Procopius

Procopius
Location
Rockford, Illinois, USA
Birthday
February 05
Bio
I'm a regular middle aged guy, living in a regular middle class neighborhood, in a regular middle-sized community in the middle of America. I am an expatriate Texan transplanted to the Midwest, and wondering how I got here, and where I'm headed.

MY RECENT POSTS

Procopius's Links

Salon.com
JANUARY 11, 2010 6:03PM

Turnpikes and Toll Roads

Rate: 9 Flag

 

toll booth

 

Travel has always been one of my greatest pleasures in life.  I’ve written several blog posts about the more interesting places I’ve traveled.  Not all of my favorite trips have been exotic, however.  I’ve garnered a great deal of enjoyment from good old fashioned road trips right here in the U.S.of A. 

Part of what I like about an American road trip is planning the route.  I take into consideration many factors, such as natural wonders found along the way, scenic variety, and of course, convenience, especially when time is limited.  When it comes to convenience, the Internet has proven to be a terrific aid, particularly Mapquest.  I don’t rely solely on Mapquest, but its tool that allows you to specify your beginning and ending points of a trip to determine the optimal route is really quite impressive, definitely a factor to consider when plotting the route.

This summer, I plan to take the family on a vacation from our home in Northern Illinois to Washington D.C.  Not being one to wait until the last minute to plan the trip, I went to Mapquest this afternoon and asked for directions.  The result looks pretty good on the map.  Fairly direct, with some interesting scenery along the way.  However, when I pulled out my Rand McNally Road Atlas, I noticed nearly the entire route has me on green highways, not the usual blue Interstates.  Green, of course, is Rand McNally-ese for toll roads. 

The good folks at Mapquest inform me that the best route from Northern Illinois to Washington D.C. involves 659 miles of tollways, including the entire route through Illinois, Indiana, and Ohio, plus about half of Pennsylvania.  The total of all tolls will be $42.00.

I know it is expensive to maintain highways, and the concept of a user’s fee is something I understand.  However, $42.00 just seems a bit steep to me.  I can choose an alternate route that has absolutely NO tollways, and will involve about 75 more miles of driving.  This alternate route will provide better scenery, take me through some interesting towns, and still take place on the Interstate highway system.

So what would you do on a two-day trip?  Spend $42.00 on toll roads, or take an hour of extra time and spend a little more gas money and avoid all those toll booths?  Are the Illlinois/Indiana/Ohio/Pennsylvania turnpikes really worth it?

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I did several Penna-Ohio trips last year and used the turnpikes, but I was interested in speed. The northern interestate route through Pennsylvania (I-80) is a lovely route in the summer--mountain laurel blooming, but there's no good way to get you down to DC except the toll route of the PA Turnpike NEast Extension (I-476) and then taking I-95 (traffic!!!) or doubling back west on I-81 and then taking I-83 down into Maryland.

The PA Turnpike does give the advantage of putting you near (relatively) Gettysburg--which might appeal to you. Need to take smaller roads for a distance to get there. Following I-81 into Maryland (which you can do from the Turnpike) brings you near Antietam, a quieter (much less visited) battlefield, and then you can take I-270 past Frederick (Barbara Fritchie's town) down to DC.

BTW, PA Turnpike tolls went up this month--is that cost based on the new tolls?

Let us know what route you choose!
Thanks, Pilgrim. With an alias like that, you've got to know your way around!

That cost is based on the new rates, per the turnpike's website. The alternate route I'd take goes through Wheeling, to Washington PA, then down to Morgantown and I-68, or perhaps Rt. 40 through Uniontown to I-68.
Steve, this post brings back some memories of the old days for me. When I was young we lived for a few years in Pennsylvania and I remember the PA turnpike from way back then. Also the Mass. pike both from my earlier days and more recently. I haven't had to take the NY Thruway in a long time but I remember the tolls on that too. Looking at the roads from a historical perspective they have come a long way from Colonial days when logs were laid down along a route--I guess that was called a corduroy road.

It looks like AtHomePilgrim has given you some very helpful and solid advice about your route! There is so much to see in D.C. that I am never able to take in but a fraction of it at a time.
Don't know that route, but it will probably be scenic in the summer also. (Turnpike isn't very scenic, though there are some spots with great views.)
Before the I-95 went all the way from New Jersey to Florida, it was necessary to take Route 301 part of the way. Not everything we saw was beautiful, but it was certainly an eye opener. Spend the extra time. See the real America.
R
Never take the main roads -- if it can be avoided.
It's so scenic around there, I'd go for the scenery. My sons always used to tell me, "Not the pretty road again, Mom!"
Wait a minute. This is one of those questions where I KNOW you already have an answer. And it is the same as mine!
Avoid the toll booths! Take a little longer and drive local. It's more interesting.
Depends on whether you are more interested in the journey or the destination. Remember that during those extra miles aren't free.
Better scenery is good. Saving money even better, so long as it's not involving farm roads or those old US highways. The only thing that might make me choose the toll road is if tractor trailers were banned. That would reduce the stress a bit. Hope it's a great trip and you and your family have a wonderful time.
I was just saying (over the holidays) that I'd be willing to pay a couple pennies more in taxes so I didn't have to pay tolls. They're so irritating!
It's been many years since I traveled the PA Turnpike (and back then I did it frequently) but it was not maintained as well as interstate highways.

I would definitely take the 75 mile longer route, especially on a 2 day trip. I'm surprised bbd hasn't commented here. He's a strong proponent of blue highways and it's not the interstates that are blue on his maps. :)
The PA Turnpike does have some beautiful scenery west of Harrisburg. However, the drudgery of I-80 across IN and OH is snoozeville - not worthwhile.

I like some of Pilgrim's suggestions, such as a detour to Gettysburg (beautiful and haunting), then on to I-81, etc. Beyond Harrisburg, continuing towards Philly just leads to a lot of congestion and annoyance if you're looking at I-476 and I-95.

If you did something like I-39 south to I-74 east to I-70 east, you could pick up the PA turnpike south of Pittsburgh. US 15 is a bit of small town rambling from the turnpike to Gettysburg. If you've never visited the battlefield, it's well worth spending a day and exploring it in depth. I recommend the Brickhouse Inn if you stay there.

If you want to continue a bit of small road wandering before getting back on the interstate, continue south on US 15 from Gettysburg to Frederick, MD, where you're relatively close to Antietam and Harpers Ferry. Then you can pick up I-70 to 270 to DC.

I've always liked mixing up interstate travel with some sections on small roads. Blue Highways is one of my all-time favorite books.

I hope you have an excellent trip with plenty of good memories.