AUGUST 6, 2009 10:07AM

A Canadian's tale of socialized medicine

Rate: 10 Flag

   Since last December,  my family has spent a disproportionate amount of time in the hospital, and I figure their experiences might give some Americans a little insight into how the Canuck system actually works. 

 Dad's condition is the least serious, and probably most common, so it seems a good place to start.  Dad's had diabetes since the mid 90s. Up til last year, it was controlled with pills, but  after some careful monitoring, the docs decided insulin would be a better fit for him.  While he was making the change over, he was monitored by the community health nurse. 

  My younger sister was diagnosed with colitis in 2000, just before she graduated from high school.   Since then she's had 8 major surgeries and 3 or 4 minor ones on her bowels.  After trying a lot of options, she and her doctors came to the conclusion that a permanent colostomy was the best option for her.   They came to the decision in mid  October 2008, and she had the surgery done on December 3rd 2008.  Her surgeon is the Chief of surgery for the hospital, and  his schedule had a lot to do with the delay.  This was major surgery, but  waiting really wouldn't affect my sister's health at all.   That ought to give you some ideas  about wait times. Due to complications, she spent three weeks in the hospital, and another month having nurses come in to change her bandages

  Mom went to her GP for a  regular checkup in  mid July of 2007  and offhandedly mentioned she'd had  a little trouble swallowing for  a few weeks. She was scheduled for an MRI the next week. Two years ago to the day, my mother met with an oncologist, who told her she had esophageal cancer. She started an agressive chemo and radiation campaign in early September.

   Esophageal cancer is one of those  very agressive cancers that usually isn't diagnosed until its too late.  My mom fought the disease for 20 months, which I'm told is a very long time all things considered. The radiologists, and oncologists were very good about making sure we understood what was happening, every step of the way, and her GP made housecalls to make sure she was comfortable. 

   The Canadian system is far from perfect, but  my family has gotten very good care from it over the last few years, and we haven't had to go bankrupt to do so. 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
This is great, Peppermint. American's really need to get this sort of information. All we here are conservative talking points about how bad the socialized systems are and never anything good.
Thank you.
sorry, that was, of course, "all we hear"
Americans need to hear from Canadians about their/our system, not just the absolute lies in the American noise machine.

On Tuesday I posted an op-ed from the LATimes by a Canadian doctor, giving his perspective.
http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/opinionla/la-oe-rachlis3-2009aug03,0,673919.story?track=newslettertext
But, but...what about not being able to choose your own doctor? You say that has never, ever been an issue in Canada? Like, it was totally made up by a big fat lying liar? Oh, well never mind in that case....
anton said: But, but...what about not being able to choose your own doctor? You say that has never, ever been an issue in Canada? Like, it was totally made up by a big fat lying liar? Oh, well never mind in that case....

um, what? I think it might've been made up by a big fat lying liar, because it's certainly nothing I've experienced in either of the provinces that I lived in in Canada. Not all GPs accept new patients, but that's the only limitation I've ever heard of.
I have lived under both systems. Canada has a great system. I picked my doctor from a list of ten.
Right now in the US I think it is a huge patchwork quilt with huge holes. I inhabit such a hole with no healthcare.
Keep on putting up stories like this one my friend. Americans need to hear these.
I thank you for this
There are many ways to skin the healthcare cat; the U.S. would be wise to really think about the values of other systems and the tradeoffs therein, and then decide what it wants. good post.
Sorry about your Mom too.
I must agree: there are no restrictions here about which doctor you must see. That is a restriction I associate with certain American HMOs, not the Canadian medical system.
I'll take any Canadian testimonial I can get. Thanks for providing one. I do think we may face the issue of not having enough providers, but we have that problem now. And if there are enough providers in a geographic area, one may not be able to have access if one does not have insurance. Likewise, being a doctor has become increasingly undesirable for American students due to the fact that you don't spend much time doctoring - you spend most of your time dealing with insurance companies.
Thanks for your comment on my cancer and sex post. You have been through a HELL of a year my lady. Thanks for putting some of your sorrows to good use by educating us Americans.

I am the author of a recently published book Everything Changes: The Insider's Guide to Cancer in Your 20s and 30s. I get lots of emails from readers in Canada, UK, Australia. They are disgusted by the stories in my book that reveal the ineffective, inefficient, and down right broken system of healthcare in America. All I can say is "ditto".
Best,
Kairol
http://everythingchangesbook.com/