Karen McKim

Karen McKim
Location
Wisconsin,
Birthday
August 30
Bio
Middle-aged, middle-class Midwesterner. I have conservative political values: I want to conserve things like our traditions of liberty, justice, voting rights, Medicare and Social Security, good public schools, religious freedom, and safe communities. Because I do not want to sacrifice those things to increase the profits and power of international banks and oil companies, most would call me a liberal.

MY RECENT POSTS

Karen McKim's Links

Salon.com
FEBRUARY 14, 2012 4:26PM

Data entry for a ton of democracy

Rate: 8 Flag

I spent last Friday afternoon feeling the weight of democracy in my hands. The voice of the people was handed to me in half-inch-thick stacks of 50 petitions demanding the recall of our governor. Approximately 50,000 hours of data entry are needed for the more than a million signatures turned in to Wisconsin’s Government Accountability Board last month.  During my shift, I worked my way through four stacks—2.6 pounds of pure democracy. 

I came to the job with a dry sense of civic responsibility, expecting as much fun as data entry usually offers. Three hours later, I left vibrant with affection for my fellow citizens and gratitude for the process of self-government.

An actual petition filled in with fake signatures, for illustration. 

Late on a gray February afternoon, about 60 of us brought our laptops to a large, plain basement room in a large, plain suburban office building, where we sat at folding tables and plugged our computers into extension cords taped to the floor. The instructions were projected in PowerPoint on the wall. 

Working with photocopies made before the petitions were turned in, we were entering names into a database in preparation for answering challenges that will soon be filed by Walker’s organization. My understanding is that signatures can be challenged for something as minor as a ‘9’ that looks more like a ‘7’ in the zip code, but those whose signatures are challenged can, if contacted, correct them. 

On my shift, we were to enter only the circulators’ names (one per petition.) The signers' names were being entered by others into a different database. Once we were set up and instructed, our work was entirely between ourselves, our keyboards, and our stacks of petitions. This was work, not a social event.

As I unclipped my first stack, I expected to encounter many sloppily written, even illegible names. But instead, every page contained carefully written names and addresses, as if every signer felt the same need to speak in a clear, strong voice. Only a  few were sloppy, and I did not see one that was completely illegible.

I shouldn’t have been surprised. At roadside booths during November and December, I had collected signatures myself.  Everyone took time to listen to our instructions: "Print your name clearly in the first column; sign your normal signature in this column. Then print your mailing address here, and your voting municipality here—make sure you check one of these boxes to indicate whether it’s a town, village, or city.  I can look it up for you if you don’t know. Finally, make sure you get the date right; today is..."

Even in the cold winter wind, people would remove their gloves to get a good grip on the pen and position the clipboard firmly in front of them to make sure they got the right information in each space. No one scribbled and ran. When they were not being used, we kept the pens in our pockets to keep them warm; people didn’t want to sign with slow-flowing faint ink.

Personalities emerged from the petitions as I keyed in the names. One circulator’s signature was written in careful Palmer Method penmanship, but Melvin’s hand shook and applied uneven pressure as he inscribed his information.  I looked at the signatures he had collected: Esther, Lucille, Phyllis, Francis, Alvin. Most were written in similarly shaky but disciplined old-school penmanship.  Several lived at the same address. Melvin must have circulated the recall petition among his friends in an old folks’ home.

Names like Britney, Brandon, Jason, and Ashleigh filled other petitions. On one, I recognized addresses in a student-housing neighborhood near the University of Wisconsin campus in Eau Claire, where my son attends school.

Petitions came from Milwaukee and Madison, of course. On these, I recognized addresses from tony upscale neighborhoods and from the poorest areas. Most petitions came from cities I did not know as well—northwoods Minoqua; east-central industrial Appleton; southeastern bedroom suburb Brookfield; and the Mississippi River town of Onalaska. Dozens came from little villages and townships I'd never heard of.

I wondered whether a reviewer would notice that on one of the petitions I had circulated, most of the signatures had the same last name and were dated November 24. How many other Thanksgiving gatherings had been occasions for petition-signing? Dozens? Hundreds? Maybe thousands. Petitioning had begun just the week before.

Shortly after we began circulating petitions, Madison's right-wing propaganda factory, the MacIver Institute, began promoting talk about “Mickey Mouse” signatures, while other Walker supporters were actively encouraging people to sign as Adolf Hitler. (Yes, that’s against the law.) These stories were then, as usual, amplified by Governor Walker’s people and his friends at Fox.

But I did not see one obviously fake name on any of the 200 petitions I worked with. I thought of the  Tea Partiers in Arizona and Texas who have signed up to review petitions online, eager to find ridiculous attempts at fraud. Slogging through un-amusing page after page of real names and addresses will be their appropriate reward.

I didn't find a fake name, but someone else did. A would-be saboteur had printed “Re-elect Gov. Walker” in the space for the printed name. Apparently wanting to take credit for his cleverness, the saboteur then provided a real address and his signature. Since the signature—not the printed name—is what counts, that Walker supporter had added a valid signature to the petition.

When I was done, I turned my 200 petitions back in and saw them stacked with the other 10,000 or so that had been entered during the shift. At the end of the night, they would be put back with the other 142,350 petitions. News reports have put their total weight at between one and three tons.

Because of the road conditions, my husband was coming to pick me up in our four-wheel-drive vehicle. As I waited for him in the twilight, I thought about the signatures and watched the snow fall. Not one of the nearly-weightless snowflakes would, by itself, make any difference. But as they piled up, they were transforming the dirty-gray February landscape and making Wisconsin fresh and clean again.

BackyardTwilight

You don't have to take my word for it. Just look at this blizzard of democracy . 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Wow. I cannot believe this has no traffic. It's an excellent post that I wish I had read. This is my point on the EP thing. This is EP perfect, and with a little publicity would had gotten read. Don't give up, you are an excellent writer. I have been following this intently and thank you for the lesson in how this is being done and the great people who volunteer to to do it! The 18th is my third anniversary on OS. I had no writing or computer experience and could not buy a reader then. I got mad and started writing political posts, which I found I was very good at. I also used a lot of profanity and pissed off a lot of people. I did it to get attention and I insulted the cliques and called out the big dogs. Hah! I must have looked like an idiot, but I wasn't about to let these people ignore me. I had something to say and I wasn't going to let the cliques that were widespread them keep me off. I even invited all the newbies to join me. Yes, I got noticed. I had some battles with some people and after about a year, I stopped. I started writing mostly fiction, poetry and current event stuff, with a touch of politics. I still love it. I now have a pretty good readership and have made some lifetime friends that I never would have met if I would have let the editors and others keep me down. I tell you this to keep you here. We need all the excellent writers we can get. Please, send me a link when you post and I'll be here. Some days are busier than others, I'm actually finishing up a book and I have OS to thank (or blame) for it. I learned how to write and use a computer here and there is not a better place to blog on the internet. Believe me, I've quit here 3 times and I always come back. Once you make some friends, this place is like a drug. Thank you for friending me and I'm sorry I took up so much space. (luv your Bio)
I can't add much to what scanner said. This is an original and a very well written piece. I enjoyed this read much. R
Thanks for the comments, guys. I'm sure you've both received similar reassurance from your readers, and you know how good it feels. I had already decided I was going to keep going for at least a few more months, even in this near-silence, and your comments will make it easier to do so even if things don't pick up. Thanks again!
This is a very affecting piece. Scanner mentioned you in a comment on his post, so I came to take a look. Good work.
Kosher sent me a message to check you out. I'm very impressed. Not only have you done a most worthy thing for both your state and the country, you have shared the drudgery and the joy of doing so in an engaging, thoughtful, and well-written essay. Thank you so much. I'll be back. If you don't see me (I do get busy), send me a PM and I'll get over here in a couple days.
A blizzard of democracy? This was also a blizzard of fine writing, Karen. If it hadn't been for Koshersalaami, I would have missed it, too. Everything Scanner said is absolutely spot on. Please stick around and build your readership. You have many other storms to deliver!

Lezlie
Kosher sent me and I am glad he did this has been worth the read. If it is against the law to sign as Hitler then it is against the law to urge people to do so, after all the democrats can’t implore their constituent's to shoot Walker now can they? When you are done in Wisconsin could you make your next stop NY?
Good work, all around.
R
Update: The Government Accountability Board has released its final report in preparation for its meeting on March 30 (tomorrow.) Excerpt:
Determining fictitious names is an inherently subjective process because there is no master list of residents to compare against names that are identical or similar to names of historical figures, celebrities, or fictitious characters. In reviewing the Walker
recall petition, staff identified as fictitious and recommends striking the following names: Adolf Hitler, Mick E. Mous, Donald L. Duck, Fungky Van Den Elzen, and I Love Scott Walker. Several other signatures were flagged as potentially fictitious, such as Princess High and Mohammed Ali, but were ultimately accepted when staff located these individuals through either the State Voter Registration System (SVRS) or telephone directories. In total, staff identified ... 5 fictitious signatures..."

Someone needs to contact Ms. Princess High and ask for her comment. No, on second thought, that might be rude.