Peterson Toscano's Blog

ruminations of a queer performance artist

Peterson Toscano

Peterson Toscano
Location
Hartford, Connecticut, USA
Birthday
February 17
Company
p2son productions
Bio
Musings of Peterson Toscano, a quirky queer Quaker where he writes about sexuality, gender, faith, veganism and so much more! Peterson is the creator of Doin’ Time in the Homo No Mo Halfway House. An actor, playwright and activist his other works include Transfigurations, a play about transgender Bible characters

Editor’s Pick
NOVEMBER 3, 2009 11:19PM

I moved to NYC to repent of Homsexuality. Really.

Rate: 21 Flag

I spent 17 years begging God to transform me into a heterosexual--to make me into a man of God. For 10 of those "ex-gay" years, I lived in New York City. Not Little Rock, AR, Huntsville, AL or Odessa, TX, but in big bad Sodom itself. In fact, during that time I met scores of men (and some women) in NYC who attempted to live as straight-acting former homosexuals.  And typically they did not fare so well. Neither did I, but oh what a funky ride!

I lived in NYC from 1985 to 1995 where I received all sorts of reparative therapy designed straighten me out. As a born-again Evangelical Conservative Christian with an acute case of inflamed homosexual desires, I easily encountered  ministers and Christian counselors in the city who were more than happy to de-gay me  (think of deboning a live fish.) In the late 1980’s I attended LIFE Ministries, the Manhattan-based ex-gay support group founded and run by former actors. We met each Saturday night for pasta, praise and testimony to the power of God to deliever the gays.

Dismayed at seeing many of my fellow ex-gays marry then fail in their new lives, I sought further help at area churches and ministries where I fell prey to various servants of God providing counseling, “healing-prayer” and even a deliverance session with freelance exorcist.  (Long story. It eventually got broken up by the police.)

After awhile I got so good at playing a straight character in my own queer life that I actually convinced others and myself that I was no longer gay. The regular relapses into the arms,beds, and crotches of fellow ex-gays and all kinds of cute guys on the street didn't deter me from the fantasy that God delivered me from homosexuality. The bumps seemed like little pot holes on the highway to Heaven.

In fall 1990 I married my closest friend, a young woman from my church. On the same stage that premiered My Fair Lady our wedding took place at the Mark Hellenger Theater, home of Pastor David Wilkerson's Times Square Church, my church home for much of my time in NYC. My wife and I felt hopeful that God could do anything if we only believed and kept beliving and then believed some more.

Five years later my wife and I left NYC for the mission field in Zambia. Shortly after that, (1996) our marriage ended in heartache and divorce, no surprise to our family and friends looking on, but devasting to me who had believed in the miracle. It was then, broken, desperate but still hopeful to change from being controlled by desires for man flesh, that I entered the Love in Action program in Memphis, TN. For nearly two years, (at $950 per month) I worked on my issues and sought the Lord with all my heart. I  ultimately graduated from that program two years later.  I then came to my senses a few months later. I've been coming out ever since.

I spent the past few days NYC in order to hang out with my nephew, a college student at Pace University and to meet up with other ex-gay survivors. I visited old spots where I used to eat and shopeand walk around. I felt a little like the girl in Our Town visiting ghostly places and people long gone. Except I am no ghost; I feel more solid and real than ever before.

I cannot undo all the damage I did to myself and to others. The recovery process from all that madness has been intense. At times I feel sad and downright silly for the nearly two decades I spent living in a bizarre alternate universe that turned out to be a futile mistake.  I understand why I did it and how even in spite of my intelligence and creativity I handed my brain and life over to ministers who believed they knew best for me even though they didn't have understanding of basic psychology or sexuuality.  It was a tragic loss of time and energy.  I work hard to redeem that time and get good out of it, art, meaning.

I tell my story as a witness and warning to others.  I know that in this city today and in cities all over the world, young men and women still struggle to understand their queerness, particularly in light of their faith and family pressures. I pray they don't spend decades seeking the impossible. I pray they see themselves clearly, focus on REAL issues and reject the false promises and the allure of pleasing others in the name of serving God. 

Author tags:

nyc, reparative therapy, ex-gay, gay

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Thanks for your constant, prayerful witness. I'm sorry you had to suffer so much, for so long, but you are, indeed, "redeeming the time."
Wow. Peterson, the more I learn about your story, the more impressed with you I am. First, exorcism??? WTF??? I must hear this story! Second, David Wilkerson! I read the Cross and the Switchblade comic book when I was pretty young and the actually book as a teen/young adult. I was so impressed by that story. (But let's not get into Christian heroes that failed us. Sigh.)

I think of your story as a true redemptive story. You found your voice and your calling. In my eyes, you are a "man of God". You are a beautiful and compassionate person who uses your creativity and intelligence to connect with others. I'm really proud of you.
Eva, hey thanks!
Gwendolyn, it has been a crazy long and winding road. Great material though, eh? I've begun to work on the memoir. 45 pages done!
Have you read Mel White's most excellent book, "Stranger at the Gate"? He has a powerful ministry reaching out to gays who have been through similar experiences as yours. You're right about it taking a long time to disentangle yourself from the damage done...I imagine what you experienced would qualify as a post-traumatic stress disorder. I'm happy for you that you are living authentically and truly. That is where the Bible is right when it says that the truth will set you free. Excellent post.
Horrific stuff. It's quite a shame how your pure faith and desire for your religion sent you into that spiral of denial. If you can take one thing away from it though, it should now be obvious that you are an incredibly driven, sincere and determined person.
Excellent - and congratulations. It's great that you didn't waste more precious time trying to be something you're not. It's also a shame that ignorance and fear blind some to the beauty of the human spirit.
Rated.
No where is there better proof that we are what we are from birth, than in the ex-gay movement.

My dearest friend spent his life struggling to reconcile his baptist faith with his homosexuality. He married and divorced and was plagued by the guilt of this "failure". He was convinced that his suffering was deserved and I think that in his heart of hearts he believed that his HIV was punishment for his sexual orientation. If he could have made himself straight he would have done so in a heartbeat.

No one deserves to suffer so, and there is nothing "Christian" in thinking that sexual identity can be reshaped. I am glad you survived the misguided ministrations, with sense of humor intact no less!
Honest, authentic and poignant. Thanks.
Thank you for sharing this. When I think of the damage our culture continues to inflict on our gay brothers and sisters, I ... I just lost my words.
Fella...anyone who would worship and adore a god who gives a rat's ass about what or who turns anyone on...is a jerkoff.

Either the people who get into all that "homosexuality is an offense against god" have got the message all wrong...or their god is not God.

Frankly, I don't know if there are any gods involved in all this life and living thing...but if there is...and if the god is so petty and childish that it actually cares about bullshit like that...

....we've got lots more to worry about than we think.
Thank you for your courageous honesty and gut-turning story. I can not imagine trying to fight against your true nature and have support for it by ministers. It is heartbreaking. Rated.
"The regular relapses into the arms,beds, and crotches of fellow ex-gays and all kinds of cute guys on the street didn't deter me from the fantasy that God delivered me from homosexuality." I find your promiscuity more abhorrent than your choice of partners. Do you blame God for that too? You crack me up.

You treat those who tried to help you as well meaning buffoons and dismiss your promiscuity as a God ordained creative act. You need more help than trans formative ministry. Did you EVER have a revelation besides one between your legs? How sad....
I pray for that too...because I am just as G-d made me to be!xox
You may have read it already but if not Martin Duberman's "Cures: A Gay Man's Odyssey" about his frustrating, strange, and finally, gratefully failed attempts to become straight, is a wonderful read. Terrifying, but ultimately wonderful, considering Duberman went on to become one of the foremost spokespeople in the queer community over the past thirty years, certainly one of the brightest. I saw an interview with him in which he described reparative therapy as 'an attempt to change who you are,' and he went on to add, 'It hasn't worked for anyone I know, and it doesn't work for anyone I don't know either.' I think that's a great statement not only against the reparative nonsense, but also against subjectivism.
Congratulations on surviving this. Amazing to me that anyone would put themselves through such torture. My experience was almost the opposite - as soon as I knew I was gay, Christianity just slid off me like snow from a roof.
Nothing to do with God, love and faith but everything to do with control and egos that think they are gods. Stay true and keep creating!
Congratulations on becoming a human being once again Mr. Toscano.

You get the toaster back AND an original cast CD of "Anyone Can Whistle."

I've seen your postings and such elsewhere on the net and from the looks of this piece you've got a book. Someone has already brought up Marty Duberman's "Cures." It's a classic -- and he was at the tender mercies of the Harry Stack Sullivanietes rather than organized religion.

And speaking of the latter --

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vEKuGcmW70I
So-called "reparative therapy" has been denounced and discredited by the American Psychological Association for it's destructiveness on the victim who undergoes the treatment.

The tragedy here is organized religion has done such a number on many gay men and lesbian women. The problem isn't being gay but I do think and I believe, the problem is with God's followers.

I hope you find peace and acceptance and if you're gay, please know there is nothing wrong with you. You are perfect as you are.
Reading this I felt as though I was looking in a mirror.
Thank god (small g) that we are both ok now.
The faster you can be who you are, after sifting throught the shit the better off you will be
I'm glad you woke up. I'm thinking of all the others (gay and straight) who haven't.
Wow - you have quite a story to tell here. P.S. - I'm sure you know that Christianity has always had kind of a problem with sexuality of any kind. They don't call it the "missionary position" for nothing.
Philos777 completely misunderstood this article and read into what s/he wanted to see. For those of us who are GLBT the effort to hide that we are GLBT is part of what leads to the permiscuity that concerned Philos777. Had we been treated as siblings in Christ, instead of the horribly unrighteous, we would have found that focus of Love, for God IS Love, that leads to monogomus relationships in which our focus is not sex but Love. But Christians like you made that nearly impossible, and i use "nearly" here because God is greater than you. As yet another gay person who tried the celibacy and prayer route, i can tell you that i do now know that God does Love me and wanted/wants me to find a single individual with whom to share my life - the gender of that person is irrelevant, but the Love is everything.