sWell

(random riffs on topics medical)

rahul k. parikh

rahul k. parikh
Location
Walnut Creek, California,
Bio
Physician & Writer of Salon's Vital Signs

Editor’s Pick
AUGUST 24, 2009 12:48AM

Who Is Losing the Health Care Debate? You Are.

Rate: 5 Flag

 375416-man_with_paper_bag_on_head_large

 

Over the past month, our national discussion about health care has gone from bad to worse to embarrassing.  

That's because any dialogue about how to fix health care--like refocusing on making the primary care-patient doctor relationship stronger, using electronic medical records to create a seamless system of care, and testing drugs against one another to see what works best--has given away to a lot of hollering by the left and right.  

Thus, we've reached a point where the health care debate has become less about ideas and more about:

  • Barack Obama versus Conservatives
  • Barack Obama versus Liberals
  • Sarah Palin's Facebook Page
  • Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid conducting business as usual
  • Betsy McCaughey twisting Ezekiel Emanuel's words
  • Betsy McCaughey being "smacked down" by Jon Stewart for twisting words (though  he wasn't exactly right himself in how he read of House Bill, either)
  • Barney Frank's back talk to a town hall attendee
  • Charles Grassley saying who knows what?  At this point, I'd stopped caring.
  • the AMA, the AARP, America's Health Insurance Plans, PhARMA, and other special interests jock ying for airtime, advertising space and the op-ed page to spin reform and where they stand on it.  

Nowhere in this list is You, and your health needs, or those of your loved ones.  

So where can one go these days to read/listen to thoughtful ideas and deeper discussion? Here's a couple of suggestions:

 

____________________________________

www.rahulkparikh.com

www.twitter.com/docrkp

 


 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
These are clearly difficult times for discussion and debate in America. I do not know what will be the final decision as to what America will have, but I have some light as to the experiences of those already under a government run system for health care.

It is examples of ONE system, but not neccessarily the same as what America will finally choose.

http://open.salon.com/blog/jonmagee/2009/08/14/national_health_service_yes_it_can_do_it


http://open.salon.com/blog/jonmagee/2009/08/19/accommodation_freely
Insightful and informative...Thanks...
It has been 10 minutes and still my last comment has not been posted. I had thought Salon was a champion of free expression not censureship.

John E Moore MD
Your experiment is anything but scientific. Your data is purely anecdotal. The impoverished have the same responsibilities as the rich. It is not our responsibility to feed the poor. It is their responsibility to escalate within the social strata. To those standing in line at McDonalds Isay if you want healthy food get a better job. In typical liberal fashion you are fomenting class warfare.


John E Moore MD