Mildly Unsettling Commentary & Occasional Literary Confrontation

Palindrome

Palindrome
Location
Santa Cruz, California,
Birthday
September 15
Bio
Essayist. Recovering poet. Mother of a small wonder. What else can I say? I write here about parenting, politics, pop culture, and other parenthetical particulars. Only half of my name is a palindrome...

Editor’s Pick
FEBRUARY 12, 2009 3:01PM

What Love Looks Like A Decade and An Illness Later

Rate: 29 Flag


On the drive to the therapist’s office, the rain is beating down on us. We haven’t fully unpacked since our move back to California, so I don’t know where my umbrella is. We don’t talk. What is there to say? You speed along the curvy, tree-lined roads, going far too fast for my comfort, and I look out the window, hoping to gain some insight from my present state of mind.

We are each buried, for different reasons, under the haze of anger. There is low visibility ahead. Just for today: have no fear, the advice columnist offered earlier that morning. I ask myself, how hard could that be?

At the office, the therapist asks us to sit down. We lower ourselves onto the stiff brown couch, take off our coats. “Is it too cold in here?” she asks, as if there is a reasonable answer to the question.

In the book we once made together, there are many pictures of us. In the book we are young people, less afraid of love and time. I can still see your denim-blue eyes looking out over Coney Island in the middle of winter. I remember the pea coat you wore, the striped orange and black knit cap, how good the hot dogs tasted on that cold day, and the way you put my hands in your pockets to warm them up. Why didn’t we ever wear gloves? Silly Californians in New York, unable to dress themselves properly.

worcester_coney_island02


Now, here we are, in a tiny little office lined with books about anger and joy and the inability to express emotions. Here we are, skating out on Kierkegaard’s frozen lake of indecision.

It has been ten years since that day we called in sick and took the F train to Coney Island. You still have the bard’s eyes, but there is less confidence in them. We are parents, we are borrowers, we are traffickers of spirit and cynicism, of lightness and dark. We have seen too much, felt too much. We have come back from this war, torn and tired, our bodies worn thin from so much doubting, your body worn thinner from disease.

When will we get it back? The levity. The certainty. The feeling that there would be no one else more perfect for me than you. Remember our bodies in summertime, impervious to the paralyzing humidity, tangled for long afternoons in that 8 floor walk-up on 11th and A? Walking, smoking, reading, eating, drinking, fucking, sleeping. How long before that cocoon of unending pleasure undid itself?

You see, some days I have to travel to faraway places to figure out where we left the light. I know in my heart that it will make its reappearance, but for now it seems we need the help of some solitary woman to help us see it again. She will tell us things. She will share her wisdom with us.

This is what I tell myself when I go to sleep next to you at night: Keep moving forward—assuming that is, that you can still walk—into the long and descending but decidedly beautiful shadow of grief. Stop, of course, when you see that it is time to stop. Your nerves will tell when this time has come. The inconvenience of darkness is only of a temporary nature.

This is what I ask myself when I am going to sleep next to you at night: Is there a poem that would make a better song in your head than the sad one that you are hearing now? Is there a poem, at all? If there is not a poem, then you should find one. What good is your life without a poem? You can survive without money, even if you lose it all. You can survive illness, if you are lucky, but you cannot survive without a poem. I promise you this.

Please help bring us back to that light, dear lady with wisdom. How much can we pay you to bring us back there? How much can we pay you to bring harmony back into our lives? To bring the certainty that once was. To bring our young, careless selves back, the people we were before we decided to take a bite of the American dream—you know, the one that turned into the American nightmare. Can you bring the levity back, at least so we can look closely at it again, just for one afternoon, just for one moment?

Where that kind of love has gone, we have gone too. But we, the we that remains standing, or sitting for the time being on this uncomfortable couch, are still here. We are still here, and we will keep being here.

What do we know for sure about our relationship?, the therapist asks. It is a point well worth considering. We have not given up, we have just changed. All the things of the world have changed us, made us less recognizable to each other. All of the sharp edges, the imperfect feelings, transgressions, regressions, depressions, etc. etc. All the etceteras.

We know about music. We know about poems. We know about laughter, which we have always had a lot of. We know about children, about beauty. We know about death. We know about crushing helplessness, the long drive home. We know about hoping, and hoping, and losing hope, about waiting for things to get easier, waiting for the ship that never comes. We know about love that never ends. We know a lot about those things.

And we soldier on, either in spite of them or because of them, where the road leads to no familiar, and finally, to that room in which, when we leave the wordsmith’s shoes outside the door, we narrow down enough to be.

Happy Valentine's Day, my love.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Are you and your Love dancing out of step? My prayer to you that the two of you can find the path together again and waltz your way to perfect dual happiness.
Thank you, Jess D. We are trying our best to keep it together and hoping we will.
Palindrome, this is beautiful and honest. It is the letter that thousands of those who are in long term marriages write. It is the rut, the questioning, the doubting that every marriage must go through, sooner or later. It is the crucible time. It is the time that studies speak of. Couples who endure the long periods of unhappiness up to 5 years are happier than before the unhappiness began. The pathway to intimacy is through disillusionment, one of the hardest things for couples to hear, but it is meant to be a light of hope. I love the question, "what do we know fur sure about our relationship?" Another way to ask it is, "What works in your relationship? What worked in the past?" Go back to it. Practice it. Do more of what works. When you're in it, it's hard and dark. But it's so normal. I leave you with one of my favorite quotes about marriage and hope it brings you hope.

“You move into marriage in the springtime of hope, but eventually arrive at the winter, with its cold and darkness. Many of us are tempted to give up and move south at this point, not realizing that maybe we’ve hit a rough spot in a marriage that’s actually above average.

The problem with giving up, of course, is that our next marriage will enter its own winter at some point. So do we just keep moving on, or do we make our stand now—with this person, in this season?

That’s the moral, existential question we face when our marriage is in trouble.

Bill Doherty
Thanks Mary T.

I love the quote. especially this question: "The problem with giving up, of course, is that our next marriage will enter its own winter at some point. So do we just keep moving on, or do we make our stand now—with this person, in this season?"
Thank you Palindrome for your beautiful, honest, sobering, hopeful, brave post. My first husband and I struggled for a long time in the last bad 5 years of our 28-year marriage and eventually could struggle no more.. We are much happier with our second spouses, but we have not moved from springtime to inevitable winter. I suspect it might feel familiar.

Thank you for the quote Mary, especially the one Palindrome quoted.
Beautiful writing as always. Your love for your husband shines through...what marytkelly said/quoted.
MaryTKelly - I am guessing that you are a fan of Dr. Schnarch, the author of Passionate Marriage (http://www.amazon.com/Passionate-Marriage-Intimacy-Committed-Relationships/dp/0805058265/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1234473900&sr=1-1) ? I, too, bought into his theory...for many, many years, and at one point in my marriage it may have helped if we had been able to see a therapist trained by him. In the end, though, I found what he was selling was not true for me. I think perhaps he was describing a kind of marriage, but not all marriages as he claimed. I also began to question what his theory was based on. What research backed it up?

Books which are based on real research I found to be more helpful: The Good Marriage: How and Why Love Lasts (http://www.amazon.com/Good-Marriage-How-Love-Lasts/dp/0446672483/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1234473814&sr=8-1) and any book by John Gottman.

I also found it helpful to learn about the history of marriage, to reshape my idea of marriage: Marriage, A History (http://www.amazon.com/Marriage-History-How-Love-Conquered/dp/014303667X/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1234473985&sr=1-1) and Love and Marriage in the Middle Ages (http://www.amazon.com/Love-Marriage-Middle-Ages-Georges/dp/0226167747/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1234474034&sr=1-3) as well as a book on the history of marriage in America.
"Couples who endure the long periods of unhappiness up to 5 years are happier than before the unhappiness began. The pathway to intimacy is through disillusionment, one of the hardest things for couples to hear, but it is meant to be a light of hope."

That is hard to hear...the question becomes are we two tangled branches, together for a time but other times winding outward, only later to return to wrap around each other again? Or are we untangling and moving on divergent paths that have no hope of intersecting in the future? I hope your branches re-connect.
This is so good, so heartfelt, so helpful. I am not only giving it "thumbs up," but emailing it to friends. I especially liked Bill D.'s suggestion about the Winter-time of relationships that if endured, makes even better a spring.
Buzz, I don't know about any of those books, except the historical one (Marriage: a History), which I found absolutely fascinating. I quoted some of the factoids in an article I wrote. It really does give some perspective of the way in which culture shapes our attitudes about love (big surprise, huh?)

Thanks for your suggestions...
I literally had to pull away from my screen to read this.

So close to home. So painful.

I am 16 years into the relationship and seven years into the illness.

It is all changed.

Take care.
This rings so, so true, Palindrome. Best wishes to your family.
Beautifully written. For what it's worth, I left my first marriage after 20 years and found true love in a second one.

Good luck ahead.
I read every word. I've been through it all too. (We started on 11th and A too.) Now that she's gone, I look back with an understanding that was totally impossible when she was alive. The suffering at times is unbearable. There seems no way out--but what a fool to think there ever was.
This is real and oddly hopeful.

Thanks.
This is beautiful, what a story you tell with sadness and hope.
After three decades, it has come down to a question of who is my family and this man is that to me. Not much like those early days but then, that would take more energy than I would like to spend. We have a life together. I know his people; he knows mine. Made a child who loves us both. It is those times when she visits, finding us together in her childhood home that makes us both happy. Loyalty counts for something. Compassion means everything.
"And we soldier on, either in spite of them or because of them, where the road leads to no familiar, and finally, to that room in which, when we leave the wordsmith’s shoes outside the door, we narrow down enough to be."

this sort of sentence is the reason i always look forward to reading what you write....
The Buzz: Believe it or not, but my husband and I spent about 5 sessions when we were first married (by the way, my first marriage of 21 years and 4 kids ended in a divorce...this was the absolute right choice for me) with the famous Dr. Schnarch. I didn't care for him one bit. For me, he was brutal, and I would not recommend him. I am also good friends with the well known author of Divorcebusting. We don't see eye to eye on a lot of things, especially divorce. However, given the high divorce rate of 2nd marriages, people would do well to make sure they are not going through a typical rut or the disillusionment that must come when we realize our partner can't come close to meeting our needs. A recent study showed that 70% of divorced people regretted their decision. This is surprising to me. My second life and second marriage have been the best parts of my life.

John Gottman is the go to guy on marital research. I teach all my couples about his Four Horsemen of the Apocolypse. But, like everyone, he's human and on his 3rd marriage.
I hope you're able to navigate these rough waters. Your post was beautifully written. rated.
Just this morning, I posted the following on Bradley Moore's blog, and it seems apropos here also: The beauty of a long relationship is the shared history. I sometimes look at my husband and find myself thinking that he has become my family, and not by birth, but by shared experiences. We have the same children. We've been battered by the same storms. It has been a roller coaster; but we get each other's jokes, and he can still make me laugh.

I would also like to take the opportunity to put in a plug for my favorite relationship book:
"Why talking is not Enough," by Susan Page
(http://www.amazon.com/Why-Talking-Not-Enough-Transform/dp/0787995290/ref=sr_1_4?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1234490325&sr=1-4)

I was touched by your post.

Rated.
Beautiful and heartbreaking. Good luck to you.
"you cannot survive without a poem. I promise you this."

I totally believe that. Ten years, and kids? Try "The Four Agreements." Might work for you. I can hear the love between you in your writing. Spring will come!
My god sometimes I look at the naivete and I am floored. What possible evidence is there that life is anything other than suffering? Please, throw out your ads for lemony fresh Pledge and look inside at your belly the next time you make love and ask yourself what is actually happening there.
Having just past my 25th wedding anniversary I can tell you that I've had many moments when I thought that it would be better if we went our separate ways. But every time I slept on it I realized that I was ignoring the millions of moments when I couldn't have possibly been happier. I suspect that everyone has a clinically depressive moment about their marriage, but it is at those moments that you have to decide to just give, not take.

I think Diana Lane's comment hit it on the head. If you both can realize that your history together defines who you are, you'll understand that no one else could possibly be a substitute.

Illness, though, is a raw deal, period. We all lie in wait for that inevitable obstacle. But, hopefully, your history, the good parts, are enough to see you through whatever end is in store.

I don't think I believe in staying together for the kids. I think I believe in staying together for you.
Painful to read. Wishing you the best.
Mary T. Kelly...

Thanks for the comments. I saw him and his wife at a workshop. It helped for a time. The session of therapy that let me know my marriage was over was with one of their longtime students. I don't know; i think they describe a certain kind of controlling relationship but I don't think they have a handle on what a good relationship is like.

To me the book The Good Marriage was the one that gave me hope that happiness was possible, more than any other one.
I am infinitely better off and happier for having endured periods of doubt and having chosen to walk forward together. Good luck.
Palindrome

I just saw your response to me. I was married for 13 years and spent about 7, 8 years struggling hard with it. I had therapy out the wazoo. I read a bunch of books on marriage. There's a lot of people who don't have a clue trying to help. I was so frustrated by the lack of helpful, genuine information.

The history books in many ways were the most useful as they made me question a lot of my underlying assumptions about what marriage was and whether divorce was bad or not.

When I first read The Good Marriage, I cried my eyes out because I didn't think that I would ever be able to have what she described. Now, though, I jump up and down b/c she talked about happy second marriages and described them and this what I feel has happened to me, like a total miracle.