AUGUST 18, 2009 1:44PM

When Will Obama Re-Take The Ball on Health Care?

Rate: 9 Flag

With football season now gearing up, it's hard not to think of this health care reform debate as the Super Bowl of politics.

So much of our political, economic and social life over the years has been in preparation -- in training -- for this big game.

That's why things have been getting so ugly. The need for reform is so great, the stakes so very high and the opposition so powerful.

Those of us in favor of significant health care reform essentially elected President Obama to be our quarterback. And -- unless the news reports prove me wrong, and I hope they do -- it looks like he might be giving up the ball too many times in the first quarter. And as we all know, few football teams can win when the QB forgets how to throw or give clear direction.

Many Democrats in Congress fear they're about to be betrayed, after they've been tackling opponents over the public option at Town Hall meetings across the country all summer.

And those of us who cheered on Obama during the primary and general elections, putting in countless hours to register voters, canvass neighborhoods and call voters again and again, are watching our dreams of a reform touchdown slip away as the game clock winds down.

Yes, We Can. Hope. Change We Can Believe In. Huh?

Instead, we're getting secret deals with the pharmaceutical industry, a probable reversal on the public option and a push for so-called health insurance "co-ops"?

As Wendell Potter, a former health insurance company spokesman pointed out on CNN.com this morning, the health insurance industry is running the whole show. Working with big PR firms, they're coming up with more key messages than reform opponents can manage to spew out on a single cable news show or picket line.

These masters of manipulation are controlling the debate. Are they also controlling the White House?

Is there really just one coach directing both teams?

New York Times commentator, Bob Herbert, wrote this morning that "Insurance companies are delighted with the way 'reform' is unfolding. Think of it: The government is planning to require most uninsured Americans to buy health coverage. Millions of young and healthy individuals will be herded into the industry’s welcoming arms. This is the population the insurers drool over."

And with no public option, we will have just one option -- the private insurance industry.

Herbert also says to forget about those co-ops, a proposal that pretty much just popped up out of nowhere over the weekend. Watching them play the Blue Cross Blue Shields and Aetnas of this world would be like watching peewee footballers go up against, say, the New England Patriots.

And unlike in those sentimental underdog movies from Hollywood, those little coops can't possibly get a winning goal in the last ten seconds of the game.

Obama campaigned to become a "transformational" president who would fight the big money and special interests, Eugene Robinson reminded us in the Washington Post this morning.

And as Obama faces this, the biggest challenge of his young administration, Robinson asks where will he "draw a line in the sand?"

Okay, so we're all grown-ups and we accept that politics requires some compromise and that campaign promises are just that -- promises. But if Obama compromises us out of real reform on this critical issue, before we even get to half-time, he will turn around to find his team has left the field and abandoned the game.

In this writer's humble opinion, a loss of this magnitude will leave Democrats -- and the country -- with a political price to pay for generations to come.

We're also grown-up enough to know that there is no incentive whatsoever within the medical industrial complex to reform the system itself, no matter how much the major players may pretend to be going along with the gag. Too many people are making too much money to truly want to alter the status quo.

At the same time, some Democratic leaders, including Pelosi, Rockefeller and Feingold, seem to be putting more muscle into the game even as they watch their QB stumble down the field, and this renewed effort from Congress offers some hope for an eventual win.

Because if we lose this game, the GOP will regain some of its former power -- if you'll forgive another analogy -- like a hurricane gathering strength out in the Atlantic.

While the full force of that storm may not be felt until the elections of 2012, our best chance right now is to blow some really cold wind in its direction and push it back out to sea.

web stats

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
To follow through with your analogy, there's an old saying that eventually you just have to play the game. This summer's "debate" has been like the interminable pre-game show. So what do you think - will the quarterback's shoulder hold up? His doctor says he's ready but you never know. He seemed to wince during the warm-ups. Let's turn now to the quarterback of the losing conference finalist and get his opinion.

Oh what passes for "news."
The analogy ultimately fails, of course, because football is just a game and health insurance reform is not. Too many lives at stake.
Forgive me if this sounds bad but, we ned to take the insurance industry by the throat and scare the shit out of them. Why do people fear reform? If it is rationing care then what do you call it when an insurance company decides that you aren't worth the cost of the drugs your doctor prescribes? if it is death panels then what do you call the person who tells your doctor that you will not be covered for lifesaving treatments that are expensive? If we don't get a viable federal health plan then we are doing nothing more than throwing money at the people who raised the cost of health care to the ridiculous level it is now.
I completely agree, bobbot. We currently have the worst kind of rationing imaginable. I may have health insurance, and my policy says it will pay such-and-such, but will it come through if I need it? My neighbor has a pre-existing condition and now must pay $4,000/month for insurance. Insurance companies are making life-and-death decisions for people -- they are the ones rationing the health care -- and there hasn't been a damned thing we could do about it. Let's hope that changes soon.
Indeed, complaints about the government rationing care are fairly absurd given the rationing already going on. I try to tell myself that the process we're watching is, as Bismarck remarked, sausage being made and thus unpleasant. I just hope that the end product is digestible.
Interesting post Rebecca. Rated
Ever since Vietnam the public has had a fear/distrust of the government and the corporations have been using this to their advantage to undermine any government legislation that seeks to protect you from them.
Great post. We can only hope that someone picks up Obama's fumble.
Sausage, indeed, AHP. Especially when Obama is compared to the Nazis.

Holding onto the status quo, marcelleqb, is the core of the conservative philosophy. Even when it isn't working.

Or that Obama picks up his own fumble, brie, and makes a beeline for the endpost. And for good measure, kicks a field goal!
RIGHT ON SISTER! (AS THEY SAID IN THE 60'S)