Ranjit Souri

Ranjit Souri
Location
Chicago, Illinois, USA
Birthday
November 02
Bio
In April 2010 I am reading books about the Holocaust and blogging about them. I live in Chicago. Banner by Ric Tresa.

Ranjit Souri's Links

New list
No links in this category.
APRIL 1, 2010 9:22AM

The Holocaust Reading Project

Rate: 6 Flag

The last survivors of the Nazi concentration camps were liberated in 1945.

 

For the most part, the Jews who were allowed to live (mostly as slaves) in the concentration camps were those of working age. The old and the young (typically age 14 or lower) were often exterminated either soon after arriving at a concentration camp, or in the periodic “selections” that took place whenever the Nazis wanted to reduce concentration camp populations.

 

Add all of the above facts together, and we can conclude that the vast majority of the youngest of the concentration camp survivors are now in their 80s. (There are a few miraculous exceptions such as Tova Friedman, who is 71.) That means that right now, the number of concentration camp survivors still living is creeping inexorably toward its permanent zero.

 

Within a few years, there will be none left.

 

There will be none left to tell first-hand of the pounding on their doors in the middle of the night by SS or Gestapo or by locals who were incited by the Nazis.

 

There will be none left to tell first-hand of being crammed into rickety boxcars or cattle-cars, with standing room only, with almost no ventilation, with no food and little water, with no seats or facilities, to spend days and nights in the dark, moving slowly, perhaps in freezing temperatures, in their own filth, to a fate that many of them could not even grasp until the very end.

 

There will be none left to tell first-hand of disembarking the trains hundreds of miles from home and being forced to go “right” or “left” with one of the directions meaning death today, and the other direction meaning life in a slave camp with only a slight chance of survival.

 

There will be none left to tell first-hand of working in the very gas chambers that snuffed out the lives of their fellow prisoners en masse—and of the heart-wrenching guilt of knowing that working in these gas chambers might preserve their own lives just a little longer. [1: See endnote #1 in comments.] 

 

There will be none left.

 

*

 

Aside from the World Wars, the Holocaust is probably the most well-documented massive-scale tragedy in the entirety of human history. This is due to at least five factors:

 

1. The abrupt collapse of the Nazi regime at the end of World War II meant that the Nazis did not have time to destroy much of the documentation regarding their “Final Solution”. In the immediate aftermath of the Third Reich’s demise, over 1,000 tons of documentation were recovered throughout Germany. [2]

 

2. Numerous diaries were kept during the events—by victims, by perpetrators, by onlookers, and by those who helped the victims—and many of these diaries were preserved and later published or made available to researchers.

 

3. Many Holocaust-related memoirs were written and published in the years following the Holocaust.

 

4. The Nuremberg Trials and the Nuremberg Military Tribunals resulted in hundreds of hours of sworn testimony from all sides of the tragedy as well as over one million pages of documentation. [3]

 

5. In the decades since the Holocaust, volumes and volumes of research-based books about the Holocaust have been produced by historians, professors, journalists, and others.

 

In short, “what is known” about the Holocaust is awesome in its breadth and depth.

 

*

 

Yet, when it comes down to us—the non-historians, the non-academics, the non-experts—for the vast majority of us, our knowledge of the Holocaust is superficial at best. “What is known” by us as individuals is miniscule compared with “what is known” by those who do the research and write about it.

 

For example, we all know about Auschwitz; but how much do we know about the subsection of Auschwitz called Birkenau (a.k.a. “Auschwitz II”) and the morbid relationship between the purpose of Auschwitz and the purpose of Birkenau?

 

Or: We all know about the gas chambers; but how much do we know about the Einsatzgruppen (special operations units)—the SS killing squads that traveled from village to village in Eastern Europe, systematically mass-murdering most or all of the Jews in each village? This was part I of the Final Solution, and it was only after months of this process that the Nazis decided they needed a more efficient and less traumatic (for the perpetrators) and less public way of killing. Thus, the gas chambers and crematoria were born only after hundreds of thousands of Jews had already been murdered in their own villages, towns, and cities by the Einsatzgruppen and its henchmen. And even once the gas chambers and crematoria were put into operation, the Einsatzgruppen kept working. In all, of the six million Jews murdered during the Holocaust, fully 1.5 million were killed by the Einsatzgruppen.

 

Or: We all know about the liberations of the Nazi concentration camps in 1945; but how much do we know about the Displaced Persons camps (“DP camps”) that housed many of the freed survivors for the next several years? Repatriation was difficult. These survivors had lost most or all of their possessions, and many of them had lost their families. In addition, their bodies and spirits had been ravaged by months or years of any or all of the following to extreme levels: malnourishment, slave labor, exposure to the elements, exposure to communicable diseases, and continuous terror. According to John Guzlowski [4]:

 

After liberation, the repatriation of the refugees took a long time. There were about 12 million refugees (Jews, Poles, Russians, Italians, Gypsies...) in Germany after the collapse of the Nazis. They lived in DP camps and some were still there as late as 1952.

 

*

 

It is often said of the Holocaust that “We must never forget.” Of course that is true, but I would take it a step further: To simply remember is not enough—we must also strive, as individuals, to increase our learning about and understanding of the Holocaust.

 

So today I begin what I call the Holocaust Reading Project.

 

I resolve to read several books about the Holocaust this month (April 2010) in observance of National Holocaust Month. And I will blog about those books here on Open Salon. In fact, this month my blog will be devoted exclusively to books about the Holocaust. I hope to read and blog about at least 10 Holocaust-related books during April. [5]

 

I invite you to join me in any of the following ways:

 

1. You can commit to reading at least one book about the Holocaust this month. If you’d like to get my Holocaust book suggestions throughout this month, feel free to “favorite” my blog now and then un-“favorite” it at the end of the month. I promise I will not take your eventual un-favoriting personally.

 

2. You can join the Facebook group I have just set up called “I will read one book about the Holocaust in April 2010”.

 

3. You can recommend a Holocaust-related book in a comment to this post.

 

4. You can participate in this Open call in observance of National Holocaust Month: Anytime during April of 2010, if you post an entry related to the Holocaust, please begin the post-title with “OC / Holocaust: ” (or, if that is too long, perhaps "OC / NHM: ") and send me a PM. I cannot promise to take the time to compile periodic round-ups of all or some of these Holocaust posts, but if I can I will.

 

*

 

Certainly, to remember is important. Candlelight vigils, public moments of silence, out-loud readings of victims’ names—these are important ways for us to honor the victims of the Holocaust.

 

But perhaps we can do something more this month, and push the boundaries of what we (as individuals) know about the event and how we understand it.

 

My hope is that by the end of April 2010, both you and I can answer “yes” to this question: Do I have a better understanding of the Holocaust now than I did a month ago?

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
ENDNOTES:

1. Concentration camp prisoners who worked in the gas chambers were known as Sonderkommandos. The vast majority of them were eventually themselves murdered by the Nazis (because they had seen too much), but a small number survived. The most famous of these surviving Sonderkommandos is Filip Muller whose 1979 memoir Eyewitness Auschwitz: Three years in the gas chambers tells the story.

2. Source: “Masters of death: The SS-Einsatzgruppen and the invention of the Holocaust”, by Richard Rhodes.

3. Source: Harvard Law School Library Nuremberg Trials Project.

4. John Guzlowski was born in a DP camp in Vinenberg, Germany, in 1948. Both of his parents were Polish Catholic survivors of Nazi concentration camps, and they met in a DP camp. John moved with his family out of the DP camp and to the U.S.A. in 1951. Eventually he got a Ph.D. in English from Purdue University and went on to become a professor of literature and poetry. He is a widely-published writer of poetry and prose, and he travels across the United States speaking about the Holocaust. John writes brilliantly about the Holocaust on his Open Salon blog LIVING IN PARTIAL LIGHT and in his book of Holocaust poetry LIGHTNING AND ASHES. John was kind enough to serve as a sounding-board for me while I worked on this essay. The quote that this is a footnote to is taken from one of the e-mails he sent to me while he was helping me with the essay. I am grateful to John for his expertise, perspective, and time.

5. I’ve gotten a head-start toward this goal by reading a few Holocaust-related books during March, that I will blog about in April in addition to those Holocaust-related books that I read in April.
Terrific post, Ranjit. What's interesting is I became obsessed with World War II earlier this year, and spent January and February reading about it, but more from the historical and political angle. That said, I re-read Art Spiegelman's "Maus." Incredibly powerful. For my part, I'd like to learn more than the superficial knowledge I have right now of the "holocausts" that have taken place in my lifetime....Rwanda, and in the balkanization of Europe.
Sorry, make that the political and WARFARE (military historical) angle....
Ranjit, thank you for taking on this project, and I will do what I can to let my friends know about what you plan to do.

I recently posted a piece about Holocaust Remembrance Day, April 12 at OS about how ultimately despite our best efforts we will never know what the Holocaust was like.

http://open.salon.com/blog/john_guzlowski/2010/03/31/april_12_is_holocaust_remembrance_day
Elisa, I had never heard of “The Zookeeper’s Wife”, but I just looked it up and it looks terrific. I am adding it to my reading list, either for this month or for the long term.

ChillerPop, Maus is terrific—it’s one of the books I’ve read in the last couple of weeks as I got a head-start on this reading project. Your superficial knowledge of Rwanda and the balkanization are probably more than what I have, and if you blog about those as you learn more I’ll be glad to read.

John, thank you for your help and for all that you do here. You are under-appreciated at Open Salon and I hope that that changes.
Thanks for the ... Remembrance.
The Museum / Memorial? Wow.
The DC Remembrance is a must.
Visit The National Remembrance.
Yes.

DCs Remembrance of the Holocaust had a powerful impact on my family. Railcars, tracks, ovens, shoes, photos and the many other visuals ... Just seeing the DCs Reminder changes your life. I took the family when it opened. The most horrid photo/exhibits were guarded by a barrier to protect a child from seeing what human nature can become.

Monstrous. Depravity.
I remember the smells.
The Leather shoes etc.,
`
Folks from the West Coast visited my Family while on vacation one year and they wanted a "tour-guide" of DC and ask me`Where should we go?

The First DC site ... that came to my thinking was `The Memorable National Remembrance, Place,
The Reminder of Jewish History. The visitors were not Jewish.

I said:`
"We can all visit The National Holocaust Reminder!" I remember after the visit the wife expressed a 'Tease" - as in annoyed. "The DC Zoo would have been better?"

Vacation? Oh, Disney?
I was dumbstruck. I am more sensitive to certain people who refuse to 'Touch' enormous Pain. Pain that 'cuts to the quick,' as in Pain Pierces the human conscious/heart more than they are ever prepared to know.

I say`Touch the Pain.

That attitude, in my opinion is anti-`Numbness and a denial trait? Numbness is a form of inner-weapon of escape. I'm not Jewish, but I've been deeply wounded/seared by human ...inhumanity.

My soul piercing?
Grief was `Nams War.
apology. I'm chatty.

I'll still always recommend the eye opener Jewish History Remembrance, First.
Second? Visit more hurt.
The Native American Remembrance.

The Planet Earth, Turtle Island, was much better managed and preserved before the British/French Greedy Colonial Invaders Plundered. Sorry. Focus> yes.
One day I hope to read John Guzlowski etc.
I'll email this to Teacher, Robert H. Deluty.
Mr Deuty has had more of an influence on my life than any other Jewish human being. I buy his books and give his books away to people I sense are sensitive.
I go on-on, crying out-loud?
as they say, figuratively, sigh.
`
Tolerate a last personal remembrance?
In the early seventies I visited Dachau.
I was so sad post-war. Then, Dachau.
What inner Grief. I was wiped-out.
It seems I gravitate toward pain.
Pain makes you know Ya Alive.
Thanks for this Remembrance.

John? You give tours?
I hope. I'll bring milk?
I'd love to drive to DC.
You are not far away.
I give you a book?
R.H.D. I'll email?
I'll email a goat?
hi Robert H. D.
How do Ya do?
Thanks for your comments, Art. I agree, we must face the pain of the Holocaust even though we can only do so in an indirect and imperfect way. If you write about the Holocaust this month, please let me know and I will try to call attention to the piece.
Ranjit! It is so cool that you are doing this! I have read quite a bit over the years on this subject both in and out of my book club. Some of my favorite books for you to consider: Sarah's Key (excellent but historical fiction), The Book Thief. This is a subject near and dear to my heart because of Marlene's parents (my closest friend growing up) and learning about their history throughout my life. In fact, Marlene is going to the Bergen Belsen concentration camp next week to their 60 year commemorative memorial event that her mother was invited to.

I will absolutely keep on top of your blog and find a new book to read on the subject.
Thanks very much, Laura. I just learned this about Marlene earlier today--Brian told me. I've met her so many times and never knew of her very personal connection with the Holocaust.

Thanks for your recommendations too. The Book Thief is on my bookshelf right now, waiting for me to read it this month. I've added Sarah's Key to my list, probably for sometime later, since my lists is already saturated for this month.

The next time I see Marlene I will have to find out more, including about her trip to Bergen-Belsen.

I'm glad that you are joining in this endeavor. Let me know what new (to you) book(s) you end up reading.
I am deeply touched by your commitment to this. _r
Thanks very much, Joan. I appreciate your stopping by and commenting.
Marlene and her mother came into the kid's school when they were studying the Holocaust. What a unique opportunity the kid's had -- to actually meet a survivor. I have her story on a power point presentation that you are welcome to see. Although survivor's downplay their stories, it is fascinating and I know I am a better person having seen and heard it (and of course grown up with her as my serogate mother).

I invited Marlene to this site and hope she will partake in the dialog.

Take care.
The gypsies (Romani) were targeted by the Holocaust. Gypsies are always living on or outside our boundaries. Within the loosely affiliated Romani "tribes" they spoke different languages and practiced different cultural norms. Most lived nomadic lifestyles. They were forcibly sterilized, sent to concentration camps, had Zyklon B tested on them, subjected to "medical" experiments, and killed. No one knows exactly how many died--from 200,000 to 400,000.