Procopius

Procopius
Location
Rockford, Illinois, USA
Birthday
February 05
Bio
I'm a regular middle aged guy, living in a regular middle class neighborhood, in a regular middle-sized community in the middle of America. I am an expatriate Texan transplanted to the Midwest, and wondering how I got here, and where I'm headed.

MY RECENT POSTS

Procopius's Links

Salon.com
JANUARY 11, 2009 5:28PM

Cambodia 1993: Vestiges of War

Rate: 17 Flag
                   Into my heart an air that kills

                         From far yon country blows.

                    What are those blue remembered hills,

                         What spires, what farms are those?

 

                    That is the land of lost content,

                         I see it shining plain,

                    The happy highways where I went

                         And cannot come again.

 

                                                                        A. E. Houseman

  

This is the second in a series of blog entries about a trip to Cambodia I took in the spring of 1993.  The first post included a brief historical outline of Cambodia during the traumatic period from about 1969 through the peace accords of 1991.  You can read that here.  In addition to historical information, that post featured everyday street scenes from the capital, Phnom Penh.

 

My trip to Cambodia occurred just two years after most fighting had come to an end in the country’s long war between Maoist Khmer Rouge guerillas, royalists, nationalists, and the Vietnamese supported government.   Only after the 1991 peace accords went into effect did the country truly open up to the outside world.  By 1993, a very shaky peace existed in most (but not all) of the country, but its recent history was sadly noticeable wherever one went. 

 

A generation of genocide and warfare leaves scars that cannot be portrayed adequately by photographs.  Pictures can't show how young the Cambodian population was in 1993.  It was striking how few people, especially men, there were in their 40's and 50's and 60's.  Another alarming reality was the large number of beggars, often missing one or more extremities, the lasting result of war and torture, and of the scourge of landmines.  Finally, pictures cannot show psychological scars.  One can't help but wonder how great a toll has been inflicted on the Cambodian nation by suicide and depression.  Like a missing leg or blinded eye, those are consequences that last long after the guns have fallen silent.

 

My pictures, therefore, show only a small part of Cambodia's recent war-torn history. 

 

*********************************************** 

 

 

Cambodia bombed bridge 

In the distance is the old bridge crossing the Tonle Sap, a tributary of the Mekong River.  The bridge was destroyed in 1973, during fighting between the government of Lon Nol and the Khmer Rouge guerillas.  The bridge was one of two major approaches to Phnom Penh from the east.  There is some dispute as to who was responsible for the bridge'e destruction.  Some say the Khmer Rouge blew it up.  Others say the government destroyed it to prevent the Khmer Rouge from being able to enter the city in 1973.  Of course, two years later they entered the city almost unhindered.  The bridge was repaired several years after my visit.

 

 

 

Cambodia Red Cross  

The peace agreement of 1991 called for the Red Cross to provide humanitarian assistance to the war torn country.  I have always held that organization in high esteem.   After my trip to Cambodia, my admiration grew even more.

 

 

 

Cambodia UN  

This was a common sight throughout Phnom Penh:  White vehicles sporting a large, black "UN".  The United Nations maintained a very visible presence in the capital during the early 1990's.  Its task was to keep the various factions from reverting to the civil war that had raged since 1979, following the collapse of the Khmer Rouge.

 

 

 

                                Cambodia temple ruin 

About 40 km outside of Phnom Penh is the old Khmer capital of Oudong.  In 1993 it was in an obvious state of neglect and damage from the war.  Guidebooks published in the early 1990's warned tourists to Oudong not to venture off the trails due to the likely presence of landmines, buried there since the 1970's.

 

 

 

Cambodia Oudong Ruin 

This is the remains of what was once the largest temple in Oudong.  It used to house a huge statue of the Buddha, its head as tall as a grown man.  The temple was damaged badly by American bombs in the early 1970's.  After the Khmer Rouge took over, the damaged temple was blown to bits as part of the regime's attempt to wipe out all traces of Cambodia's religious traditions.  Although much of Oudong has been restored, this temple remains in ruins.

 

 

 

Cambodia wat restoration 

Whether in Phnom Penh, or in the countryside, one did not have to go far to see a ruined temple, mosque, or church, sheathed in scaffolding as workers attempted to restore the damage inflicted on houses of worship by the Khmer Rouge so many years before.

 

 

 

Cambodia villa 

What were once stately colonial mansions along Phnom Penh's major boulevards were only empty shells in 1993, plundered and decaying, their formerly manicured lawns a wild, unkempt tangle of tropical foliage.  Many of these old buildings have been torn down to make room for upscale hotels and guesthouses during the past several years.

 

 

 

                                 Cambodia poster 

Among the saddest remnants of the war that I saw were the posters scattered throughout Phnom Penh, put up by the Red Cross to advise residents how to track down family members missing following nearly 20 years of brutal repression and civil war.  By 1993, most of these posters were tattered and faded.  Did they achieve their purpose?  One wonders how many were reunited with long lost loved ones. and how many learned a sadly tragic truth of a missing loved one's fate.

 

 

Next:  Driving Into the Countryside 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Your pictures are, however, quite evocative, taken with your excellent text.
Rated.
Steve, it was great to see your next installment here! What a shame that so many sites of antiquity and religious importance that have been damaged or destroyed over the years. It reminds me of how the Taliban destroyed the two large Buddhas in the Bamyan valley of Afghanistan.
O'K and William, thank you. It's eeasy to be evocative and riveting when the subject is a place like Cambodia.

John, it is a shame, indeed, and I also thought of the similarities with the Buddha's in Afghanistan. I'm also amazed at how utterly dehumanized many revolutionary societies are, even when they supposedly seek to improve the lot of the people. Taliban and Khmer Rouge bore similarities in that regard. Ideology can be blinding.
Well presented, both photos and text.
As you look at those photos, you imagine being there 34 years ago and just can't imagine, I'm sure. It's like whenever I visit Gettysburg, I feel like I can hear the young men who died. It has an aura around it unlike most American cities. I've always wanted to visit Normandy and stand, looking out at the waves breaking on the beach.

The country has come a long way. Thanks for sharing Steve.

Peace,
G
(rated)
your pictures are quietly devastating
Greg, your observation is correct, you attempt to imagine what it was like, but you really can't. I have read first person accounts of those dark years, and even then it is hard to fathom.

Sandra, yes they are...Thanks for commenting.
Yes, this again brings back memories of my trip there. My driver was a child in the killing fields and when I asked why he did not seem more bitter he said it was both his Buddhist upbringing and the fact that anyone and everyone around could have been a part of the Khmer Rouge and it did no good.

And two years ago, construction was huge. The country was thriving.
Lea, from the pictures I've seen, and articles I've read, it sounds like I would hardly recognize Phnom Penh now. It does appear the country is rebounding. I wonder if places like Gaza and Kabul will ever be as successful? Of course, the first requirement is for the population to have the desire to move beyond the tragedies of the past. I'm not too sure there are enough people in today's hot spots who have that desire.

Maybe you're correct, too, that Buddhism enabled the people of Cambodia to overcome the desire for vengeance.
Procopius,

Nicely done. The ghosts that populate my mind when I’m in a historic building or setting are called forth by your photos and your brief descriptions of the past. Your essay evokes for me a flow of different emotions; sadness, anger, confusion, and hope are among them.

The sadness, anger, and confusion come from thinking about the suffering these people have endured, and from considering the motivation behind the cause of that suffering. It all seems so preposterous, so pointless.

The hope springs from the idea that human beings may yet, someday, actually truly learn from our greatest historical blunders.

RATED
Rick, thank you for your thoughtful comments. The question they raise in my mind is this: Why do some societies rise above the tragedy and hatred of the past, and others do not? Cambodia seems, so far at least, to be among the former.

Your anger is well placed, too. What, exactly, was achieved by the tonnage dropped by American B-52's? What tragic absurdity it was. The same for the evils perpetrated by Pol Pot and his followers.
Proco,

You ask, “Why do some societies rise above the tragedy and hatred of the past, and others do not? Cambodia seems, so far at least, to be among the former.”

That’s an interesting question. I might begin such a discussion with a question of my own: Which countries would you enlist as examples of those who did not “rise above the tragedy and hatred of the past”? The Mid-East comes to mind as possibly offering some examples.

Perhaps with such a comparison, we could consider specific differences in a particular situation and then perhaps generalize some theories from there to cover a broader assembly. What would you say?
I was especially moved by the poster "Looking for your Family."

War breaks up families and kills them. Forty years after WWII
Rick, I think of the Balkans, and the ages old animosities that exist there, where people still look back with anger on a battle that happened 700 years ago. I think of lasting hatreds that exist in the Caucasus.

Maybe Cambodia is different because there is no ethnic aspect. It was largely Khmers vs. Khmers. Lea suggests it has to do with their Buddhist traditions. I do think the ethnic issue is big, though. If our own Civil War had pitted peoples with different language or skin color against one another, maybe we would still be fighting that one today. I really don't know.
John, those posters moved me, too. That's why I saved that picture for last. Thanks for stopping by and commenting.
Proco,

The ethnic aspect; that makes sense to me.

I think we can see evidence to support that thesis even in our Civil War. While it was not one ethnic group against another, there was the racial issue of keeping blacks in slavery. And that aspect led to divisions that have endured for over 150 years here in America.

Another aspect that probably is a factor in other conflicts in which the hatred is long-lived is religion.
Rick, Good point regarding religion, of course. How strange it is that religion inspires such hatred. Not always, but far too frequently.
yeah, patriotism and religion -- irrational beliefs generally lead to irrational behavior.