Oryoki's House

Where's the Mojitos? I have the guac!

Oryoki Bowl

Oryoki Bowl
Birthday
February 03
Bio
Quaker buddhist, kinda quirky, loves cooking and knitting and movies. Dr Who fan, Scandinavian-aquarian and cat lover. Would love to be paid to travel around the world and write about local healing cultures. While eating and drinking and dancing. One day I will have a health cruise in the fjords.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
AUGUST 9, 2012 1:55PM

No One to Watch Over Me

Rate: 36 Flag

If you haven't already, read Christine Geery's piece on Caregiver Burnout.  

Yesterday, I had a spontaneous lunch with a good friend.  I have been working on summer schedule, which means a lot of half days.  When I return from my vacation I am taking soon, it will be mid September and half days will turn back into full days, and I will have to revv up for a while.  My summer "break" can be seen in a number of ways.  I choose not to fret about unearned money, from loss of hours, and view it as rest and renew time.  I have been investing some of my dollars into rolfing, a very specific kind of body work for structural realignment.  I have been exercising more, taking some dance and fitness classes, knitting a sweater that will accompany me on my trip.  I have been reading more, and letting a little more space in between the thoughts.  Yesterday, my rolfer had to cancel, as his 6 year old was ill and he needed to stay home with her.  This gave me the chance to call my friend to see if she was free, and she was.

We are both childless, but have pretty good communities.  If anything, both of us are most often the caregiver in the relationships we have.  We provide the ancillary support to friends and family who do have children, and are the people who have the childfree time to give a hand to those who need a hand.  And, professionally, we provide education and care.  When people ask about the childfree status,  there is often a charge of being selfish or otherwise, I wrote about it recently here.  Then there is the idea that when you don't have children, you won't have anyone to care for you in your old age.  But, this is neither fair nor true for many people who do have children. 

This friend and I were discussing the possibility of moving, and how we establish our communities of care.  We aren't that old yet, about 40 on either side, and pretty vibrant and active as we can be.  Both of us have had to face disability in life, and work daily to get ourselves out of disability's way to the best we can.  We may have friends and family who can help a little, but mostly we do what we can to not have to ask for that kind of help when we don't have to.  Mostly, because we know it isn't really there, and because we want to save it for when we really, really need it.  

My sister is thinking of moving here, part time.  She does not like Arizona, but she cannot afford to stay in California, and she cannot handle living in Vermont in the winter.  Her heart is in at least 3 places, and our mother lives in Denmark.  My sister, also childless, also faces lifelong constraints of ability and disability.  She has been permanently, partially disabled due to a neck/back surgery from when she was a teenager.  She is also a cancer survivor from her 20s.  Many surgeries and lots of pain.  She is also a caregiver, having spent all of her life babysitting, doing doula work, helping out, offering a hand.  She has had to rely on many friends for a lot of help when she was helpless.  And she has given ten times back in love and kindness, child care, gifts, dinners, rides, friendship.  She is thinking she can buy a house with me, and have it there for her part time.  It will allow her to go where she needs to be (Vermont, for her charity foundation), where she wants to be (California, helping my brother's family with the day to day of small child care) and Denmark (where she and my mom can bliss out in their own special land).  She is my sister, and until one of us dies, she will always be on my list of dependents, and likewise.  Whether or not I marry, this is not negotiable.  

The way of the future is already here.  More and more people live alone, or become single and remain single through out their late adult life.  More and more people eschew marriage and children.  Many women find themselves with a child and still alone in support, as they lack parents in the physical, emotional or material sense.  Statistically, mothers under 30 years of age are unmarried and dependent on their own parents, financially.  Whether you agree with it or not is irrelevent, it is how our society is.  Women are divorcing their husbands instead of just outliving them, and consigned to living alone until they die.  The children they have had are not likely to live near them, or be helpful to them if they do.  They don't give the emotional and material help that any of us, man or woman, parent or childless, need.  Everyone is expected to be self sufficient, but that is impossible.  

Every time I need to do laundry, I must wait for my sweetheart, because I cannot lift the basket.  The last time I tried to do it, I needed to rest out my sprained back for two days.  My laundry piles up easily.  Still, it is no longer something I can do on my own without a lot of pain, struggle and risk.   I also cannot lift the box of cat litter.  Without having my sweetie here, I would have to move to a one floor apartment, with a built in laundry, and reconsider having a cat companion.  I can do almost all the rest of things, though mopping cannot be undertaken lightly.  I am as fit and active as I can be, but that is not enough for self sufficiency.  And I don't have to be on pain meds, psych meds or other meds.  

I have longed to move away from Arizona since I moved here over ten years ago.  I realize now it becomes decreasingly likely.  My sweetie's two children are young, and neither self sufficient in any way.  It's increasingly clear that will happen closer to 25 than 20, if at all.  My aunt and uncle live nearby, and we give each other the support they don't get from their own children and I don't get from my parents.  My sweetie's family lives far away and has never given him financial or material support at any time.  I wish his brother could live closer, but it won't happen.  He has been taken in by my family.  My sister is looking for a house that can hold us, his kids when needed, our animals, and her animals, and some space.  If I get enough yardage, I can have room to put up a yurt or two should another one of my friends need a place to live.  I am happy to make chicken soup, and come knocking, when I have the time.  Yesterday, I had the time.  This goes beyond friendship, these are the people to whom I am pledging my mutual caregivership. 

The reality is that far less than half of our population can look towards a loving and supportive spouse, a financially and emotionally stable family, and responsible and independent adult children.  Every week, I hear from my patients in their 50s and 60s, whose adult children have continued to live off of them, who have abused drugs and alcohol and dumped their children onto the grandparents, who have caused despair to many, who have been abused by partners, and who do not now nor likely will ever provide any semblance of care to their parents.  Their circle of life is broken.

These women may or may not be married, they may or may not be financially able to leave an abusive or emotionally dead marriage, they may or may not have a single person in the world who will show up and help them out.  Many of them quiver in exhaustion, challenging the very notions of what love and family should look like.  For many of them, they will be sucked dry until they are dead.  They know that when the time comes, they will be put in a home and left to compost.  Until then, they are fighting for the last shreds of health and wellbeing they can muster to take care of what they have to take care of every day.  Disabled husband, emotionally disturbed daughter, orphaned grandchild, elderly neighbor with children who don't have time to help.  They still have jobs, because they can't afford not to work outside the home.  They have no savings because they spent it raising their children's children and bailing people out left and right.   There is no respite or comfort in their old age.  

I will not have children to watch over me when I am old.  I will have relationships with the children of my friends, some of whom I have helped out with along the way.  I will not have aging parents to take care of, as my father already died and my mother lives in nursing care half way around the world.  I may or may not be partnered, only time will tell.  My caregiver circle is for me and my sister, my aunt and uncle, several of my unmarried and childfree friends, and my sweetie and his family.  Over these years, I am working on establishing the kinds of friendships that will continue to acknowledge and honor these relationships.  I worry some for my friends with children, as they have no way of knowing if they will ever grow up to be self sufficient, kind or generous.  I worry for some of them who are already overly dependent on their own parents for help, because those parents are getting old.  And I hope, that when the time comes for me, my sister and I can just walk out into the ocean and let it all float away. 

**** 

Open call: who is your caregiver community?  How have you made the connections you will need to support you when you cannot support yourself?  How has your life been changed by disability or caring for someone who is disabled?  If you have children, or a supportive spouse, do you have other friends in your "family" circle?  

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Food for thought. It's nice you've got that relationship with your sister. I'd like that but they both rejected the idea of living close after retirement. Something will turn up. It always does.
This story really resonated with me for a number of reasons: my mother and two brothers do live in Arizona and mostly like it. I too am never married and probably never will (one must be realistic). That ship may have sailed. And while I tended to a lot of my admittedly quite healthy mother's emotional and other issues until two years ago, I cannot say it is not nice to know my two brothers can now take on some of the effort. As they have lived away from the Midwest for so long. Lots to think about, for certain. Lots to make one pause. Thanks.
Phyllis- it is true, there are many people who don't have this relationship with their siblings. I have another friend, divorced and childfree, who is the caregiver to her parents, and the "flex" person in the family. Always providing help or support to her married with kid sister, always being the one to bend and accommodate. And, if she ever learned to ask for help which she doesn't, it will likely come from me and not her family. She was the one who stepped up for me when I was hurt in the car accident. Not my then boyfriend whom I lived with and expected to marry, or any member of his very large and living nearby family. He threw me out because his sister said I was too needy (with the concussion and the broken arm and amnesia).

Mary- thanks, I know these are real issues that I and many of my friends deal with, every day, with little acknowledgment.
This resonates loudly with me as well, as my husband has been living out of state for most of the last almost two years -- only now do I see how easily our life together became dependent on him to do even our most fun recreation: canoeing. I couldn't get that thing on our car if I wanted! Much less to the shore...
Sounds minor, but as a catalyst for my awareness being burst wide open, it's been huge. Changes must be made....and that canoe is just one, and the least important in ways, of the many areas I've noticed this issue in the past year or two.
I love your sentence about having space for a yurt for friends -- our friend owns a dome company, and I've eyed a spot in the yard ever since we moved in for exactly that reason (not a full 5/8ths dome, a lower 3/8ths dome)...although I think I'd live in it and rent the house for income if need be.
Good luck! ...and I'll bet you will work things out in the best way, you incredible smart woman you...
One friend of mine back East got her 60-something yr-old friends together and they went in on a small multi-plex, -- apts? old house? ...not sure, but they all share the building now and when/if needed, will give a free unit to a full-time nurse in some type of exchange for care.
I thought that a brilliant idea.
@ Mary: my mother got married at age 80 to a widower friend from young adulthood days, she said it was just for this very reason. They halved their expenses and shared a condo and kept each other company...and *then* fell in love...
Never too late!
I have always thought my brothers and sisters and I will come back together as we age, moving in to assist where needed. I also believe my grown children, God willing, will be here for me, but if this doesn't work then I will do my best to look forward to what really happens.
Thought provoking and very worthy of an Open Call my friend. I am going to have to give this one some thought and try to answer it.
Your post first served to make me thankful for my own children, who are indeed kind, helpful and self-sufficient. None of us can ever know, though, who will be alive for how long, and who will have financial, physical and emotional resources to spare. The communities we've intentionally built are subject to all the forces that cause us to need them in the first place.

One unfortunate (to me) consequence of looser family arrangements is that fewer young people witness long-term relationships that persevere in difficult times. Interdependencies seem neither permanent nor dependable, so building them is not a priority.
Spouses, siblings &c are only potential care-givers should you find yourself in need.

You can never know whom you can depend upon until the need arises. You may be pleasantly and unpleasantly surprised with different people in your life. Only at that point will it be revealed who are your true friends.
The first time I came back from China was in late Nov., too late to apply for a teaching job, so I took the first job I could get, working with dementia patients. After two days of training (CPR, elder care needs, how to transfer a patient from bed, to wheelchair, to toilet) for 3 years I did this work (even after I got a teaching job I kept one client Betty).

Someday I will write about Betty. For her, she lives in the 1950s, she thinks Ronald Reagan is president, and she had schizophrenia on top of dementia and her (wealthy) daughter did not know how to cope. Betty's husband Bob was a bright alert, exercising kind of Democrat and he and I talked books and politics 2x a week when my job was to pick him up, then get Betty from the Alzheimers facility and take then on an outing (lunch, the mall, a movie, the zoo,....)

Betty could be challenging, but every single day of that job I thanked God it was not me, that I knew family members had so much repressed anger at her for never being the "mom" they needed (she cut all the legs off the furniture when left alone some years back, she said she was "fixing" them).

Sometimes, a non-family care giver is the best option. We don't come with years of repressed baggage.

P.S. Her daughter let me go after 3 years because her mom needed someone "less intelligent." Her daughter was a flight attendant who married a millionaire, and I would take her parents to visit her and was not impressed with her "California lifestyle" and refused to answer her question every time she asked me.

She had her millionaire life-style in California, while I worked for $15 an hour taking care of her parents.

I look back and see what a "karma" job it was. It paid the rent until I got a "real job", but my natural sense of warmth and humor was always enough to carry me over the rough spots.

The work we do for others is our "karma jobs". Through loving kindness we earn our place on the pillow of Nirvana.
Wow, this is a difficult post to comment on. I've very rarely thought that someday I may need help just to get me from point A to point B, as I have always been the caregiver. While I took care of my ill husband for many years, I also had my daughter and son to care for. Plus I worked 45 hours a week, cleaned house, gardened and cared for our dogs. There was no time left for me. I didn't realize that I needed ME time. There simply wasn't any left. It was then that I developed Fibromyalgia and since then have had 2 neck surgeries. I may be well on my way to my third.

My daughter is high functioning and if she had to she could live on her own. I have grappled with this for a long time. If I let her go(which she doesn't want to do and neither do we), I would feel so much sadness for her because she is unable to make and maintain friends, and is easily influenced by others. I'm so happy that she doesn't drink, smoke or do drugs. It kills me to think of her sitting in own place by herself. However I know that someday she will have to.

I consider myself so lucky to have( after 7 yrs) a wonderful, supportive husband, someone I can lean on for a change. Our plan is that we will buy a duplex so that Erin can live next door but still get used to being in her own space. As far as our care goes, I know she will be there, God willing. When we get to the point of needing constant care, as I said in my last post, we would say goodbye gracefully./r

This is an excellent post. It forces one to think of the future./r
Care giving and the ability to recognize the need for it comes in degrees. I've always considered myself independent and never ever in need of a caregiver. I still do; but for a harsh dose of reality check out my August 4th post: It’s Alive!!! TMI? 911 & yet Another Near Death Experience.

There's a big difference between the pride of independence and a being a bonehead.
Very good question. I have no kids, and at my age I don't expect to have any. My parents are both gone. My siblings don't live close by.

My husband is slightly younger and in better health than I am, so he's the most likely prospect. He is a true friend who takes care of people when they're in need. He's always helped me through a serious health crisis and a few less severe ones, and was my rock throughout it all.

But if he ends up taking care of me at the end, who will take care of him later? I hope that one of his nieces or nephews or one of his closest cousin's kids will help.
You live your life so thoughtfully OB. I admire that greatly. That you are building your relationships with care. I have sisters that would care for me to some degree, we are very close. My friends have dropped away and I know my son would probably not be the first to step up, I don't know why I think that, but I do. My daughter and husband would be there but if I needed long term care, I think my husband would opt for a nursing home. I just don't think he could do it. Bluntly said, and painfully thought but true.
Walking out to the ocean>
Yeah.....I think so.
I've thought about this a lot in the past few years, when I got sick both my kids didn't want to be bothered with me. I think it surprised them more than it did me. The youngest needs me now because she has a baby but she's not really the caregiving type, I suppose I'll be on my own and have to do the best I can. Times change, it's kind of every man for himself these days and most people want to get ahead or be out and about instead of burdened. Maybe by the time I can't fend for myself they'll be putting excess people to sleep like we do with the unwanted dogs and cats at the pound.
I have learned that many with fibromyalgia carry the weight of their world on their shoulders. They either won't ask for help, they don't know how, or it didn't occur to them soon enough that they should. It can change, but first we must ask for help or draw boundaries.
Right after I posted this, I had a new patient who met and exceeded everything I mentioned. For her, it has become a life or death situation. Thankfully, I had the wonderful comments, wisdom and insight of so many of you here to draw on. And I am praying she is taking our words seriously.
This post, and just life in general, leaves me thinking that we can only try our best and leave the rest to faith, of some kind. I have a bit of problem with the term "caregiver." I think we love who we loev and we care for who we care for for a million seperate reasons. Giving it a name strikes me as too clinical sounding. Best of luck with all of these challenges. Your thoughfulness will see you through.
So well thought and written thank tou!
My husband and I think about this sometimes. We don;t expect either of our sons to look after us in our old age cause they'll have families of their own then. We don't want to burden them but we are taking care of my father-in-law who has severe Parkinsons and dementia. I hope the boys will learn by seeing that this is what families do. I'm an only child, husband has an estranged sister-so I don't know who will look after us when we are in need. R
This was a fascinating, if sobering, look into the future many of us face. I wasn't aware of the statistic about how few people have a family to fall back on. It makes me wonder what went wrong along the way, but I imagine that's a whole different blog post.

Rated.
Alan- I just was reading the statistics the other day, in that they quoted in another report about young mothers not being covered by their parent's insurance and the gaps in health care law that are still unmet. The surprising part was that mothers under thirty are now less likely to be married and more likely to live with or have financial dependency on their parents, and most don't have jobs that provide health insurance. Because law allows parents to cover their children under 26 on health policies, many do, but it does not extend to pregnancy. One cannot give their unmarried partner benefits, but marriage is not a good financial option for many young men and women who have bad jobs or no jobs.
I'm afraid too many of us, me included, kick the can of denial down the street even while we know the dead end is dead ahead. Thoughtful and thought-provoke essay, OB
Tamar and I care-give one another and I have to say thinking abt a time when one of us may not be able to feels damned dicey.

This is a brilliant essay.

R.
As phyllis said, serious "food for thought"here. Like you, I am childless, but married. My mother is in a nursing home about 1/2 hour from our home and I call her every day and see her at least once a week. I am her only visitor; my brother has divorced himself from her "situation" (Alzheimer's) and life, except for periodic calls. Aside from my husband, I will have no one to watch over me. Such a fragmented society we live in.
Makes one wonder about the extended families of bygone days. The more estranged and solitary our relationships, the more lonely and doomed we are in old age. Excellent piece. Deserves the Ed Pick.
Your points are all valid, and especially poignant to me, since I am one of those children my mother had perhaps counted on to take care of her and who at this point (more than a few years past adulthood) still does not have the financial ability to do much for her. She had four girls, and all of us have had off-schedule lives (according to the "normal" adult progression of careers, marriages, increasing income, kids, property ownership, etc.) and three of us have been or still are financially disfunctional in our daily existence. She is still supporting us in many ways, especially me. I came back to live with her after I lost everything when I got seriously ill and had no health insurance to offset medical expenses. In just a few months I lost my job, my home, my independence and all my savings. My mother and I are great friends and I ended up staying with her even though I could have gotten my own place several years ago. She became the caretaker for her husband when he got Alzheimer's and I was working and gone more than eighty hours a week during most of his decline, which left it all up to her for the most part. I am doing better financially now, much helped because I live with her and have not had the additional expenses of living alone. I plan on caring for her if that time comes, however I can. But how will we afford it?
My father's decline has had me thinking of my own aging and what will happen then. My sisters and I are very close, so I would hope that we will help each other---but none of us has the huge amount of money it would take for a nursing home or Alzheimer's care for any of us. The cost of caring for my father, a good man who worked hard all his life, is horrendous. He wasn't a rich man, but he had savings, which are draining away thanks to the wretched healthcare system we have. Whether or not one has children or famly to help, we must have adequate and affordable healthcare for every single person in this country. This is the crux of the problems you discuss. And healthcare must address the costs of care for the aging. Devastating illness and long-term care costs can destroy anyone's financial life, at any age, as I learned the hardest way possible all those years ago when I had to move back in with my parents after decades of an independent life of my own.
Now, luckily for me, my union has healthcare (which has more than doubled in cost in the few years I've had it, by the way). I just went to the ER for a freak pericardial effusion, a heart problem caused by a bout with the flu. This can happen to anyone, at any age, who has a bad reaction to a normally unpleasant but passing virus. A simple procedure with a long needle fixed the problem and I was good as new. The (thank heavens I was insured) cost for my two days in the hospital? $28,000.
As for not having children, I've never wanted them and I am proud of my choice. We are overpopulating this world as it is, and as you say (and I have witnessed personally) children may cause a lifetime of pain and resource depletion and give their parents back nothing when their parents need their help most. Also, in visiting my father each day in his quite expensive memory care home, I saw so many people there who never had a single visitor. Their families spent much money but rarely gave their elderly relatives the gift of time together. I suspect in many cases it was because the children or spouses were working to pay for that care and had no time, themselves.
I just read a great memoir about friendship called "Let's Take the Long Way Home", by Pulitzer prize-winning writer Gail Caldwell. She had a friendship (with the wonderful writer Caroline Knapp) which was so strong it guaranteed caring and commitment all the way to the end of life. Perhaps we as a society need to give friendships, that circle of people who deeply care for each other, a new status and seriously consider it as a common, accepted and acceptable safety-net in this society where we all live longer and our families spread further and further away from each other in an ever-evolving world. Thanks for your post. - Renee Prince
Renee- phenomenal piece, and if you feel like, you should repost this on your blog. It's true, all you say about healthcare and aging. Also true, is that we keep playing a big self delusional game about independence and cost, and personal responsibility. My own mother would have died years ago if not for socialized medicine and health care. None of us had the money, or any resources, and just now as professionals, struggling to get by and pay off student loans. I no longer want kids, but I also would not have the ability to support them in the manner I see fit. Not spoiled, but well cared for.
I do see that families with a special needs brother or sister often grow up with a different sense of responsibility, in part, because they know their sibling can never be on their own. When that inability to self rely comes later in life- due to mental or physical illness, accident, or other, there is far less compassion or support. Everyone assumes recovery means complete wellness. Anyone who has had a major illness or surgery know that they are rarely the same again.
Oryoki,
Thank you for the blog suggestion. I will do that, as soon as I figure out how to insert a link to your blog to reference what I'm talking about. I'm not a Luddite, but am new to this platform. By the way, after a second reading of your blog, I find myself wondering how it is that people, as you mentioned you experienced, decide to label one "selfish" for not having children. Such a strangely illogical judgement, especially given that you are a caretaker by career choice.
Yeah, this living alone thing is fine as long as one has health and ability. I've been giving the whole matter some thought, as I have one dependent daughter close by and one who could conceivably help us if and when but who lives far away...
And, thank God (Thor or whoever) I live in Canada, where health-care costs are not a consideration.
OK Ok I will watch over you ...just because
........(¯`v´¯) (¯`v´¯)
☼•*¨`*•.¸.(ˆ◡ˆ).¸.•*
............... *•.¸.•* ♥⋆★•❥ Thanx & Smiles (ツ) & ♥ L☼√Ξ ☼ ♥
⋆───★•❥ ☼ .¸¸.•*`*•.♥ (ˆ◡ˆ) ♥⋯ ❤ ⋯ ★(ˆ◡ˆ) ♥⋯ ❤ ⋯ ★R
I took care of my husband for decades, then he died. Along the way I cared for my mother, his mother and my son. Yes, I am a caretaker who is worried, not about me so much, but about my son who is 45 and just now starting life after prison. My new husband is doing a fine job in helping me, though it is much tougher to be taken care of I'm discovering. I do worry about something happening to him, but I don't dwell on it. I have a brother who has taken care of a wife with colon cancer. It seems those who can do. I think about this more and more as I fight off my own disease. Thought provoking and excellent blog.