Procopius

Procopius
Location
Rockford, Illinois, USA
Birthday
February 05
Bio
I'm a regular middle aged guy, living in a regular middle class neighborhood, in a regular middle-sized community in the middle of America. I am an expatriate Texan transplanted to the Midwest, and wondering how I got here, and where I'm headed.

MY RECENT POSTS

Procopius's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
JUNE 6, 2011 9:54AM

Erosion

Rate: 25 Flag

Erosion.  Anyone familiar with my blog might wonder why I would put out a post on something like erosion.  After all, the majority of my blog entries deal with history, not ecological issues.  The fact is, history cannot be separated from ecology.  Ecology has been one of the great driving forces of history, contributing to waves of migrations and the fall of great empires.  Conversely, history has impacted the environment, causing huge changes in flora, fauna, and the landscape that supports them.

Of course, the "environment" or "ecology" entail far more than could be covered in a blog like this.  I'm therefore focusing this post on just one small aspect of ec0logy.  I have chosen to look at erosion.  We see erosion everywhere.  Sometimes its effects are minimal;  quite frequently not.  I'm not trying to make any partisan points.  Erosion is not a Democratic or Republican issue.  It simply is.

Here, then, is a little look at erosion.

 *************************************************************

 

erosion beginning
 
 

This photo was taken in an acquaintance's back yard.  A few years ago, a new subdivision was built not far from where this photo was taken.  This small erosion channel did not exist prior to the construction of that subdivision.  The owners of the property shown here are understandably concerned.
 
Notice the woods in the background.  The owners of this property used to have a walking trail in those woods, complete with a wooden walkway over a small swampy area.  Here is what erosion has done to that walkway during the past couple of years:

 

erosion woods
 

The effects of erosion are often most apparent in arid or semi-arid regions, where vegetation is too sparce to hold the soil in place against strong winds or thunderstorms.  Pictured below is a scene in West Texas, near the city of San Angelo.  This part of the country is subject to extreme droughts, broken by the occasional violent thunderstorm.  The result is the appearance of gullies that slowly eat away at the earth:

erosion gully-mesquite-cacti
 

Of course, water is not the only natural factor that causes erosion.  Just as consequential is wind.  In fact, wind may be a greater factor than water.  We've all seen photos of massive wind-driven dust storms like this:

erosion dust bowl

This is a famous photo taken in the Texas Panhandle during the height of the Dust Bowl years of the 1930's.  These dust storms were caused by high winds and draught, of course, but were also caused by human activity.  Overgrazing and poor farming techniques were the greater cause of the Dust Bowl than natural weather conditions.  So great was the loss of top soil between 1925 and 1940 that much of the Great Plains today are actually about four or five feet lower in elevation than when European-Americans first settled there.

Wind erosion is not entirely a thing of the past.  Although dust storms like the ones that occurred during the 1930's are rare in America today, they still occur in other parts of the world.  Even in America, dust storms are still a common occurrence.  I once drove from Abilene to Lubbock, Texas, and nearly had to pull over to the side of the road due to poor visibility caused by blowing sand.  That dust storm was not life-threatening like those of the Dust Bowl, but it was very unpleasant, and looked a lot like this photo that was taken a few years ago in Lubbock:

erosion lubbock dust storm

 

When European-Americans first came to the South Plains, they looked on a landscape covered with tall grass prairies in the east that slowly gave way to short grasses as they travelled west.  When the settlers introduced cattle to that drought-prone country, the native grasses were quickly depleted.  When ranching proved to be unprofitable, farmers plowed the sod and replaced the deep-rooted natural grasses with shallow-rooted wheat and oats.   That was fine as long as the rains came, but when draught hit, there was nothing to hold the dirt in place.  The dirt blew away, exposing the limestone bedrock.  Nature hates a vacuum though, and soon hearty prickly pear, mesquite, huisache, creosote, and juniper replaced the grass on land that had lost much of its fertility.  The result is a landscape that looks like this throughout a wide swath of the Southern Plains:

 

erosion san angelo cacti
 

The effects of erosion are usually not aesthetically pleasing, but that is not always the case.  A million years of erosion have created one of America's hidden scenic gems, the 100 mile long Palo Duro Canyon in the Texas Panhandle, a small portion of which is pictured here:

erosion palo duro1

 

Nowhere are the effects of erosion as immediately apparent as along the coast.  As polar ice caps in Antarctica and Greenland continue to melt into the sea, we can expect coastal erosion to accelerate with huge economic consequences.  Of course, some argue that global climate change is a naturally occurring phenomenon, and the melting of the ice caps would occur regardless of human activity.  Certainly, there is support for this idea in the historical record.  There was far less ice in Greenland a thousand years ago than there is today, and the milder climate of those days enabled the Vikings to establish fairly successful colonies along the Greenland coast that lasted for hundreds of years.  While it seems likely to me and most of the scientific community that human activity is behind modern climate change, natural factors could certainly be playing a significant role as well.

There is no doubt, however, that a lot of coastal erosion is the direct result of human activity.  When people put buildings on the beach, they disrupt the natural distribution of beach-creating sand.  When we dredge shipping channels through a barrier island, we disturb the natural flow of water in and out of the leeward bays and lagoons.   Couple that with the jetties that prevent channels from silting over, and the effect on the beaches is noteworthy.  Just look at this GoogleEarth image of the Matagorda Peninsula on the Central Texas coast.  Blocked waves and currents have greatly reduced the landmass southeast of the jetties:

 

erosion matagorda
 

Continuing further up the coast to Galveston, you will reach Highway 87.  This highway was built parallel to the upper Texas coast about the time World War II started.  That coastline, stretching from Texas all the way to the Mississippi River delta in Louisiana, has experienced severe erosion during the past several decades.  In fact, the coastline has receded so much that a 20 mile stretch of Highway 87 is no longer passable.  Just take a look at this GoogleEarth image that clearly shows remnants of highway pavement being battered by the surf:

erosion hwy 87 google earth

 Here is a close-upview of what was once a busy highway:

erosion hwy 87
 

Highway 87 manages to become a functional highway as it moves inland closer to the Texas-Louisiana border.  The coastal erosion is less visible in much of Louisiana since a large part of that coastline is far removed from highways and other roads.  The impact of erosion, however, is even greater in Louisiana than it is in adjacent areas of neighboring states.  One of the most drastically affected coastal areas is the Mississippi River delta.  Take a look at this map of the southern reaches of Plaquemines Parish, which includes the delta:

erosion plauemines parish
 

Most maps will show an image similar to this, with a long finger of land extending out into the Gulf of Mexico.  These images are really out of date, and do not take into account the loss of shoreline that has taken place during the past 20 years.  This satellite image of the exact same part of Plaquemines Parish illustrates just how much erosion has taken place in the Mississippi River delta:

erosion mississippi delta
 

Want more?  Here is a photo of the Chandeleur Islands Lighthouse taken in 1960:

erosion chandeleur light 1960
 

Now take a look at the same site in 2001.  The island has receded at least a hundred yards,, and it is much smaller than it was in the earlier photo.  What's more, as the Gulf waters encroached on the lighthouse, the old lightkeeper's quarters were eventually washed away, and all traces of that home have been obliterated:

erosion chandeleur light 2001

 The Chandeleur Lighthouse took a direct hit from Hurrican Katrina in 2005.  You may be wondering how it fared during that terrible storm.  The answer is, it didn't.  All traces of the lighthouse were washed away by Katrina.  In fact, all traces of the northern Chandeleur Islands were washed away.  The islands are slowly regenerating, but the human history has been forever removed.  It's a pattern that will repeat itself on coastlines around the world as we enter an era of higher seas and more violent weather.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Well done! This is difficult to look at, but so important to know about...now for the solution to the problem! xox
Well researched and, as always, well written. Though erosion is a natural occourance, the human factor has certainly multiplied its effect in so many areas as your photos clearly show. We all have marveled at photos or have seen in person the majesty of the Grand Canyon....another result of erosion. This piece is well deserving of the EP it has received....well done.
Steve, a great post about a very important topic and I really appreciated all of the historical references and photos you have added here. The story of the fate of the lighthouse is especially dramatic in light of the many strong hurricanes we have had over the years. I see some evidence of erosion in my area but in the immediate region there are so many stringent regulations in place by the state, county, towns, and the NYC DEP that have prevented any serious erosion such as we might have seen in the '50s or earlier.
Thanks Robin. I wish a solution were easy to come by!

Torman, I almost included the Grand Canyon in this piece, but as I understand it, tectonic uplift is also a big factor there, coupled with erosion.

John, I suspect we'd see some erosion on Long Island's coastline. But you are correct, its more insidious effects can be limited by smart regulation.
"Erosion is not a Democratic or Republican issue. It simply is."

It is nice to come across a straight forward, informative post like this.
Well done, Steve. Erosion is only one of the many severe problems our children and grandchildren will encounter in this time of climate change. I wish our president would focus on this oncoming crisis with more legislation and protections.
Fascinating post. Erosion shows the history of our Earth. Thank you for this informative piece and the photos.
♥R
Scarlet, thank you for your kind comment.

Lea, we as a nation are really lagging in our response to climate change. I'm afraid our children and grandchildren will not think kindly of us in that regard.

FusunA, yes it does. The Palo Duro Canyon that I showed in this post exposes rocks dating back to the Permian age, more than 300 million years ago.
Not to worry, Pro. People are nothing more than cosmic parasites. ;) Something tells me that when we're gone, the planet will continue to thrive into the next ice age.
The before-and-after Plaquemines Parish photos are startling. Thanks for the education.
Informative and disturbing, both.
Bravo on this whole piece. The effect of the environment on history is incalcuable. Seemingly small changes in weather patterns can turn a thriving city on a major trade route into another habitation abandoned to the desert (see Petra, Jordan). And we won't even begin on the droughts and erosion in sub-Saharan Africa and the expansion of that desert.

Considering the rate of global warming, you may want to advise your son to invest in the Yukon's northern coastline, which should be fine beachfront property by 2070.
I like that you made your case without buzz words. Well done.
Thanks, Pro, excellent survey of close-to-home effects of natural and human-assisted erosion, especially impressive are the before-and-after shots
Belinda, you're correct -- the world will survive without us just fine.

dianaani, neilpaul, & Sarah, thank you for your nice comment. Glad you stopped by.

Stim, hmm, good investment advice. As long as that shoreline doesn't wash away.

Stacey, I hate buzz words.

Roy, great to see you again. Nothing tells the story quite so well as the before and after shots.
Wow. Once again I'm now smarter cause of you. I like that!
Thanks Roger, glad you stopped by!
I love the progression from a small amount of erosion. Great story!
Congrats on the EP! I am catching up after vacation....
R
Susie, thank you. Glad you caught the progression from micro-erosion to macro!
While I gather that the desired take home point of this post had more to do with human influence, the stunning photos you have posted remind me at least of just how dynamic our home is. The last anecdote about Chandeleur Island is most striking in that respect to me. There was very little that people did to 'cause' the erosion that washed that island back to the sea. And even though it was washed back to the sea, it's coming back.

The ebb and flow I guess.

I do think that people, in general, do a great deal of harm to the environment in the name of short term success. The personal experiences of your friends with erosion directly caused by development is a good example of that.

But I was think we can't get too big for our britches. While we have a significant role to play in shaping the world around us, we certainly do not play the only role and we may not even play the largest role. There is still so much for us to learn about how and where we impact the world, in both positive and negative ways. For that matter, it seems hard to me to define 'positive' and 'negative' universally.

The mesquite taking over the southwest would certainly claim erosion is a 'good' thing. So would BBQ enthusiasts would like mesquite!

Thanks for the pictures, though. They are quite striking. You're a very good storyteller.
demon, erosion is, and always has been, part of the natural flow of geological forces. Barrier islands like the Chandeleur chain have always been among the most dynamic landforms in the world, constantly shifting, and sometimes even disappearing and reforming. In the case of the Chandeleurs and others in the Gulf of Mexico, human activity is certainly playing a significant role, however. The taming of the Mississippi, with its dams and levies, inhibits the flow of sediments into the sea that are major builders of the islands. This increases the impact of natural erosion, and makes them more vulnerable to higher sea levels.

As for your larger point about the uncertainty about just how much humans are impacting this natural process, I certainly agree with you that we really don't know, although we certainly have some measure of impact. As for mesquite, too bad the erosion couldn't have attracted hickory -- that's a much better BBQ fuel IMHO!
Erosion never sleeps. Nice collection and details.
Don't know why it took me so long to read this. I'll echo Chicago Guy's comment, in that I now know something I didn't know before.

Well done.
Well written and painful to see and read. My little yard problem this morning is truly miniscule by comparison. Your piece underscores the reason why I went through all that craziness to save my topsoil.
Thank you for this informative and wonderfully written piece on erosion...& great photos! It reminds me of a book by Wangari Maathai, called "Unbowed." (She is the first environmentalist and first African woman to win the Nobel Peace Prize). It is interesting, because her story is also the story of erosion in Kenya, which happened during her lifetime. She started to reverse the effects of man-made erosion by planting trees and creating "belts" of forest to hold the soil and water. It started out as a very small grassroots effort, & the Green Belt Movement now has planted over 45 million trees and restored ecosystems throughout her country...Maybe with enough visionary people and effort, these restorations will take place around the world...?
Steve this is truly sobering. Sometimes it seems, if one owns an older house, that our function is to stave off the effects of erosion, not just in a landscape context, but also with the natural breakdown of brick, motor, and other natural materials. Water, being the main corrosive agent, is relentless.

This is a great piece...thanks so much for this.
Sorry for being so delinquent in responding to everyone who took the time to read and comment on this post during the past day. I really appreciate your nice words.

Clay ball, thanks for mentioning Wangari Maathai. I vaguely remember hearing about her when she won the Nobel. You are correct, we could use a lot more like her. Parts of Africa in particular suffer the effects of macro-erosion, often with results similar to what America experienced during the Dust Bowl.