"The moments of impact end up defining who we are"

Patrick Frank

Patrick Frank
Location
Asheville, North Carolina, USA
Birthday
September 26
Bio
I am a poet-essayist-singer-songwriter, and advocate for the poor, with a teaching and counseling background. I grew up in Florida, now live in Arden, North Carolina. I also lived in New England 20 years. I love nature, music, and poetry. I am married and we have three adult-kids between us and four grandkids! I am interfaith, leaning toward Taoist, Celtic, and Native American spirituality, and an "Obama Democrat." I am now focusing on our upcoming move (within Asheville) as well as my music and poetry-writing. I also continue to write political columns.

Patrick Frank's Links

New list
JUNE 10, 2009 6:49AM

Standing Up to Unresponsive Bureaucracy

Rate: 3 Flag

Standing up to bureaucracy when it tramples on people is hard to do, but we need to do it sometimes. It could be government bureaucracy or private bureaucracy, but when the needs of people for basic respect are ignored, folks need to push back. You can't play Don Quixote all of the time, perhaps (pick your battles) but there are times to do it. It's scary, but important for self and others. I know: I am doing this right now in my life, in one situation.

It could be an employer, a utility company, the welfare department, a bank, a school, college or university--when you have a large organization, sometimes people within those bureaucracies feel that they can act with impunity, with little thought to the effect of their decisions on real, live human beings. When clients, customers, employees are hurt in the process, the hurting can easily go unnoticed--that is a big part of the problem, the invisibility involved. (The same potential problem occurs when folks interact over the internet, in a forum like Facebook or OpenSalon, etc; it is easy say things impulsively to people you have never met and will likely never meet without considering their feelings and the possible harm that your words may inflict).

Bureaucracy is not used to people standing up and appealing decisions; yes, it happens, but more often than not folks just bite the bullet and take their lumps when they feel they have been dealt with unfairly.

Of course, the question arises, when we ourselves assume the role of bureaucrats or social network participants will we behave with the same degree of unregard for the feelings and legitimate life concerns of those on the receiving end of our words and acts? We are all capable of inflicting such harm when are speaking/acting "at a distance." The question is, will we remember how it feels to be on the receiving end?

Bureaucracies are not used to being challenged, when they run amok; they sometimes are surprised when folks make an appeal. There are many authoritarian aspects to our culture that go unrecognized; we like to think of ourselves living in "the land of the free." The truth is, sometimes freedom and individuality are supported in our culture, and sometimes not--too often not.

But, in general, I see us as a freedom-loving people who are likely to grow impatient with unresponsive bureaucracy. But I fear that we have been lulled into a state of complacency or passivity by eight years of top-down Republican rule. However, the problem runs much deeper than politics. Democrats can act oppressively too, of course. What I am describing is a problem of social structure and way of life--the latter is culture, American culture, not necessarily Democratic or Republican culture.

What I am saying is, we can change the sociocultural dynamic; but the change must occur at the grassroots level (or it will likely not occur at all), by folks standing up and saying no, when individuals are treated as objects, and their legitimate needs and aspirations are ignored.

To take such action takes courage. Let us support one another when the need to stand up to unresponsive bureaucracy arises.

What I am saying is, we can change the sociocultural dynamic; but the
change must occur at the grassroots level (or it will likely not occur
at all), by folks standing up and saying no, when individuals are
treated as objects, and their legitimate needs and aspirations are
ignored.

To take such action requires courage. Let us support one another when
the need to stand up to unresponsive bureaucracy arises. Challenging
these entities may be new and scary, and may not work, and may feel
like a mistake, but sometimes it is the only thing one can do--to
preserve one's self-esteem and sense of integrity. I was reminded this
morning of this important and relevant quote of Albert Einstein:

"Anyone who has never made a mistake has never tried anything new."

I have been reminded that when standing up means that one's livelihood or shelter or reputation are threatened, it can be especially difficult to challenge the powers that be. That is so true. One must always weigh the risks versus benefits of taking a stand. 

To coin a phrase, "There is a time to stand up, and a time to stand down." No one can make that decision for me or you. But it helps to make a wise choice, while preserving one's integrity, when you have the support of friends and/or loved ones.  

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
You Know what Patrick Frank, as one of the worst offenders, here, with my lead pipe, brass knuckles, take no prisoners approach, it may surprise You to know that I DO agree with YOU.

However, and in no way defensively, when I was in Casablance, Morocco (a multi-lingual country) I tried to speak Arabic.

When in Spain, Spanish, when in Bangkok, Thai, and so on through the dozen or so countries in which I've lived or worked

Faced with liars and pro-torture folks, homophobes, racists and cretin, I have found that even reasoned discourse does not budge them one iota. So deeply are they immersed in kool-aide, they are tone deaf, so I speak in Cretinese, as nothing else works anyway, and it allows me to release a little but of my pent up fury.

(rated and proud to make the first comment and rate)
Not more than five minutes ago I was reading about a grassroots organization in my state that provides support and information for people trying to find their way through the process of dealing with unresponsive bureaucracies.

We have to help and support and, yes, validate each other. What you're doing with this blog post is educating people, a critical job in the American journey, both back and forward, to constitutional guarantees for the protection of our inalienable rights as human beings.

Thanks for being part of the solution.
Thanks for your comments. I was reminded today of this quote:

Anyone who has never made a mistake has never tried anything new. (Albert Einstein)

Challenging unresponsive bureaucracy may be new and scary, and may not work, and may feel like a mistake, but sometimes it is the only thing one can do--to preserve one's self-esteem and sense of integrity. This is not so much a political issue as it is a more broadly cultural one.