coach, too. His reputation at the time was certainly the equal of Joe Paterno. In 1935 UC halfback Jay Berwanger was the first recipient of what later became known as the Heisman Trophy. And yet.
Robert Maynard Hutchins was the President of the University of Chicago in the late 30s, and as much as the football team added to the reputation of the school (as well as being a profit center), Hutchins made the very radical decision in 1939 to abolish UC Big Ten football totally. And in 1946, Chicago withdrew participation in any Big Ten sports. Why? Because Chicago wanted to concentrate on academic excellence, and not on athletics. This move seems to have served the University of Chicago pretty well -- given that it is in fact one of the top ten academic institutions in the world under any yardstick.
Penn State has also had a reputation for academic excellence. And now it finds itself in a nightmare that will never end. As long as Penn State has a major league football program, its players will always enter the stadium on Saturdays under a cloud. If they're the visiting team, it will be hard for the crowd to resist making cruel jokes, chants, and displays at the expense of the Nitany Lions. Forever.
Yes, I know that much of your school identity is wrapped up in football. Yes, I know how much money it brings in each year. Yes, I know how important football is in general to the people of Pennsylvania. But if you are ever going to get out from under the cloud that Jerry Sandusky et. al. has placed you under -- there's only one solution:
Give it up.


Salon.com
Comments
However, I think if Sandusky was a star professor and his charity about reading, the results might have been the same. None of the people involved could believe the man they thought they knew could be a pedophile and the institutional memory was too fragmented to put the pieces together.
It's a great pity that alumnae don't seem to be as willing to contribute to generous labs and world class research as they do to new stadiums and bowl-winning football teams.
Favorite Hutchins quote: "Every time I get the urge to exercise, I lie down until it goes away."
I'm not sure Penn State could handle the change.
There are respects in which I like the suggestion. The main one is that anyone anywhere who witnesses anything like this on a college or university campus will forever jump all over it.
By my reckoning there are probably only three Division I programs remotely clean -- Vanderbilt, Northwestern, and Stanford -- and it's not coincidence all three are noted first for academic, not football, excellence. Some say the military academies should also be included in that list. Maybe.
Sad as it is to say, I don't think anyone would be surprised to find cheating -- or at least seriously bending the rules -- going on at any of that half-dozen institutions. Personally, I'd like to see universities give up their association with "college" football altogether. Let the NFL use the existing system for the minor leagues -- since that's what it is now.
Football programs make the same claim. I've yet to see a forensic accountant's review of any of such claim. Do these programs add any cash to their school's endowments? I suspect not.