sWell

(random riffs on topics medical)

rahul k. parikh

rahul k. parikh
Location
Walnut Creek, California,
Bio
Physician & Writer www.rahulkparikh.com www.twitter.com/docrkp The information here is not direct medical advice.

Editor’s Pick
NOVEMBER 10, 2008 12:56PM

Filthy Doctors!

Rate: 9 Flag

Let's do a simple test association test.  I'm going to write down a word.  After you read it, close your eyes and think of the images that come to mind.

 

 

 The word is:

 

 

 DOCTOR

 

 

(close eyes now)

 

 

Welcome back.  Now it's likely that the images that crossed your mind included the following:

White Coat

Stethoscope

Those two objects are probably the most famous symbols of the medical profession. 

 

 

But a slow, steadily growing body of evidence suggests that the sleeves of doctor’s coats (especially the pockets and sleeves) and the head of their stethoscopes are reservoirs for bacteria. Our hands touch you, we place our stethoscope on your chest to listen.  Like magnets, bacteria attach to our hands, sleeves and instruments. That bacteria that then can be spread between patients, leading to infections that we doctors are then solely responsible for. 

 

 

While doctors are now very diligent about washing our hands between encounters, not so with dry cleaning our coats or cleaning off our stethoscopes with, say, an alcohol swab. 

 

 

Mostly, we're trekking a common bacteria called staph aureus around  with us.  Most of have some of this on our skin but in a hospital or medical setting, where we have people who are often ill with diseases that compromise their immune system (AIDS or cancer for example), even a common bacteria can lead to serious problems.  Also, more cases of what's called methicillin resistant staph aureus (MRSA) are starting to emerge.  This is a particularly tough strain of bug that many antibiotics can't treat, making it that much more dangerous. 

 

 

Last year in the U.K., the National Health Service recently banned white coats altogether   (of course, that might mean we're just carrying the bugs on our own shirtsleeves out of the hospital to home and elsewhere, rather than just leaving them there). And while we can't do the same with stethoscopes, I'm certain that all of us in the medical profession will be hearing more and more about washing our hands and our doctor toys).

 

 

And let's not forget the non-doctor personnel who wear white coats iand use stethoscopes in the medicial profession these days--they include nurses, respiratory therapists, lab workers, pharmacists and just about anybody who comes into contact with a patient. 

 

 

The big irony here, for those of you who are history buffs:  The white coat itself was initally adopted by doctors as a symbol of both their scientific know how and their dedication to sterile techniques. 

 

 

 But, like so many other things in medicine, times really have changed. 

 

 

 

  

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Dr. 90210 wears a MUSCLE coat. Maybe he is on to something, HMMMMMM???
I refer you to Doc Tueter's blog where I mentioned the need for better hand washing routines and in passing brought up this white coat issue more than a month ago. Doc T tried to make me look like an idiot or irrational doctor hater in the comment thread, but it sure is nice to see Salon's own pet doc agreeing with me now.
I had no idea about the bacteria level on the white coats and stethoscopes. I'll be certainly have that on my mind every time I'm in a doctor's office.
I've often wondered why doctors are allowed to have anything long sleeved at all. Certainly 3/4 sleeves or short sleeves make a great deal more sense?
Why not a sort of scrub sans the coat? And new, sterilized equipment at each examination? It could be done with minimal expense.
I heard about the U.K. situation in an NPR story, but didn't they also mention that there's a similar movement to ban neck ties, and for the same reason?
What do you recommend for hospital staff (nurses and the like) who do not wash their hands? I recently spent four days and nights with a seriously ill friend who was hospitalized. I washed my hands more than they did. And no, they didn't always use gloves.
yeah, the necktie thing is really getting play. i mean, the white coat gets washed every once in a while; how often do you think the dr. washes his tie?
I've stopped wearing my wedding ring and my wristwatch so I can wash my hands more carefully between patients. Many doctors are banning ties from their offices.

I'm going to institute a policy that the stethoscopes at our surgery center are wiped with alcohol between each patient and thoroughly cleaned at the end of the day.

Thanks for the article-
When my father was recovering from being gravely ill in the hospital a doctor came around and told us the goal was to get him out as quickly as possible. Not because of health insurance issues. But because, there are so many germs floating around the hospital that anyone with a compromised immune system is a greater risk in the hospital than at home!
Gary is right. I got my dad out as quickly as possible. Hospitals are bad for your health.

(rated)
Now Dr's wear coats to keep their regular clothes clean and to avoid the transmission of bacteria. The Dr I work for does not wear a white coat. (We are in Internal med)

And for stethoscopes, we clean ours after each patient.
There’s more to patients getting sick in hospital then just "dirty" coats and unclean scopes. Often it’s from unclean hands and their VISITORS!

Visitors pose a great threat to infection as well. MRSA, which is passed through wet mucosa (nose, mouth) can come from anywhere these days. Including your grocery store!

And this was also a UK study.
The hospital I work for has a 100% compliance with hand washing and clean clothes.

While many medical staff, (out side of those caring a PHD) do wear coats, its to protect us from YOU!

My coat saved me from urine, blood and vomit exposures many times.

So before you nay say the coat, perhaps many in the medical field need to change our techniques. In surgical situations the coats are changed and washed daily (as they should be)

But in other situations such as lab, where there is minimal PT exposure, (those coats are used to protect the user from bodily fluids.) the concern is far less.

So my answer...If EVERYONE washed their hands, and washed their clothes daily, this entire country would be far less ill.

And if you think my stethoscope is dirty? I bet its still cleaner then your cell phone or your kid!

;0)

A Mind
Very interesting. I've always had that suspicion. But, just in practical terms, instead of banning white coats like the NHS in Britain, why not require that they be laundered daily? Just as a start...
When I was in practice a few years ago, the teaching hospital I worked for attempted to enforce a practice that you couldn't have artificial nails if you were involved in direct patient care because a study showed that they harbored a higher level of bacteria.

Now this divadoc doesn't wear tips, but does get gel overlays. Unfortunately the frumps that created the policy had no understanding of nail "culture," (pardon the pun) and attempted to restrict me from patient care (something I actually would have welcomed, as overworked as I was).

I carried on about my right to divatude (I work with teens after all...there are standards to uphold) and said that I would not comply with such a rule until rings, ties, stethoscopes and other fomites were also banned. It got heated until finally one of the ID docs realized that the overlay only covered the top surface of the nail. The undersurface of the nail was my own fingernail and not an artificial nail...as such the overlay could be considered a really, really, really thick layer of nail polish and is thus acceptable.

Three years later here is more evidence that I knew what I was talking about!