O'Really?'s Blog

Think of it as "cartouche lite"

O'Really?

O'Really?
Location
One of many,
Title
Soloist
Company
Less often than not
Bio
A work in progress

MY RECENT POSTS

SEPTEMBER 17, 2010 7:42AM

10 Reasons Why I Don't Fast on Yom Kippur

Rate: 26 Flag

Yom Kippur is the holiest day in Judaism.  On this “Day of Atonement”, one reflects on his or her sins over the past year by partaking in a 24-hour period of fasting.  What this basically translates to is a hunger strike that is imposed on you by the faith you were born into, married or eventually chose as your own. It's kind of like being in prison without food or water, without the prison.

The fasting period begins at sunset this evening.

While I have tremendous respect for those who take it upon themselves to starve for an entire day (which should in no way be confused with people like Victoria Beckham, who apparently thinks she is Jewish and that it’s Yom Kippur 365 days of the year), I reserve my right to avoid this practice like the proverbial plague.  Because hey, if it was written into some religious law to jump off a cliff or partake in a plague for a day or two each year, would you do it?  Would you?  Just asking.

                      posh  

As the daughter of a Holocaust survivor, I often asked my parents why we didn’t participate in this annual act of self-denial ritual, and was given the same response each year.  “Your family starved enough during the Holocaust and the war, and no member of our family will ever look like Victoria Beckham starve again.”  Fair enough.  But this was the same answer they gave when I asked the burning Passover question, “Why is this night different than all others?” or "Why can't I stay out past midnight?"  Call me naïve a quick study.  Or hungry.  Or both.

As I grew into a somewhat mature adult, I began to see the wisdom of my parents’ argument, but also managed to form some opinions of my own regarding religion and fasting.  

Herewith, the Top Ten reasons why I refuse to don’t fast on Yom Kippur:

Food and caffeine. I can’t exist without them.  Preferably administered on a reliable drip, like IV fluids.

Fasting is punishment.  If I am to atone for my sins by thinking about or acknowledging them, who needs hunger pangs to interrupt me and get in the way of dealing with them?

Martinis.  On an empty stomach, they make you say and do stupid things.  I like martinis.  I don’t need to be drinking them on an empty stomach to say and do more stupid things than I already do when I have food in my belly.  Capisce?

Bad breath.  Fasting causes bad breath.  I hate bad breath.

Moodiness.  Fasting brings out the mean and ruthless in people.  Hell, my dad is mean and ruthless when he’s not fasting.  Add me into the mix without food, and you’re going to witness this in stereo and probably get a fight on your hands.  Who needs more mean people?

Lethargy.  If I’m going to tryptophan the light fantastic, there better be turkey involved.  Just sayin’….

Do you have any idea how much those temple tickets (and the appropriate outfit) cost to go along with this whole idea of suffering?  If I really wanted to suffer, I’d be married. 

Parking spaces at temple.  Damn near impossible to find.  You’d think it was Costco on Christmas Eve.

Hypocrisy.  Pretending that you are going to absolve yourself of being an asshole the other 364 days of the year by being “really good” in the eyes of snooping, suddenly holier than thou, one-day-a-year Jews checking out your jewelry the lord by “atoning for your sins”, is about as ludicrous as expecting to go on a diet and lose the 50lbs you gained last year over the course of one day.  Not happening.

Nothing changes.

I’ll probably go to hell for all this, but I’d be lying if I didn’t say this was the truth; at least for me.  And, in case you’re wondering, the same reasons above apply to why I don’t shop the day after Thanksgiving.  Or go out on New Year’s Eve and make dumb resolutions. 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I love this. I might be going to hell for saying so.~r
At least I'll be in good company, Joan....
I don't think you are going to hell. For starters, I think the only hells there are are the ones we make right here in this life.
Well...... this is clever, but I, personally, take the holiday, esp the the days between Rosh Hashonah and Yom Kippur very seriously. Fasting is just part of it for me. Maybe being a Southern Jew in a small town makes it easier all 'round...esp the parking, for example.:)
this just reassures me once again that the coin has two equally valuable sides. I read Lea's YK post and would be torn to have to choose which I enjoyed more. Tsom Kal.
Sounds good to me.

(In my religion, every holy day is a feast day. No fasting days at all. Wine is usually involved too.)
The last one is why I forgo any organized religions. So I guess I'm going to hell with the other party girls.
O'Really ... it is always good to see you (and I mean that in only the nicest of voyeurish ways).

As you know, I am a religious historian, and as such, my studies (and findings) deal with the evolution of religions. And Yom Kippar is a prime example of this. As you said, "Fasting is punishment. If I am to atone for my sins by thinking about or acknowledging them, who needs hunger pangs to interrupt me and get in the way of dealing with them?" This was the same conclusion arrived at in the early Christian Church (later on to become Catholic). So they replaced Yom Kippar with Confession. Similarly, the Protestants replaced wine with grapejuice for communion because so many kids were over-indulging in the "blood of Christ." They also replaced wafers with bits of Saltines, but this was not a religious move, only a cost saving one.

But such is the evolution of religions... and why I, a non-practicing Baptist-Episcopal-Lutheran-Presbyterian (who has indulged in Catholicism and Judaism), can be eating food tonight; we have no idea what to do ... so we ponder it over a good meal with plenty of booze to drink. I'm thinking a Vodka Martini (shaken, not stirred)followed by steak and/or lobster, accompanied by a nice Merlot.

Hope to see you again (wink!) real soon. {{{R}}}
Cartouche, I loved this.
My Dad had the same feelings about fasting for religion, must be the childhood poverty rearing it's ugly head. He also used to say being good for a day, doesnt change the fact that some people are asses the other 364. Makes perfect sense to me. Guess I'll be joining you all in hell. I just hope there's good parking and no overpriced admission fees.
The only time I will fast is when the doc says I have to before some procedure, and then I am cranky. Now I need another scone with my coffee!
lolol

signed,
never did and never gonna 'fast' jew
This is GREAT.
and so true.
(your family earned a pass. a permanent pass.)

(frankly I'm not so sure anyone's watching all this breast beating anyway)
One word to shoot down Nr. 4 and thus put the lie to your title, which is one helluva sin in anybody's devotional: breathmints.

If I could forgive you, I would.
I live with a bad Jew. He celebrates nothing.
My mother was Jewish but I was raised an Anglican.
I respect more Jewish customs than he does.
I think we are all living in hell. Great piece and rated with hugs
Yes, Hypocricy sweeps it all under the carpet and makes a mockery of the practice. Most people who follow the tenets of a religion do so to appease their conscience, yet on the other hand if they looked at their day-to-day living, do they really apply those principles? Good for you O'Really ! ~R
There are reasons for the fast that no one speaks about. In ancient times, someone had to prepare meals and, back then, without refrigeration, microwaves and other modern conveniences, this took hard work - so much so that, in order to free the attention of those who would otherwise prepare the food, a fast was declared so that everyone in the family could partake of the spiritual exercise without distraction. It is also true that 24 hours of abstention doesn't do anyone any harm...no one has to drink martinis every single day. In psychological terms, the fast is a marking mechanism that's designed to focus one's attention on the importance of the occasion...just as feast days, like Passover. The difference is that fasting is a solitary experience, even when you do it in the company of others, while feasting is a communal experience. No one feasts alone. You may gorge alone, but feasting requires company. The feast of Passover is predicated by the fast of the first born (only eldest male children are required to perform this fast...but I digress.)

Fasting is a basic spiritual practice. Sufis are occasionally given permission to perform a 40 day fast during which they are allowed only a sip of water and three dates each day (the fruit, not sexual excursions) while performing various spiritual exercises. It has been said that, unless you have performed such a fast, you cannot enter into the ranks of the elevated.

Fasting is a form of sacrifice. It's a gift you give yourself, if you have the strength to do it.

The odd thing is that I often go a day without eating (I simply forget to eat sometimes) but this is one day out of the year where I am compelled to eat.

I am compelled to eat because, while I am an agnostic, I'm not a hypocrite. I hold that anyone who doesn't perform the daily prayers, observe the dietary laws, attend regular prayer services, and conduct themselves as observant Jews, has no business fasting today, as though this one act of observance cancels out 364 days of profligacy. That's not religion, it's superstition, based upon the Christian concept of absolution: the washing of sins by performing spiritual duties. It don't work like that.

So, today, I eat, just to remind myself that while I love the Jewish people, and our traditions, I am a stranger in a very strange land, a stranger living among strangers....but I am starting to wax poetic so here I stop.

L'shanah Tovah my friend.
well done, friend.
Now...I am a far better Jew than any here as I fast TWICE in Yom K.
Betw B-fast and Lunch and betw Lunch and Dinner. ....... okok....

r.
List me as another Jew who doesn't participate in the High Holy Day rituals. I have eliminated the middle man (organized religion) and I deal direct.

Bacon (without butter on it) and eggs sound good for breakfast tomorrow.
Sage has some good things to say. In most of the world, for most of our civilized history, gathering and preparing food took most of the damned day. I was recently at a concert, where an African drummer/singer did a song, abbreviated version, because the real thing took hours, which was done while gathering the daily firewood and digging up roots and mashing and boiling and on and on. We with our freezers and microwaves and supermarkets and deli counters forget that. A fast was a much-needed break for mom.

Forget atonement for sins - a day of fasting (and sunup to sundown ain't that long) could be a time to be thankful for our abundance of easy food (okay, maybe some atonement for our casual over-indulgence...)

And, haha, the idea of three dates of the non-fruit variety a day for someone on a 40-day fast - oooweee. Anyone who survives that is some kind of saint.
I bookmarked this one for a revisit because I knew the comments would be as entertaining as the post.

@mypsyche - There isn't a better party in heaven or hell than the table the party girls here are hosting - I'm claiming a seat right now~ move over honey and start the music.

@Rod - saltines? prolly not because the time I snuck a bag of wafers off the shelf in the office supply closet at a very Baptist place, they were absolutely tasteless. (whaaat!? I was huuuuungry OK?)

@ Sage - grab a bottle, call some friends, and have a feast buddy. No one needs or deserves it more. You think too much. Oh, and some people do need martinis ...
e v e r y s i n g l e d a y.

and Sheepie, go ahead and toss on that butter - it's a Holi-day for cripes sake. Live a little! (then die a little, hehe)
Read, rated and looking forward a nice dinner after the service.
I make a bundle every year scalping High Holy Day tickets at wealthy sinagogues.
R
I don't fast on Yom Kippur either. Not being Jewish may have something to do with it.
The joy of Catholicism is we don't fast, we "give up" at Lent. We give up Clark Bars or Lima Beans and other things of importance. Come on over to the Dark Side
@ Gabby: Thanks for responding to the comments for me! I've been busy trying to fix blu's breaking of OS. (I'm just sure he's responsible for the freaky cover reversion and slow page loads today. Look at how long it took him to come back and post and he hasn't even showed up here to banter, the bastard.) But now, you'll have to excuse me. I have to head south on a totally unrelated mission that requires even more attention than blumenthal does. Keep your eye out for me, wouldja?
Best line:
Do you have any idea how much those temple tickets (and the appropriate outfit) cost to go along with this whole idea of suffering? If I really wanted to suffer, I’d be married
First off, I don't think Binaca is forbidden on Yom Kippur, which eliminates the bad breath problem. (After all, I don't think the ancient Israelites had Binaca, but I could be wrong.)

I used to pass by a synagogue in Hollywood. Agents and producers went there to atone on YK. The next day they went back to stabbing each other in the back.
oops! sorry 'touche! didn't mean to blog hog but it was a good comment string and I can use all the laughs I stumble across these days, and I hope your mission was accomplished (tell me you didn't put on your diamonds and head off to temple...).
I enjoyed reading this too. I just recently heard about the temple tickets. My Jewish friend said that her super WASP husband got a ticket from friend but did not get one for her...I gather that they are hard to come by. I think I may try it (the fast and atonement) next year after I read more. It is an interesting tradition that I would like to experience as a non-jew.
You should go Christian. You can have a big smoked turkey leg in your fist and accept Christ, get born again, with your mouth full of meat shreds, and go to heaven if you keel over the next second. Let's hope Hitler didn't have time to accept Christ. (I might go to hell for this comment.)
If I fasted I'd have a panic attack from low blood sugar. I can ponder and atone with food in my belly. Great post, O'!