Procopius

Procopius
Location
Rockford, Illinois, USA
Birthday
February 05
Bio
I'm a regular middle aged guy, living in a regular middle class neighborhood, in a regular middle-sized community in the middle of America. I am an expatriate Texan transplanted to the Midwest, and wondering how I got here, and where I'm headed.

MY RECENT POSTS

Procopius's Links

Salon.com
AUGUST 29, 2011 8:42AM

Rick Perry on the Recession and God's Purpose

Rate: 10 Flag

Texas governor and presidential candidate Rick Perry recently appeared on evangelist James Robison's television program.  The discussion that ensued was pretty much what one would expect.  Perry apparently likes to talk about his religious beliefs, at least with certain audiences, and to be honest, I don't have a big problem with that.  If a candidate's political philosophy is strongly influenced by his personal faith, then I am glad that he is willing to discuss the tenants of that faith and explain how they color his policy agenda.  Think of it as a form of "full disclosure".

I was actually grateful, therefore, that  Perry was willing to discuss his religious interpretation of the current economic circumstances of the United States. What America is experiencing, Perry explained to his television host, is nothing other than a message from God:  "We're going through those difficult economic times for a purpose, to bring us back to those biblical principles."

Here is the video, and the quote above takes place at about 1:05 into the clip:

 

 

OK, in a way, what Perry is saying is not really all that radical.  Similar messages are delivered in churches all over America every week.  Everything that happens, happens for a reason.  The Christian god is a living, omnipotent presence, who is actively involved in events on Earth.  

But the implications of what Perry said are very far reaching, and may tarnish the message he hoped to deliver.  If our economic downturn has been ordained by God in order to bring Americans back to biblical principles, what is the corollary of that idea?  Does that mean economic prosperity is likewise given by God as a reward for following biblical principles?  One would assume that a loving God will do more than simply punish the sinful.  A loving God will reward the faithful.  If God will punish us as a nation with economic hardship, it seems obvious he will reward the country with economic prosperity when we do his will.

When, in recent times, has the United States been most prosperous?  Since our current economic downturn has been driven by the high unemployment rate, maybe the economic indicator of unemployment will be a good tool to determine when America has strayed from biblical principles, and when we have been better engaged in promoting God's will.

unemployment graph
Using this unemployment chart as a guide, let's see how well America has adhered to biblical principles since the election of Ronald Reagan.

1981-84:  Reagan's first term:  Strayed from biblical principles

1985-90:  Reagan's 2nd, early Bush I:  Followed biblical principles

1890-93:  Bush I:  Strayed from biblical principles

1993-2001:  Clinton:  Followed biblical principles

2001-04:  Bush II first term:  Strayed from biblical principles

2004-07:  Bush II second term:  Followed biblical principles

2008:  Late Bush II:  Strayed from biblical principles

2009-2011:  Obama:  Date inconclusive

Now some notes on the data

1. Reagan's first term was centered on large-scale tax cuts for upper income brackets, and a more aggressive foreign policy toward the Soviet Union, including a large buildup of medium range missiles stationed in Europe.  Bad ideas, we strayed from biblical principles.

2.  Reagan's second term was dominated by the Iran-Contra scandal, when many Reagan officials were convicted of breaking the law and lying to Congress.  These things were good and followed biblical principles.

3.  Bush I:   Bush attacked Iraq after that country's invasion of Kuwait, and raised taxes to fight a growing budget deficit.  Bad ideas, strayed from biblical principles.

4.  Clinton years:  Steady reduction in unemployment, obviously the most godly years our nation has experienced in recent memory.

5.  Bush II, first term: Although Bush claimed to have read the Bible every morning, he must not have gotten the message.  Strayed from biblical principles with those tax cuts and military interventions.

6.  Bush II, second term:  God maybe had second thoughts about that first term.  Things improved from an employment standp0int.

7.  Bush II, late presidency, early Obama:  Hmm, God changed his mind again.  Maybe Obama should have rescinded those Bush tax cuts like he promised he would do during the 2008 campaign!

There is one important point that Rick Perry failed to mention.  If God ordains hard times on Americans for straying from biblical principles, wouldn't he do the same for other nations across the globe?  On the flip side, shouldn't America take notice of nations who have avoided the current economic downturn that has affected so many worldwide?  Perhaps, if we look overseas, we will find the nations that are adhering to God's will.

Over the past couple of years, as America, in the words of Gov. Perry, has "struggled through those tough economic times for a purpose, to bring us back to those biblical principles," China's economy has grown over 10% annually, and India's over 8%.  Holy cow!

Author tags:

recession, god, rick perry

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I'll be away from my computer for much of today and won't be able to respond to comments very promptly. In the meantime, thank you for taking the time to stop by.
Steve, as you point out, there is plenty of information that runs contrary to Perry's message. Among the many strong points against his concept is this part of your graph: "1993-2001: Clinton: Followed biblical principles" and your closing statement: "China's economy has grown over 10% annually, and India's over 8%."--looks like some other gods are working overtime for the China and India these days! Thanks for this thought provoking post!
The Taliban takes many forms and many religions. Save theocracy for the Millennium, when presumably the divine administration can handle it the way it's intended. Since humans haven't mastered it without killing off hoards, humans should stick to human administration modeling the social justice part leaving the fire and brimstone part to the provenance of the various houses of worship.
Commonweal = Pharoah
Citizenship = slavery
Rick Perry = Fred Thompson

This is wickedly well presented. China and India indeed.
John, sort of goes to show that a candidate needs to consider the full ramifications of what he says!

Algis, that's a good one!

bbd, it almost sounds like you would advocate a separation of church and state!

Stacey, I assume you didn't really mean to say "wickedly presented"...I prefer to think of it as "divinely" presented.
If you take a strict Calvinist approach that God rewards those on Earth whom, thanks to predestination, He's already saved, defense contractors, Wall Street bankers and the politicians they've paid off are heaven bound. The rest of us better get used to the eternal heat.
Wickedly clever! The right-wingers will not doubt be utterly dumbfounded by a reference to Clinton in the same breath as a reference to Godly or Biblical...
Stim dangit, you've got me sweating.

Blue, what can I say? Numbers don't lie.
You can't argue logic and facts with these people! But they are funny.
Ghost, I feel better now -- it's all just a comedy act!
Gee, and I always thought the Lord maketh the rain to fall on the just and unjust alike! I guess I was reading the wrong Bible translation...

Rated for common sense.
Alan, you've obviously been reading too much of that post-modernistic biblical criticism. See, that's what happens when you live in Germany for too long.
And God said: "My Neo-Chosen People did not obey my commandments to feed the poor, so I sent a plague of locusts disguised as Reaganites to strip them bare of all their possessions. I sent the Dogs of War Bush and Cheney to cause them to impoverish themselves by beating their plowshares into swords. Then I caused the false prophets of Randian heresy to rise up among them, and fools paid them heed. I sent shrieking sirens Sarah and Michelle to torment their souls and rot their minds. But still, they refused to heed the commandments I sent my Son to deliver unto them, to care for the least among them. Must I now send Satan himself to open their eyes and hearts?"
Tom Cordle, an Elijah for the 21st century!
makes me wanna go roast a damn fatted calf.

perry is an energetic, vibrant,
handsome, fit
dangerous
version of bush2.

just as bachmann is a parody of palin, whom i miss.

romney is..uh..
one of 50,000 manufactured that yr.
english was so so tough to program
in his head.

etc
shown this to people and watch they have an attack at the Clinton years.