Reaction to Dave Cullen's "Columbine" by a Victim's Parent
I was in the bookstore today here in Littleton, Colorado, looking for Dave Cullen's new book on Columbine. I should mention I am the parent of fifteen year old Daniel Mauser, one of the deceased victims. To say that I had looked forward to the release of this book is not exactly true, but I do have an ongoing interest, for obvious reasons. I guess I did look forward to the release in that anything that sheds light or insight on this particular atrocity I see as helpful. I didn't look forward to it because . . . well, does that really require explanation?
I had expected that the book would be on prominent display at my local Barnes & Noble. Several months ago a prior book which touched on Columbine (Wally Lamb's "The Hour I First Believed") had an entire rack dedicated to it, with a couple of eye-catching signs. Today, I strolled around the store several times and was about to conclude that I had the release date wrong. I was starting to look for a clerk when I saw three copies lying rather discreetly on top of the desk where one asks for information. It made me wonder whether there is still some tangible revulsion for that particular day in Littleton, and the bookstore managers concluded that they didn't want to further wound sensibilities with a prominent book display.
I commenced browsing the book. Thanks, Dave, for dedicating the book to the victims. It appears to be quite comprehensive and well written. I appreciate the fact that he did not take us through yet another rehashed shot-by-shot account of the shootings.
I thought Dave took a fair look at the Cassie Bernall controversy. I myself was never offended by their claims. I do think Misty quite sincerely believed that Cassie said what she did. Misty never made the claim that Cassie was some sort of pure angelic character. I read the book "She Said Yes" a number of years ago, and she portrayed her as a somewhat alienated, troubled girl. The Bernalls had hoped to help turn her life around by getting her into a church youth group and apparently succeeded. I would probably have done things a bit differently, not being of an evangelical bent, but I don't want to scoff at what was an apparently positive outcome. And, as their pastor pointed out, even if she didn't actually say the words of a martyr, she did manage to get her life back on track, and I think that should count for something. I believe the book was written out of love and care for her daughter as well as the actual belief that Cassie said what she purportedly said.
Of course I had to check all the entries in connection with our name. I had to chuckle again (although on one level it makes me very angry) about accusations that my husband somehow was "profiteering" from our son's death as was mentioned in the book. This was an accusation made largely by pro-gun people against my husband, who was working hard to try to get Amendment 22 passed here in Colorado. If profiteering can be construed as having drawn a paycheck (equal only to what he was making as a manager in the state transportation dept.) for one year, then I guess he profited. However, he also took a leave of absence from the state for one year to pursue this work. SAFE Colorado (the local gun control organization) authorized him a salary, which he earned through very hard work.
I have not finished reading the book yet, and will probably not finish it until after April 20 has passed, but a couple more things struck me. Dave referenced Chuck Green, a local columnist, who ranted in a column about the "millions received by the Columbine victims." I would just like to correct the impression that some people may have drawn from this. Most of the "millions" (and I would question how many millions -- I'll bet not more than 2 or 3) went to the families of the severely injured, and none are exactly millionaries, from my best understanding, especially considering the number of injured victims -- 23 in all. Of the $1.6 million in settlement received by all of the Columbine victims, each family of the deceased received not very much at all. I don't recall the exact amount, but I remember telling my husband that we wouldn't be able to even afford a new Ford Taurus with the settlement amount. Families of the deceased did receive $50,000 from the United Way. Severely injured students received substantially more (but not a huge sum if you're looking at lifetime paralysis). A lot of money was donated to the Never Forgotten Fund, which provides scholarships for 13 students from local high schools every year. This was NOTHING like 9/11, wherein families of deceased people really did get a million dollars or more each. In fact, I remember the trial judge saying at the conclusion of the settlement something to the effect that this is a travesty (that Columbine victims got so little).
We were not ever a part of any lawsuit, and the lawsuits that were filed against the Klebolds and Harrises were dismissed.
I haven't studied enough about psychopaths, as Harris was purported to be, to really have a strong opinion as to whether one can simply be born that way. I'd like to think that nurture could be a strong counterbalance, but it's possible that bad brain chemistry can win out sometimes. I suppose evil will always be a bit of a mystery.
Apart from the book, my own feelings this time of year are quite predictable. In late March or early April I can usually count on at least a couple of graphic nightmares and a few bouts of insomnia and general sense of impending doom. I rather suspect that they will be with me always. I'm always relieved when April 20th has passed.
Daniel, we miss you.


Salon.com
Comments
Thank you for a balanced and generous post about a fellow blogger.
I've physically had the book for five days and haven't been able to bring myself to start reading.
Peace to you and yours.
Pax vobiscum
Rated
Thank you for your honesty and reasonableness in talking about what has to be a hellishly personal matter for you.
I'm so sorry for your loss, I have that fear in my own life in that I pray my own children outlive me. I cannot fathom what you had to go through. Thank you for your stark honesty.
Thank you.
Once again, thank you.
Rated
Re: the book, I finished it a few nights ago and it is still with me. I think Dave Cullen did an exceptional job balancing the accounts of the victims, the families, the police, and the shooters. In the book, he was pretty clear about the amounts that were divided. I did not get the impression that it was "millions" and after the reading the book, I was struck by how little it was.
To lose a child in any way is horrible enough; in this fashion I cannot imagine. May you find some peace. Thank you for your perspective.
Peace be with you and your family and I hope that reasonable gun control does one day become reality in this country.
Wonderful post and all the best wishes your way...
I lived in Arvada at the time (that is another Jefferson County town north of Littleton for those of you reading this out of state) and recall my feelings quite clearly, as I had 2 in HS that day.
I heard the book discussed on the radio this morning by David Sirota. Seems that it is being judged realistic and a valuable addition to books written about this horrific event. Mental illness, of the kind Eric Harris must have suffered from, shatters many lives.
I have not yet Dave Cullen's book (although it is next in my must-read pile) but I appreciate your balanced and objective reaction to it. It must be so hard for you and your family that such a book has occasion to be written at all. Reading it and reliving those horrible events all over again must be unimaginably painful for you.
Thank you so much for reaching out to this community. I wish you and your family much peace, healing, and comfort.
This is obviously a tough time for you, and I hope the writing helps in some small way. I'm really sorry about Daniel.
I knew years ago that I wanted to dedicate the book to the victims. I had always planned to dedicate my first book to my parents, and my mentor Lucia, and possibly people like Joan who helped me learn to write. But I didn't expect this to be my first book. Once I got going, I realized I could thank those people elsewhere and dedicate other books to them. This one had to be for the people who paid so dearly.
I also thought the profiteering charge was ludicrous, and that series of Chuck Green columns really mean-spirited. I hope that came through in the book.
Good luck with the next few weeks. I hope it passes quickly, at least.
God bless.
I look forward to more of your writing here on OS.
I have some compassion for the Harris and Klebold families, also, who will have to live with the knowledge of what their sons did and that it can never be undone.
Thank your husband for his hard work on behalf of SAFE Colorado.
Susan Mitchell, it wasn't the anti-gun lobby that made the profiteering claim as it clearly says in this blog post. It was the gun lobby, and yes, that kind of loathesome attack is right up their alley.
everyone here, I wish you well and a healing heart.
God Bless
as a former student at CHS (from way back) i am always struck with such a great sadness around the spring - the loss of life, and the loss of innocence in the community...ah, i can't articulate.
thank you for weighing in here. your honest and forthright and thoughtful comments are appreciated and i look forward to hearing more from you.
peace to you and your's
Thank you to you and your husband for turning your grief into positive action around gun control.
No matter how much or how little money victims' families receive in compensation, it may cover expenses but nothing else.
I wish you and your family peace and comfort.
I would hope that people aren't bored. Appalled would be good, as we need to keep these kinds of incidents in the forefront of our memory. If there is ever a way to be more vigilant, to be in a position to prevent such a catastrophe, it will come about through the continued remembrance of those whose lives were abruptly ended.
My thoughts and prayers are with you, at this time and always. As a parent, I cannot imagine losing one of my kids - it just doesn't parse.
I read most of the book Sunday and I think Dave Cullen is very respectful of the victims, while at the same time trying to clarify facts and to take a look at the myths.
I think there is value in helping all of us to understand this horror better.
Your son, I'm sure, is proud of both you and your husband.
Nothing will ever replace your child. Like Dave, we all know that. And like Dave, we all wish you and your family whatever peace you can find in continuing to celebrate Daniel's memory.
Thank you for sharing your personal insights and information here. You are all in our thoughts and prayers.
I admire the grace with which you write and the way you honor your son. Peace be with you.
That it takes a long time. It lasts a long time.
I've been stressing this in a lot of my interviews, but I don't think people fully get it, nor are they going to, coming from me.
I think people hear "a long time" and think months, God, maybe even a year or two.
When they hear that after ten years, you're just now being able to wrestle some of that down--and once they learn that is a very common timeframe--I think that will really hit home with people.
I think that is a huge contribution, just for getting started on it out in the open.
I've read your earlier posts and of course they've gone way beyond that. I highly recommend that people go back. There's so much to learn here.
I'll read David Cullen's book.
I'm so sorry about your son.
denese
Thanks for sharing Daniel with us.
http://columbinefamilyrequest.org/
I finished Cullen's book a couple of days ago, and (aside from unanswerable questions about the killers) one of my burning questions had to do with what you and your family thought of it. I went looking for an answer and was fortunate enough to find it here. Every death that day was a tragedy, but Daniel's is the one that has always stuck with me.